HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pmoriarty

58,606 karma · joined May 4, 2014

He who lives without folly is not as wise as he thinks.

  -- Rochefoucauld
submissionscomments
pmoriarty··on The real lesson of The Truman Show
Anyone who liked The Truman Show should watch Abre Los Ojos (aka "Open Your Eyes), and which was later remade in to the inferior Vanilla Sky*.
pmoriarty··on Cities turn to ‘extreme’ water recycling
"To demonstrate its technology, Epic Cleantec, a water recycling company, has even brewed a beer called Epic OneWater Brew with purified graywater from a 40-story San Francisco apartment building."

I've got to say that this beer would not be high on my list of beers to try.

pmoriarty··on ChatGPT: Fear Litany
Claude has no problem with it either.
pmoriarty··on ChatGPT: Fear Litany
"The field of philosophy called epistemology deals with what knowledge is and how it is obtained, and the field overwhelmingly agrees that it is necessary (but not sufficient) for knowledge to be a (1) belief that is (2) true, and (3) justified."

How do you know if something's true, though?

If knowledge of truth has to be true, how do you know that the true knowledge of truth really is true? Etc..

pmoriarty··on Plain text journaling in Vim
I take a voice memo and transcribe it on my laptop later.
pmoriarty··on OpenLLM
"Discord is just a rich IRC replacement"

That's only half true. Yes, Discord does allow a "rich" chat experience, with channels and servers, but there the similarities end.

IRC is based on an open protocol, with many open source clients available for it, and a decentralized server infrastructure.

Discord is closed and centralized, with only a single client available for it.

You can easily log IRC channels, but there is no easy way to do that on Discord, if it can be done at all.

I've logged every channel I've ever visited on IRC, and I can use powerful text tools to regex search through all of my conversations on IRC and have the results appear instantly. Nothing remotely like that is possible with Discord.

Paging through IRC logs is virtually instant on a modern terminal, while Discord makes you wait a long time between every other page load, so if you need to look through more than a handful of pages it's incredibly slow and painful.

Some IRC channels have their logs published on the web, making them fully searchable through web search engines, but to my knowledge no Discord channels do that.

What happens in Discord stays in Discord.

pmoriarty··on OpenLLM
Discord is a black hole where information goes to die. Its search and scrollback is awful. It's awful at being an archive, as finding anything that was asked more than a day or two ago is impractical.

To use Discord in good faith and with open eyes, you have to prioritize communication in the present, and give up hope of archiving anything that was said for people who might need the information in the future.

pmoriarty··on Migrating Netflix to GraphQL safely
GraphQL is such complete and utter garbage for anything but the simplest of queries. I pity anyone who has to use it for anything more complicated.
pmoriarty··on The WFH future is destroying bosses' brains (2021)
I'm shocked that in this entire thread there's nary a mention of the elephant in the WFH room: the commute.

Not only is commuting a (potentially huge) waste of time, but it forces me to risk my life on the road.

In the US this commuting time is uncompensated, and I've never heard of anyone being compensated for risking their life by driving/flying to work, and that risk is not even acknowledged.

It's also far less stressful to roll out of bed and "be at work", as it were, than brave the commute, rush hour traffic, the belligerence of other stressed-out commuters, potential road rage, traffic tickets, stressing out even more when you're late or you're stuck in traffic, etc...

All for what? I'd rather spend more time with my friends and family than my coworkers.

No, now that I've tasted WFH life, I'm going to do everything in my power to avoid commuting. Maybe if they doubled or tripled my salary I might consider it, but nothing short of that is remotely worth it (pardon the pun).

pmoriarty··on What I’ve learned from 35 years of wearing computerized eyewear (2013)
If everyone could just calmly discuss divisive topics instead of freaking out or resorting to violence, the world would be a much better place.
pmoriarty··on Falcon LLM – A 40B Model
"Some would say that pornography implies sex. Others that it is defined by the content’s purpose. Some would contend that considering the mere exposition of the female body outside of any sexual interaction as pornographic is, in itself, objectification and sexualisation."

It definitely varies from culture to culture. In the US a bared nipple on national television was a sensation, in the UK it's par for the course.

In some cultures women regularly go bare chested, in the US being topless on a beach could land you in jail.

In some cultures men wear nothing but a penis-sheath in public, while that would be considered outrageous in many other cultures.

In the US it used to be considered indecent if a woman showed an ankle, and uncivilized not to wear a hat.

In India hugging or kissing in public might get you assaulted[1], while it's no big deal in many other countries.

There are taboos in every culture, but what is taboo varies from one culture to another.

[1] - https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-india-65593675

pmoriarty··on Falcon LLM – A 40B Model
"Why are tech companies so puritanical? Adult content is not immoral."

It's all about "optics" and PR. These companies don't want their brands associated with porn. That's why YouTube doesn't allow porn on their site, even though it would be enormously profitable.

pmoriarty··on What I’ve learned from 35 years of wearing computerized eyewear (2013)
"Could this be another iPod or iPhone moment—where Apple wasn't the first to do it, or arguably even the best, but they somehow, despite being ostensibly late to the party, managed to get it right in a way where it truly changed things?"

The iPod and iPhone didn't cost $3500

pmoriarty··on What I’ve learned from 35 years of wearing computerized eyewear (2013)
I've kind of given up on expecting most people to be rational on emotionally charged subjects. Most people don't think things through, and the more intense the emotion involved the less likely there's any chance of reasoning with them.

Highly emotionally charged attitudes commonly held in society may change, but it'll probably take generations to do so.

pmoriarty··on What I’ve learned from 35 years of wearing computerized eyewear (2013)
People have a strange relationship to surveillance.

Many of them will freak out when they see another person point a camera at them, but they don't seem to care that dozens if not hundreds of surveillance cameras film them every day when they walk around a city.

Out of sight, out of mind.

pmoriarty··on The Secret Sauce behind 100K context window in LLMs: all tricks in one place

  > > For which applications is that worth it?

  > Programming, primarily
...and law and medicine where a doctor/lawyer may want to prompt with lots of information on their patients/clients and possibly related cases.

Certain scientific experiments (like the LHC) deal in enormous quantities of data that may be desirable to include in a prompt.

That's just a few examples off the top of my head. I'm sure there are plenty of others. Programming is far from the only application.

pmoriarty··on The Secret Sauce behind 100K context window in LLMs: all tricks in one place
I got access right away through poe.com
pmoriarty··on No, GPT4 Can’t Ace MIT
From what I understand, it's trained mostly on English, and performs better in English. So it's not at all surprising it would make more mistakes in German or some other language.
pmoriarty··on No, GPT4 Can’t Ace MIT
"It literally did not change. Not one bit."

How do you know?

Even if the base model didn't change, that doesn't mean they didn't fine tune it in some way over time. They also might be passing its answers through some other AI or using some other techniques to filter, censor, and/or modify the answers in some way before returning them to the user.

I don't know how anyone could confidently say what they're doing unless they work at OpenAI.

pmoriarty··on Planescape: Torment pitch document (1997) [pdf]
I found the first Pillars of Eternity game incredibly boring, and actually liked the 2nd one more... though I also grew bored of it before too long. BG2 was ok, but I don't think any of these games can hold a candle to PS:T in terms of writing.

I haven't tried Pathfinder: Kingmaker, because it has an enormous number of very negative reviews, so I'm surprised you'd put it in the same league as PS:T.

pmoriarty··on The Secret Sauce behind 100K context window in LLMs: all tricks in one place
"I believe Anthropics' Claude is somewhat underappreciated. In some instances, it outperforms GPT4"

I've found Claude to be better than GPT4 at creative writing and explanations, while GPT4 seems to be better at logic-puzzlish stuff.

pmoriarty··on Planescape: Torment pitch document (1997) [pdf]
That's probably because the last thing studio execs (and gamers, who eat up so much shoddily written garbage) care about is writing.

If gamers rewarded well-written games, and avoided poorly written ones, pitches would focus a lot more on writing.

pmoriarty··on Planescape: Torment pitch document (1997) [pdf]
"People have rose tinted glasses when they talk about old games. PS:T was a cut above the other cRPGs of its time mainly because it had adequate writing and an engaging story when most other cRPGs were trite."

Adequate writing? The writing of 99.9% of games is simply atrocious, and PS:T was and still is miles above them.

"PS:T has now been bested by plenty of modern cRPGs"

It's been bested on the gameplay and graphics level, but I've yet to find a game with better writing.

pmoriarty··on Hexyl: A command-line hex viewer with colorized output
"So, in other words, they perform precisely how you’d expect a stochastic parrot to perform?"

Or exactly like you'd expect a human to perform.

Train a human mostly on English, and they'll speak English. Train them mostly on Chinese, and they'll speak Chinese.

pmoriarty··on Psychedelic scientist sends brains back to childhood
The effects of microdoses are below the threshold of perception.

If you can tell a difference when you take it then it's a small dose, not a microdose.

pmoriarty··on Hexyl: A command-line hex viewer with colorized output
In my experience, LLMs are poor at working with unpopular languages -- probably because their training data does not contain a lot of examples of programs written in those languages, or explanations of them.

They do much better with popular languages.

pmoriarty··on European Union votes to bring back replaceable phone batteries
"IP permissions, i.e., copyrights, are not natural rights, they are instead government "grants" of protection"

There's no such thing as a natural right, period. They're all imaginary creations of humans.

pmoriarty··on Generative AI is also a revolution for computer interfaces
"Do I really want to wave my arms to control an interface? No, they'd get tired immediately."

They would, but only because you're not used to using them much.

Using our arms more would probably be really good for us.

If we had to use our legs and feet to move a mouse then computer programmers might be some of the fittest people on the planet, instead of some of the fattest.

I say this while lying on my bed and tapping with my fingers on my tablet... we're doomed...

pmoriarty··on Hexyl: A command-line hex viewer with colorized output
It's easy to test it with something unpublished
pmoriarty··on Hexyl: A command-line hex viewer with colorized output
After seeing an LLM do something like this, I've got to ask people who think that LLMs are just "stochastic parrots", "just predicting the next word", or are merely "a blurry jpeg of the web" to think about what's really going on here.
← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →