HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pinkmuffinere

3,655 karma · joined August 8, 2021

I like engineering, finance, and tech. My biggest project (as part of a team) is stingray resistant booties: https://mydragonskin.com/
submissionscomments
pinkmuffinere··on The Leaked Audit That Exposes OpenAI's Real Financial Crisis [video]
This is extremely low effort content. How did this get 14 points?
pinkmuffinere··on Reasons robotics is hard
Ahhhh, that makes sense, that is an interesting point — I think you’re saying it’s just not high risk enough for them to make sure it’s got coverage
pinkmuffinere··on Reasons robotics is hard
Ya, this does strike me as pretty high on the list of the thing I'd intentionally seek out if I was doing this job, along with object-in-the-road, icy road, tornado/hurricane, wildfire, and perhaps hail.
pinkmuffinere··on Reasons robotics is hard
I think the fact that there are laws about it is not good evidence that it should be in the training data. Laws often cover weird edge cases, and if an edge case happens 50 times in 100 years, there's likely a law covering it. At the same time, that's probably not enough occurrences for it to naturally end up in a dataset -- the edge case would probably need to be intentionally sought out. I'm not saying that driving-in-deep water only happens 50 times in 100 years, it's certainly more common than that, I'm just saying that despite laws on the topic, it may still be too rare to be well represented in training data. For example, in real life I've only seen a car drive into deep water once. Even if we include recordings that I've seen, that would maybe bring it up to 20?
pinkmuffinere··on Invisible Companies
My family is Persian and I grew up in Turkey. You definitely develop an appreciation for carpets, and it's sooooooo heartbreaking to see people use art as an entryway rug, simply because they don't know :(
pinkmuffinere··on Reasons robotics is hard
> I am confused at how Waymo engineering can be so robust as to yield an astonishingly good safety record, and yet so slapdash as to happily drive into deep water.

I feel this is actually somewhat straightforward. I assume deep water on roadways is not commonly in the training set, because frankly it isn't common in real life, and when it is common people do not drive and do not gather that training data. As a result the proper response has not adequately been beaten into the models. There are probably also challenges of world-sensing, since water can act as a mirror, and maybe other complications. So waymos are bad at handling deep water on roadways. However, deep water on roadways is also not common in the areas where waymos are deployed. As a result, waymo's have a great safety record, and at the same time they make mistakes that are obvious to a human.

A common criticism of AI discourse is that people act as if LLM's "think". I don't want to be a vocabulary purist, but I suspect that's related to the astonishment here -- the Waymo doesn't know what flooding is, it doesn't fear drowning, it doesn't think. So unless it's been repeatedly trained, or a special case has been hard coded by manual effort, it doesn't know that flooded roadways are dangerous.

I have made a lot of assumptions here, and I don't truthfully know what the training data looks like. Feel free to push back if you think my assumptions are wrong. I'd especially be interested if somebody can show that water on roadways _is_ in the training data

pinkmuffinere··on How accurate have Ed Zitron's AI skeptic predictions been?
Upon further thought, I realized this should be counted as a correct prediction for Zitron! Zitron did indeed “keep writing this stuff until…proven wrong”. Zitron’s prediction says nothing about what happens after being proven wrong.
pinkmuffinere··on Evidence of Fraud in an Influential Study About Procrastination
I think you're right that this will be the most common objection, but wrong that it will be exceedingly difficult to find an advisor that would support this. I assume that if you _can_ overturn some foundational result, you won't face criticism over novelty (potentially you can argue that overturning important accepted results is inherently novel). Then the rest is just math:

Assume that n% of foundational studies are demonstrably incorrect if replication were attempted. Then if you replicate X foundational studies, there's a 1 - (1-n/100)^X chance that you'll show one foundational study to be incorrect. Then I think you just need to find an advisor who believes the incorrectness rate n, and the replication attempts X is high enough for you to revert a foundational study over the course of your PhD.

pinkmuffinere··on How accurate have Ed Zitron's AI skeptic predictions been?
> February 2025: "I will keep writing this stuff until I’m proven wrong." Wrong (Zitron continues to write despite repeatedly being proven wrong)

Lol, I appreciate the sprinkling of well timed humor in an article that is mostly straightforward facts and analysis.

pinkmuffinere··on Evidence of Fraud in an Influential Study About Procrastination
On the other hand, this seems like a super interesting path for an (unglamorous) PhD -- replicate the N most important findings in a field, subject to some restrictions (maybe focus on the ones that are "easy", or haven't been replicated yet, or the ones that could be patched together to make an acceptable PhD thesis). This sort of stuff really appeals to me, I think I might end up doing something like that in 5-10 years.
pinkmuffinere··on Ex-Crips leader found guilty in 1996 murder of rapper Tupac Shakur
Wow, it sounds like he admitted to it on a talk show at least 7 years ago, and wrote about it in a book [0]! Can't believe it took this long.

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x3uoB8zvLdI

edit: just watched the youtube video in full, and it isn't an admission. It's just discussing the shooting in general, and he puts blame on others.

pinkmuffinere··on Lion-man
Ya, I tend to agree. I think I personally have spent 9 weeks of effort on gifts for 2-3 people in my lifetime, and I don't even have kids yet.
pinkmuffinere··on Lion-man
> > The basic shaping is estimated to have taken around 200 hours, and in total the recreation likely took more than 370 hours.

> Nearly a year of "full time" work at 40hrs/week went into this

Sorry, I think you may be mistaken? From the section you quote, it looks like it's about 370 hours, or 9 weeks of full time effort. That's still a lot, but certainly not nearly a year.

pinkmuffinere··on Evidence of Fraud in an Influential Study About Procrastination
> The study seems extremely easy to replicate (no fancy equipment needed, just ask some people to proofread), and yet nobody did until now

They were just putting it off.

pinkmuffinere··on Our decision on Cursor following its acquisition by SpaceX
> We know that the people most affected by this decision are the developers who rely on OpenAI models in Cursor. We care about their experience in this transition and we’re ready to go above and beyond to support them.

Do I smell a cursor-analogue from openAI?

pinkmuffinere··on Small Models Have Arrived
I empathize, and I have the same preference, but I wonder how this interacts with other people (many of them being our coworkers) using LLMs. There is no authoritative source for the models to pull info from, so either people will have to exercise good judgement and double check important claims, or they will trust too blindly and fall close to the level of whatever LLM they use. In that case, I prefer my coworkers to use an LLM that does have world-knowledge -- I will still hear them spout ridiculous claims, but at least it should be less frequent. It strikes me there's a sort of prisoners dilemma here, where if nobody trusts others to critically evaluate info, it's in our interest to make the tooling do it instead, to whatever degree that is possible. Maybe I'm too cynical about working with others though.
pinkmuffinere··on Starbase, LA
I wonder how coastal they intend to be. They make a lot of claims about repairing the wetlands and coastal regions, but a lot of it is likely going to be underwater in the next 25 years because of rising sea levels [0], regardless of how many wetlands are repaired. And I suspect infrastructure like this probably has to be usable for something like 100 years to payoff. Maybe they're actually going to build inland, where the eventual coast will be?

[0] https://www.klfy.com/louisiana/interactive-map-shows-which-p...

pinkmuffinere··on Starbase, LA
somewhat topical video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O3dSjY4j7Ak

tl;dw -- louisiana has a ton of natural resources and wonderful harbors, but has allowed corporations to get away with almost anything without paying their fair share of taxes, cleaning up their waste, or generally being held accountable. And likely related, there is a long history of rampant corruption in the area. With sea levels rising and cancerous pollution filling densely populated areas, life in Louisiana has generally become very difficult :(

pinkmuffinere··on Canada will match US tariffs 'dollar for dollar' as trade talks break down
Are you saying PMI is a survey of 400 manufacturing executives about the status of manufacturing, and you don't think it carries meaningful signal about the status of manufacturing? I wonder what you think _would_ carry meaningful signal, if you're not satisfied by asking the people that are doing said manufacturing?
pinkmuffinere··on I like 'em thick: an apology to my English teachers
> this is an illusion. The ideas are not already good. They need to be thickened.

I think this is a good candidate to hang on the wall, or perhaps for a tattoo.

pinkmuffinere··on Norway should buy OpenAI
> Not only is the bar for being a competent government not particularly high on the world scale

This is such a ridiculous, preposterously self-confident claim. Claims like this give HN (and engineers in general) a bad reputation.

Edit: relevant xkcd https://xkcd.com/793/

pinkmuffinere··on GIMP Development Update
Autosave sounds nice, I’m excited to have that!

I appreciate the backwards compatibility they highlight in the article, and more generally the ownership oss gives you over your files. My small business uses gimp, canva, and Inkscape, and they all have their purpose, but one of the complaints we have with canva is that it’s really hard to get the original files backed up somewhere, aside from canva itself. You have to download each file individually , which is quite a pain (please correct me if there’s an easier way!). Gimps openness is an obvious path for oss, but really is a great feature. If the gimp team stops, we’ll still be able to edit our gimp files. If the canva team stops, we mostly lose all the canva stuff.

pinkmuffinere··on GIMP Development Update
From tfa

> A lot of new and existing contributors have submitted improvements to GIMP’s user interface and its user experience. We wanted to highlight their efforts, and encourage you all to continue sharing your feedback on our design issue tracker.

I see no active resistance. If you have feedback, maybe share it with them?

pinkmuffinere··on Google is making private AI practical with homomorphic encryption
Oh I see, you’re arguing that computer growth will make this more attractive. I think it’s a decent argument, although personally I find it unconvincing. More compute will be allocated between all the existing options, and I suspect it will go towards faster/better inference, instead of encryption. For most use cases people just don’t care much about encryption, and when feature prioritization comes around it always gets a back seat
pinkmuffinere··on Google is making private AI practical with homomorphic encryption
What, how is that relevant? the transistors on a microchip double about every two years. That’s descriptive, not prescriptive, so whatever you’re trying to imply about the future is kindof a toss up — there’s no promise the parents hold. And, it doesn’t really have to do with tfa, as far as I can tell? Do you perhaps mean Murphy’s law, “whatever can go wrong will go wrong”?
pinkmuffinere··on Grok 4.6 scores 61 on the Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index
> So you’re asserting that the ends justify the means or?

They claim that spacex has competitive advantage. They take no stance on condoning spacex’s behavior. Personally I strongly dislike musks behavior, but I appreciate discussion of competitive advantages/disadvantages, independent of moral views. I liked the thread, it adds new info to the conversation.

pinkmuffinere··on Depression has tripled in the last 15 years. Arthur Brooks about the cause
Just to be clear, I'm arguing that there _does_ appear to be evolutionary pressure here, so we probably will evolve in response. That argument doesn't require predicting how exactly we will evolve; you're kindof asking an orthogonal question. But I don't mind orthogonal questions, and I can imagine some ways that we might evolve in response:

1. Human reward-seeking becomes longer-term, with less of an emphasis on short term rewards. I'd bet this trend has probably already been ongoing for a long time. But I wonder if there are some negative effects of this -- for example perhaps it takes us longer to learn things that truly do have very quick, direct feedback loops. Maybe it takes us longer to learn how to walk, swim, etc as a result.

2. Screen-avoidant communities start to dominate the human population. Eg, Amish communities, "traditionalist" communities like that, your friends that religiously don't use social media, etc. I'd bet this is already happening too! Would be really interesting to look at the proportion of new births, perhaps controlling for usage of birth control. I wonder if this effect could result in humanity generally becoming more religious (as opposed to the recent trend of becoming less religious). Admittedly, this is more of a cultural change than a change in our dna, but I feel it fits the category -- it's a widespread change across humanity in response to the pressure of distracting apps.

3. Humans grow a stronger distaste for blue light. I suspect this wouldn't be the "end" state, because if it happens we'll probably just start buliding devices that put off less blue light.

pinkmuffinere··on Depression has tripled in the last 15 years. Arthur Brooks about the cause
Why not? The claim (which I believe is well supported) is that these things hijack some innate impulses to trap us in bad decisions. If you consistently make bad decisions (eg, put off developing your life) your line is less likely to continue.

This is just like animals that didn’t run from humans — they didn’t know to be scared of us and now they’re dead. Even massive things that could crush us can be killed if we slip through their defenses. The ones that survive are the ones that learn to fear the dangerous thing.

pinkmuffinere··on Depression has tripled in the last 15 years. Arthur Brooks about the cause
I 100% believe there is such an effect, and that it’s confounding the measurement of population level changes. But I want to point out that the existence of such an effect is not really evidence _against_ the changes, it’s just another confounder. Your wording is very accurate — you “consider it realistic that depression did not increase”, ie it is possible that depression didn’t increase. But whether depression actually did increase or actually didn’t, is not possible to determine from these numbers directly. Without controlling for confounders and doing some fun statistics, we largely just have opinions
pinkmuffinere··on Danish high schoolers will have to verbally defend written assignments
> We ask Master's students to give US instruction on a topic (drawn randomly on a card in front of them, from a list they know a few days in advance)

This is also an absolutely great way to ensure the participants really understand what they’re saying, even aside from ai-related concerns. You could always pull definitions straight from textbooks, and write something which mostly makes sense but that you don’t really understand. But you really can’t teach something unless you do understand it, imo. The best command I ever got on a topic was due to TA’ing

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →