1,835 karma · joined May 22, 2010
http://hodgen.com
Email address: my username at gmail.
My second thought was that science fiction is writing itself in real time here, right in front of me. Re-engineer a planet . . . To make it "better". (Certain terms and conditions apply, no warranty express or implied . . . .)
My third thought was a memory of the eugenics movement of the '20s and '30s. This is a much cleaner and more scientific way to rid yourself of unwanted segments of the human population, and easier to execute at a distance and at scale.
Right now it seems so innocuous: you can't leave the country for limited reasons. Expect the reasons to expand in time. Scope creep is routine in Federal law.
I am a tax lawyer, and I am disgusted. Land of the free, indeed. Peh.
2. I assume your side projects will probably not generate a lot of money. Most side projects fail. (That's a feature, not a bug).
3. Don't spend money until you absolutely must. Money is energy stored in rectangular pieces of paper. Save your energy.
4. Don't spray your attention all over creation. Focus on one thing -- your side project. Unless your side project is named "ClerkyKiller" :-) do not focus on company formation.
5. You have nooooo idea how much extra work and annoyance you will endure as soon as you touch the legal and tax paperwork system. Stay as far away from it as you can, for as long as you can.
I am a lawyer and I approve this message. :-)
https://www.manager-tools.com/map-universe/trinity-one-ones
Essentially, 10 minutes for them, 10 minutes for me, 10 minutes on the work front. It varies by person and phase of the moon. Personal stuff is important to discuss, I think.
I'm still learning how to do this after six months. We _rarely_ fail to have one-on-ones.
Failure. I am one of three people I have seen this happen to. A MBP is vastly more capable.
When I see iPad sales continue to slide, I don't wonder why. It is not all that useful.
I'm a tax lawyer so my needs are modest. I'm no power user. But spreadsheets, omnigraffle, Scrivener, etc are all better on a Mac. Multiple windows are a necessity.
The people I have seen who evangelize the iPad Pro as a primary device (macstories.net, brooksreview.net) seem to put far more effort into bending their lives to the tool. I'd rather get shit done.
Website designers must have a gear loose. Grrrr. Pop ups of any kind are anti-customer.
I am an international tax lawyer and I advise startups that do business all over the world.
I do not have a good answer to your question. There is insufficient data upon which to make a suggestion.
However, here are my guidelines:
- if there is a US person involved in this business as an officer or owner, you will experience exquisite agony in opening a bank account abroad.
- until your net profits from non-US sources amount to $2M - $3M per year, the tax benefits are likely to be trivial.
- an hour of founder time spent thinking about tax is an hour wasted. Think about building your product. Think about getting a customer. That's much more valuable.
- as soon as you add a foreign corporation to your business structure you have probably added $10K - $20k to your overhead. Minimum.
There are exceptions to every rule. Your situation may be different. Good luck.
Also . . . I know it's petty but if you are selling extreme rigor ("unbreakable servers") please demonstrate this trait in all of your affairs. A trivial failure to pay attention to details I can see (hint: typo) tells me you might be sloppy in things I can't see (software on your unbreakable servers).
Fix your typo.
Edit: now the website loads on iOS. Also unhackable, not unbreakable. Sorry I got that wrong.
Not a suitable post for HN for multiple reasons.
Having said that, we have tried many things and the best solution we found so far is an installation of dokuwiki on our internal server. People actually use it.
The shiny software doesn't matter if people don't refer to the SOPs.
FWIW I went to Chase Bank. I'm not happy, I'm not sad. Banking is as exciting as a loaf of bread. The less I interact with a bank and the humans at a bank, the happier I am.
This is not because of bitcoin. That's just a distraction. This is about tax evasion, which is an existential threat to a government. Without revenue, a government dies. With visible disregard for laws, a government dies.
Coinbase must, therefore, submit. The Federal government has no alternative. If the current laws are inadequate to the task (hint: the current laws are quite adequate, thank you very much), additional laws will be enacted to accomplish this.
If the Department of Justice can bend the biggest banks in the world to its will, why should we expect Coinbase to be able to stand unbowed?
We need only look at recent history to predict Coinbase's future. Look at enforcement actions against Swiss banks, and the massive fines imposed by the U.S. This has acted as an efficient "pour encourager les actress" strategy.
Related: see the U.S. government's crusade against online gambling, or the way the eBay tax data hole was plugged so that sales are now reported on Form 1099.
Prediction: Coinbase will provide data to the government.
Recommendation: if you use Bitcoin, report your income (oblig disclaimer). And do business with companies that have zero contact with the U.S. -- no offices, no assets, no owners, no employees.
(Disclosure. I am a tax lawyer. I have defended many, many innocent :-) Swiss bank accounts against Federal tax evasion claims. I have dealt with tax problems involving BTC as well. It's easy to predict the future.)
But it irks me that I follow the easier, softer way -- knowing that I am causing trouble to myself by doing so.
And it is a telling indictment of the corporate character displayed by Google:
- Exploitable for minor personal convenience ("Use Gmail! Use Gcal! Simple and free!")
- Not to be trusted under any circumstances with important matters ("We can evaporate your existence from the internet for all practical purposes and there's not a damn thing you can do about it.")
Some day, it will become important for us to own our own lives again. And I say this as someone who runs his business on GApps. I'm as guilty as everyone else.
1. For Coinbase, this will not end well. The best Coinbase can hope for is a pretense (for marketing purposes) of Standing Up to The Man. Then a total data dump to the Department of Justice or go out of business.
2. For Bitcoin users, don't cheat on your taxes. (Oblig.) If you are concerned about information leakage to the U.S. government, do business with a company that has no ties to the USA.
It's not hard to see trendlines if you have watched for a while. Remember G.K. Chesterton's fence.
I say this as a tax lawyer, finance guy, and small business owner. I have lived (and continue to live) in this problem space.
HR. I am sorry, but software will not solve your problems. Governments (and you are dealing with more than one) tend to be actively hostile to employers. California (where I am) is the worst. You will make mistakes. A single overtime claim can cost you tend of thousands of dollars.
For HR I hired a consultant to document everything. The consultant's work was cross-checked by a labor lawyer. We do quarterly reviews of the employee manual and all procedures. You have to live by the rules you write.
I hate being an employer. I really like the people who work with me. They are great.
You, as a founder, should preserve your attention. You should also protect your reserve of courage -- don't have incipient, nagging fear that you are doing it wrong. I suspect you are there now, by your comment about converting your people from contractor to employee.
Accounting. Hire a really, really good bookkeeper. At your size you need someone in house, at least part-time. We have have our outside accountant and two part-time bookkeepers (a junior day-to-day person and a senior manager-level person) feeding data to our accountant.
Software: Xero. My personal opinion is that QuickBooks is shit, but you use the tool that the craftsman favors. Our senior bookkeeper loves QuickBooks Online and can make it sing.
International. I happen to be an international tax lawyer. I know about the complexity of having employees in other countries. This simply means that the true cost of having a distributed team is higher than you think.
Bookmark your sense of alarm. Your sense of impending doom. Remember your feelings today, then get on with life. Come back in a year or two. How will your perception today compare with reality two years from now? (I have a prediction . . . .)
This is said by someone who has watched the sky fall and people throw hissy fits since the 1968 Nixon victory.
Seriously though, I would not be surprised to see MP3s from these bands as an additional marketing tool.
The cassettes are likely to be viewed by the audience as collectibles, creating word-of-mouth marketing. They are "social objects" to use Hugh Macleod's insightful phrase.
My son was wearing a t-shirt made by a tiny shop in San Diego. You only own this shirt if you know the maker. He was touring a college to see if he wanted to apply. He was accosted by a student. "Where did you get that shirt?" They were both friends of the maker.
This creates a sense of "I belong".
Interesting side note. This shirt -- and the tiny company -- wildly and deliberately violates trademark law. Not to make money, but for the same reason (I think) that musicians use samples.
This is why corporations are expensive. "Meh paperwork". But the first thing the IRS asks for when they start an audit is the minute book to show the meetings of the Board of Directors and the meetings of the shareholders.
Moral of the story: if you're not willing to pay for maintenance, don't buy a Ferrari.
Moral of the story: OCD and anal-retentive behavior are rewarded in TaxWorld. Pragmatism and "good enough" are punished. :-)
I have done this type of structure MANY times, for humans and for payment processing.
EDIT: also, I completely missed your reference to State taxation, and when SaaS stuff is taxable/not taxable. Yeah. State taxation is painful, because the tax is low but the pain for screwing it up is high. On the other hand, the rules are arbitrary and unpredictable, so you have that going for you.
The reason for your problem is that a human working in the USA is "doing business". And if the human is a company's employee, then the "doing business" attribute belongs to the employer. This is standard principal-agent theory.
There are a couple of ways around this. One is the income tax treaty. It says, interpreted, "you don't have to worry about US tax if you don't have a _permanent establishment_ in the USA". That magic phrase is jargon and means an office or factory etc. a single human wouldn't necessarily be a "permanent establishment".
Unfortunately the Canada/USA treaty was amended in 2010 to put companies like yours at risk. (Ask Mr Google about the Fifth Protocol). Now, a single human's presence can be a "permanent establishment" subjecting the employer to income tax.
There is a day-count test. Too many days in the USA for that human and the Canadian employer is doing business in the USA. The reverse is true for US employers with Canadian-located employees.
So a sane employer will not rely on the treaty.
A sane company will spin up a little US corporation, wholly owned by the Canadian corporation. The only thing this US corporation does is hire the US employee and provide the results of that employee's labour (see what I did there?) to the Canadian corporation.
The US corporation runs at break-even profitability. It pays no tax but spawns a buttload of tax paperwork on both sides of the border. By "buttload" I mean that I wouldn't be surprised if it adds $10,000 per year to overhead to do this.
You can question the sanity of your diplomats and government bots now. The US and Canadian diplomats who negotiated the Fifth Protocol made it more expensive to hire people across the border.
I am an international tax lawyer. But right now I am eating a carne asada burrito at Lucky Boy.
2. Work one-on-one with another person. Someone helped you. Now you help someone else. Then another. The ego says you must impact millions. Truly, you will do more by changing one person's life. Then another. The chain reaction will take effect.
3. Serve a small group in your community. Be a worker among workers. A friend among friends. Don't go for glory. Don't try to be the Big Cheese. Be there for service to make the organization better.
Your work can be a channel for these efforts. So can being a spouse and a parent.
Everyone wants to be Steve Jobs or Bob Dylan or Martin Luther King.
Just be a good dad. There is a universe of value in that.
If you can say to yourself "I will light this investment of my time and money on fire and I don't care" then Legalzoom is a good choice.
If the stakes are high enough, you'd be batshit insane to is an "out of the box" solution until you know what they put in the box. Maybe the documents are fine. Maybe they're not. Care to bet your new business that everything is gonna be ok?
Filing an LLC-1 in California is a commodity service.
People think the LLC's operating agreement is a commodity. They couldn't be more wrong.
Similar conclusions apply to corporations.