HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

plinkplonk

14,193 karma · joined February 20, 2007

Ravi Mohan

http://twitter.com/ravi_mohan , magicindian@gmail.com

Please feel free to email me about anything I can help you with! :)

submissionscomments
plinkplonk··on Ask HN: Ex-FAANG developers, where are you now and why?
great reply, thanks for taking the effort.

I hope to never work for other people again, but if I did, Stripe would be on top of the list of companies I'd apply to (despite their use of Ruby ;-) ). The CEO seems to have his head screwed on straight, and all employees I interact with seem very competent and pleasant.

This is a great answer, and I particularly appreciate the "bad differences".

plinkplonk··on Why the novel matters in the age of anger
agreed.

First, tell a good story. If the story can additionally be interpreted metaphorically to support specific viewpoints, so be it.

There are exceptions, but most of the time, when I reach for a novel, I am not looking for political commentary.

plinkplonk··on Rejected Then Recruited: Our Journey into Y Combinator
that's great to hear! so it seems you just had the bad luck to stumble across an exception to the 'rule'.
plinkplonk··on Ask HN: Do you regret becoming a programmer?
a more interesting question might be "Do you regret staying a programmer (after the first n years)?"
plinkplonk··on Rejected Then Recruited: Our Journey into Y Combinator
"The YC partner I met had the feedback that an online REPL is not really a startup -- it's just a fun toy -- and that instead, I should join another company building a superficially similar technology."

Interesting, especially since PG has stated that many a good company looks like "just a fun toy" in the beginning. I'd have thought that would be a heuristic YC folks keep in mind, and not use it to dismiss an idea.

plinkplonk··on Ask HN: How do I choose between a job offer from Google and a promising startup?
>if the startup is successful you_might_ make $10m

if the startup is the next facebook, sure. But usually an employee doesn't make 10 million, even for 100 million dollar(+) acquisitions. Founders do, but that is a different game.

plinkplonk··on India’s Aadhaar Software Hacked, ID Database Compromised, Experts Confirm
> I just checked other news sources in India, and no one has any news about any recent Aadhaar breach.

here you go

NDTV

https://gadgets.ndtv.com/internet/news/aadhaar-software-patc...

It is on the front page.

It takes mainstream sources a while to react to news. In 24-48 hours, all mainstream newspapers will have the news.

plinkplonk··on Transmuting Low-Value Programmer Cred into High-Value Status Illegibility
yeah highlighting "Uncle" Bob as a "10" with respect to programmer cred was a weak point of the essay. He is basically a one trick (TDD) evangelist pony and I doubt he has any serious developer cred outside the agile methodologies circlejerk groups. Not like he is Linus or Carmack or Jeff Dean.

That said, the actual phenomenon that the author was trying to highlight with example is pretty valid imo.

"Companies like this don’t hire 10s because a single 10 will single-handedly raise their margin or even land them clients. They do it to grease the skids of recruitment. That hire is neither about clients nor about work product — it’s about recruiting."

Pure Gold.

plinkplonk··on Peter Thiel: “Hypnotic Mass Phenomena”
Peter Thiel seems to be persona non grata in HN circles because he supported candidate Trump (in 2016) and later joined some sort of inner circle when Trump became president (is what I can make out from half a world away).

This kind of flagging is borderline insanity imo. (I have no stake in US or SF politics / social phenomena)

plinkplonk··on Interview with Patrick Collison
I really like the fact that this book is explicitly addressed to (CXOs of / senior managers of) companies that have already found a product / market fit, and is now transitioning into a 'BigCo', which means that startup founders who are not going through that stage of company growth can skim the book, (as can people who want to remain engineers). There is a lot of 'managerese' in the book, which is inevitable given its focus. I still can't decide if some of the interviewees are actually insightful, or just happened to be at the right place at the right time, and are now mouthing platitudes.

This book is really meant for people who want to be senior managers in a company that is growing like crazy, and want to take on the people and organizational challenges that result.

Also the book is very explicitly centered around the "SF way" of building companies, and I wonder how much of this advice would apply to, say, a Chinese unicorn. (I think, not very much. e.g: 'diversity' as key focus area for the CEO seems to be a very SF centric (or at least US centric) way of doing things, and reflective of social and political phenomena in the USA. I doubt Chinese or Korean CEOs spend as much time on 'identity politics' flavored 'diversity hiring' as a CEO would in SF)

So if you are scaling up a post product/market fit company in SF/the USA, and are in a senior management position in that company, this book is likely to be of great help.

Even otherwise it is a good roadmap to how you can "live long enough to see yourself become the villain" ;-).

The book has a different focus from many "startup" books and that is refreshing. Overall I liked it, modulo the 'platitude problem' I mentioned above.

I really liked the interview with Patrick Collison, who seems to have his head screwed on right.

plinkplonk··on How two strangers set up Dropbox and made billions
from the article (medium, not BBC)

"The pair worked tirelessly for three months in a cramped office in Cambridge, waking up everyday at noon and working till dawn the next day. “I think we started like most of these tech companies begin. Just a couple of guys in their boxers coding in a dark room,” Houston says. “We just kept our heads down and built.”"

plinkplonk··on Ask HN: What are your heuristics for deciding which HN links to click on?
I actively avoid anything to do with geopolitics/US politics/social justice wars/fads (cryptocurrency), and as a result, I find HN (still) useful and informative.
plinkplonk··on Ask HN: Which book have you re-read the most times? how many times?
(have an upvote)

IF I were that interested in a book,(THEN) I'd just learn the language of the original (Sanskrit for the BG) and read the original. Most translations miss many nuances.

plinkplonk··on How my role as CTO has changed as we've grown from 1 to 100 engineers
"At this point, I believe technical co-founders have a binary choice: Stay on the technical track and hire a professional manager (usually given the VP of Engineering title), or give up coding and focus on the management aspects yourself. It really isn’t possible to do both."

For me this is the key quote.

I have a friend who went the other way from the author of this article. He started as one of two company founders working out of an apartment doing all the technical work while the other founder focused on business stuff.

When the company grew to a point where he had to decide between staying technical and people management, he hired a VP of Engineering, stuck to coding, and still codes 6-8 hours a day.

The company is now at about 200 people, is profitable, raised a series A after figuring out the business model, and blowing past the goals set by the investors. His stake in the company is worth many tens of millions today.

Just an existence proof that 'sticking to coding', can be a viable strategy, if an unusual one.

He is not interested in blogging/social media etc, or else I'd have persuaded him to write up his experience.

I have to agree with dang. Most people running successful startups don't have (or take) the time to write about it.

Which is too bad (imo). We could use more writeups from the successful subset.

plinkplonk··on Seattle officials repeal tax on large companies
Thanks, that makes a lot more sense.
plinkplonk··on Seattle officials repeal tax on large companies
Great article. Much better than the New York Times article.

From TFA

"Is this really all about Amazon?

No, but you’d be forgiven for thinking it was. Council member Kshama Sawant, who exhorted her supporters to “Pack City Hall!” in a mass email yesterday, has consistently characterized the head tax as a “tax on Amazon” and Jeff Bezos, whom she described earlier today as “the enemy.”

Demonizing individual corporations is rarely a path to building broad community coalitions, and that’s especially true when that corporation is Amazon, whose name many Seattleites (rightly or wrongly) consider synonymous with “jobs.” This is one reason head tax opponents were able to so easily spin the head tax as a “tax on jobs,” and to get ordinary citizens to gather signatures against a tax that would really only impact the city’s largest corporations."

That seems like bad politics. Isn't it politics 101 to anticipate that the affected parties (here Amazon and Starbucks) would push back? And if enough political support to overcome this hasn't been built up in the first place, why would someone try passing the head tax at all? This is like playing chess looking only one move ahead.

I don't get it.

Help me understand?

(Due Disclosure: Not a US citizen, nor a Seattle resident, I don't have a position, pro or anti, on the tax measure itself)

plinkplonk··on Ask HN: What are some good examples of test-driven C codebases?
having a test suite is different from being test driven .
plinkplonk··on The end of India’s ‘IT miracle’?
I am not 'defending India'. I could care less about what people think of India. I am not a nationalist or 'patriot'/desh bhakt and have no problems with criticisms of any country or institution. FSM knows India and Indian institutions need plenty of criticism.

I'm just pointing out lazy forms of argumentation, essentially generalizing from narrow experiences, or media propagated stereotypes about millions of people, which is why I explicitly created a sentence of the same form substituting a stereotype about the USA.

My constructed 'criticism' is just as much out of whack as the original, and has no 'truth' in it, when made as a general statement about all of "Americans" / or more condescendingly "you guys".

There doesn't seem much of a link between 'bureaucratic work cultures' and size of the economy (Germany, China, Korea, Japan)

If you didn't understand that point, I don't know what to say.

I'll just say YMMV, and leave it at that.

plinkplonk··on The end of India’s ‘IT miracle’?
"I really hope that you guys learn a less bureaucratic and hierarical way of working"

These generalizations make as much sense as me telling a random American HN user "I really hope that you guys stop indulging your blood lust by invading other countries and killing millions of innocents to make profits for your munitions industry and you as a country become less bloodthirsty"

Most Americans are not killers, though the subset someone from an invaded country has encountered maybe. All Indians don't have a "bureaucratic and heirarchical" way of working, though the subset encountered by someone seeking cheap outsourcing may be.

If you try outsourcing dev to China you'll encounter the same 'bureaucratic and hierarchical' ways of working, but they have massive product companies that are on par with anything in America. So the reason why India doesn't yet have dominant software product companies lie elsewhere.

Meanwhile these 'hopes' that "you guys learn to be less bureaucratic" are just sneers and stereotyping in disguise.

As a stereotype "bureaucratic ways of working" can be applied to Germany (for example) or Japan, or Korea, and while I'm sure there are bureaucratic Germans, they seem to doing fine economically.

But,carry on. This is the internet.

plinkplonk··on Ask HN: Are you working on interesting technical problems?
At least Google/Facebook/Amazon/Microsoft seem to be hiring experts in all areas of Computer Science (compilers, machine learning, operating systems, networking ...), though the interesting jobs seem to be need a PhD or at least a Masters. If you have the degree, trying to get into a good group in any of these companies might be a solution to your disappointment. (you probably need to prep for jumping through some whiteboarding hoops, but still...).

At least in the USA (and probably Israel and China as well), there seem to be enough jobs that need solid academic credentials.

Alternatively. keep the CRUD expertise, move into the business side (which is fascinating if you have an interest in how the non technical world works).

plinkplonk··on Top Mistakes and Learnings from My Startup: Postmortem Samsamia
"Startup pressure can bring out the true character of a person. The problem though is that you may not know the true character of someone until startup pressure is applied -- even if that someone is your best friend."

This is true enough, but it need not be 'startup pressure' that reveals character. Many life situations can apply the same or greater quantum of pressure. So if you are going to do stressful startups with a friend, see if you have gone through hell before and come out on the other side still friends.

Tangentially life crises are very revealing of who your true friends are. Likewise romantic partners. When you are going through hell, just look around to see who is still there, and who ran for the hills.

plinkplonk··on A New History of Arabia, Written in Stone
"He wrote to professors in Semitic studies around the country asking for guidance. They all replied, “Nobody starts with Akkadian—you need to learn Biblical Hebrew, classical Arabic, and Syriac first,” he said. For two years, he studied those languages on his own in the library. After graduating, he was accepted into Harvard’s doctoral program in Semitic philology."

wow he learned 3 languages on his own. Very impressive.

plinkplonk··on Vipassana for Hackers [pdf]
In retrospect, the best book I should have read was Shaila Catherine(spelling?)'s "Wisdom Wide and Deep", which sets out a full practice program based on the (Theravada) Buddhist texts Abhidamma and VishuddiMagga. This is about as hard core a book as you can find. Richard Shankman's "The Experience of Samadhi" is a much more lightweight alternative on just Jhana (and not Vipassana iirc), nowhere as deep but an easier read.

In reality, I had to piece together 'algorithms' from random sources and test them out. The basic instructions for jhana and vipassana meditations I ended up with match with those in SK's book, though her path involves getting into extremely deep states of jhana before switching to Vipassana, wheras I developed both skills in parallel (which is a valid method and used by other Buddhist schools)

I used to meditate 2 to 4 hours a day (more on self set 'retreats'). These days I meditate about an hour to 90 minutes per day. I'm not interested in going beyond basic jhana and vipassana and did not do 'skeleton meditation' , 'corpse meditation' etc, because at that point, - about the middle of Shaila's book - the meditations begin to seriously embody Buddhist dogma about the nature of reality and purpose of life etc, specifically ways to 'shake loose' your identification with your body, and so on. I have no wish to be 'liberated' from 'samsara', or otherwise be a full time Buddhist monk or the equivalent, so I stopped with achieving the ability to do either Jhana or Vipassana meditations for a few hours at a time.

I use these purely in a non religious fashion, as 'weight training for my mind' and am happy with my limited achievements.

Even at this relatively minor level of practice, things begin to get funky at the edges, as Steven's paper illustrates.

plinkplonk··on Vipassana for Hackers [pdf]
I totally agree that a community centered effort, with expert teachers etc, would be exactly what a lot of folks need. I have no problem with whatever structure works for anyone.

I was just pushing back a bit against the "only way" phrase in the paper. I'm just saying, from direct personal experience, that one can learn on one's own.

There is the essence, and then there are the superficial details.

e.g: you don't really have to sit cross legged on the floor to learn the technique, just because ancient Indians or Burmese people did.

You can sit on a chair or stool, with your back straight, and feet flat on the ground, hands on your knees, and your meditation (Vipassana, Jhana, whatever) will work just fine.

This is not to say that learning to not move around in a painful position isn't worth learning, just that it has little to do with the core technique itself.

When you learn by yourself, (as you correctly point out) some things are easier, and some things are more difficult, than when learning within a community structure.

As I said above, I really enjoyed reading the paper.

plinkplonk··on Vipassana for Hackers [pdf]
yow! Torture indeed. I'd be running for the hills if I had to listen to this every day. Maybe it is there to validate you are learning the technique. If you can keep calm while being subjected to this, you've learned the technique ;-)
plinkplonk··on Vipassana for Hackers [pdf]
you could just use the meditation algorithm, and meditate by yourself for 10 (or however many) days for multiple multi-hour sessions a day, and avoid having to sit through Goenka's religious meanderings, weird sound tracks and cultiness.

Check into a cheap hotel during non-tourist season, sometime in the mountains or near a lake or sea. Switch off the phone. Eat + meditate + sleep * 10 days (or however many you want). Et voila. You get all the benefits without all the cultiness.

Vipassana is a technique. You master the technique by doing it. Attending a cult's course is one way of doing it.

Whether it is the optimal method is open to debate. The key seems to be to spend long hours practicing the technique for many days (vs 30 minutes a day). I'm not convinced proficiency in the technique can only by attained by a retreat with a specific organization.

One can learn to program in Clojure (say) by attending a 10 day course by $ClojureGuru. One can also learn to program with a book and a laptop, and occasional questions on irc. Both methods work, and have different trade offs.

Personally, I learned Vipassana (and Jhana) meditation by myself, by reading and experimenting. I've since encountered advanced Buddhist mediators (abbots of Buddhist monasteries etc) who 'confirmed' I'm "doing it right" (fwiw, I wasn't really looking for validation or advice, it just came up in conversation). They didn't seem surprised I taught myself. So I doubt it is that uncommon. If the only way to learn to 'hack' is to attend a 10 day course, that isn't much of a 'hack' in the first place.

I strongly push back against the "only way to learn is be attending a 10 day course" idea. Other than this, I enjoyed reading the paper, Steven is an excellent writer.

My 2 cents. YMMV, as it should.

PS: I do admire the grit of anyone who actually completes the 10 day retreat, not so much the meditation as enduring all the culty BS. As grit training, it probably works ;-)

PPS: I have no belief in the religious dogma of any Buddhist school. I just think the techniques are useful

plinkplonk··on Vipassana for Hackers [pdf]
There is some skepticism about the 'professor' part. No one can locate the colleges at which he supposedly taught neuroscience.

A reddit discussion.

https://www.reddit.com/r/TheMindIlluminated/comments/6sx7n7/...

plinkplonk··on Pilot.com raises $15M to bring bookkeeping into the modern era
Due Disclosure: Worked at Intuit, once upon a time

QuickBooks has network effects (most accountants use it and are familiar with it) and lockin effects (once you have many years of your data in it, there is no way to get it out and into another software. at least that is the way it was when I worked there).

Other products with these characteristics have been disrupted and so can QB. But it will take a lot of work, or a powerful change in perspective. That said, from the article on TC, I don't think Pilot is actually competing with QB.Seems to be more like a layer on top.

I also agree with most of what curun1r says. Intuit is a weird company in many ways, but they do know what they are doing businesswise.

plinkplonk··on Cold calling for my startup and how I learned to embrace the challenge
I hate getting cold calls. So I avoid doing it to other people.

Yes that makes me less of a salesman. So be it.

Tangent: In India you can report unsolicited sales calls to a central (government) authority, where you can sign up to get on a "Do Not Disturb" list, and get any sales caller who ignores this fined, and eventually get his number disconnected etc.

The system isn't perfect, and there are some impressive hacks to bypass it, but the situation now is much better than before these regulations existed. Where one used to get multiple spammers a day, now weeks and months can go by before getting one (who I promptly report). My number must be on some shared "cranky idiot who hates cold callers" list, I almost never get these calls now.

A minister was interrupted in parliament while presenting the annual national budget (iirc) by someone who wanted to sell him a credit card(!), which led to this regulation.

And it is a godsend. Cold callers should all burn in hellfire (imo)

plinkplonk··on Let’s have no managers, instead of managers with no engineering experience
I don't think 'no managers' is a good idea. There are managerial 'things to be done' in every project.

As a thought experiment, if management were 'just a role' and people could switch into for a period of time and then go back to their 'real jobs' with no loss of pay or prestige, that might lead to some interesting effects.

(warning, anecdata:I've worked on teams where the 'manager' role was cycled among engineers/testers/designers etc throughout the project lifetime, and it worked well. I've also seen managers come back to being full time developers, and their perspective from the time of being managers really helped with their effectiveness as developers)

← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →