HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

piotrkaminski

731 karma · joined October 2, 2013

I run https://reviewable.io. You can reach me at piotr at ideanest dot com.
submissionscomments
piotrkaminski··on I’m not a programmer, and I used AI to build my first bot
Are you not a programmer because you use a compiler and "paste" its output into the executable? Or an assembler, instead of flipping bits by hand in memory? Are people making complex spreadsheets with hundreds of formulas not programmers?

We've been raising the level of abstraction in code for decades and it looks like LLMs might just be the next level up. Yes, using LLMs will put more complex code within reach of more people but I'm sure it won't be nearly everyone, and I bet that it'll raise the ceiling of what the best programmers can do at the same time.

Of course, we're free to redefine what "programmer" means at any time as well, if a new definition proves to be more useful.

piotrkaminski··on Stop Arguing over Elite Schools. Just Make Public Colleges Free
> devalue the diploma from the public college

Huh? How so? If the only change is that you no longer need to pay for college, but otherwise admission standards and education quality remain the same, then why would the value of a diploma change? Unless the diploma was implicitly a signal for wealth, of course...

piotrkaminski··on Reorient GitHub pull requests around changesets
> That said, one of my favorite features from gerrit at a past job was that the commit message itself could be reviewed.

Reviewable lets you review your commit messages just like any other file, BTW! (Disclosure: I'm the founder.)

piotrkaminski··on Reorient GitHub pull requests around changesets
Most frequently, I think it's because you want a single platform to store all company code, but not all teams agree on using GitHub PRs vs a more advanced code review tool. Other potential reasons include having access to the other GitHub features: issues, actions, security stuff, the merge queue, etc. You could pull all these together from less-overpriced more-specialized alternatives, of course, but sometimes it's nice to have a single integrated platform even if you decide to replace one of its features.
piotrkaminski··on Reorient GitHub pull requests around changesets
I'm curious, are you allowed to name any folks using CodeCommit? I thought it wasn't particularly popular.
piotrkaminski··on Reorient GitHub pull requests around changesets
Here's how I like to think about it: GitHub is a generalist. They have a big platform with lots of features besides code review, so even though they also have lots of employees they won't be able to focus on code review as much as a dedicated company could. They also have a huge number of users to please so they can't afford to rock the boat too much or make the learning curve too steep.

I think therefore it's pretty much inevitable that if you need a more advanced code review tool you'll end up picking a third party one. Though admittedly, as the founder of Reviewable, that thinking does rather suit me too. ("It is difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary depends on his not understanding it" and all that. :D )

piotrkaminski··on US car giants gripped by history-making strike
So are you saying that car-making is a natural monopoly solely because of the unions? <half-joking>
piotrkaminski··on US car giants gripped by history-making strike
> it's difficult for new competitors to emerge

Counterpoint: Tesla, Fisker, Rivian, Lucid, Faraday Future, not to mention all the new Chinese brands that I don't follow. Difficult maybe but far from impossible, and not at all a natural monopoly.

piotrkaminski··on Tech workers now doubting decision to move from California to Texas
> It's not like the SF Bay Area where you have water, desert, mountains, etc all very close by.

Wait, desert?!

piotrkaminski··on Do growth mindset interventions impact students’ academic achievement?
This is a systematic review and meta-analysis of the literature on growth mindset interventions. The abstract's punchline:

> We conclude that apparent effects of growth mindset interventions on academic achievement are likely attributable to inadequate study design, reporting flaws, and bias.

piotrkaminski··on Iowa School District is using ChatGPT to determine banned books
I'm not a lawyer, and especially not a freedom of speech lawyer, but my understanding is that everyone has an obligation to follow the law whatever it might be (modulo intentional civil disobedience). If the law is unconstitutional then it needs to be challenged in court and struck down that way. AFAICT this law is specific to books in school libraries, which might shelter it from first amendment concerns to some degree.

But again, I'm not a lawyer, and just thought it was cool that the district was like "your law is stupid [implied] and a waste of our time, so we're just gonna throw AI at it so you can't blame us for doing nothing".

piotrkaminski··on Iowa School District is using ChatGPT to determine banned books
The law is what it is, but I thought the response from the district was quite rational:

> “Frankly, we have more important things to do than spend a lot of time trying to figure out how to protect kids from books,” Exman told PopSci via email. “At the same time, we do have a legal and ethical obligation to comply with the law. Our goal here really is a defensible process.”

piotrkaminski··on Mercedes beats Tesla to autonomous driving in California
Hmm, the latest article [1] specifically about the California authorization says:

> When active, Mercedes takes responsibility for Drive Pilot's actions.

and

> "Mercedes-Benz Drive Pilot is the world's only SAE Level 3 system with internationally valid type approval," Mercedes CTO Markus Schäfer said in a statement.

Not as clear-cut as you'd want it to be but certainly leaning towards the claim. I guess we'll know for sure once the cars actually go on sale in California.

[1] https://www.roadandtrack.com/news/a44139131/mercedes-benz-se...

piotrkaminski··on Mercedes beats Tesla to autonomous driving in California
There were a ton of articles around 2022-03-20 (e.g., [1]) that had a line like this:

> Once you engage Drive Pilot, you are no longer legally liable for the car's operation until it disengages.

Not quite a press release but given that Mercedes never denied the claims it's pretty close. It'll be interesting to see how this is implemented legally, of course.

[1] https://www.roadandtrack.com/news/a39481699/what-happens-if-...

piotrkaminski··on Overnight 'hotel train' could link San Francisco and Los Angeles
Cabin (https://www.cabinprivatetravel.com/) used to offer an SF-LA sleeper bus circa 2017, but looks like they're just doing private charters nowadays. I guess they couldn't make it work even with $115 one-way tickets. The sleeper train here is admittedly aiming at a slightly different audience but it's not clear to me it'll be any more successful...
piotrkaminski··on Even when we know they’re “fake,” placebos can tame our emotional distress
> I understood the grandparent post to mean that the harm can sometimes outweigh the benefits when the vaccine is forced. Not that it's always the case.

On careful re-reading I believe you're correct. Though if a hypothetical 100% effective zero side-effects vaccine doesn't pass their bar of outweighing psychological harm then it seems unlikely anything could, hence my interpretation of GP as an absolute statement.

> Are you suggesting that the COVID vaccines were able to completely stop transmission?

Hah, I wish! No, just going with the GP's hypothetical.

piotrkaminski··on Even when we know they’re “fake,” placebos can tame our emotional distress
> Even then, the emotional distress and reverse placebo effect of coercing people to take a vaccine if they don't want it still outweighs any benefit.

That's ridiculous -- of course benefits can outweigh psychological side-effects. Usually you'd want those benefits to accrue to the person suffering the side-effects, but living in a civilized society means accepting that sometimes the good of the many outweighs the pain of the few. If a vaccine for a deadly, highly communicable disease can completely stop transmission then I think it's perfectly ethical to require everyone to accept it or isolate from those willing to do so.

piotrkaminski··on Seattle's new airport terminal can’t fit planes it was designed to handle
> Originally earmarked to cost no more than $968 million, the Port authority was forced to pump an additional $18 million into the project in 2021, but now there are fears an additional $78 million will need to be found to address the gate layout design.

Wait, they're complaining about a potential *10%* cost overrun? They should drop by California, I've got a lovely HSR system to sell them. It won't cost a dollar over $33 billion, I swear.

piotrkaminski··on Anti-porn bills could force device makers to censor sexual material
> This year, Florida, South Carolina, Maryland, Tennessee, Iowa, Idaho, *Texas* and Montana lawmakers are all considering versions of the bill

(emphasis added)

piotrkaminski··on Who owns private home security footage, and who can get access to it?
> I think an important difference is if he “owned” and solelt possessed the data, the warrant would be his to fight (or not comply with) in court.

My understanding from the article is that he was, in fact, given 7 days to contest the warrant, and elected not do so because he didn't want to spend money on a lawyer. Which sounds pretty similar to the options he'd have if he had sole possession of the data and the warrant was served directly to him, though of course IANAL.

piotrkaminski··on Bflat – a single ahead-of-time crosscompiler and runtime for C#
Indeed -- curse you, irregular standard note structure!
piotrkaminski··on Bflat – a single ahead-of-time crosscompiler and runtime for C#
Wouldn't B double sharp just be C? I guess they'd need to call it "B triple sharp", which is just getting silly.
piotrkaminski··on The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter
> public transportation and alternative forms of transportation (ie, biking, walking, micro-mobility)

In the kind of cold weather that cuts EV range, per the OP? I've been there, and thanks but no thanks -- I'm too old for that shit. I'll stick to my car even if its range is reduced.

> Return the spaces occupied by parking lots, parking garages and use that space to house people.

This I heartily agree with, but it can be compatible with cars if we can get self-driving finally sorted out. Just have your car drop you off, then go out of the city to wait for you (and perhaps charge itself at the same time).

> Death to the suburban experiment.

Suburbs have different problems than cities do, but I'm not convinced they're particularly worse or more plentiful, and there are certainly other (dare I say better?) ways to solve them than abolishing suburbs outright.

piotrkaminski··on The cold hard truth about electric vehicles in winter
I have much the same question -- it seems like PHEVs would be perfect for the next 10 years or so, while we improve batteries and build out charging infrastructure. And yet there are relatively few PHEVs on the market, and most of them have <40 miles of electric range, whereas I think you'd really want something like double that number (especially in the context of this article!).

I'm really curious to see what Mazda will do with the MX-30 next year. It's an dismal failure as a pure EV, but apparently they're planning to add a rotary engine as a pure generator to it (i.e., not driving the wheels). If the car keeps the current version's 100 mile electric range that could be a very interesting combo.

piotrkaminski··on We're moving on from Firebase
Not OP, but I'm guessing they're referring to the "readability" approval process, which can sometimes be pretty brutal. (Or at least that was the case a decade ago, don't know how it's evolved since.)
piotrkaminski··on Show HN: I developed an app that creates interactive product demos in minutes
FYI, the sample demo is broken for me. When I hit play it the whole frame "vibrates", apparently switching between two (nearby) sizes every frame or so. (Hotspots are still clickable.) Resizing the window or moving to a different DPI screen doesn't help. Chrome 106.0.5249.103 on Win10.
piotrkaminski··on Should billboard advertising be banned?
Yes, the tragedy of the commons. The only way to win is not to play. It may not be rational, but I refuse to do something bad just because the alternative is somebody else doing something worse.
piotrkaminski··on Should billboard advertising be banned?
That's an easy one: your product is good only for some people, who happen to have the problem you're solving. You could tell everyone about it, but you'd reach a lot of people for whom wasting time hearing about your product is a net negative, and it's entirely possible that the overall value to other people's lives of advertising in that way would be negative as well. Of course you could try more targeted advertising to mitigate the negative externalities, but that carries its own costs in terms of invasion of privacy, etc.

So yes, it's certainly possible that advertising raises the overall well-being of the recipients, but it's by no means a given.

piotrkaminski··on Should billboard advertising be banned?
Spoken like a marketer / salesperson. I am indeed a developer and run a successful, bootstrapped software business. I agree that you need to initially get the word out that your product exists at all. However, this can be so targeted and the scope so small that I doubt most people would put it in the same category as the advertising practices that many find objectionable.

Once you've got some interest bootstrapped, you CAN in fact rely on unprompted word of mouth for growth. My users and buyers spread the word about my product simply because they find it useful. Many bring it to their new employer when they switch jobs.

So no, I disagree with the blanket position that you have to advertise -- especially in the intrusive fashion that's the subject of the article -- to get people to use your product. (Though I don't dispute that doing so can be a good shortcut.)

But all that is irrelevant to my claim above: my position is simply that a dearth of advertising options is what drives product innovation, by necessity. And hence, limiting advertising is likely to actually be good for consumers.

piotrkaminski··on Should billboard advertising be banned?
> Meanwhile, a spokeswoman for another trade organisation, the Advertising Association, says that "all advertising plays a crucial role in brand competition, drives product innovation, and fuels economic growth".

You know what actually drives product innovation? Not being able to lean on advertising to drive sales, so you're actually forced to improve your product and get the benefit of positive word of mouth instead.

← PreviousPage 2 of 9Next →