HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

philwelch

36,564 karma · joined March 23, 2009

submissionscomments
philwelch··on Schools Never Taught Critical Thinking: AI Exposed the Lie
We may not have AGI yet (“artificial general intelligence”, AI equivalent to a human), but we sure have AGI (“artificial Guardian intelligence”, AI equivalent to The Guardian).

Corollary: since self-driving isn’t a solved problem yet, this proves that cab drivers are already smarter than the Guardian.

philwelch··on GitHub Stacked PRs
You can review PR’s commit by commit, and you can ask people to review PR’s commit by commit. Not a big deal.
philwelch··on GitHub Stacked PRs
Not at all. One of the tricks of using AI is context management and managing the Git history yourself can be a big part of that. If the AI has a stupid idea and implements it, even when you tell it, “that was a stupid idea, don’t do that, change it back”, the history could persist and the stupid idea will poison the context window every time an agent reads the commit history. It’s even worse if you had the stupid idea!

Also, my current workflow actually has hooks to block agents from creating or changing commits. I know at some point this will be a limit to scaling, but I think that will result in me spending more rather than less time in git.

philwelch··on GitHub Stacked PRs
Squashing is fine if you’re just making a mess of temporary commits as you work and you don’t want to keep any of those changes separate in master, but that’s not a useful review workflow. A lot of times I’ve built a feature in a way that decomposed naturally into e.g. two commits: one to do a preparatory refactor (which might have a lot of noisy and repetitive changes, like changing a function signature) and another to actually change the behavior. You want those changes to be separate because it makes the changes easier to review; the reviewer quickly skims the first commit, observes that it’s a mechanical refactor, and the change in behavior has its own, smaller commit without all the noise.

“What if there’s feedback and you need to make changes after the code review?” Then I do the same thing I did before I posted the code review: make separate “fixup” commits and do an interactive rebase to squash them into my commits. (And yes, I do validate that the intermediate commits build cleanly.)

There’s nothing you get from stacked PR’s that you don’t also get from saying “please review my feature branch commit by commit”.

philwelch··on Apple update looks like Czech mate for locked-out iPhone user
No but they might be able to fix authentication problems, which is what this is.
philwelch··on Apple update looks like Czech mate for locked-out iPhone user
Jobs was a perfectionist and a minimalist. Part of minimalism is that sometimes you delete marginal features (arrow keys) that you still end up wanting back.

If you never delete too many features, you aren’t deleting enough features.

philwelch··on US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ban unconstitutional
You’re right, it’s much easier to replace the entire federal bureaucracy.
philwelch··on US appeals court declares 158-year-old home distilling ban unconstitutional
You’re confusing a few of the issues here. This isn’t an interstate commerce case, it’s a tax power case, which does reflect on the NFA but not on Wickard v Filburn or civil rights. The important aspects of federal civil rights law aren’t legally justified by the commerce clause either.

Though I would gladly see Wickard v Filburn overturned. Commercial regulations already vary by state, and the US would still be more cohesive than the EU is today, but the amount of water that flows through my showerhead doesn’t have to be a concern of the federal government. In fact, we don’t even need Wickard v Filburn to be a more cohesive federation than Canada, which doesn’t even have free trade between provinces.

philwelch··on AI Will Be Met with Violence, and Nothing Good Will Come of It
There isn’t really a shortage of money for those things, just rampant levels of fraud, corruption, and incompetence in the government to make those things artificially expensive. California spends so much money on high speed rail and gets 0 feet of track because they’re not paying for track; the whole thing is a scam where the politicians give taxpayer money to their political supporters in exchange for political support. Defense isn’t immune to this either; Boeing, which builds a shitty heavy lift rocket out of Space Shuttle spare parts and delivers it late and over budget, pulls the exact same bullshit with their defense contracts, and there’s always some shitty Senator siding with them against the American people whenever anyone gets upset.
philwelch··on AI Will Be Met with Violence, and Nothing Good Will Come of It
Coding is one thing that is genuinely more enjoyable with AI than without it. It’s a different (but overlapping) skill set, but my median AI sessions remind me of the most exhilarating design discussions I’ve had with colleagues, and I get a lot more done more quickly than I used to.

Customer support is kind of something you can use AI for; most companies will foist you off to some system of exchanging written messages, which is annoying, but then you can use an AI to write your side of the conversation. It’s ill-mannered to do this when you’re interacting with actual people, but customer support is another story.

> Look at Suno. Fantastic tool, but where was the capital need to make music generation so cheap that no musician could ever compete with it? Did the world really wake up one day and concluded that, "wait, we're spending too much on musicians"?

People didn’t know what LLMs would be capable of until after they were invented. Cheap music generation turned out to be easy once we had cheap text generation, and cheap text generation turned out to be a tractable problem.

philwelch··on AI Will Be Met with Violence, and Nothing Good Will Come of It
What a load of pointless handwringing.
philwelch··on Artemis II safely splashes down
So someone who can barely walk is supposed to safely jump from a space capsule to a boat in the middle of the ocean?
philwelch··on Artemis II safely splashes down
“Stepping” from one vessel to another in the middle of the ocean is not like getting on your buddy’s sailboat at the marina even if you have your sea legs. Astronauts don’t even have their earth legs when they splash down; when they return from ISS they can’t even walk right away, though Artemis was a shorter duration mission than that.
philwelch··on Artemis II safely splashes down
This is the same mission where the commander radioed to Houston, “I have two Microsoft Outlooks, and neither one of those are working”.
philwelch··on Artemis II safely splashes down
If we got to a point where going to the Moon was significantly safer than that, we’d better start trying things even more ambitious and risky or we’ll stagnate as a species. The fatality rates for circumnavigating the globe or settling in North America or attempting to invent a working flying machine were much, much higher than that.
philwelch··on Copilot edited an ad into my PR
It's because of the way companies align their own behavior. "Listening to feedback" is just a good intention but increasing engagement with copilot is a measurable goal. With apologies to George Orwell, imagine an OKR stamping on a human face--forever.
philwelch··on AI overly affirms users asking for personal advice
Working as intended

Most people who ask for advice actually want affirmation. If you ever give them advice instead of affirmation, you end up kicking off a rousing game of “Why Don’t You/Yes But”. (https://ericberne.com/games-people-play/why-dont-you-yes-but...)

philwelch··on Migrating to the EU
A few years ago I got annoyed at Google and switched to Apple Maps. Earlier this year I got annoyed with Apple Maps and tried Google Maps again before switching back. Point of interest data was a minor factor in all of this. It might be enough to lock me into using Google to find local businesses I didn’t know about before, but that doesn’t force me to use Google Maps for turn by turn navigation.
philwelch··on Migrating to the EU
This is a lot simpler if you own a personal domain name. You’re still going to have pain setting that up the first time, but afterwards any future migrations will be much easier.
philwelch··on The future of version control
I can definitely relate to that, and I'm actually quite fond of git myself. I just never expected that people would stop trying to make a better version control system. That's not entirely fair, a lot of work has been invested in Pijul and Fossil, but I would have expected much more interest in alternatives. I remember all of the reasons Git was so new and exciting at the time, but now it feels like we're all locked into it, not out of any deliberate attempt at vendor lockin but out of complacency, and because fewer and fewer of us still remember a time that it felt possible to invent a better version control system.
philwelch··on The future of version control
Regardless of the merits of CRDT's, I'm just glad someone is finally trying to create a new version control system. Everyone loves to complain about Git but nobody's actually tried to move beyond it in two decades.
philwelch··on Afroman found not liable in defamation case
Yes, this sort of thing has been a plague against the English language for a few years now, responsible for such ugly constructions as "to unalive".

(I understand and respect the linguists who would maintain a descriptivist view of this sort of thing, but I'm not a linguist and I'm not required to suspend my aesthetic opinions whenever an ugly fashion rears its head.)

philwelch··on Wayland set the Linux Desktop back by 10 years?
Hey at least they finished Perl 6!
philwelch··on Afroman found not liable in defamation case
"PDF" is a zoomer euphemism for "pedophile".
philwelch··on Afroman found not liable in defamation case
To be fair, this raises an interesting question of epistemology. Can any man know for sure that his wife has never had sex with Afroman? It's almost always possible, however unlikely. One can and probably should trust that his wife hasn't had sex with Afroman, but it's rarely possible to be absolutely certain.
philwelch··on Polymarket gamblers threaten to kill me over Iran missile story
Ballistic missiles are pretty expensive. You'd have to bid a lot of money for it to be worthwhile to shoot them at a country just to make money on Polymarket.

If there was a prediction market for whether I'll be hit by a car tomorrow, and it was lucrative enough that it would actually be worth anyone's time to deliberately hit me with a car, I'd stay home and bid on "no". Pretty sure I'd make more than enough to cover the cost of ordering pizza.

There are already perverse incentives to commit arson, like insurance. And it's entirely possible that prediction markets can make insurance even more cost-effective.

philwelch··on Polymarket gamblers threaten to kill me over Iran missile story
> Are you gonna tell me residents in Tel Aviv will be able to hedge their chances of surviving tomorrow?

Yes, of course! If you had some advance warning your home town was likely to be struck with missiles soon, are you seriously saying you can't think of a single thing you could do to prepare? I would, at a minimum, make sure I was stocked up on first aid supplies, water, and food that I could eat without needing power or gas to cook it.

philwelch··on Hollywood Enters Oscars Weekend in Existential Crisis
They might have been in the last decade, but now it’s just yet another franchise audiences have stopped caring about.
philwelch··on Hollywood Enters Oscars Weekend in Existential Crisis
They have no one to blame but themselves, judging by the quality of Hollywood movies in recent years.
philwelch··on No leap second will be introduced at the end of June 2026
You make a good argument for the opposite of your conclusion. If you’re planning a system that’s supposed to last for millennia, that system shouldn’t depend on the fiat of the International Earth Rotation and Reference Systems Service.
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →