HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

plow-tycoon

152 karma · joined September 14, 2020

submissionscomments
plow-tycoon··on Ask HN: Who wants to be hired? (January 2021)
Location: Vancouver Remote: Yes Willing to relocate: Not to the states Technologies: Largely Web front and backend tech (JS, Typescript, Vue, Python, Some GoLang, Postgres) Resume: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1RnfArCET7EqXjhRq1-GXV8EI_ra... Email: luke at luketully dot ca
plow-tycoon··on Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement
I've seen people literally scrub off the coating, but it's not quite at that point yet. Thanks for the suggestion though. I was just expecting to either be told whether or not it's in the repair window, or what the display replacement and battery would cost, if it did become unusable. Oddly, the one comment where the support person confirms that it's not in the window was removed from the transcript.
plow-tycoon··on Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement
I definitely accept that mistakes could be made, and do plan to follow up. It's not within the repair window, but I'll see what can be done.
plow-tycoon··on Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement
I'd love to see iPads become more versatile. The iPad Pro seems like a pretty nice device, particularly because of the high refresh rate screen. But it's very heavily consumption and illustration oriented. My iPad 3 has been passable since it was new, with some degradation in performance, but I haven't found a more interesting use for it besides YouTube and Pocket. I imagine that it could be a great device for interactive systems or 3D modelling, but I'd really be trying to justify the purchase at that point. I do also agree that the fingerprint sensor is a nice addition, but along with it they made it almost impossible to recover data in the event of catastrophic failure.
plow-tycoon··on Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement
I can feel all of that. I went from a custom gaming PC, which was ok aside from having to re-install windows once every few months, then to a 2009 MBP 13" which lasted 4 years until I sold it for a ridiculous sum, then a late 2013 13" MBP which I used until 2018 until it was stolen. I then went to a 2017 non-touchbar model, which was just... fine, but had the keyboard issue, delamination, and an insanely hard to troubleshoot deep-sleep/wake from sleep issue which led to it being replaced by Apple under warranty (when I finally re-produced the issue 100% of the time) for my current 2019 MBP 13" w/ 16gb of ram.

Other than that, my impression of Thinkpads is that, while they seem a bit clunky for me, they are at least in the top tier of non-MBP laptops. Likewise, my brother just picked up a 2019 XPS 13" which has earned some praise from HN folk and seems to be pretty solid. I'd personally like a gaming rig of some kind, but if I'm realistic, I won't get that much use out of it until the rainy season.

plow-tycoon··on Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement
I've updated the post with a screenshot of a previous in-warranty repair bill that indicates the screen cost around ~$500 CAD. Even the logic board and screen came out to around ~$1100, which is largely the basis for the surprising numbers.
plow-tycoon··on Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement
I think that's worth something. That's what I was generally happy with around the same time, and tried to emphasize that in the post. Buying an Apple product generally meant that you didn't need to worry, and hopefully you'd get some help for that investment when something did go wrong. Though I would say that I've never had a completely out-of-warranty major repair done. Ironically, the only out-of-warranty repair I had was when I ripped the SATA cable in my 2009 MBP. They sold me a new one and I was on my way.
plow-tycoon··on Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement
I agree, but would suggest that it's newsworthy simply by virtue of it not being unusual (as well as the current holes Apple seems to be digging deeper into). Everyone will read the post with a different set of eyes, so there could be any facet that stands out to someone. One of those is that they seem quite happy to do a specific repair as long as it's under warranty, and will replace literally every major component multiple times before replacing the computer. I've also updated the post with a reference to a previous repair bill that was covered under warranty.
plow-tycoon··on Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement
The first time I experienced this, I was travelling through the U.S in 2018, in what seems like a similar event. I almost didn't get them to agree to do it, but it was up to their discretion and they obliged. However, the kicker was that they had to mail it away and it'd be gone for at least a week. I tried numerous Apple stores on our way up through California. Some said they did do MB repairs in store, but their hands were tied, they'd have to mail it away. Insane.
plow-tycoon··on Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement
I suppose the tone is open to interpretation, but I didn't try and mischaracterize the interaction. Both of us were incredulous as to the responses we were getting. When asking the same questions in a store, especially before agreeing to anything, I'd expect and have received clear answers or documents that do that.

Likewise, though I didn't mention this in the post, the first few emails Joe sent were not quotes, but payment requests with no further detail as to what was happening. I've gone ahead and updated the post.

plow-tycoon··on Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement
I've been using MacBooks for 10 years, and while they've recently been less reliable, I have had good experiences for at least 60% of the time. So if you can get them repaired for a reasonable price, and they don't break that often, I still don't see many good alternatives. Especially if you still like the OS
plow-tycoon··on Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement
> The numbers Joe suggested in this conversation are either entirely fabricated, or belong to the cost of replacing the entire machine if its experienced catastrophic damage. But, after clarifying numerous times about what the numbers actually represent and comparing to previous repair bills for the same issue, my belief is that the rep used a false and obscured repair order to persuade me to replace my girlfriend's minimally damaged screen with a new computer.
plow-tycoon··on Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement
That was my thought too, which I was I asked numerous times for clarification. I've gone through the screen replacement before, and the number wasn't remotely close to $2000, much closer to yours. I usually don't lean towards malice, if there's a better explanation, but he seemed quite aggressive in not answering questions and linking me directly to the product page for a new computer.
plow-tycoon··on Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement
Thought I'd add here that all the values are in CAD, and that the one comment missing from the official transcript is where the rep states that the computer is out of bounds of the repair program window. It's an odd ommision, but that's how it was downloaded.
plow-tycoon··on Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement
Yep. I haven't updated the site much lately, and quit twitter years ago.

Oddly, in the interaction with customer support I posted, there is one comment missing, and that's where the rep says the laptop is outsode the repair window (4 years).

On my personal machine, I used the repair program multiple times because the screens are just so vulnerable to delamination and damage.

To elaborate, when I experienced the issue on my machine in 2018, I also couldn't let them ship it out for a week. I believe they made a note on my file, which worked out in the end, but no subsequent technicians were able to rely on that note and had to do their own inspection

plow-tycoon··on Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement
It is baffling sometimes, but I think the inclination for people to just replace their device is why it was necessary to post this. If someone isn't rich, they should be getting more longevity out of their products, but it's easy to pressure someone into the replacement with some fuzzy numbers.

For my current mbp, (the one used in the comparison) I only have it because my late 2013 model was stolen, and needed a new machine quickly. Then I got the 2018 fn key 13" which I was forced to first replace the screen on, then the logic board, then the entire computer under warranty. They gave me the 2019 model as a replacement.

plow-tycoon··on Apple Tried Charging the Price of a New MacBook Pro for a Screen Replacement
That's sort of what I was hoping for in this case. In the past, I've brought my laptop in, and per their discretion they've either honored a repair program or just made a quick fix.
← PreviousPage 2 of 2