HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

phil21

7,434 karma · joined March 13, 2014

I do Internet infrastructure stuff.

phil21@phil21.net

submissionscomments
phil21··on Solar surpasses nuclear power globally for first time
Sure, but their energy budget includes everything. They don’t have the luxury of importing energy others invested into decades ago when convenient and having it be off balance sheet like Denmark does.

China would actually have to build stuff to do that. Denmark can just pretend it doesn’t exist.

phil21··on US federal budget deficit jumps 12% in one year to nearly $2 Trillion
Not how it worked in my home state growing up. The state intermittently ran budget surpluses and were net givers to the federal budget. Still are today.

I’m also not entirely sure how relevant that is due to states (and provinces) not printing their own currency though. Very different situations.

phil21··on US federal budget deficit jumps 12% in one year to nearly $2 Trillion
You don’t make meaningful progress when you focus on a rounding error part of the budget. It’s like targeting private jet use for climate change. It’s for the feels so you can pretend you’re on the right side of things while doing absolutely nothing that matters in final effect even if 100% successful.

If you want to solve the budget deficit you need to go after the things that matter which is mandatory social spending these days. That and the revenue side combined are all that matter. Even the military is starting to become more and more irrelevant as social spending and debt service eats up all the air in the room. You could end it entirely tomorrow and you’d still have a deficit. It’s not the 1990s anymore.

Anything else can be immediately written off as unserious action brought by unserious people. The bike shedding of budgetary politics.

phil21··on Delta’s Biscoff cookies were supposed to be temporary
Depends where you fly out of mostly. When I lived in MSP Delta was both the only real choice, and also pretty damn good for an airline. Especially with top tier status.

I moved to Chicago and am stuck with United now. I miss Delta most times I fly, they simply had a better product.

phil21··on Delta’s Biscoff cookies were supposed to be temporary
Same. My theory is the ginger in them. But who knows!
phil21··on Banks are now trying to offload the AI data center debt they just underwrote
They wouldn’t mine with them, they would just offer cheap inference with open models.

This is already happening.

phil21··on Banks are now trying to offload the AI data center debt they just underwrote
Good luck powering a 400kw rack in your basement, if you are looking to do frontier model type stuff. Just a single machine can run in the 150kw range these days for the less exotic stuff.

It can certainly be parted out with proper motivation but it’s going to take a whole new ecosystem to support these in your typical home lab. Even then 20-30kw slices are electric car level energy consumers.

phil21··on Why isn't the industry freaking out about DeepSeek 4.1 Flash?
> do they plan to increase production? No.

Micron has 3 brand new fabs currently under construction, 2 Boise, 1 in New York as the first of 4 planned for a campus.

Plus expanding other existing facilities.

These things take ~3-5 years from breaking ground to full production. You'd have had to anticipate the current demand years before it happened in order to be bringing production on-line before 2030 or so.

Samsung and HK Hynix also have fabs under construction and planned.

CXMT started 11 years ago and only now is reaching any real volume. If they decided a year ago to react to the current demand cycle they'd be 6-7 years out.

Not much you can really do to wish for more fabrication to exist on any timeline not measured in fractional decades.

Could they do more and react quicker? Probably, but everything I've read on the subject seems to point to 3 years is absolute bare minimum if you happen to have a shovel ready project with the land bought, local permitting completed, infrastructure extended to the site, and a skilled workforce already in place. They could suspend buy-backs/dividends today and dump it all into building production and there would be no material impact until around 2030.

> The Micron CEO just recently said this is the exact plan

CEO simply stated the demand pressure will not go away through 2027, and supply will not increase until around 2028 when currently under construction fabs start shipping volume. The article does not support your statement.

phil21··on Anthropic reported diary entry to police, woman faces felony charge
I had a list of controllers that we forgot the usernames and passwords to. We knew it was some combination from about a half dozen of each, just not exactly what was what. A few hundred of them so a tedious task for a human to go through and validate them all.

Got flagged for attempting to have Codex write a quick script to basically dictionary attack my own infrastructure with a tiny dictionary file.

A bit silly, but it doesn’t take a whole lot.

phil21··on Micron CEO Says Memory Supply Will Be Much Tighter in 2027 and 2028 Than in 2026
> So your inability to supply that demand resulted in you creating the conditions for competition to show up, and that competition can very likely outcompete you out of the market.

Doubtful. Your competition started building out additional production roughly when you did. Lets say you got a 1 year head start on shovels in the ground.

Those competitors have decades of experience producing RAM. You do not. Even if you get your facility on-line to first wafer a year earlier than the incumbents, it's unlikely you will beat them to full production output as even extremely experienced operators take 6-18mo to get a fab from first production to expected nominal output.

The only way to "win" this is to have started before the supply crunch happened back in 2021 or 2022 - or more likely much earlier. Like CXMT did.

If you were able to find a bunch of investors to give you $40-50B today, already had a site ready to start construction literally tomorrow, by the time you are on-line you will be competing with new capacity currently being built by Samsung, Micron, and SK Hynix - not to mention CXMT. The only way you will be profitable is if the current demand exists through 2031 and beyond.

I know I certainly wouldn't be investing in such a project, since the entire bet is that RAM prices 5 years from now will still be at roughly what they are today. Which is simply a bet that the current AI bubble and infrastructure build-out is still ongoing.

phil21··on Micron CEO Says Memory Supply Will Be Much Tighter in 2027 and 2028 Than in 2026
> But here's a CEO saying he's going to make sure prices stay high enough, long enough that you can spin up a competitor

2 years is not remotely enough time to spin up a competitor. It's not even enough time for a current leading competitor to spin up another fab.

If you are a newcomer you are talking a decade or more before mass production. If you are HK Hynix perhaps 5 years or so.

The majors all have large fabs under construction, but the majority of new production from those facilities won't be coming fully on-line until 2028 at the earliest. Even from the date of first wafer shipped most of these facilities take 6-12mo to reach mass production level output.

Chinese DRAM is interesting only because they started building capacity (expertise) a decade ago. Only now are the expected to have any material impact on the total volume of the market. And if they want to gain even more market share, they will be under the same ~5 years to spin up a brand new fabrication plant. Perhaps a bit less because they are China, but still multiple years.

phil21··on Everybody’s home. No one’s coming over
It's a loose RSVP. A few extra folks showing up last minute is not a big deal, the meals are usually "family style" and leftovers get taken home most of the time.

If someone is rolling in with a larger than usual group they typically bring enough extra food to go around.

And yep, a lot of these are pot luck style to some degree. Host makes main course, everyone else pitches in on other stuff.

Definitely some loose coordination involved and the host will typically call a roll call the day before to get an estimate of number of people dropping by.

phil21··on Micron CEO Says Memory Supply Will Be Much Tighter in 2027 and 2028 Than in 2026
And it's not just a few people. The sophisticated scalping operations have hundreds of straw buyers in their network. For items that generate far less profit than a 5090 currently does.

I've watched vans dropping of an endless stream of people in the parking lot of my local Costco to buy out all the cases of Pokemon cards within 20 minutes of the "random" drop they put on the floor. They go in, buy the max quantity of the item with cash provided by their keeper, bring it back to the van with a receipt and change, and get the $20-30 per item pay they were promised. There were 2 or 3 'legit' buyers out of hundreds of obvious straw buyers.

If the profit per item is $4-5k, expect this to go into turbo mode and be done in a marketplace/automated fashion and go viral. Just sign up to your favorite scalper's platform, submit your information, get a quote and a prepaid label and drop the box you got from nVidia off at USPS the next day. That "tens of thousands" of individuals will turn into "millions" really quick once it gets known there is rent money involved by clicking a few buttons and it goes viral on all the social media platforms.

The only way out from that is manufacturer enough cards to meet demand, and at that point the retail channel doesn't really matter.

phil21··on Everybody’s home. No one’s coming over
I helped implement the concept of a "Sunday Supper" with our friend group in the city. It's basically held every Sunday and rotates to different households who feel like hosting that day. Luckily one person is sort of the "default" since their family's child situation makes it more convenient for them to host vs. go elsewhere.

It's basically an open invite for a group of friends, and a standing thing that just happens. If you have no other plans, you basically go. Sometimes I have to drag myself out of the house to do it - but it's worth it every time. The group that attends sometimes is just one other couple, sometimes it's a house full of 30 people if everyone comes, brings their kids, and a few friends of friends tag along.

Definitely one of the better things I've been involved in!

phil21··on Revealing the details of how OpenAI agents hacked Hugging Face
> Especially when they cross into the physical realm as in not properly secured and air gapped control systems. SCADA is scary.

What about the bad actors (choose your own evildoer here) who purposefully do not air gap their agents? And specifically train them to attack in such a manner?

I'd much rather have relatively benign stuff like this hit first, because the former is coming sooner than later. It's already here in a limited manner, likely more than any of us currently realize.

Botnets could crack passwords faster than anyone thought possible over 20 years ago now. This is just the latest iteration of such a concept.

There is so much low hanging fruit in this space that frontier models are currently utterly irrelevant. It's going to take decades of human-speed securing of IT to make superintelligence or whatever you want to call it a necessary component for such attacks.

At this point, someone with a rack or three of GPUs with 100kw to burn can replicate such attacks if they feel like it. the bar for entry is not even 7 figures.

phil21··on Oracle on the hook to pay data centre investors even if site has no electricity
It’s almost always both. Basically every single retired person I know in my family or friends of family are relying on their home to be their primary asset/income in retirement. It’s always a much larger chunk of their net worth than any retirement savings, if they even have the latter.

They were commonly called forced savings accounts when I was growing up. The standard advice was to buy a home as an investment vehicle. Every older family member giving me advice would preach about how they don’t make any more land and the price will only go up.

You can - to this day - talk until your are blue in the face to these people that your primary place of living is not an investment, but they will refuse to even entertain the idea even with the stark cold math staring at them in the face.

If these retired folks can’t sell their homes for a huge profit they will be in for some very difficult times a decade or two from now. They are highly motivated to keep the music playing as long as they can vote and show up to local city council meetings.

phil21··on Federal judge orders Texas to air condition all prisons by the end of 2029
Rehabilitation has never really been the point of the US prison or even correctional system at all.

The fact you can serve your time, earnestly work on rehabilitating yourself, jump through all the hoops, etc. but still be under the economic death sentence more or less summarizes how people feel about it.

It’s basically NIMBY applied to the justice system. Everyone loves to pretend they want rehabilitation but also wants someone else to do it. This shows up in hiring, apartment leasing, social benefits, etc.

phil21··on What California is learning from solar panels built over irrigation canals
> The U.S. locks up people at 5x the rate of South Korea. Whatever the difference is, it’s not because the U.S. is unwilling to punish people.

The difference is in consistency in enforcement and general background crime rate.

If you have a nearly guaranteed chance of getting caught doing something, the punishment almost doesn't matter. If every single time you went over the speed limit you got a $500 fine 100% guaranteed, there would be effectively zero speeders ever. If you have a 1 in a million chance of getting caught but the punishment is 10 years in prison - there will still be plenty of speeders all over the place.

Humans do not do well with estimating risk on low probability events. We are all just big children in the end. Consistency in consequences are what actually matters, not overly harsh punishment.

phil21··on GPT-6 Sol and Luna
There was/is a loophole where if you signed up via the iOS or Android app, it allowed it.

It's been disabled for some time now though otherwise, I check about once a day myself and keep and eye out on social media.

Annoying since I was about to upgrade back to the $200 plan after downgrading to the $100 plan due to being on leave and not needing as much usage the month prior. Doh.

phil21··on Everybody's Lost Their Minds
> For all my efforts to get LLMs to work for me, they've failed. I figure it is because the tech space I work in (Industrial Automation) simply doesn't have the training data that someone building webapps does.

Putting safety critical aside (given that is a giant aside) for the moment, I'm a little surprised at this.

One of the most useful things I've found for AI Agent stuff is having an agent live on my home network and finally get the hundred or so random sensors and other IoT devices finally configured and talking together.

It's definitely not perfect though, and not anything I would trust my life to. This year however, I was able to set up enough sensors in my garden to have by far the largest hot pepper harvest I've ever had by min/maxing watering and fertilizing via way too many sensors and data fusing. This was mostly describing the sensors involved, the outcome and dashboarding desired, and pointing it to the various vendor API docs.

I could have done all that stuff manually, but never would have gotten around to it since it was just a tedious boring task. But with AI help I now can tell you precisely the soil moisture level, EC reading, ambient temp, etc. for each of my planters. And with some combining of my rain gauge data and sunlight sensing, tie that into automated irrigation runs. Then the bot just pings me when it thinks the next fertilizing cycle is due.

I don't know if that's revolutionary, but it took a project that would take me weeks to accomplish myself due to around a hundred sensors to configure/setup/etc. to a couple nights of messing around learning what all this talk was over these AI agent things.

I think there are plenty of use-cases where if AI gets things wrong 5% of the time it really doesn't matter a whole lot. I have plenty of these areas at my job.

phil21··on The American Religion of Self-Storage Facilities
Sure, only if you haul away the other 14 giant objects as well! And at least lie to me well enough that they will all go to a good home :)
phil21··on The American Religion of Self-Storage Facilities
It’s such an annoying problem to solve.

I have all sorts of “stuff” I would give away to someone who can use it. I just don’t want to spend 3 hours per object doing so via posting on Facebook marketplace, having 8 people flake out on pickup, and a Saturday afternoon killed because I need to wait around for someone to show up.

It gets worse with more esoteric things like nerdy electronic gear which is absolutely worth something to the right person, but that person happening to be in my area and also searching for that particular bit and bob at that exact moment are almost nothing. Some of these things can be hundreds of dollars if you need to order new or off eBay.

I’d be fine with giving it away to a reseller if I could. Just very difficult to throw it away since it’s so wasteful.

phil21··on A coffee shop owner used AI to make a menu poster. Then came the angry DMs
The most fitting description of an owner of a small coffee shop is "barista". Most barista's I know also handle far more than just making coffee and serving customers. They do everything short of being personally financially responsible for the business itself.

It's quite clear that if anyone was operating in bad faith here, it's not the commenters challenging your position. Small business ownership is almost always simply a riskier version of having the job you're also hiring for with a very small chance of upside. Usually at lower pay.

In this particular case the owner was simply doing a task other barista's like herself were doing as part of the regular job of a barista.

> The owner was not personally either making or serving the coffee.

This is the part I do not follow. Of course she is? What small coffee shop owner do you know does not personally make or serve the coffee on a regular basis? The only way not to take your original post in bad faith is to not understand your meaning.

phil21··on A coffee shop owner used AI to make a menu poster. Then came the angry DMs
Funnily enough, I was thinking of exactly those photos when writing my comment. I never found them to be all that misrepresentative - that they took a photo from their family friend of their father taken 20 years ago for the same dish they are making me and have it on some faded menu board behind the counter is... honestly pretty close.

It's the fake AI generated "shine" I guess that is the difference to me. Obviously totally made up, not real food, and made to look pretty.

It's mostly the uncanny valley. Both are indeed false advertising, but the AI generated ones are so obviously made up and not real it's a little off putting to me.

Wouldn't really stop me from ordering if I were already there, but it might make me order from their competitor if I were on Uber Eats or whatnot.

phil21··on A coffee shop owner used AI to make a menu poster. Then came the angry DMs
I don't follow. Even a little bit.

Every single small coffee shop owner I know has employees. They work alongside them and do every job in the shop along with them. They operate in shifts, sometimes the owner is there for both open and close.

What does hiring a barista have to do with not making coffee yourself?

Gonna go with the "hilariously out of touch" comment. These places rarely print money to the point an owner can be an absentee manager type.

phil21··on A coffee shop owner used AI to make a menu poster. Then came the angry DMs
I think there is a big difference between using AI generated food pictures, vs. taking real pictures of your food and using AI to create a menu/poster.

The former is both weird, creepy most of the time, and false advertising. The latter is as you say - the state of the current status quo. I can tell that it's AI, but honestly it's just replacing low-effort human crud for low-effort AI crud. Doesn't bother me at all, it's actually a great use for the technology imo.

phil21··on Nvidia dismisses "circular financing", says every $1 it invests brings back $100
> The utilization rates of GPUs for AI workloads in a datacenter run by cloud service providers (CSP) is between 60% and 70%. With such utilization rates, a GPU will typically survive between one and two years, three years at the most, according to a quote allegedly made by a principal generative AI architect from Alphabet and reported by @techfund, a long-term tech investor with good sources.

This is just extremely unbelievable to me. I am certainly not operating at a level the hyperscalers are and have much more limited direct experience. But I do actually put various GPUs inside datacenters (and much harsher locations) and have operated them at balls-to-the-wall 100% utilization for over a decade now.

You get the typical bathtub curve of failures. Unless the hyperscalers are operating these things even more overclocked and beyond thermal specification limits than early GPU crypto miners used to do, I simply cannot believe that the average hardware life is less than the useful life of the whole chip generation itself.

I have plenty of decade old GPUs that operate today just fine. Both consumer and datacenter form factors. The failures tend to be board-level like capacitors and such, so if you are operating at a massive scale partnering with someone who can fix those relatively cheaply is not all that difficult either.

It could be that these H200 and above class sort of stuff is engineered extremely fragile, but I seriously doubt it. The prevailing "common knowledge" pre-AI for GPUs were that they'd burn out in a year or two of heavy use, and that was simply untrue. I saved a ton of money buying batches of used units because everyone was terrified of this - and had no more early failures than I did buying brand new after basic refurb of re-pasting and putting a new fan on them.

phil21··on Europe's "Less" Is Doing More Than Anyone Gives It Credit For
Only if you use dollar value output as some weird substitute for actually making things.
phil21··on LG says we're fake news [video]
Mostly bug fixes relevant to higher end home theatre setups. Typically bleeding edge stuff where a TV is released before a new HDMI spec is fully baked or whatnot. One of my older OLED panels needed a number of updates to get proper Dolby Vision profile support a few years back.

Typically not all that relevant most of the time to the average consumer, but if you’re having a persistent annoyance it’s worth looking through release notes from time to time.

This ignores that the vast majority of consumers actually use the smart tv features like the Netflix app. Then updates start to become far more relevant and eventually mandatory.

phil21··on LG denies TV spying claims, says tracking and snooping concerns 'not true'
It also gates some "features" like the "AI" auto-detection of media type to automatically switch the TV between sports, movie, gaming, etc. modes as well. At least from my memory of a recent LG OLED setup.
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →