HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

physarum_salad

119 karma · joined July 23, 2025

submissionscomments
physarum_salad··on Sustainable memristors from shiitake mycelium for high-frequency bioelectronics
Most wet organic or biological materials will produce memristive (pinched hysteresis) IV curves when measured with macroelectrodes (1–20 mm contact scale) due to inherent interfacial electrochemistry, ion migration, or redox processes at the electrode-tissue interface.

Macroscale memristivity is an artifact of slow interfacial kinetics sampled over large diffusion volumes. Shrink electrodes below ~100 µm → hysteresis vanishes.

Dry biological materials almost never show true memristive (pinched, history-dependent) IV curves at any electrode scale (macro or micro) under standard DC sweeps. The reasons are structural and physicochemical—drying eliminates the ionic mobility that sustains memory.

physarum_salad··on Tim Bray on Grokipedia
The best source is the one that provides the widest breadth of information on a topic.

This is a good use of wikipedia: "Like, if there's a subject about which you aren't personally an expert, and you have the choice between reading a single review paper you found on Google or the Wikipedia page, which are you going to choose?"

But that is like skim reading or basic introductions rather than in-depth understanding.

physarum_salad··on Sustainable memristors from shiitake mycelium for high-frequency bioelectronics
How is this related to that at all? The fungi they used are clearly dead...
physarum_salad··on Tim Bray on Grokipedia
"Warts and all" says it all really. What are those warts? Who's responsibility are they?

Wikipedia is really not ideal for the LLM age where multiple perspectives can be rapidly generated. There are many topics where clusters of justified true beliefs and reasonable arguments may ALL be valid surrounding a certain topic. And no I am not talking about "flat earth" pages or other similar nonsense.

physarum_salad··on Sustainable memristors from shiitake mycelium for high-frequency bioelectronics
Preserved through dehydration? This means the fungus is dead.
physarum_salad··on Tim Bray on Grokipedia
"Wikipedia, in my mind, has two main purposes: A quick visit to find out the basics about some city or person or plant or whatever, or a deep-dive to find out what we really know about genetic linkages to autism or Bach’s relationship with Frederick the Great or whatever."

Completely agree with the first purpose but would never use wikipedia for the second purpose. Its only good at basics and cannot handle complex information well.

physarum_salad··on Scientists can't define consciousness, yet we think AI will have it
The only successful experiments probing consciousness are in anaesthesia or psychedelics. Everything else is wonderful but theoretical.
physarum_salad··on Sustainable memristors from shiitake mycelium for high-frequency bioelectronics
Was the fungus alive or dead? How did the memristive curve change depending on viability? Are all biological materials alive or dead memristors? In this case what is it about the property of the IV curves that is so ubiquitous? Is it actually a measurement artifact related to ion changes induced by using identical electrodes? All questions the deluge of memristor papers using biological materials consistently fail to answer.
physarum_salad··on Sustainable memristors from shiitake mycelium for high-frequency bioelectronics
That is because it is cool theoretically but not useful in practice. Every organic material is a memristor and even good memristors are not scalable.

RRAM resistive switching is the far more useful property and this has already been investigated extensively.

physarum_salad··on We do not have sufficient links to the UK for Online Safety Act to be applicable
You are discussing the possibility of a transit arrest for merely hosting a network for free and open-source software projects? No big deal? LOL
physarum_salad··on Testosterone Administration Induces a Red Shift in Democrats
Hilarious and also a great example of how stupid peer review is.
physarum_salad··on Surveillance data challenges what we thought we knew about location tracking
Well its always funny to observe politicians/other VIPs use similar technologies to the most "loopy" prepper when they need to. Like actual faraday/signal jamming tents during negotiations or similar.
physarum_salad··on Making sure AI serves people and knowledge stays human
We should have access to a Borges/Thomas Pynchon style dictionary of many possible paths to information. That kind of thinking should be encouraged. It can be confusing and controversial.

- I would avoid giving the impression that a simplified narrative is established (unless it won a nobel or is really beyond any reasonable doubt).

- End the use of "controversy" sections where it is used to minimise the impact of perfectly acceptable science. This is clearly used as a tactic in certain instances to minimise results.

- Allow for mixed expert, AI, conventional editing. There is nothing wrong or elitist with including edited articles by academic experts as cut outs of a particular topic. Almost like if scholarpedia and wikipedia were merged.

- Try to combat omission biases. There are some pretty wild ones on wikipedia.

- New results should be handled properly in terms of editing and language.

- Reproduce multiple versions of the same text to show how it would be different if certain hypothesis/experimental results were valid. This is easy to do if using LLMs.

physarum_salad··on Making sure AI serves people and knowledge stays human
What's ur opinion on adult neurogenesis? Do you think the progression of that article suggests that wikipedia is the model to follow for scientific information?

What about important and controversial historical events? Do you think that wikipedia omitting information is acceptable?

Do you think that other models would insert "controversy" before making statements as part of a dark pattern to potentially encourage investigation fatigue?

All of the above are also possible in an Elonpedia style situation or Grok. I never said it will be absolutely BETTER.

physarum_salad··on Making sure AI serves people and knowledge stays human
Academics with diverging views just started editing wikipedia to suit their views and the whole thing was very preliminary and not accurate for a long time. Then it was bailed into a "controversial" section. I intentionally picked a mild example lol.
physarum_salad··on Making sure AI serves people and knowledge stays human
Yes but with AI, in principle, there is more wriggle room to present a spectrum of opinions on a single topic. It is all about what is baked into the models. Like can it discuss x topic from multiple competing angles and capture the complexity. That is important for history, politics, medicine, science and so on. This does not currently happen on many wikipedia pages in these domains imo.

Narrative engineering with AI is a pretty scary prospect so I can see how the wikipedia model with genuinely random human editors might have a major advantage there. If it is simply a vanity project, and not an uncensored Grok model, then obviously it would be garbage and hilariously biased.

physarum_salad··on Making sure AI serves people and knowledge stays human
Definitely not! It will be better on certain topics and worse on others. It is all down to whether you think Grok is more thorough with controversial topics, scientific and medical information, etc compared with the current human edit-a-thon on wikipedia.

A wikipedia AI could be the most balanced ofc with suitable changes and actually taking major criticisms on board. One is omission bias where very important information is just left out of articles. Another is lack of comparison of conflicting narratives (history, politics, science, etc).

physarum_salad··on Making sure AI serves people and knowledge stays human
For example, the page on Adult neurogenesis had an overreliance on early and limited evidence in 2010s with lots of editing wars occurring by academics. Then it got shifted to "controversial" which is better but the process for dealing with new scientific results is not ideal.
physarum_salad··on Making sure AI serves people and knowledge stays human
It is a great example of "objectivism" where on the surface it seems neutral and rational but actually is the subject of intense motivations that corrupt the content. This is particularly true for anything related to politics, history, nation states, celebrity tech bros, and so on. An average article on "the history of bicycles" is not a problem and not what I am referring to ofc.

For a different reason it is host to a wide range of superficial treatments of scientific and medical information. Which is not ideal. See scholarpedia for a better alternative for this kind of information (although its not well populated).

physarum_salad··on Making sure AI serves people and knowledge stays human
scholarpedia is the best because it has almost zero biography pages/knuckleheaded political slants. However, it seems to have just have stopped in its tracks c. 2008
physarum_salad··on Making sure AI serves people and knowledge stays human
Yes, I am interested to see if Grokpedia can live up to the initial hype. As much as I dislike wikipedia it is a difficult thing to get right. In particular where lots of political and business interests (and others, etc) apply pressure to manicure pages. With everyone banning everyone they don't like it may just turn into another boring partisan internet split.
physarum_salad··on Imgur pulls out of UK as data watchdog threatens fine
Yeah let us find random ways, that we never used to care about, to ban all foreign websites so a "brit" can take over haha. This is quite authoritarian and corporatist and worthy of some criticism from more libertarian minded onlookers.
physarum_salad··on Imgur pulls out of UK as data watchdog threatens fine
Hopefully many more companies do this and British internet users migrate to use of VPNs. This will apply maximum pressure on the government to reverse these parochial laws.
physarum_salad··on The Long Trip from Silica to Smartphone
"Computing with rocks"
physarum_salad··on How did we all miss the bacteria taking over her body?
Another option is to completely cover tick infested areas with suitable fungal spores: https://www.wur.nl/en/newsarticle/fungus-potential-viable-al...
physarum_salad··on How did we all miss the bacteria taking over her body?
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S002228362...

Bacteriophages might be an interesting approach to treating Lyme disease in future. Pretty speculative at this stage though and how do you even know the bacteria are there (as this article points out). Once detected how do you avoid the bacteriophage causing an immune reaction, etc.

physarum_salad··on Meat is a leading emissions source–but few outlets report on it, analysis finds
"Food and agriculture"
physarum_salad··on Britain to introduce compulsory digital ID for workers
The "brit_card" is on your phone and you will carry it everywhere. It is also a walking surveillance beacon and hacking target.
physarum_salad··on Britain to introduce compulsory digital ID for workers
Yes, and this cultural attitude really goes way back, like since pre-1500s for England. Then throw Scotland and N.I. into the mix and there is absolutely no interest in this type of system...to put it mildly!
physarum_salad··on Ishkur's Guide to Electronic Music
Yeah I would find this more interesting than the current tags e.g. IDM which is such a nonsense/confusing term anyway.
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →