HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

philipn

2,968 karma · joined October 27, 2008

https://localwiki.org
submissionscomments
philipn··on Show HN: OneBody Church Directory software I've been hacking on for 7 years
I just wanted to say that I've been following your work for a while now. I find it really fascinating! You've got a really active niche (if you can really even call it that!) and an interesting, polished, open-source project. Also, you seem to really care about design, which is an unfortunate rarity in the FLOSS world.

I agree with the folks saying you should start a SaSS service. Even if it's extremely un-optimized (e.g. you spin up a new EC2 instance per-order), I think many, many churches would be interested. Hosting is a huge liability, time-sink, and all-around pain in the ass, and I think you'd do well enough to at cover your costs (at the very least!)

philipn··on Squatter doesn't sit well with Airbnb host
This "30-day for just-cause-only eviction protection" isn't, as far as I know, quite right. Given that AirBnB guests don't really sign any contracts (aside from the website boilerplate), you may be correct in this case. But in general, it's very possible to sublet your apartment in SF and have your subtenant sign an agreement to wave their just-cause eviction protection on the grounds the rental is temporary. See this page for more information: http://www.hrcsf.org/subletting_basic.html
philipn··on The new 501(c)(3) and the future of free software in the US
Yup, lots have. The Apache Software Foundation has a scientific exemption, and IPython is fiscally-sponsored by NumFocus (http://numfocus.org) which has a scientific exemption as well.
philipn··on The new 501(c)(3) and the future of free software in the US
I'm the ED of a 501(c)3 non-profit (http://localwiki.org), and when we applied for our (c)3 status we got some flack along these lines, as well. Here's my advice to the Yorba Foundation folks:

If you haven't received your final rejection, you can appeal.

Don't try and do this yourself. The post says they spoke with folks at the Software Freedom Center, which is great, but I highly recommend finding a specialized attorney who's seen lots of applications and knows the right angle. Hire an attorney who specializes in obtaining 501(c)3 status. We made this mistake early on, thinking we could work through the NOLO book and apply ourselves. It cost us. For around $1k you can find a good non-profit attorney to help.

We got flack for the open-source thing, too. Our original exemption application was basically "Hey, we're a charity! We give things away for free and release open source code, which can be used by everyone!" Depending on the IRS agent assigned to you, you might get flack for this as well. Generally speaking, they may not like that a for-profit business can use your organization's by-product to make lots of money for themselves. We spent some time explaining how OSS worked to the agent, and was able to convince him that because (most) of our OSS is copyleft, that it would be a continually-free-and-open good, not a private benefit.

Nevertheless, just releasing OSS is NOT an exempt purpose. If you read the IRS regulations, they are very specific as to what a core exempt purpose is. You'll need to pick one that fits best. Generally speaking, it's 1) Church stuff 2) Scientific advancement and research 3) Furthering of the arts 4) Education 5) "Charity," meaning helping people who are disadvantaged in some way 6) Some others that I'm not remembering.

Most OSS 501(c)3 don't get exemption by just releasing open source software-- they get exemption by being an educational institution. So you may want to go that route -- the organization's core exemption is the creation of educational materials that help education members of a particular community in XYZ ways. This is what we ended up doing -- we're classified as an educationally-exempt organization. If you look up the 501(c)3 apps of some other OSS non-profits you'll see similarly -- e.g. Plone Foundation is set up as an educational organization.

Edit: If you'd like to take a look at some of our back-and-forth with the IRS agent at the time, check out the page here: http://localwiki.net/org/Historic_501%28c%293_application_pr... You'll see his response was similar to yours, but we decided to pursue educational exemption and were granted on that basis in the end. Also, you can call up the IRS Agent assigned to you and talk to them about the application, which can be extremely helpful.

philipn··on Why Python doesn't need blocks
I don't understand this. You can just define a function anywhere in python and use it (in local scope). I do this all the time, and it's a lot more clear than an unnamed lambda function. What's the use case here?
philipn··on Window into Airbnb’s hidden impact on SF
SF is a bit different than other communities in that most apartment buildings are really just these large, zany old victorians. Few have tenant associations or real management. My apartment, for instance, is a 4-address building, with each address subdivided into 4-5 sub-units. The building is owned and managed by someone who grew up in the building. I've lived in SF for 7 years, and never lived anywhere that's like a conventional apartment complex.
philipn··on Window into Airbnb’s hidden impact on SF
I'm glad there's beginning to be some discussion on AirBnB's impact on the housing stock in SF.

I really like AirBnB when I'm traveling or when I want a nice getaway, but it's been incredible to see how how many units around me here in SF are full-time AirBnB rentals. Walking down my block alone, I'd estimate that 30% of the units here are full-time on AirBnB. Each afternoon, I begin to see the tourists and travelers roll in with suitcases, and I've noticed an increasing number of coded lock-boxes outside of many of the houses near me

Whether or not you support rent control is an entirely different issue, but I feel like AirBnB, as it presently operates, is incompatible with the system. In the days of yore, friends of mine would have rooms open up in their apartments and would rent them out to fellow tenants (or subtenants). Now, many folks I know are converting their open rooms (against SF law) to AirBnBs, as the tenants can make a killing off of them.

There's always been bad actors in the SF rental market -- many people would sublease rooms directly to tenants for far above the rate they were paying to the landlord. I think AirBnB just makes it a bit more appealing.

philipn··on Show HN: Silk, a profiling tool for Django
Thanks for posting this! Could you add a download link somewhere?
philipn··on Ask HN: Examples of tech worker cooperatives?
IO Coop (https://iocoop.org/) is a member-owned tech infrastructure (colo, vps, some other services) cooperative.
philipn··on Dear Web Developers: EFF Needs Your Help
A lot of the work here is parsing contact forms from sites using a bookmarklet. Lots of details here: http://theunitedstates.io/contact-congress/
philipn··on Aviation is stuck in the 60s – a reflection on MH 370
I don't know much about aviation, but a number of these technologies are being implemented in commercial flights now, including NextGen (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Next_Generation_Air_Transportat...).
philipn··on Prefer mercurial to git
git is licensed under the GPL (== v2), just not GPL (>= v2).
philipn··on Yes, There’s a Pilot Shortage: Salaries Start at $21,000
Here's a great summary of what's involved by askcaptainscott on YouTube: Can I be an airline pilot if I start training in my 30s? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WJk9Skxyi84

I'm far from an expert on air travel, but my understanding is that the regional airlines have become the backbone of budget US travel, and have a huge role in this salary gap (between regionals and non-regionals).

Frontline did a great piece on the regional airlines, focusing on safety problems called "Flying Cheap" - http://video.pbs.org/video/1412744270/

philipn··on NSA seeks to build quantum computer that could crack most types of encryption
If you're curious (as I was) about the estimated cost of breaking RSA-1024 check out this paper:

http://tau.ac.il/~tromer/papers/cbtwirl.pdf

tl;dr - estimate is ~$10M

philipn··on Ask HN: Getting paid to work on open source full-time?
I love your comment, but I disagree with your assessment of LiveJournal in the last paragraph. The reason Facebook beat LiveJournal had nothing to do with their ability to use memcached or other open infrastructure developed by the LJ/Danga team. It likely had a lot more to do with Six Apart, resources, energy, etc.
philipn··on A 140-Acre Forest Is About to Materialize in the Middle of Detroit
There's some more info on the Detroit LocalWiki here - http://detroitwiki.org/Hantz_Farms. When I asked my friend about it, he responded with "long story."
philipn··on Tessel: The end of web development as we know it
This is certainly interesting, but this title couldn't be more hyperbolic link-bait if it tried, especially since content has nothing to do with "the end of web development as we know it."
philipn··on What Does it Really Mean to be Non-Profit?
I suspect the author doesn't live in the US, as a few of his points don't apply to US non-profit law.

In particular:

"A charity (except in special circumstances) cannot pay a salary to anyone. Typically everyone who works for a charity is a volunteer."

In the US, when people talk about non-profits they're usually talking about organizations with the 501(c)3 tax status (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/501%28c%29_organization#501.28c...). Those organizations are further classified as either public charities or private foundations -- the former being what people typically mean by "non-profit."

US non-profits almost always pay some people for some of their work. There are restrictions on salary, insofar as you have to explain that salaries are justified to the IRS (this really only applies if the salary is beyond normal market rate).

"A charity must disclose all of its financials publicly, in great detail, and be audited by several government bodies. "

The same is true in the US, though non-profits do not have an audit requirement here. Large non-profits typically hire a CPA to do an audit each year, though, as multi-million foundation grant-givers often require it.

"A charity may only do things which have charitable purpose for public benefit, and nothing else."

This isn't strictly true in the US. A charity can engage in unrelated business, but it's taxed on it and it can't account for a substantial amount of revenue. For instance, most Museums have gift shop, and selling stuffed animals isn't usually their charitable purpose, so the organization will typically pay tax on that revenue.

"A charity receives large amounts of tax-relief from the government for conforming to these rules."

True in the US -- non-profits don't pay income tax and donations are tax-deductible.

philipn··on YC Will Now Fund Nonprofits Too
Hmm, $10M/year seems a bit off. This (http://www.ssireview.org/articles/entry/how_nonprofits_get_r...) says the figure is $50M/year in revenue.
philipn··on PyPy.js Update: A Proof-of-Concept JIT
If an admin could update the URL to point to http://www.rfk.id.au/blog/entry/pypy-js-poc-jit/ (w/o the anchor) that would be awesome!
philipn··on Setup.py vs requirements.txt
I guess this is where I'm confused. Isn't this the same as using the '-e' switch inside of a requirements.txt?
philipn··on Setup.py vs requirements.txt
You refer to dependency_links as a "misfeature," but I'm wondering why?
philipn··on Releases – a workflow for shipping software to end users
Is there any way to add the release notes via a git commit? This is very nice, but it introduces further dependence on GitHub if something like that isn't possible. I suppose as long as there's API access someone could / will write an exporter, though. Anyway, great stuff either way!
philipn··on Mark Shuttleworth: Canonical leads Ubuntu, not 'your whims'
Complete linkbait title, a HN mod should change this. Typical of the Register.

It's worthwhile to read the actual post:

http://www.markshuttleworth.com/archives/1228

On the subject, I started to hear a lot of criticism of Canonical's Ubuntu efforts right around when Unity was first released. I just updated to 12.10 on my laptop a couple of weeks ago, and as one of the 31337 d00ds Mark speaks of, I was pretty confused -- everything was different! I didn't quite understand the point of the whole thing.

But I run a tiling window manager on a years-old Thinkpad without even a trackpad (trackpoint!). I'm a freak. And most of us here are.

Then the other day I picked up a new Macbook Air for some Mac-centric development work. And Unity completely clicked for me. If you look at the direction of OS X it's clearly converging with iOS. I right-swipe to get notifications! There's all these awesome gestures! My IM client shows my phone's text messages, for god's sake!

This is the kind computing experience normal people are expecting over the next several years, and in order for Ubuntu to fully realize its mission it needs to adapt. And it looks like they're doing a really good job. I mean, have you seen the Ubuntu phone videos? It looks really slick.

philipn··on Django 1.5 released
I develop a new, serious, widely-used platform and I love Django. I've definitely been around the block, have developed python-based web apps without frameworks, etc.

I've never had an issue with Django being inflexible. The strong conventions and the fact I don't have to make a decision about every little thing makes me, and the ecosystem, more productive.

philipn··on Introducing Contributions
Hmm, but once they hit master they will be back-dated as contributions for that time period?
philipn··on Introducing Contributions
Very cool! I used calendaraboutnothing /extensively/ - it was a hugely important motivational tool for me.

Unfortunately, it doesn't look like this counts contributions to non-master branches? I work mostly in branches and my calenderaboutnothing streaks were much longer.

philipn··on Mark Zuckerberg donates $500 million
You're right - updated comment
philipn··on Mark Zuckerberg donates $500 million
Silicon Valley Community Foundation is a Community Foundation (in contrast to a Private Foundation), which means that they manage lots of different pools of money from different sources. It also means that donations to them are tax-deductible in the exact same way it is with other charities[1].

I'm not familar with the specifics of the Silicon Valley Community Foundation, but it looks like SV Community Foundation, similar to most Community Foundations, does a lot of work managing what are known as donor-advised funds. Check out this Wikipedia page for some good info:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Donor_advised_fund

1. Private Foundations have a few different rules in place, including lower maximum deductibility for donors, required 5% funds disbursement to charitable organizations, etc. Check out this link for a comparison http://www.programforgiving.org/charitable/pages/considering...

philipn··on Mark Zuckerberg donates $500 million
Community Foundations[1] such as the Silicon Valley Community Foundation can receive stock donations that are tax-deductible to the owner. If the donation was in dollars it would also be deductible for the owner, but the owner would need to sell the stock first, which would mean paying capital gains taxes.

1. Differences between Community Foundations / donor-advised funds and Private Foundations can be found here: http://www.programforgiving.org/charitable/pages/considering...

← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →