HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

plopilop

591 karma · joined June 2, 2016

submissionscomments
plopilop··on Teenager facing prison for downloading unsecured files from government website
In France, we had a similar case, a computer guy with the pseudonym Bluetouff[0].

He downloaded loads of national agencies confidential documents, because they were available on Google.

However, he was sentenced (3,000€ fine), because when he explored the website, he arrived on a connection page, thus realizing he should not have accessed these files, but continued anyway.

I just hope for the teenager that he did not encounter any login page in his search (which seems unlikely because he used a script).

[0] (in french): http://www.maitre-eolas.fr/post/2014/02/07/NON%2C-on-ne-peut...

plopilop··on Notice of Data Breach
As mentioned in the Reddit thread, the terms now specify that that they share your data with partners. I guess the consent they got from you was "Oh hi, so here's the new version of the app, btw we updated our policies, click anywhere to agree".
plopilop··on Notice of Data Breach
Maybe they just sold your email, they don't need to have been breached for that.
plopilop··on Probabilistic Filters By Example
"Valid" configurations do not exist, there are only optimal/suboptimal and saturated/unsaturated ones. The classic FPR makes no assumptions about this (indeed optimality is derived from FPR minimum), and as such should apply as well to suboptimal saturated configuration, were it correct.

However looking at theorem 3 in [0] I think the difference between "classic" and "real" FPR is small, especially for larger n and m. At the end of [0] is mentioned a study in which the authors could not reach the classic FPR in their simulations, but attributed this result to bad pseudorandomness of elements. [0]'s author claim that the difference may instead come from the real FPR value (which is actually very hard to compute, so it's hard to be sure).

The 5/8 probability mentioned is indeed correct. First element has four equiprobable possible outputs for its two hashes: (0,0), (0,1), (1,0) and (1,1). Same for the second element, which yields 16 different cases. Out of these 16 cases 10 will lead to a false positive.

plopilop··on How I Erased Facebook Comments and Likes
Oh, my bad, I misunderstood your sentence.
plopilop··on Probabilistic Filters By Example
Strange coincidence, just this morning I was reading a paper [0] from 2008 about Bloom filters. Specifically, their false positive rate is higher than what is usually advertised - even on Wikipedia.

Edit: also as is written in the document, Cuckoo Filters and Bloom filters are not adapted to unbounded streams. Better options may include, for instance, Stable Bloom Filter[1] and block-Decaying Bloom Filter[2]

[0]: http://cglab.ca/~morin/publications/ds/bloom-submitted.pdf

[1]: http://webdocs.cs.ualberta.ca/~drafiei/papers/DupDetExt.pdf

[2]: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11390-008-9192-1

plopilop··on Probabilistic Filters By Example
The idea is that two elements x and y despite having the same fingerprint, will be stored into two different buckets. So you can have several time the same fingerprint in a Cuckoo filter, which you can't in a Bloom Filter.

When you want to remove x, you remove one of the two fingerprints, it does not matter which since they're the same. Next when you query y you will be sure to still have a positive answer.

Note that however the deletion won't necessarily make the filter forget about x. It will just clear some place in the structure.

plopilop··on How I Erased Facebook Comments and Likes
I don't think it's the case yet. GDPR will enforce the right to be forgotten and as such truly delete data about you, but other than that, I don't think there are other regulations forcing you to delete data.
plopilop··on The Dirty Secret of ‘Secret Family Recipes’
I have an opposite story.

Once upon a time in the French countryside, there was an old pastry chef who was well known for her unique creation (of which I forgot the name), that, even 40 years later, my father still praises.

The recipe was only known by the pastry chef, even though the famous local restaurant chef (Georges Blanc, now 3 Michelin stars, at least 2 stars at the time) begged her to sell him the secret, whatever the price. She said, "my recipe will follow me into the grave". And it did.

TL;DR: come in Bresse, best food ever.

plopilop··on Hacker News's Undocumented Features and Behaviors
Sure, but most of the time I don't feel like I have things relevant to add to the discussion, I'm more of the lurker type.

I just wanted to point out that in my case, getting points was not that easy. But I actually don't care about it, so everything is fine for me. :)

plopilop··on Hacker News's Undocumented Features and Behaviors
Aaaaaaaand now this comment is my most upvoted comment. Obviously.
plopilop··on Hacker News's Undocumented Features and Behaviors
I don't find it easy personally, my most upvoted comment has 14 points, most are under 4 points.

But then, I don't comment often and I don't care about being able to downvote, so I think I'll survive.

plopilop··on Capturing Starman from 1M miles away
- According to wikipedia, the launch mass of the Falcon Heavy is about 26 tons for a geostationnary launch, which is quite a lot and definitely enough for ISS like launches. I guess either the launch mass is way lower for leaving earth's orbit, or either they just wanted to prove they could ship in something of significant mass without having to pay for all the required fuel.

- For Roadster's orbit, most of the time it will be fine, however some have predicted that it will end up crashing on Venus in a few million years [0]. And that makes me wonder whether the Roadster has been properly disinfected (I very much doubt so).

Also, for one of your original questions, the car is completely alone on its orbit, not enclosed in anything. From what I understand [1] the last booster separated itself from the car before burning during re-entry. You can see clear and beautiful pictures of the car around Earth [2]. Edit : I was wrong, the car is still attached to the last booster. See [3]

[0]: https://www.theregister.co.uk/2018/02/15/orbital_calculation...

[1]: https://www.theguardian.com/science/2018/feb/07/space-oddity...

[2]: https://www.mercurynews.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/falco...

[3]: https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/25016/what-all-is-...

plopilop··on Science’s Pirate Queen
All right, but then why are most open-access papers under $3000?

If an editor can survive with these fees even when the paper will be publicly available, how can Nature need $30,000 for a paper people will pay to read?

plopilop··on Calculating Tupper’s Self-Referential Formula with SQL
Then you may be interested in Jakub Trávník's self referential formula: http://jtra.cz/stuff/essays/math-self-reference/index.html
plopilop··on Three Meanings of E=mc²
Well, yes, but it's the same thing, really. It's what my last paragraph above is about.

E=mc² is not about nuclear reactions, it's about every reaction. A chemical reaction of combustion transforms some fuel molecules into new molecules. If you compute the mass of the products of the combustion and compare it to the mass of the fuel before burning, you will notice a sliiiiight difference (probably negligible, barely detectable). The disappearing mass has been converted to kinetic energy (and heat, but who cares).

plopilop··on Three Meanings of E=mc²
I did not know about this relativistic mass, but doesn't wikipedia says it is only true if you consider the mass as m = F/a rather than m = p/v?
plopilop··on Three Meanings of E=mc²
Well, in case of a rocket, there are two phenomenon resulting into thrust.

The first one is the action-reaction principle: fuel goes in one direction, rocket goes in the opposite one.

The second one is indeed the E=mc^2 equation: as the fuel burns, some of its mass (a negligible part, but still results in some decent amount of energy) is converted into energy and this energy can be used to propel the rocket. The rest of the mass is ejected, see first point.

So if you compare the mass of the rocket + fuel before the take-off and the mass of the rocket + burned fuel after the take-off, you will indeed see a delta, which comes from a partial conversion of mass into energy of the fuel during combustion.

Actually, as pointed out in an other comment, every reaction (or most of) leads to a decrease of the energy of the objects: an empty battery has less energy than a charged battery (yes I know I'm a genius for pointing that out). The difference of energy results, according to m = E/c², to a loss of mass. In the case of a battery, the delta is waaaay to small to be detected, but it exists.

plopilop··on Three Meanings of E=mc²
Sure, but it's less noticeable. The Sun loses 4.4 millions of tons every second (out of a mass of 10^30kg, but still)
plopilop··on Three Meanings of E=mc²
The conversion you are talking about is true only if you annihilate your fuel (which creates photons), and then you convert photons into speed in some way with 100% efficiency.

But really this never happens, rockets work by ejecting mass at a tremendous speed. Thus not all the mass of the fuel is not converted into energy.

But otherwise, yeah, converting mass to energy completely works. This is what happens in stars and nuclear bombs, actually.

plopilop··on Three Meanings of E=mc²
As I explained in an other article here on HN, another meaning (and the most important one imo) is the one Einstein actually wrote about: the inertia of a particle depends on its energy.

The thing is, you don't read E = mc² but rather (as Einstein wrote in his surprisingly easy to understand 2-pages paper [0]), m = E / c². The direct interpretation of this formulation is that inertial mass is actually just a side effect of the energy of a particle. Put into a catchy phrase, mass is energy at rest.

Edit :

[0]: https://www.fourmilab.ch/etexts/einstein/E_mc2/e_mc2.pdf, translated in english. Note the understatement of the sentence before the last one: "It is not impossible that with bodies whose energy-content is variable to a high degree (e.g. with radium salts) the theory may be successfully put to the test."

plopilop··on Making network authentication simple in a Bring Your Own Device environment
Ok, I see, my bad.

Well then, no idea.

plopilop··on Making network authentication simple in a Bring Your Own Device environment
As stated in the article, the previous version of the network required MAC addresses for authentication, and you can easily code something that will allow you to add a MAC to your account from a Web page.

But they wanted to do something new, where you don't have to ask students for something quite obscure for non-techs such as MAC address.

Of course the biggest caveat here is the number of VLANs (4096) that limit the scalability, but which was satisfactory in their case.

plopilop··on Minitel – The Rise and Fall of a National Tech Treasure [video]
È and À are actually easy to write: the grave accent ` is ALT GR + è, then type your letter.

Special thought for the ù letter, which has its own key even though it's only used in one French word 'où' (ok, we use this word fairly often, but still).

plopilop··on 6 alternative (and better) uses for blockchain
What bothers me with this blockchain is, who will actually run the nodes? If only the merchants do so, then they can also counterfeit everything just as they want. In the end you rely as much on your trust to the merchant than with the classical method (i.e., a tag that reads "Product of [country]", which is way more eco[nom/log]ical.
plopilop··on Two suns? No, it's a supernova drawn 6,000 years ago, say scientists
Soooo... This 6000 years old carving depicts two suns and the constellations of Orion and Taurus.

Yet these constellations were invented by the Greeks, inspired from the Egyptians, and should be at most 4000 years old.

I'm not an astrophysicist but I'm pretty sure something is off.

Edit: reread the article and the stone comes from Himalaya. Yet the Indians, the Chinese and, well, pretty much every civilization had their own constellation map, that did not include either Orion or Taurus.

plopilop··on Pentagon Tiling Proof Solves Century-Old Math Problem
Unless I'm wrong, the link you gave only speaks about impossibility for regular convex polygons, whereas the original links deals with the more general impossibility for any convex polygon with more than 6 sides.
plopilop··on Bloom Filters by Example
I remember I played with this specific scheme a while ago, and from what I remember it was doing the work well (I did not run a comparison though).
plopilop··on Does the Inertia of a Body Depend upon its Energy-Content? (1905) [pdf]
You can think of it as a dual approach. We can consider "E is defined as mc^2, so basically we can extract energy from mass". Alternatively, we can consider "m is E/c^2, so inertial mass is actually energy at rest".

Both explanations are valid, which doesn't mean they are contradictory.

It's kind of like one person in the train sees the person on the ground moving, even though from the person on the ground's point of view, it's the person on the train who is moving. Who's moving? Well, the interpretation depends on the referential you choose. So here, you can say there is a referential "mass" and a referential "energy". They will give seemingly different interpretations, but which are actually equivalent.

(On a side note, there are indeed no differences between E=mc^2 and m=E/c^2, it's just that it's easier to conceptualize inertial mass as being energy at rest with the latter.)

plopilop··on Does the Inertia of a Body Depend upon its Energy-Content? (1905) [pdf]
An interesting point to note is that Einstein derived m = E / c^2 rather than E = mc^2. Even though both formulae are obviously equivalent, the interpretations may vary.

For instance, for nuclear fission we use E = mc^2. Uranium breaks into smaller atoms, but some mass has disappeared: it's because it has been radiated in the form of immaterial energy, hence nuclear plants and A-bombs.

On the other hand, m = E/c^2 gives an interesting interpretation to what inertial mass is. According to this equation, mass is actually "energy at rest". If you want to move your object, you have to give it some energy, so that the resulting energy of the body will result into the desired motion. It's kind of similar to how hot air (the energy you give) and cold air (system at rest) mix to form "medium-hot" air (system in motion).

And just because I like writing, note that we have no idea whether inertial mass (the m in m = E / c^2 and Newton's Third Law, F = ma) is equivalent to gravitational mass (the m in F_gravitation = G * m_earth * m / d^2), but experiments dismiss any difference bigger than 1 in 10^12. The principle of equivalency between these two masses is the fundamental postulate of general relativity.

In a nutshell, m = E/c^2 defines the inertial mass, and general relativity assumes it's equal to the gravitational mass.

← PreviousPage 5 of 6Next →