HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

plasticeagle

694 karma · joined November 4, 2022

submissionscomments
plasticeagle··on Claude Code is steganographically marking requests
Why oh why, please why, did you use AI to write this? It's about five times longer than it needs to be. It repeats itself over and over again. It's agony to read.

Please, just write normal English that we can read. Please, for the love of god, respect our time and the attention we will be spending on the text you provide.

Anyway, one can scarcely be surprised that the AI companies are being dishonest in their tools. They're consistently dishonest in their marketing. They're famously dishonest in their financials. Why anyone trusts these people with anything is entirely beyond me. But here we are - people handing over their creativity, their productivity, to these things.

You don't have to. You didn't need these tools before, when you were creating content, when you were writing code. You don't need it now. Fight back. Stop using it. It's not hard. It's easy.

plasticeagle··on OpenCV 5 Is Here: The Biggest Leap in Years for Computer Vision
The thing I love about OpenCV is that it remains hands down the best library for simply loading images and video. I've never even used any of its fancy computer vision features, but if I need to load a video file and look at the pixels - which I did need to do recently for an art project - OpenCV does it in about four lines of code.
plasticeagle··on The 29th International Obfuscated C Code Contest (IOCCC) 2025 Winners
I downloaded and built this, and I feel confident in stating that this is the most impressive thing I have ever seen.
plasticeagle··on What Apple and Google are doing to push notifications
Massively overlong article that really could have done with an editor. Although obviously editors cost money, and I'm reading it for free, so I can scarcely complain. Nevertheless, some concision would have been appreciated.

I'm very unclear to me what the thesis of the article actually is. Yes, push notifications run through the vendor's servers. Yes, Apple fucked up hard by modifying the text within them - and I contend that such modification is impossible to perform automatically without unreliability becoming the norm.

The author also appears to believe that "broadcast copy" - otherwise known as Spam by those who like to write slightly more honestly - is a legitimate use of push notifications. It is manifestly not, and any app that tries will at the very least be immediately silenced. I wish I could find the tweet that put this sentiment more entertainingly than I ever could.

If App developers continue to abuse the push notification system in this way, Apple and Google will be forced to take steps to solve what becomes an end-user's problem. Yet another tragedy of the commons.

plasticeagle··on Throwing AI-generated walls of text into conversations
Why, considering that this article makes a good point, was it written using AI?
plasticeagle··on C++26 Shipped a SIMD Library Nobody Asked For
I don't use AI at work either. Never will.
plasticeagle··on 1024000^2 Blocks, 2B2T Minecraft Server World Download Project, and Discoveries
I don't know anything about this project, but reading the text in the readme I was very pleasantly surprised to discover not a single hint of the dreaded AI voice in there. Instead, a real human voice shining through. Thank you, whoever you are, for trusting in your humanity and your ability to express yourself without the help of the infernal machine.
plasticeagle··on C++26 Shipped a SIMD Library Nobody Asked For
Nobody should read that AI slop article. Nobody.

Maybe there's an interesting story in there, it's certainly possible. But the "author" could not be bothered to write it, and so why should we waster our time reading it?

plasticeagle··on Scouting's Real Crisis Is Not Marketing. It Is Decades of Neglect.
AI;DR
plasticeagle··on An AI agent deleted our production database. The agent's confession is below
I personally have absolutely zero sympathy for anyone that uses "Agentic AI" - or any other form of AI - for anything at all.

It has been so transparently clear for years that nothing these people sell is worth a damn. They have exactly one product, an unreliable and impossible-to-fix probabilistic text generation engine. One that, even theoretically, cannot be taught to distinguish fact from fiction. One that has no a priori knowledge of even the existence of truth.

When I learned that "Agentic AI" is literally just taking an output of a chatbot and plugging it into your shell I almost fell off my chair. My organisation has very strict cybersecurity policies. Surveillance software runs on every machine. Network traffic is monitored at ingress and egress, watching for suspicious patterns.

And yet. People are permitted to let a chatbot choose what to execute on their machines inside our network. I am absolutely flabbergasted that this is allowed. Is this how lazy and stupid we have become?

plasticeagle··on PostgreSQL production incident caused by transaction ID wraparound
AI;DR

Which is why it's

TL;DR

Boring shit article about obvious problem.

plasticeagle··on The Grand Line
AI;DR

Horrible soulless dross.

plasticeagle··on We moved Railway's frontend off Next.js. Builds went from 10+ mins to under 2
The answer is to write your server in portable C++, and just rebuild it for whatever new OS you're dealing with.

The speed. Imagine the performance. There are plenty of mature C++ web server frameworks, it's really not difficult. If you're afraid of C++, you could choose something else. Rust if you're insane, or golang if you're insane but in a different way.

Anyway. Nginx is not going away, so the argument is a bit silly. "What if js went away". Same thing.

plasticeagle··on We moved Railway's frontend off Next.js. Builds went from 10+ mins to under 2
AI;DR
plasticeagle··on OpenClaw privilege escalation vulnerability
Open Claw cannot be made "secure" by any normal definition of the word. Unless I'm very much mistaken, fundamentally it's a tool that lets LLMs do stuff.

So you take the output of an LLM, which is obviously impossibly to guarantee correct, and use that to choose a tool and execute it. Like, send an email or whatever. And you take the input for that LLM not only from prompts, and various files, but also your system and random stuff you download from the internet.

I am telling you people, this is lunacy. No good can come of this.

plasticeagle··on I am definitely missing the pre-AI writing era
"I think that is the beauty of writing, the raw , unedited emotions of the person behind every words either for entertainment or educational purposes, is what makes it special"

This is not the beauty of writing. Everyone's writing needs editing. The "raw unedited emotions" are not something anyone wants to read, and this article is no exception.

The author tells us that English is their fourth language, which is certainly impressive. However their writing is messy and poorly constructed. It's difficult to read, and not at all enjoyable. The choice is not between doggerel like this, and LLM empty perfection.

plasticeagle··on Do Not Turn Child Protection into Internet Access Control
AI;DR

It's too late in any case, the Internet as we know it will eat itself. It will be destroyed by AI, and AI agents from without. And it will be destroyed from within by stupid laws such as the ones under "discussion" in this AI-edited and AI-illustrated nothingpiece.

By which I not mean the infrastructure. I mean the current crop of social media websites. The infrastructure will remain, and perhaps something better will come along to use that infrastructure.

plasticeagle··on The L in "LLM" Stands for Lying
Acko.net remains the best website on the internet.
plasticeagle··on How to talk to anyone and why you should
I agree with this article completely.

I've had three long and very memorable conversations on internaltional plane flights in the past, with three extremely interesting and intelligent people. I don't tend to take those flights anymore, they were for work and the novelty of international travel for work wore off. Now I get out of it whenever I can.

But those three conversations have stayed with me.

plasticeagle··on An AI Agent Published a Hit Piece on Me – The Operator Came Forward
Well, it looks like AI will destroy the internet. Oh well, it was nice while it lasted. Fun, even.

Fortunately, the vast majority of the internet is of no real value. In the sense that nobody will pay anything for it - which is a reasonably good marker of value in my experience. So, given that, let the AI psychotics have their fun. Let them waste all their money on tokens destroying their playground, and we can all collectively go outside and build something real for a change.

plasticeagle··on Internet voting is insecure and should not be used in public elections
I applied for my passport online. If it's secure enough for that, then it's secure enough for voting.
plasticeagle··on Beowulf's opening "What" is no interjection (2013)
I love the phrase "Subtly wide of the mark."
plasticeagle··on Can you slim macOS down?
"Power Users", whatever that might really mean use MacOS because it works. They use a Mac laptop because it always and instantly wakes from sleep. Because the audio always works, and is always low latency. Because they have work to do, and the OS is extremely reliable. Also because it is light, and the battery lasts for a very long time indeed.

My laptop has been up for 43 days, not very long in a server world, but excellent for a personal device that I use for development, hardware design and audio production. The last time it restarted was probably for an OS upgrade, but I can't recall.

My work linux laptop is also pretty reliable, but this is only because I never upgrade anything on it and only use it for development. Its battery life is terrible, so I only use it plugged into the wall. My work linux desktop has issues with bluetooth audio and graphics, neither of which I can be bothered to fix.

plasticeagle··on A decentralized peer-to-peer messaging application that operates over Bluetooth
This is entirely false, Apple allows the use of threads in their applications.
plasticeagle··on ChatGPT Health
It also doesn't make any sense. It's like self-driving cars that require you to pay attention at all times anyway.
plasticeagle··on ChatGPT Health
This is absolutely going to kill people. In a country that had even a modicum of regulation around providing healthcare this would be illegal.
plasticeagle··on Cameras and Lenses (2020)
Incredible. Not a whiff of AI (I mean, obviously I see now because it's from 2020). Just fantastic to see clear and elegant writing again.
plasticeagle··on The "confident idiot" problem: Why AI needs hard rules, not vibe checks
The first thing I do on Hacker News when there's an AI post is run to the comments for a good time. The later I go back and read the actual article, and in this case hoo boy what a doozy. An AI-written summary of a seemingly not vibe-coded python library written by a human being who apparently genuinely believes that you can fix LLM hallucinations with enough Regular Expressions.

It would be magnificent if this is satire. Wonderful.

plasticeagle··on The "confident idiot" problem: Why AI needs hard rules, not vibe checks
I have had conversations at work, with people who I have reason to believe are smart and critical, in which they made the claim that humans and AI basically learn in the same way. My response to them, as to anyone that makes this claim, is that the amount of data ingested by someone with severe sensory dysfunction of one sort or another is very small. Helen Keller is the obvious extreme example, but even a person who is simply blind is limited to the bandwidth of their hearing.

And yet, nobody would argue that a blind person is any less intelligent that a sighted person. And so the amount of data a human ingests is not correlated with intelligence. Intelligence is something else.

When LLMs were first proposed as useful tools for examining data and proving answers to questions, I wondered to myself how they would solve the problem of there being no a-priori knowledge of truth in the models. How they would find a way of sifting their terabytes of training data so that the models learnt only true things.

Imagine my surprise that not only did they not attempt to do this, but most people did not appear to understand that this was a fundamental and unsolvable problem at the heart of every LLM that exists anywhere. That LLMs, without this knowledge, are just random answer generators. Many, many years ago I wrote a fun little Markov-chain generator I called "Talkback", that you could feed a short story to and then have a chat with. It enjoyed brief popularity at the University I attended, you could ask it questions and it would sort-of answer. Nobody, least of all myself, imagined that the essential unachievable idea - "feed in enough text and it'll become human" - would actually be a real idea in real people's heads.

This part of your answer though;

"My paper and pen version of the latest LLM .... My paper and pen version of the latest LLM"

Is just a variation of the Chinese Room argument, and I don't think it holds water by itself. It's not that it's just an algorithm, it's that learning anything usefully correct from the entire corpus of human literary output by itself is fundamentally impossible.

plasticeagle··on What they don't tell you about maintaining an open source project
Particularly frustratingly because it's so unnecessary in this case. It's not even that much text, just write it yourself. It would probably take less time.
← PreviousPage 2 of 6Next →