HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pknight

622 karma · joined January 9, 2011

submissionscomments
pknight··on Blisk – a browser for web developers
I love the idea of this but I have no reason to trust the browser. Just installed it to give it a test run. Tabbed to the history tab and it is showing files and locations I've accessed outside of the browser prior to installation. Add the lack of information on their site about who they are and what they do with data, this doesn't inspire confidence.
pknight··on Show HN: Consol – Desktop First Productivity with End-to-End Encryption
Video and concept are really amazingly done. I still cringe everytime someone uses doge speak, but the video otherwise was brilliant.
pknight··on React Inline Styles and the Future of CSS
I wonder if we're making out CSS to be harder than it is. Yes, there are difficulties and common problems in practice, but news tool and approaches introduce their own. The biggest of these: overhead in the form of tooling, performance and a higher barrier to entry.

Consider the cases where CSS's common painpoints are maximized: complex pages with a lot of (3rd party) components. Does the added cleverness of the tools make that much difference, or does ultimately, a complex page come with unavoidable challenges by definition? So far I'm not completely convinced that the value-add is big enough to warrant such a different approach.

pknight··on The E-Cat has been replicated?
Check out http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2423692

"We here report a meta-analysis of 90 experiments from 33 laboratories in 14 countries which yielded an overall effect greater than 6 sigma, z = 6.40, p = 1.2 × 10^-10 with an effect size (Hedges’ g) of 0.09."

Non-fringe scientist Daryl Bem published a very controversial study involving 9 experiments. Replications were encouraged and were done across the world in the years following. With failures and successes, resulting in this meta study.

Amount of critics persuaded? Not that many probably.

The parallel here is lamenting the lack of an accepted theory or no theory at all and concluding that thereby the results are fraudulent as well as the process involved in deriving the results, by definition.

Bystanders often say, well if it's true why isn't there a peer-reviewed study etc, as if it matters. You can publish papers up the wazoo it won't matter.

If there's something special happening, there's going to be this period where mainstream science denies or disproves of it, regardless of studies and papers. Especially when gatekeepers have vested into a position of rejecting the idea.

As far as LENR is concerned, I can't say Rossi inspires confidence, but the fact that many institutions are researching this area tells me there might be something special going on. Many people aren't comfortable with the feeling that something might turn out to be false, so they assume it's a hoax a priori.

pknight··on The E-Cat has been replicated?
There have been studies with over 5-sigma confidence intervals that are not taken seriously simply because it's controversial. It's just we're wired to the status quo and nobody likes to be tricked.

And you can't keep say, a factory or a house running on snake oil, so it will be evident pretty quickly.

pknight··on The E-Cat has been replicated?
A 'real scientific' article wouldn't do anything to convince people - it would be picked apart and doubted. Which is kind of an interesting thing in an of itself. I think for controversial stuff, you simply won't get scientists to budge no matter how transparent or rigorious the reporting. If the stuff turns out to be true, there will be a long delay before acceptance.

I no longer believe that open replications make much difference either (there have been open replications and I still don't know anything more).

They are focussed on industrial and consumer installations instead. I'll start really believing if people are using this in the real world and that's the strategy they have I think. So wait and see is what I do.

pknight··on Chinese Tech Group Led by Qihoo 360 Bids $1.2B for Browser Maker Opera
Terrible development. Opera was hands-down the best desktop browser. Somehow less buggy and more userfriendly than Chrome. Handles tons of tabs without problems, fast snappy and even with support for vertical tabs.
pknight··on WordPress Killed PHP, LOL
WordPress isn't moving away from PHP, you'd have to be completely unaware of WP to draw that conclusion. For starters, the REST API that will power JS based clients is built in PHP. The actions and filters API which is the bread and butter of thousands of plugins is all PHP.
pknight··on The Genius of Wordpress (and why it’s doomed)
When you use clickbait headlines (where's the part that spells out doom? Answer: It's not given and there was no intent to do so) you discredit your own analysis. This just becomes yet another fluff piece promoting a static site generator.

Why is it that alternative publishing platforms compare themselves to WordPress in order to justify their existence? Especially when platforms offer wildely different value propositions to users. Be your own thing, the market is huge. You don't need an immense userbase to have a succesful platform.

pknight··on Economic Inequality: The Simplified Version
Just as you can't say startups create jobs without considering the jobs it displaces, I think you can't hide behind the notion that startups are generally a force of good. That way you sweep all the startups that have a net negative effect under the rug.

Studies show FB can have a negative effect on happiness. In the tech startup playbook is stated that you need to make your site/app addictive. Well we've mastered that now and it must cost billions of dollars with people's time being wasted on crap.

Even startups geared toward productivity aren't that impactful in the grand scheme, they tend to make life more convenient and only when enough customers can be found at the right pricepoint.

We're training people to be distracted by trivialities and stuff that doesn't matter. Many venture backed startups are exposing the defects of the way economy functions and just how poor we are at delivering the value that is truly needed.

We don't really need another gadget or app, we need to fix the way society has painted a growing number of people into a corner. Income inequality is just one way to expose the symptoms of an increasing problem, a problem that isn't really being focused on by startups because startups are born and survive by exploiting leverage that can be turned into profit.

pknight··on Ask HN: Why is software priced the same around the World?
Depends on the software but its easy to overlook. I'm just a solo dev, so every hour I spend on customer support is an hour I'm not doing product development, marketing or generally something that is a leveraged use of my time. For customers who pay less, that time is even less leveraged.

Also, for customers who don't have a strong command of english there's translation work, misunderstandings in customer service communications that are more likely to happen, pressure to provide documentation in multiple languages...all very time consuming and thus disproportionately more costly if you are doing that work with less margin flowing back.

pknight··on Ask HN: Why is software priced the same around the World?
The cost of supporting a customer is typically fixed for a vendor regardless of what price the software is sold at. Supporting customers who paid less relative to the costs can be hard to justify. It could even lead to a net loss, so it's understandable that we don't see that much differentiation in the price for different countries.
pknight··on Rebrickable helps breathe new life into your kids’ old Lego sets
Because building random crap and building models from instructions are both fun. Even cooler when your random crap/custom creations can be enjoyed by others.
pknight··on The Story Behind the New WordPress.com
Are rich offline capabilities part of the roadmap? For a long time I've been wondering if there would be any benefits from the Simperium project flowing to WordPress.
pknight··on SSL from Namecheap: What's the difference?
I'm no expert but isn't this article being disingenuous about three listed disadvantages of free certs?

    "Short lifetimes"
The free cert I'm using from startssl is good for a year not the 30 days mentioned as 'standard'?

    "No wildcards"
But you can setup multiple domains with SNI enabled, multiple subdomains too I believe? What is stated here makes it sound like its impossible to use a cert for more than one domain.

    "Limited flexibility"
The hosting company I use makes installing a cert easy, free cert or not, via a GUI. And even I was able to setup a cert on a VPS myself. Not sure how relevant the difficulty argument is being made here
pknight··on WordPress now runs a quarter of the web
Themes rarely have hackable exploits due to what they (are supposed to) do. If there's insecure code in there it's probably code with functionality that belongs in a plugin to start with. Themes that have had vulnerabilities in them tend to be the kinds of commercial themes that are filled with features and 3rd party scripts to satiate users demands. Not really a WordPress core problem, it is a market problem. Although package management is something WordPress lacks in.
pknight··on Show HN: Rucksack – CSS superpowers, built on PostCSS
I do like the features. I was drawn by the appeal of cssnext as a way out of needing preprocessing, by being able to use soon-to-be-supported css features straight away.

But adding new spec that looks like the CSS language is not transparent, it's ambiguous. It's not a knock perse. And like you say it does not lock you in, as you can rely on the output. But I wouldn't want to use it for projects that are distributed to other users, because now they have the burden of learning and distinguishing between constructs coming from rucksack and normal css spec.

pknight··on Show HN: Rucksack – CSS superpowers, built on PostCSS
Yes, cssnext!
pknight··on Show HN: Rucksack – CSS superpowers, built on PostCSS
Looks appealing, but it is very confusing. At least with Sass/less etc you can easily distinguish between native css and non-native css constructs such as mixins and extends. But the additions rucksack make are ambiguous. Is it real spec, future spec or something that rucksack developers have added for convenience?

I'd prefer nextCSS with all the spec being based on what is actually going to make in into CSS. Otherwise it's the same downsides as preprocessing languages with the added bonus of not being able to easily tell what lines are native to css or not.

pknight··on Ask HN: How to welcome Technological Unemployment?
I wonder what it would be like if it were possible to add new dimensions to the economy. If we reward ecological, service and aesthetic contributions in a similar way we reward the exchange of scarce goods and services in the economy today... I wonder if anyone has put serious thought into how that could be done.
pknight··on Why I am pro-GPL
sigh
pknight··on Why I am pro-GPL
I'm not perpetuating this supposed fallacy. Software developers fail with their products for various different reasons, there just seems to be very little evidence that the choice of GPL has impacted economic viability. At least I can say that there is very little evidence of that in the WordPress ecosystem.

If you complain about the lack of an example of how a GPL based economy can work, you simply ignore existing markets. The WordPress ecosystem (worth billions) is almost exclusively GPL and developers are succeeding with successful products and services, operating businesses in all kinds of revenue ranges. Many small teams and even solo developers are regularly netting 6-7 figures a year. They are doing so utilizing a variety of business models, proving that almost any kind of solution can be made to work in some format, provided it's something people will pay for.

There has always been some push back for the GPL, especially by designers, in the WordPress space. Despite that things are working. We have an entire commercial themes market that is selling GPL based themes, with many successful authors raking in money. Some people thought it was crazy, but theme sales are sky high.

The only reason some developers aren't making money there isn't because GPL, it's because the competition is strong and the work is hard and some people can't or won't adapt.

pknight··on Why I am pro-GPL
You seem to be persisting the myth that developers aren't able to make a living under GPL. In the WordPress ecosystem virtually all products are GPL compatible and the economy is worth millions and millions. Developers are doing just fine under it, more than fine actually. I'd like to hear a single case where GPL licensing made a negative difference between financial success and failure (maybe they exist, but examples are never brought up, funnily).
pknight··on Why we maintain desktop apps for OS X, Windows, and a web application
are you using Windows 10? I'm wondering if the virtual desktops feature was going to make my life easier managing tons of windows. Your comment doesn't sound very encouraging.
pknight··on Semantic-UI, the Web's Most Beautiful Front End Just Launched 2.0, It's Amazing
Just started playing this. It's worth noting that nothing lower than IE10 is supported (due to flexbox and other things I suspect) and it's javascript dependent. That results in broken stuff for around 2% of traffic depending on the audience. Also missing are a date picker and range slider, which is a pity for a UI framework. Still, I'm liking it a lot.
pknight··on A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic income theory
And even if your dim view of people is true - that all but a minority of people are so lazy they would all just sit on the couch and do nothing - it would not matter. When our tools are providing all of what the population needs, what is the realist, capitalist, economic argument for employing them?
pknight··on A Dutch city is giving money away to test the basic income theory
No one's arguing that only a small percentage of people are geared toward pursuing high risk/high cost opportunities. But it's not really relevant to the idea of basic income or an indictment of the majority.

The vast majority are happiest when they are doing meaningful work, not by sitting on the couch and eating ice cream while being void of engaging work. This is true for people of all walks of life, the super bright, the super disciplined, the super motivated as well as the other end and everything in between. The concept of basic income would free people to pursue engaging work. Meaningful work does not have to come in the form of trying to cure diseases or build sky scrapers, or start a tech company.

Meaningful work is abundant and not limited by the arbitrary limitations created by a material-consumption-based society what was ushered in by the industrial age, which for the the majority has dictated what is economically viable to make a living. Meaningful work can come in the form of volunteering, gardening, looking after elders, helping the environment, creating beautiful neighbourhoods, social support, skilled crafts, the list is endless and not limited to people with above average intelligence or motivation. Right now these types of endeavours are not economically sustaining for people to focus on.

Given that technology will drastically cut down the amount of jobs required it is beyond obvious that the current orthodoxy just isn't applicable in tomorrow's world. It is obvious today and it's only get worse tomorrow. Autonomous cars and trucks alone will kill millions of jobs, how do these people find economically viable jobs? Office jobs will decline at an exponential pace, because there will be no economically viable reason to employ people for work that is done more efficiently by software.

Given that we can actually sustain billions of people's material needs with most of the work being done by our tools, rather than people, it is complete lunacy to handicap the population by limiting it because the majority won't actually be able to find economically viable work according to yesterday's economy. It is also completely arbitrary. The conditions have changed dramatically and the sooner we adjust the system to fit the new conditions, the better.

pknight··on Chromium unconditionally downloads binary blob
Which is not to be trusted in the slightest
pknight··on Show HN: A DOM text-selection highlight renderer
very nice!
pknight··on Show HN: A DOM text-selection highlight renderer
Did you take inspiration from Rangy (https://github.com/timdown/rangy) and if yes, what makes Marklib better? Would like to know if there are obvious benefits to using Marklib over Rangy.
← PreviousPage 4 of 11Next →