HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pigbucket

1,228 karma · joined February 26, 2010

submissionscomments
pigbucket··on Reddit is hiring. We're looking for 3 rockstar programmers.
>If you think it is too much to ask, well, I guess you just don't apply. <shrug>

This response seems to me thoughtless, cliche-ridden, and inordinately smug--rockstaresque even.

That "I guess you just don't apply" really doesn't seem to be the product of the thinking you claim to have put into this. Obviously there are people who might apply even if they think it's too much to ask on spec. Obviously there are people who might apply even if they are motivated by something other than mere fun. Obviously there are people who might apply even if it takes them a lot more than "a few joyful hours." Saying such people probably aren't the ones you're looking for is beside the point--beside the ethical point--except insofar as it's a pretty clearcut instance of your shirking all responsibility (it's all their fault if they underestimate their chances, or ignore the injunction to do it for fun) with the kind of callous indifference to the work and time of others captured neatly in your closing shrug.

Tl;dr? That wouldn't surprise me.

pigbucket··on A Classic 'Nontextbook' on Writing
> The chapter on revising is a seven-line excerpt of an interview with Ernest Hemingway

The underlying advice of that chapter is: rewrite 'till you've got the words right. The advice lying under the underlying advice is: don't ruin a simple message with a long water-filled chapter.

Interviewer: How much rewriting do you do?

Hemingway: It depends. I rewrote the ending of Farewell to Arms, the last page of it, thirty-nine times before I was satisfied.

Interviewer: Was there some technical problem there? What was it that had stumped you?

Hemingway: Getting the words right.

pigbucket··on Orson Scott Card: How 'Friend' Became a Verb
>"Friend" (the noun) has become "friend" (the verb). Hence, his usage is correct.

My comment was about the disparity between the title and the substance of the article, not about usage. Sorry for the confusion. But since you've got me typing again, one thing about the substance. Card is right to say historians have little to worry about, but the old hand-written letters, especially when written by the likes of Henry James, have always been more than grist for the historian's mill. They became in some cases a genuine art form. I think that is one of the things lost in the transition to electronic communication: a peculiar kind of intimate art form. Other art forms have risen to take their place: the art of the blog, the art of the 140-character witticism, but not, as far as I can tell, the art of the email--at least not if you discount the humorous trolls. It was surprising to me that Card, as a novelist, didn't address that.

pigbucket··on Orson Scott Card: How 'Friend' Became a Verb
Next time the author should write an article about how "friend" became a verb.
pigbucket··on Beekeeper Who Leaked EPA Documents: "I Don't Think We Can Survive This Winter"
I think you're close enough here to the presupposition of both my comments above as makes no difference.

That's why I said the EFED recommendations were too weak; that's why I called it an 'inadequate response.' Let me say it again explicitly: A warning is not good enough. Let me clarify again the original point: The real scandal here is that EFED thinks a warning is good enough.

pigbucket··on Beekeeper Who Leaked EPA Documents: "I Don't Think We Can Survive This Winter"
I think you're thinking that a bee precautionary label would say something like "Warning: Dangerous to Bees," in which case non-beekeeping farmers might not care. I suspect the label would instead mandate that users apply the product in a prescribed manner in order to minimize drift (one of the known causes of toxicity to bees). Pesticides typically come with fairly detailed instructions for proper use. My point, though, was that mandating such a label, in this case, is still not an adequate response on the part of EFED to the problem.
pigbucket··on Beekeeper Who Leaked EPA Documents: "I Don't Think We Can Survive This Winter"
It makes a good story if you can spin this as a case of EPA ignoring its own scientists as evidenced by a leaked report. But what the report (a public document according to Theobald) actually recommends is not that the pesticide be denied registration, but that it should only be sold with a warning.

"EFED [Environmental Fate and Effects Division of the EPA]expects adverse effects to bees if clothianidin is allowed to drift from seed planting equipment. Because of this and the uncertainty surrounding the exposure and potential toxicity through contaminated pollen and nectar, EFED is recommending bee precautionary labeling."

Grist, Fast Company, and Wired have all gone with the "Leak Reveals EPA ignoring its own Scientists" story. But that story is nonsense and distracts from the real problem; namely, the fact that the so-called leak actually only recommends precautionary labeling. What really needs to be leaked is the memo that explains why EFED's recommendations are so weak in a case where high toxicity is known to occur.

pigbucket··on On writing (and law)
>maybe it is an issue of a poor title for the piece

The simple title of the HN submission works better for me than the original title.

pigbucket··on On writing (and law)
I had intended to applaud the author and assert that this was one of the few examples of essays on good writing that I've recently read that is also itself an example of good writing. So your critical comment comes as a surprise and a challenge, especially since I think you are right in a crucial respect: it would take a bit of work to isolate and evaluate specific actionable tips on writing well from the essay. But I read the essay in the first place as an exhortation to others to aspire to write well, to recognize the importance of writing well, to appreciate and confront the difficulty of it, and, indeed, to provide an example of it. In these respects, I think the essay has succeeded admirably, and in these respects, too, it is doing something that most essays on writing, including the ones that would well satisfy the criterion that you invoke, fall short.

I think one of the important, if implicit, ideas of the essay is that it's not possible to learn to write very well without being able to fix in your own mind an ideal representation of what good writing is against which to measure your own real efforts. Reading and recognizing the right examples can go a long way towards reaching that goal, and while the essay emphasizes the hard work of writing over the work of attentive reading, it nonetheless is the kind of essay that contributes, by virtue of its logical development and style, to my idea of what good writing is.

pigbucket··on What it's like to participate in Anonymous actions
It's an appropriate counterweight, I think, to the unmitigated and much too facile condescension that some have been indulging in lately.
pigbucket··on Anonymous stops dropping DDoS bombs, starts dropping science
The focus of a large portion of media coverage here in the United States since the cables were released has been on the political response to Wikileaks' action, on the allegations of Wikileaks' criminality, on the severing of ties with the organization by major corporations in response to Lieberman et al., and on Assange and his legal woes. All of that is newsworthy, but it has come at the cost of focusing on the stories told by the cables themselves. The things said and done by US agents, in the name of the American people, have been, to judge by the cables I've read, sometimes good, sometimes innocuous, and sometimes unconscionably unethical and criminal. I'm all in favor of any action that brings the focus back where it belongs, and tries to defeat what I suspect has been a deliberate, massive US campaign of noise and distraction, albeit a campaign that increasingly seems of a rather dated style. I'll be massively impressed if Anon can achieve anything close to those stated ends. I understand people's skepticism, and even the occasional condescension, but I'm not ready to dismiss a phenomenon I don't really understand just because the participants are unseasoned and untutored in the art of studied apathy.
pigbucket··on 16 year old arrested for DDOS attack on MasterCard in The Hague, The Netherlands
I'm going to take a little bite at this, because I think it's an important question, though I don't think it only applies in the case of your imagined modern definitions. Civil disobedience has never been limited to "we're accepting punishment for {x} to demonstrate that doing {x} should not be punished." In many cases, it has been "we're accepting punishment for {x} to demonstrate that doing {y} should not be punished, or to demonstrate that doing [z] should be punished or stopped or whatever." The scope has always been wide, and activists rarely staged illegal sit-ins, for example, just to demonstrate that sit-ins shouldn't be illegal. So the question you pose has wide relevance. You can start to come at the answer in a variety of ways, but perhaps the first if sometimes insufficient criterion of justifiable civil disobedience might be that the illegal protest action should aim at preventing greater harm than it causes, and it should be action against organizations that are significantly responsible for the harm you want to prevent. I think that criterion is satisfied in this case; that is, I think much greater harm is caused longterm by the permanent restriction of funding for Wikileaks than is caused by temporary DDoS'ing MC, Visa, and Paypal.
pigbucket··on 16 year old arrested for DDOS attack on MasterCard in The Hague, The Netherlands
The boy has confessed. He's still entitled to put on a defense, I take it. And he's still entitled to seek support for that defense. In any case, you can break the law, and then argue, in certain places and circumstances, and without self-contradiction (which I suppose would be the possibility you find problematic) that you shouldn't be punished because a) the law is unjust or unconstitutional, or b) breaking the law was necessary to prevent greater harm (though if I recall correctly the latter defense by necessity is not permitted in most cases of civil disobedience in the US).
pigbucket··on Parsing the impact of Anonymous
>All people are foolish in a lot of things.

>Stop generalizing.

I'm not saying anything. I'm just quoting.

pigbucket··on Paypal.com appears to be unavailable
If you dominate a market, a serious ethical duty devolves upon you to do right by your customers, but Paypal, Visa, and MC, on which donation-supported non-profit orgs like Wikileaks almost entirely depend, have utterly failed to fulfill that duty; in fact they didn't even try. Their actions, arbitrary or spineless, have almost completely choked off funding for Wikileaks. I never imagined ending up saying this, but I'm impressed and grateful that there exists an international, anonymous horde able to begin the process of making companies like this at least minimally answerable for their actions, which no one else seems capable or desirous of doing.
pigbucket··on Anonymous Ousted from Twitter and Facebook
Good examples indeed! Especially the one about Rosie Parks. Of all the possible examples in the history of the world of disrupting business operations in a way that inconveniences people, I can see why that one came first to mind. Perfect analogue for a DoS attack: Denial of Seat!. Brilliant!
pigbucket··on Visa.com Now Also Down Under DDoS
The stuff in parentheses that you cite refers to a crime like the crime of inciting subversion. Why ohyes says "we know he actually committed" such a crime, I don't know.
pigbucket··on US Sen. Joe Lieberman suggests NYT could be investigated for espionage
Accusing NYT of bad citizenship (Lieberman) is similar to accusing people of unAmerican activities (McCarthy).

Calling on companies to withdraw services from Wikileaks (Lieberman) is similar to calling on advertisers to withdraw support from Time magazine (McCarthy).

Overwrought, fear-mongering rhetoric (Lieberman) is similar to overwrought, fear-mongering rhetoric (McCarthy).

pigbucket··on Homeland Security Messages Coming to Wal Mart, etc.
My guess is that Walmart is more concerned about finding a cheap way to deal with its parking-lot crime problem, for which it has taken a lot of flak, than it is with national security. Finding a way to encourage vigilance on the part of customers while deflecting attention from the real threat (robbery, assault) seems as clever as it is cynical.
pigbucket··on Don't shoot the messenger for telling the truth
"For freedom of speech, there's Wikileaks. For everything else, there's Mastercard. And Visa. And, um, Paypal. And Amazon." -- James Ball, on twitter.
pigbucket··on Joe Lieberman Emulates Chinese Dictators
I think this is right. While it's amusing to note the apparent heterogeneity in responses from representatives of the state to the leaks (criminal! boring! dangerous! nothing new!), looked on as a strategy of noise generation to drown out the signal (i.e., revelations of criminal activity by the state), the approach is cohesive and effective, and it demonstrates unrestrained contempt for the American people.
pigbucket··on Two Conspiracy Theories
Re: 1. The only reference in the Wikipedia entry to the pressuring of the German govt. by the US consists of this line: "On February 6, 2007, U.S. officials warn the German Government not to issue international warrants." This line was added to the article a few days ago. Its cited source is a document leaked by Wikileaks.

Re: 2. According to Harpers, and its reading of El Pais and Público, what's newly revealed by the released cables is "a large-scale, closely coordinated effort by the State Department to obstruct ... criminal investigations"

Re: 3. Espionage may be expected, even accepted. What is or should be embarrassing for the US is its employment of State Dept. diplomats for the purpose of espionage.

pigbucket··on Two Conspiracy Theories
#1 Sounds plausible, but I know nothing of it; 60% confidence seems a little high to me on conspiracy theory # 2, at least with respect to the following leaked items, which are perhaps not especially surprising, but are a little more than "baaarely embarrassing":

1. US pressuring Germany not to pursue criminal investigation of US agents' kidnapping and torture of German national (who happened to be innocent, but that's not especially relevant)

http://harpers.org/archive/2010/11/hbc-90007831

2. US allegedly obstructing Spanish investigations of torture of Spanish subjects at Gitmo and use of Spanish facilities for extraordinary rendition program.

http://harpers.org/archive/2010/12/hbc-90007836

3. US diplomats spying on foreign diplomats, including the UN Sec. Gen., (although some do seem to think this is all de rigueur).

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2010/nov/28/us-embassy-cable...

pigbucket··on Amazon speaks up about WikiLeaks decision
Amazon is making two claims of ToS violations: 1. "WikiLeaks doesn’t own or otherwise control all the rights to [the] classified content the material" 2. Use of Wikileaks content could "cause injury to [some] person or entity"

The claims have some merit and Amazon has the right to discontinue service on the basis of ToS violations. But they seem to be applying, in the first instance, the same criterion to this case as they would to ordinary cases of copyright infringements, which seems ethically weak and a little outlandish. And while the second claim is at least superficially more compelling, the standard seems unusually broad. Isn't it the case, if only trivially, that Amazon already hosts and sells a lot of content that could conceivably be used by someone, somewhere to cause injury to some person or entity? In general, is the content provider absolutely responsible for the uses to which its content is put, and does Amazon really want to be in the business of policing that? The argument, presumably, is that Wikileaks' documents constitute an egregious and specific possible cause of injury, although Amazon still seems to be blurring the distinction between "causing" and "making possible" or "enabling", and discounting the possible good that the release of classified documents can do. I think it's also worth pointing out that Wikileaks has adopted a fairly heavy hand with regard to redactions in the past months, and asked Amnesty and the Pentagon (apparently in vain) to help in that process. Some minimal context for Wikileaks' actions and the Amazon message, not all of which throws the best possible light on Wikileaks:

http://www.salon.com/news/opinion/glenn_greenwald/2010/08/20...

http://articles.cnn.com/2010-10-22/us/wikileaks.editing_1_wi...

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2010/aug/10/afghanistan-war-...

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/11...

pigbucket··on Missing the point of WikiLeaks
See also the author's earlier articulate, intelligent, and naturally controversial defense of Wikileaks, which depends on the crucial distinction between the (more or less) permanent state apparatus (whose agents are unelected and whose actions are often secret) and the temporary government power, vested in the US in elected representatives, which imperfectly harnesses it. It ends with this:

"Of course, those jealously protective of the privileges of unaccountable state power will tell us that people will die if we can read their email, but so what? Different people, maybe more people, will die if we can't."

http://www.economist.com/blogs/democracyinamerica/2010/11/ov...

pigbucket··on Inside the Fortified, Nuke-Proof Bunker that's Now Hosting Wikileaks
"...one wonders why Swedish Bahnhof would take on the challenge of hosting a site that will probably be under permanent attack for the foreseeable future.

Unless it's for the PR value"

That's a good example of allowing one's imagination of possibilities to wander over very short distances. Is it that inconceivable that a company might be motivated by something other than the bottom line? Arvinjoar commented earlier on the principled character of the Bahnhof's founder: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1959961

pigbucket··on Wikileaks kicked out of Amazon's cloud
The Pentagon has claimed that they could have shut Wikileaks down if they wanted to, but decided not to, reserving "that capability for threats of much higher consequence." Generally, the rhetoric coming out of the Pentagon is not nearly as charged as that emanating from overwrought, fear-mongering senators like Lieberman

Senator Lieberman: "WikiLeaks' illegal, outrageous, and reckless acts have compromised our national security and put lives at risk around the world. No responsible company—whether American or foreign—should assist WikiLeaks in its efforts to disseminate these stolen materials."

Secretary of Defense Gates: "Is this embarrassing? Yes. Is it awkward? Yes. Consequences for U.S. foreign policy? I think fairly modest."

Pentagon Press Sec.: "At the end of the day, as you heard from the Secretary of Defense yesterday ... this creates some awkward and embarrassing situations for the United States government, it clearly puts those who cooperate with us, even some of our diplomats, in difficult positions (hopefully not endangered situations). But, at the end of the day, it does not, at least over the long term, adversely impact America’s power or prestige."

pigbucket··on WikiLeaks Founder Added To The Interpol Wanted List
>he should certainly return to Sweden to stand trial.

He hasn't been charged with anything.

pigbucket··on Ask HN: What are the top HN posts of all time?
Following re google's new china policy got >1k

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1048800

pigbucket··on WikiLeaks Will Unveil Major Bank Scandal in Early 2011
Wikileaks takes some time to assess stuff before releasing it. That's probably not a bad thing, despite the boredom of anticipation. The general reason for the delay is dealt with in the first question in the interview (to which the article links).

Forbes: To start, is it true you’re sitting on [a] trove of unpublished documents?

Julian Assange: Sure. That’s usually the case. As we’ve gotten more successful, there’s a gap between the speed of our publishing pipeline and the speed of our receiving submissions pipeline. Our pipeline of leaks has been increasing exponentially as our profile rises, and our ability to publish is increasing linearly.

← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →