HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

placebo

1,001 karma · joined October 7, 2014

submissionscomments
placebo··on Intel Has a Big Problem
While I don't underestimate the scope and possible ramifications, I still don't understand the immediate threat to the average person. The malicious hacker that is after secret personal information does not need to go to the trouble of writing a trojan that exploits Spectre or Meltdown when a simple keylogger and file scanner would be much simpler and probably more effective.

The article itself states: "So far, Meltdown and Spectre probably pose less risk to the average person than, say, a simple phishing attack in which a hacker tries to send you to a malicious website. They won’t lead to the kind of widespread panic that resulted from the 2017 hack of Equifax’s customer database.

But that could change. Hackers who hadn’t tried to break into Intel’s hardware, believing there was no way it would leave a side door open, are now seeking ways in."

"But that could change" is a vague term that doesn't mean much to me. Again - not trivialising this nor saying Intel shouldn't do some soul searching, but I'd like to better understand the justification for the apparent hysteria - unless, of course some people more experienced in security would care to explain what it is I'm missing here.

P.S. One thing I wanted to check was whether Spectre/Meltdown breaches could somehow be caused by manipulating a web browser. Some searching revealed that this is indeed a possibility so at this point, everyone feel free to panic :-)

placebo··on JS Paint – A web-based MS Paint remake
When you double click one of the images displayed in xnviewmp the image opens in a window and then under the 'Image' menu item, there is a submenu named 'Map'. Selecting the Map submenu opens a list of functions that can be performed on the image, and one of them is 'Negative'.
placebo··on JS Paint – A web-based MS Paint remake
I have IrfanView on Mac (via Wine project) and it works flawlessly. However, if you don't want to install Wine on your OSX, there are other alternatives, some mentioned here already. Personally, I like xnview - its free and probably includes everything you'd want (and supports making a negative image)
placebo··on Cryptocurrency bloodbath continues as Bitcoin falls below $10,000
I'll be convinced when I get a satisfying explanation on how blockchain will scale to handle the rate of transactions in a real global economy (while keeping all it's advantages intact)
placebo··on Cryptocurrency bloodbath continues as Bitcoin falls below $10,000
I think around the time people started basing their counting system on the number of fingers at their disposal... :-)
placebo··on Our Visual Imagination Is Severely Limited
Would Stephen Wiltshire's talent be attributed to the same explanations ?

http://www.stephenwiltshire.co.uk/

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1223790/Autistic-art...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bsJbApZ5GF0

placebo··on The ABC conjecture has still not been proved
This got me thinking about human cognition and the meaning of mathematical truths, or even how does one know that something is true (and I assume that probably none of this is original).

At which point would Mochizuki’s work be considered proof? If another person regarded as an authority would claim to fully understand it (but couldn't explain it better to their peers)? If only 10% of mathematicians specialising in this field could understand it? If 40%?

What if only a few percent understood the proof, but managed to "prove" to others that they understood it by using this knowledge to unlock other difficult problems?

This seems to point that even in mathematics we can never claim to know what is true. At most, we can hold a belief, an assessment based on some parameters that increases our degree of belief that something is true.

In fact, there's no need for a controversial proof to show this - it occurs with the simplest of mathematical proofs - after all, everything we believe in is based on the ability to detect consistency or lack thereof, which in itself is based on the ability of a system (in this case, our brains) to have a memory and notice where something happening now is consistent or inconsistent with something stored in our memory. Now this is quite problematic in terms of proof, because how can we trust our memory with a 100% certainty? The answer is that we can't. We attribute a high probability that what we know is true based on the consistency of other things we remember, but we can never prove anything .

placebo··on When the Judge Distrusts Your Lawyers
Integrity is always an option, but it's definitely not always an easy option. I'm glad you're in a place where you don't have to test it and hope that I also won't find myself in a difficult place where it will have to be tested, but I do know that it's the only coin that is really worth anything.
placebo··on Monty Hall Problem Simulation
I find that one can get a better intuitive grasp on many things when you take them to the extreme. In this case, suppose that instead of three doors, there are one hundred doors and behind 99 of them there are goats and behind 1 there's the car. After you select a door, say number 14. The host then tells you that it might be behind door number 14 but out of all the other doors he opens all but door 92, so you are left with two doors to choose from. I think the choice is quite obvious at this point. If not, then try a million doors...
placebo··on Manipulating Human Psychology To Turn Users Into Addicts
The entire post is addressed to him, and not in a positive way. I tend to agree...
placebo··on What we do instead of technical interviews
I'm delighted to see comments that show some people here actually get this. While my conclusions are based only on my own experience, they have served me well so far. In the dozens of interviews that I've conducted over the years, not once did I need to resort to quizzes that do a fine job of showing how a person can answer a quiz under pressure of an interview but not much beyond that. Most of the important qualities I'm interested in concerning an applicant have very little to do with this sort of ability. A decision based on a chat which reveals more than any professional quiz ever could (if you know how to listen) is usually a better one.

Not only do I refuse to ask candidates quizzes, but after getting enough professional experience, I started refusing to answer them when I was looking for new positions. One such case involved two executives that interviewed me for a certain senior R&D position. The interview was going well when at a certain point one of them asked if he could test me on some professional stuff. I politely answered that while I respect their candidate filtering methods, it doesn't fit my MO and that I'll pass on that. Not surprisingly, I later received a negative reply from them. A couple of weeks passed and I was hired for the same position by a much larger company (and with much better compensation) that didn't insist on me standing next to a whiteboard to see if I can pick up on some silly trick. About 3 months later, I received a call from one of the executives in the company from which I received a negative reply. Apparently they hired someone who had managed to pass their interview tests with flying colours, but was terrible at his job and so they asked me whether I would like to work for them (of course, this time with no tests). I said I'll pass on that too.

I think the reason for the difficulty in finding the right people for the job stems from a deeper problem of people having lost touch with their inner drive and resorting to external means to understand what is good for them. It starts in grade school and continues on from there. This is not a problem that can (or should) go away quickly, but the more I see people at least being aware of the issue, the more hopeful I am that a more sane process for people fulfilling their potential will eventually replace the existing method.

placebo··on Shut up and calculate: an extreme mathematical universe
It looks like we share a similar enthusiasm for the potential of artificial neural networks (and I also assume a similar distrust in the ability of philosophy to answer these questions), and I agree that NNs are currently the best candidate to eventually create self-conscious machines (though unlike some prominent celebrities, I believe it's still in the far future). The point we depart is that you seem to be saying there is no real difference between the hard problem and the soft problem of consciousness.

We obviously mean different things by "sensation": I've implemented neural nets to solve problems using ML, I understand the theory and certainly impressed with the results . I assume that by "sensations" you are referring to the process of inputs entering the input layer of the neural net. This is exactly part of a model for solving the soft problem of consciousness. What I'm getting at is that you know what a sensation feels like before you give it any label - it has a certain "is"ness to it that no equation or concept can convey. I'm saying this becomes possible when a system becomes complex enough to be self-conscious and it is usually attributed as some sort of emergent property that is created by the system, whereas I claim it is much deeper than that, and in fact it is the other way around.

Obviously this correspondence format is not really suited to dive deeper, but I'm always happy to discuss this to find if and where I'm mistaken.

placebo··on Shut up and calculate: an extreme mathematical universe
>Just because I formulated said ontology from sense perception doesn't entail that it references subjective concepts.

My point is that calling it sense perception will not make the subjective pre-conceptual experience of it go away. I'm not advocating a ghost in the machine here, but trying to show that neither the ghost nor the machine can survive as primitives when put under deep scrutiny, but I first need to demonstrate how neither can independently exist as a valid concept.

>this sort of skepticism necessarily presupposes the very knowledge that it attempts to undermine, and therefore it contradicts itself and is literally false.

Not sure I follow how this relates to the quoted sentence, but the problem with any explanation (physical or philosophical) is that it is always limited to discussing concepts and relationships between them and can never break the boundaries of what can be grasped by thought (this explanation not excluded). My attempt is to show that thought (and thus any object derived from it) is not the pristine reality, but something that comes after reality is processed. At most, thought can point in the right direction (e.g, understand it's own limitations).

placebo··on Shut up and calculate: an extreme mathematical universe
>By saying "no conceptual explanation ever will" you put consciousness in a category of its own, supernatural or mysterious, like Chalmers. That's just a soft form of dualism.

I think you just pointed out the very paradox which illustrates my point: In which category do you place something that cannot belong to any category?

At this point you might want to say that I'm just making up an artificial nonexistent construct that has no bearing on reality and my task would be to show that not only does it exist, but it is the very basis necessary for all categories to exist. This thread would probably not suffice to achieve that :-) And by the way, I don't see it as supernatural - if anything, the process of concepts and objects created by an agent to approximate reality and then taking these approximations to be reality is what I find to be supernatural. It amazes me how evolution managed to pull this off...

>The fact that it feels like something to see red or blue? That's just sensation + emotional response.

I'm suggesting that "just sensation" is a placeholder for "I have no idea what that is"... There's a big difference between the explanation of a process and the experiencing of a process. We are so quick to categorise experiences into concepts and relationships between them that we overlook the fact that the sensory experience exists before any conceptualisation and categorisation, and in a way is much more real than any story we mould it into some milliseconds later (i.e "this is red", "this is cold" etc.)

>So the substrate of consciousness is not the brain, but the "game".

By now you probably realise (though I assume still disagree with me) that I see it the other way around: i.e that no concept can exist without knowing it. This is not the same as saying nothing exists without our knowledge, but it does mean that what exists before our knowledge of it remains by definition undefinable and inscrutable.

placebo··on Shut up and calculate: an extreme mathematical universe
I did not mean to imply that subjectivity is irreducible, but rather to say that it a mistaken belief that is the flip side of another mistaken belief (i.e reality is the objects/concepts we use to describe it).

>it still leaves us with the question of the nature of subjectivity, a term you use with impunity but without definition!

I didn't try to promote or define subjectivity, I challenged you to define an object without making any references to something subjective (as this is the ontology you said you subscribe to). What I was getting at is that you'll be hard pressed to present any object that is not a concept created by a subject. Mind you, I'm not saying objects and subjects are real, but that they are co-created by the mind and as such are equally unreal as far as representing what actually is.

placebo··on Shut up and calculate: an extreme mathematical universe
AI in general (whether via RL or whichever new development that will surface) opens up a fascinating new arena for learning about how agents operate, and investigating the soft problem of consciousness (i.e, what are the type of processes and the complexity involved that is required for having an inner experience), but I stand by my assertion that it will never explain the hard problem of consciousness, and no conceptual explanation ever will.
placebo··on Shut up and calculate: an extreme mathematical universe
I don't subscribe to either (and I'd venture to say neither does westoncb). My view is that both are flawed interpretations of reality. Both dualists and materialists assume "objects" to have some sort of independent existence and the argument between them is that the former claims there is something else that also exists while the latter claims nothing else exists. However ask yourself, what sort of existence test can any object (or concept for that matter) pass without the subjective knowing of it? The moment an ontology presumes either objects or subjects as the core premise of reality, it is already one step removed from it.
placebo··on Shut up and calculate: an extreme mathematical universe
>However, my suspicion is that the experience itself will remain not amenable to conceptual analysis

I'm in total agreement with this as well. When I suggested looking into what is it that objectivity and subjectivity arise from, I wasn't referring to the "physical" explanation (which I assume will eventually be resolved, though not in the near future) but to the core of the hard problem of consciousness. My take on this is that when looked at closely, it will not be found within the domain of anything that can be conceptualised simply because it precedes concepts. Any concept requires consciousness to exist but not vice versa. Of course the usual argument at this point is something in the line of "so the sun didn't exist before any thinking animals existed?" To which my answer is that the sun as a concept didn't exist. Neither did hydrogen, electrons or wave functions. Only pure pre-concept reality existed, neither objective nor subjective, "waiting" for a mind to evolve and eventually form subjects. objects and concepts that with increasing accuracy describe how this reality functions, and then proceed to confuse this description of reality with reality...

placebo··on Shut up and calculate: an extreme mathematical universe
You're right, and I also see how this obvious observation is consistently and elegantly ignored in most scientific or philosophical arguments that try and promote some totally "objective" account of reality.

However, it's not really that surprising: Science over the centuries has steadily (and for it's time, justifiably) eroded the role of subjectivity in order to uncompromisingly get at what is consistently true (regardless of what we'd like to be true) and this process required being very suspicious of any subjective accounts that can't be measured.

That being said, perhaps the time has come to dig a bit deeper and in the same persistent and uncompromising way ask what does objectivity or subjectivity mean? What do they arise from and to whom? I don't know if any new technologies can be derived from having clearer insights to these questions, but I do feel that it would be time better spent than any untestable mind made artifact about what reality ultimately is.

placebo··on Craniopagus Twins Share a Brain and See Out of Each Others Eyes
I believe you're referring to Dissociative identity disorder (DID), or multiple personality disorder (MPD), not Schizophrenia, and a friend who's a psychiatrist told me that in quite a few decades of practicing, he hasn't encountered even once such a diagnosis so he doubts it even exists outside of Hollywood movies.

As far as I'm concerned what matters is how many entities exist who display a behavior of a separate entity (at least to the degree that we acknowledge as being separate) - i.e display different personalities each with a cohesive structure and integrity. It really doesn't matter how many physical brains they share.

placebo··on A Minimalist Guide to SQLite
>It's used in systems as important as the Airbus A350 so it comes as no surprise the tests for SQLite 3 are aviation-grade

I stumbled upon SQLite around 2001 and have been using and admiring this gem of a software since that time, but hearing that it is aviation-grade is definitely a surprise to me...

placebo··on VS Code Roadmap 2018
True. VSCode is more open source in this sense. Of course, that doesn't mean everyone is happy... https://github.com/Microsoft/vscode/issues/17996
placebo··on VS Code Roadmap 2018
A free, powerful, open sourced editor and IDE constantly improving and growing - what's not to like? - I get that some don't like the electron-based thing/performance but it never bothered me (and I bought and use both Sublime 2 & 3) - guess it requires a degree of sensitivity that I'm not bothered with - sort of like people who claim they can't hear mp3 because they can only enjoy CD quality audio (not saying it's not true for them, just that luckily I enjoy both the same).

The question I'm wondering about is what is Microsoft's end game with this? I'm comparing this to the history of Google Chrome that, when released, was similar in the sense that it was better than the alternatives: wickedly fast, open sourced, with no apparent strings attached. The business benefits to Google and market control from owning Chrome are obvious today and I'm trying to understand the long term view in VSCode - i.e how to you eventually create business value from a free editor? Premium features? Better integration with Microsoft's services? I wonder if there's a deeper vision - I mean, as opposed to Chrome, VSCode does not know much about me personally, does not provide much data to further leverage Microsoft's services, and targets a much narrower audience to begin with. So, what's the business model behind it's development. I'm too much of a skeptic to believe it's just so developers have a warm fuzzy feeling associated with Microsoft...

placebo··on I cured my tech fatigue by ditching feeds
:-) was about to respond in a similar way, and I probably won't be telling anyone something they don't know by reiterating the cliche of "it's a matter of balance". There is nothing wrong with feeds, just as there is nothing wrong with ice cream. Addiction is the problem to address...
placebo··on To Settle Infinity Question, a New Law of Mathematics (2013)
True - you don't even need to venture into quantum mechanics, the concept of infinity has been useful in practical science far before anyone dreamed of quantum mechanics - but there's a difference between a definition of what happens to a formula when a limit approaches infinity and claiming to somehow understand infinity as a concept. I mean when you deal with infinite-dimensional operators, infinite-series etc. does it matter what ordinal of infinity is used?
placebo··on To Settle Infinity Question, a New Law of Mathematics (2013)
>Yet math is consistently being conceptualized?

Sure, how else could we capture it or convey it to others? The thing is that I don't see it as that different than conceptualizing things in the "real world". In the latter, conceptualization is done on input of the senses, while in math conceptualization is done on inputs from a higher level of abstraction. In both cases, something is defined and then manipulated for something useful. It's just that I believe that whatever is defined automatically becomes a finite concept otherwise it could not be grasped and manipulated, and a finite infinity seems problematic...

placebo··on To Settle Infinity Question, a New Law of Mathematics (2013)
Amen. Not a mathematician, but this perfectly articulates my thoughts on the subject.

>the real world does not contain infinities

I have no idea what "real world" even means, but I'd say that infinity does not exist within anything that can be conceptualized.

placebo··on Eloquent JavaScript, 3rd edition
sorry, missed your reply (so perhaps you won't see this for the same reasons) but anyway:

Mainly the feeling of giving up simplicity. Adding things (such as sourcemaps and any relevant configuration changes) usually detracts from the sense of "no middleman", although I know "no middleman" is always an illusion, it's less obvious when you don't have to do anything to create it.

placebo··on Reverse engineering of competitor’s software cost company big
This just strengthens my cynicism on the general state of the law and the degree it generates justice. I'm hardly surprised anymore. Can anyone convince me that the judges in this case put more thought into this than the vast majority of the commenters here?

Even when I try to play devil's advocate, it's hard to justify. The fact that you invented something, should not give you eternal rights to exclusively profit from it. Even the warped patent industry knows that. The laws of innovation should be a balancing act between incentive for the innovator and incentive to society, and this decision is way out of balance in detriment of society.

placebo··on After the end of the startup era
I think this was a very sober presentation of things, however it seems that it underestimates our inability to tell how the future will pan out, especially when we're moving on an exponential function of technological progress and creativity. Sure, the Internet window is closed and so is the mobile apps window but no one saw either of them coming - likewise, I can't tell yet what the next really big thing will be or when (unfortunately) but I wouldn't mourn garage entrepreneurship just yet.
← PreviousPage 7 of 14Next →