HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

placebo

1,001 karma · joined October 7, 2014

submissionscomments
placebo··on Your brain does not process information and it is not a computer
This reminds me of a great snippet from one of Raymond Smulyan's books ("This Book Needs No Title") that I think best captures the implied and unfounded fear behind these sort of articles. Here's the quote in full:

“Recently I was with a group of mathematicians and philosophers. One philosopher asked me whether I believed man was a machine. I replied, ‘Do you really think it makes any difference?’ He most earnestly replied, ‘Of course! To me it is the most important question in philosophy.’ I had the following afterthoughts: I imagine that if my friend had finally come to the conclusion that he were a machine, he would be infinitely crestfallen. I think he would think: ‘My God! How horrible! I am only a machine!’ But if I should find out I were a machine, my attitude would be totally different. I would say: ‘How amazing! I never before realized that machines could be so marvelous!’”

Adding my own thoughts to this, I think what generates these sort of articles is an intuitive and well justified resistance to the belief is "life is just a complex machine" but by using completely mistaken arguments.

The essence of life, existence and consciousness can never be reduced to any mechanical or even logical processes (although some would like to believe otherwise), but the fact that it can bloom into amazing creations like the human mind or possibly in the distant future ti some human-made artificial mind doesn't detract from it's magic.

placebo··on Your brain does not process information and it is not a computer
>Is it a mistake though to think of people as machines?

Yes and no... It is not a mistake because much (and perhaps eventually all) of observable human functionality and behavior can be logically explained and therefore eventually simulated. However, when logic becomes one's "Maslow's hammer" then of course not only are people machines but all of existence is just a giant machine. It's an easy mistake to make because we tend to conflate a very powerful tool used by the mind to operate in reality with reality itself. I think humans are unique (at least on this planet) in their ability to ask this question, but also in their ability to discover that the answer is negative - i.e there is much more to reality than a complex "dead" machine.

placebo··on Rejecting a candidate for over-qualification results in age bias
I don't think you can fight this with laws: We live in an age and society that prefers young over old, smart over wise, quick profits over steady growth - I could go on with the contrasts but you get the idea. This might change over time but don't hold your breath.

If some of the young developers reading this realize that the same might happen to them then my suggestion would be not to wait around hoping that new employment laws will save you in a few decades (which will pass faster than you think), but to start taking care of things now. This means, make sure that by the time you get to the age when someone won't hire you, you won't need or want to be hired. You can do this by either saving enough money by that age to do whatever you want (which could be a new venture doing what you love, whether it is developing software or not) or by slowly creating a business (maybe starting as a side project) which will end up with you on the hiring side (even if you only want to hire yourself).

placebo··on Eloquent JavaScript, 3rd edition
True, but admittedly, I'm so fond of the ability to have no "middlemen" between the code I write and what gets run by the browser that my dislike for any logistics/bureaucracy overhead is stronger than my attraction to ES6+ (or CoffeesScript for that matter). I know it might sound a bit irrational (I'd much rather code in C++ than code in assembly), but I think one of the perks of writing in JavaScript was that I got to have a high level language directly run by a system and now I don't want to give it up. I prefer to wait until the percentage of browsers that support ES6+ goes up.
placebo··on Eloquent JavaScript, 3rd edition
> We're all writing let instead of var now, and a book that continues to write var is starting to look a bit out of touch

Serious question: Does this also refer to client side web developers? According to caniuse.com, only around 83% of web browsers support the let statement, which in most cases wouldn't cut it when releasing a web site or web app to accommodate the largest audience.

placebo··on PureVPN Logs Helped FBI Net Alleged Cyberstalker
Point taken regarding criminals using criminal methods to gain anonymity, and I have little doubt that often the real agenda behind government action in this field is accumulation of power and control over the population in the guise of protecting it. However, like with guns, when there is an abundance of them and they can be easily and legally obtained, you will probably end up with more casualties by criminals who would otherwise perhaps not have seen the investment (and risk) in obtaining one worthwhile. To be clear, I am for everyone's freedom for total anonymity and believe it is a faster way to a better world than trusting governments with too much power - it's just that I think that it doesn't come without a price.
placebo··on PureVPN Logs Helped FBI Net Alleged Cyberstalker
Could you explain? I mean, if the government has the ability to catch criminals that think they are anonymous then how exactly is true anonymity of non-criminals maintained? To be clear, of the two evils I'd prefer having the risk of a few bad people getting their way than to trust the "good government" to always protect me by knowing everything about me, but this is far from a trivial subject. In some ways this is analogous to the issue of the right to bear arms. There's always a tension between safety and liberty and it's not always clear where the optimal line should be drawn.
placebo··on A Comparison of Four Algorithms Textbooks (2016)
Honestly, I'm blown away that someone has actually read cover to cover Knuth, CLRS, Dasgupta and Skiena. Is this a common thing? Has anyone here done something similar? For years I've had the textbooks of CLRS and Skiena at home (and a pdf of Dasgupta) but they are used only in the event I need to drill down to understand a particular algorithm to solve a particular problem. I feel that the most effective use of my time is to have a birds view of the landscape (i.e understand the categories of algorithms and the problems they solve) and dive down only when I actually need to know the nitty gritty to implement a solution for a real problem. I can understand the joy of learning them all just for fun, but who has the time? I wonder if he did all the exercises too... :-)
placebo··on What I learned about solitude from my time with hermits
The assumption that hermits are insightful is probably derived from an image of some experienced meditating wise soul, contemplating in solitude the meaning of life. While people who genuinely want to meditate upon life might sometimes wish to do so in solitude, the converse is not true and finding a hermit will definitely not guarantee finding some enlightened spirit. I'd bet on there being a larger probability of finding someone who is mentally unstable, whose condition was made more extreme by the solitude.
placebo··on FBI Hunt for 2 Missing Pigs Reveals Federal Cover-Up of Barbaric Factory Farms
> You're saying that there is a morality held in a person that is invoked in an observed situation that is being rationalized away, implying that they fundamentally subscribe to the same morals as you

No, I'm saying something even more extreme. I'm saying that ultimately, morality does not depend on any point of view (mine or anyone else's) in much the same way that what is ultimately true doesn't depend on any point of view. Immorality is simply ignorance doing its thing. I'm in no way free of ignorance, but I am actively trying to reduce it.

> I think this convergence (and I'd simply call it a projection) is an extreme claim, going against the observed variety among cultures & schools of thought around the world and throughout history. That's simply not an accurate picture of humanity.

Yes, there is an incredible and fascinating variety in humanity. Situations, points of view, emotions, agendas - all can be extremely complex and nuanced and very dependent on conditioning or "starting conditions". Yet, I think you'll find that compassion is something that is understood in any culture (as is fear), and the ability to empathize with someone else's situation (be it in another culture or another species) is not as far fetched as you make it seem.

You've obviously given some thought to your claims (which these days is refreshing), and as someone who always wants to get to the truth of things, I'll gladly give up everything I believe in if it is incorrect, but then again my understanding wasn't acquired overnight, so if you're also as keen to dig deeper and see what comes up I'll be happy to correspond further.

placebo··on FBI Hunt for 2 Missing Pigs Reveals Federal Cover-Up of Barbaric Factory Farms
> How can you both agree that a clear line doesn't exist, while in the same sentence saying "obviously wrong"?

Same way as I can say something is obviously a heap of sand without pointing out exactly at which point it turned into one from it's beginnings as some grains of sand (Sorites paradox)

Regarding moral relativism, I don't buy it, but that's not something we can argue about in an HN thread...

You are right that pure moral arguments don't change anything, but I don't think the reason is that people don't share morals, but rather have to do with people being extremely good at rationalizing away the immorality, or never questioning it in the first place. Of course, if you think ethics is a relative concept then this reply won't convince you but the argument that might convince you would not fit this format.

placebo··on Controversies in field of mathematics
Interesting question. As long as the controversies remain in the field of abstract/theoretical mathematics, I guess it would be hard to resolve them, but I would guess that if a controversial statement (not just a controversial proof) would be applied at some point to practical problems (in science or engineering) then reality would quickly point out who was right...
placebo··on FBI Hunt for 2 Missing Pigs Reveals Federal Cover-Up of Barbaric Factory Farms
The fact that a clear line doesn't exist is used too many times as an excuse to continue doing what is obviously wrong. Logically, you could take it the other way to the extreme and say that since there is no clear line, then there isn't an obvious reason not to raise certain humans for their meat either.

The fact that life is not black and white but a lot of grey levels does not imply that there is no such thing as black or white. If one's moral compass and integrity are still intact, then even knowing the constraints, one would usually try to make the grey a little brighter.

placebo··on URL to PDF Microservice
Cool. Nice to learn of another option. What would be the advantages of using this over wkhtmltopdf (https://wkhtmltopdf.org) ?
placebo··on IMF Head Foresees the End of Banking and the Triumph of Cryptocurrency
Two examples I know of are: https://github.com/metacurrency/holochain/wiki/FAQ and http://bitlattice.org/

Although I'm far from being knowledgable enough to know the disadvantages of these methods in relation to blockchain nor whether they can really deliver on their claims. From what I've learned, my intuition says they're more suited to the task - could be a wrong impression though, hope someone here more knowledgeable on the subject could expand on it.

placebo··on IMF Head Foresees the End of Banking and the Triumph of Cryptocurrency
From the little that I've managed to learn, it seems like cryptocurrencies have immense potential but, beside the natural opposition from those who prefer the "conservative way of doing things" (due to a variety of reasons, some legitimate and some less so), it seems that the blockchain (as ingenious as it is) does not really scale well to handle a global economy. There are ongoing efforts and solutions to solve this but I think they are all essentially equivalent to a person trying to do crazy contortions in order to wear in a badly made suit. There are a few projects that propose interesting and scalable alternatives to blockchain but once the herd has decided then I assume more money will be poured on making a wrong solution workable than making a right solution the standard.
placebo··on JOE – Joe's own editor 4.5 released
I found JOE while looking for a free cross-platform, preferably open source editor that could handle huge files with ease - you know, file sizes that make most editors choke and die (or make your system freeze while trying to allocate an insane amount of memory). Even vim isn't especially effective handling very large files. JOE was the first (and for the time being, the only) free cross-platform editor I found that handles the largest of files easily.

Found it here (noticed this link was submitted to HN in the past):

https://github.com/jhallen/joes-sandbox/blob/master/editor-p...

placebo··on The end of Framework Churn
>The era of Framework churn is coming to an end, and now we can all go back to working on what makes our apps unique instead of spending precious time, energy, and money jumping to something new every year.

I believe this to be naively optimistic, but I'm all for Web components or any other development that help simplify things a bit. It's just that there will never be any silver bullet. I can make a list of the types of "The era of <Problem X> is now over and from here on it will be smooth sailing forever" that I've witnessed followed by the introduction of <Problem Y> that couldn't be anticipated. In a world of exponential complexity and creativity, I don't think this cycle is avoidable. It seems that the best we can hope for is that the rate that initiatives of abstraction, consolidation and standardization will manage to keep up with the forces (market and other) of defragmentation and growing complexity.

placebo··on New research reveals methods on how best not to worry
Not sure what new insights were brought up here.
placebo··on Neural Nets Can Learn Function Type Signatures from Binaries [pdf]
I've often wondered about the theoretical limit of a neural net to learn from examples - seems like a fascinating subject with a lots of implications. From a quick search, I found this paper: https://experts.illinois.edu/en/publications/computational-l... which is already very interesting. Are there any other good pointers on this?
placebo··on Roger McNamee: I invested early in Google and Facebook and regret it
Show me one groundbreaking technology that wasn't also used to the detriment of humanity. As long as there are shitty human traits, there will be shitty use of new technology. The only question is whether good will outweigh the bad. Just as with nuclear technology, it is still too early to tell whether humanity will be wise enough to handle its own intelligence.
placebo··on A checklist of marketing ideas for side projects
That's neat, thanks.
placebo··on There is no such thing as EQ (2016)
>1. You can just invent a trait.

Of course you can, though it will probably be a useless invention.

>2. You don't have to define a trait, measure it or distinguish it from other traits or use it to predict the important ways that people vary.

Naturally, if you're going to invent a trait you should distinguish it from other traits as well as show it has predictive power. Measuring it however is the tricky part, but not being able to currently measure it does not mean it doesn't exist.

>3. EQ is a psychometrically valid concept. >4. It isn't the Big Five trait agreeableness

Don't know - didn't major in psychology.

>5. EQ measures shouldn't all measure THE SAME THING

Yes they should, once EQ measures are well defined and standardized, which they are not.

I admit that What rubbed me the wrong way about the answer was the elitist vibe I got from it - if I'd have listened to predictors about me in my youth, I wouldn't never have reached anything I've achieved. Hubris is dangerous thing, and this is the feeling I got. I'm open to the possibility that it may well be a wrong interpretation on my part though.

placebo··on There is no such thing as EQ (2016)
You are right regarding my broad claim - I stand corrected. You are also right regarding my lack of authority, but experience shows that authority (professional or otherwise) is not always backed up by a broader understanding. If I'm wrong I'll be the first to admit it. The professor is saying there is no such thing as EQ. What I understand he means is that there is no such thing as EQ in psychology, and therefore the concept does not exist or is worthless. I'm in no position to argue with a professional in psychology on psychology. What I'm saying is that psychology doesn't have a monopoly on defining what traits exist.
placebo··on There is no such thing as EQ (2016)
I'm aware he's an authority, which is exactly the reason I caution against blind acceptance.
placebo··on There is no such thing as EQ (2016)
I read the answer, and my response is to the repeated "There is no such thing as EQ" statements which are stressed throughout it. How is anything I wrote not related to that statement? (edited my reply to be more constructive)
placebo··on There is no such thing as EQ (2016)
Wow, so many wrong things with this answer...

Of course, it would not surprise me to learn that measuring IQ as a predictor for success (or at least what a measurer defines as success) is much more accurate than "measuring" EQ for the same purpose. It makes sense - IQ is demonstrably measurable while EQ is some vague concept "popularized by a journalist". However, to go from this to a broad statement that there is no such thing as EQ is just silly. You could just as well say that there's no such thing as beauty because there is no accurate test to quantify it.

For a simple demonstration that EQ is an important quality for prediction of "success", just think of all the successful people you know and ask yourselves whether you think they would be as successful if they had the emotional makeup of an 8 year old.

This Quora answer has too much of a "trust me, I'm an authority" vibe to it

edited: ok, removed stuff that upon reflection does not contribute to the discussion - my apologies for that. The main point however stands. The repeated claims of no such thing as EQ should be qualified with "in the field of psychology" - in that case, I have no objection to the answer.

placebo··on Show HN: 15-question language identification quiz
same score, same reasons :)
placebo··on [dead]
"One possible conclusion would be that if we look at the universe in totality and not bracket any subset of phenomena, the mathematics we would need would have no axioms at all. That is, the universe in totality is devoid of structure and needs no axioms to describe it."

To me, this speculation sounds intuitively true, probably because of my attraction to non-dual teachings. Of course, at that point, it raises the question of what is mathematics without axioms - in what sense is it still mathematics, and for whom?

placebo··on Soti – A $1B firm built in a basement
Thank you for a great idea for my next startup - an application to micromanage remote workers. It will be even better than office micromanagement since the boss will have a large screen where all the remote desktops will be visible and under control simultaneously and the boss will be able to assist remote developers get back on track should they ever consider taking any initiative or heaven forbid be creative. It will also make it much easier to spot activities that do not seem to be directly work related. I feel I'm really on to something :-)
← PreviousPage 8 of 14Next →