HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pneill

57 karma · joined February 5, 2009

submissionscomments
pneill··on Fortnite’s battle with Apple and Google could have an impact on news publishers
Three sincere questions for the group:

Does anyone disagree that Apple and Google have the right to just go "this app store business is just not worth the headaches, we're gonna shut it all down."

When I read hackernews a lot, I get the impression folks think these app stores are some kind of public commons.

And my second question: Who do you think customers will blame when someone uses an alternative payment approach to steal from customers? Google/Apple? The app provider? Themselves?

Third question: What's a customers recourse once they are the victims of fraud or simply want a refund for whatever reason? How easy will it be for them to reason about what to do?

pneill··on Germany begins 3-year universal-basic-income trial
Rather than funding programs like this, people would be far better served by being educated on how to better use the money they have.

Just look at the US Bureau of Labor Statistics on how people spend their money. https://www.bls.gov/cex/2018/CrossTabs/sizbyinc/xtwo.PDF

For example, a couple making less than 15K a year is spending 2K on restaurants! A couple with that income shouldn't know what the inside of a restaurant looks like. But I don't blame people for that. I think we've let people like this down by not educating them.

Nobody teaches you how to use money to improve your life.

And this isn't just for lower income folks. I can't tell you how many high income people I know that foolishly spend their money (buying boats, new cars, etc) and hardly have anything left for retirement.

pneill··on Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th
Actually, the scenario you describe "one store chain in each reason" is a common scenario. Outside of major urban centers it's not uncommon to have a single grocery store, hardware store, etc.

Energy distribution is different because it's a government granted monopoly.

pneill··on Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th
Correct. And this is not illegal.

Using the store analogy - when you purchase at a store, the store has a markup on the product (usually 40%) - you cannot demand the store take a different markup because a store down the street is selling it for less, you can't set up a sign in the store telling patrons they can get a better deal down the road, and you can't say you want to pay in a particular currency because you don't have any of the local currency in your wallet. The store can establish policies like this for any patron that enters.

pneill··on Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th
Users own the hardware, but not the software - they are grante a license to use the software. This is not about the hardware, it's about a single App, the App Store, which the user does not own.
pneill··on Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th
Yup. Exactly. Think of it this way. You manufacture product foo and it's sold to customers via some national store chain. If you anger the owners of the store chain, they can simply refuse to carry your product anymore. This happens all the time. The app store is no different. It's a national chain that Epic sells through and they've poked the bear one too many times. Lucky for Epic that it's privately held. Otherwise they'd have a shareholder revolt.
pneill··on Apple just kicked Fortnite off the App Store
What percentage is reasonable?

For a $20 app the current model is that you pay Apple $6. If you waved a wand and made it 20% you pay Apple $4. So the difference in this case is only $2 (while you get $16). That's small potatoes.

pneill··on Apple just kicked Fortnite off the App Store
Sure, but I was talking about subscriptions, but I hear your point.

What I'm trying to show is that once you accept zero is not reasonable (and most rational people accept this) and then explore the actual $$ difference between what Apple charges and what you think is reasonable, the differences are really small. Normally when I ask folks this, the difference comes in between 0.05 and a $2 depending on the purchase price. For a 0.99 app we're talking about $0.05-0.20 difference. Life is too short for folks to get worked up about that small of a price difference.

pneill··on Apple just kicked Fortnite off the App Store
Ok, 10% is your number. So after your app has been on the store for more than a year, Apple's fee falls to 15%. So you're arguing that the 5% difference is unreasonable.

Let's put that % difference into perspective. Say you have an annual fee of $10. The first year, your users pay Apple $3 (you make $7), but after that for every user that subscribes you only pay $1.50 (you make $8.50). You're saying that Apples should only charge $1. You're arguing that fifty cents is the difference between life and death of your business? Really?

pneill··on Apple just kicked Fortnite off the App Store
60% != 100%. There is consumer choice.
pneill··on Apple just kicked Fortnite off the App Store
Poor analogy. iOS does not have the market dominance that Windows/Microsoft has. In this case, iPhones represent about 15% of the global smartphone sales and I think that the OS (in the US) is a 60/40 iOS vs android split. There is a viable market. Developers, unwilling to pay the Apple fee, can switch to Android. If more apps are available on Android, that will shift the users away from iOS to Android.

When I see folks complain about this, I like ask "what do you think is a reasonable fee for Apple to charge?" Zero is not a realistic answer as Apple does incur costs to run the app store. Moreover, they're entitled to make a profit off the marketplace they created and support. So what's a reasonable percentage?

pneill··on Gates Foundation program will issue home testing kits for Covid 19 in Seattle
They get that data the same way they always do, from people seeking medical attention. People who are symptomatic for anything ( flu, cold, etc) should always isolate themselves.

What’s madness is asymptotic people testing themselves.

pneill··on Gates Foundation program will issue home testing kits for Covid 19 in Seattle
If you experience symptoms you should self quarantine. If the test comes back negative, you’ll just keep testing yourself until you find out you have it?
pneill··on Gates Foundation program will issue home testing kits for Covid 19 in Seattle
So you’re just going to test yourself constantly?

If you experience symptoms for any illness and you care for seniors, you should remove yourself from care.

No need to test.

pneill··on Gates Foundation program will issue home testing kits for Covid 19 in Seattle
What’s the point of testing? There is no treatment. So knowing you have it or not is pointless. If you have it, and it’s serious, you’ll seek medical attention regardless of whether you know it or not.

When you see the ridiculous on hand sanitizer and toilet paper, even if there was an over the counter version, you wouldn’t be able to find one in the store.

pneill··on Later school start times are associated with more sleep and better performance
Correct. It’s all discipline. When the school has late start, do the kids go to bed at the same time and get more rest? Nope. They stay up later.
pneill··on Later school start times are associated with more sleep and better performance
The reason start times are complex is buses. To save money and optimize the number of buses, the same set of buses are used for elementary, middle, and high school. So if high school kids start later the middle school or elementary school kids need to start earlier. They tried this in our community and the proposal had elementary school kids in our neighborhood on the street for the bus at 6:30 am ( which is pitch dark in the winter).
pneill··on Later school start times are associated with more sleep and better performance
I never buy these stories. Why is it that an 18 year old high school student has trouble getting up and off to school by 7:30/ 8:00 am, but an 18 year old marine has no problems getting up at 4:30 am?
pneill··on California’s housing crisis: how a bureaucrat pushed to build
It's very complicated. People have conflicting ideas - one the one hand, they want affordable housing (ie their rent to go down) or the other, not in my backyard.

Worth a view The Insane Battle To Sabotage a New Apartment Building Explains San Francisco's Housing Crisis https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ExgxwKnH8y4

pneill··on US Navy's Railgun Now Undergoing Tests in New Mexico
Does anyone know why there is a flash of light and a puff of smoke when the gun fires? Since it's electromagnetic, you'd think you wouldn't see anything.
pneill··on $1B for 20,000 Bay Area homes
Politics is a huge factor in the lack of affordable housing. Both legislation and concerns by citizen about how new housing will "change" a neighbor make it next to impossible to build higher density housing.

Watch this video - it's eye opening https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ExgxwKnH8y4

pneill··on FCC plan would give Internet providers power to choose the sites customers see
Good point, but if there was real competition in the ISP market, you could switch providers that do this. Don't fight for net neutrality. Fight for ISP marketplace
pneill··on FCC plan would give Internet providers power to choose the sites customers see
How would you propose that packets be prioritized? I don't like the idea of the government telling me what packets should be prioritized. And saying that they all need to be treated the same is equally as bad.

But the real issue here is that the need for net neutrality is a symptom and not the root disease.

The disease that needs to be solved is a complete lack of competition in the ISP market. Service providers could differentiate themselves by QoS.

You wouldn't need a net neutrality law if you had competition.

pneill··on FCC plan would give Internet providers power to choose the sites customers see
Maybe I'm lone dissenter, but I don't understand the push back on this. People who read hacker news should be among the elite technologist, do we really all believe that every packet should be treated the same?

Should an E911 call or tele-surgery packets really be treated the same as Netflix? Net neutrality forces the ISP to do that and that seems like madness to me.

pneill··on How do you argue with anti vaxxers?
You don't. You can't argue with crazy. Or as philosopher once put it, you cannot answer questions of value with statements of fact.
pneill··on Ask HN: Is there a good book on IT/Silicon Valley history?
Accidental Empires
pneill··on Year off of school vs. starting a company
Do neither. Stay in school. If you leave, you'll never go back. (trust me, this happens 99% of the time when people leave school) You can take a year off after you graduate. And job opportunities come and go. This one certainly doesn't sound like you're getting in on the ground floor of something great.
pneill··on Does the reputation of your college matter in getting a job?
Reputation doesn't matter. What matters is internships. Do those. Do those now. An internship is what will get you your first job. After that, school doesn't matter at all and everything will be about what you've shipped.
pneill··on "iPhone nano" rumor comes back to life, now with $200 unsubsidized price tag
Doesn't make sense to me. You could buy an iPhone for a little over $250 if the carriers wanted. Consider this: An iPod touch is an iPhone without the phone. That costs $230. You can walk into any carrier and buy a cellphone without contract for less then $20. So iPod touch + cell phone = iPhone. Should cost between $250-300. The unsubsidized prize of $600 bucks is just baloney.

Maybe the real story is that Apple is going to insist that the carriers cell the iPhone without a contract?

pneill··on Ask HN: WordPress or Drupal?
I've used both Drupal and Wordpress. Each system has virtues. But from what you say, it sounds like you're looking for something that is going to be small and you don't want to spend a much time maintaining it. So I'd recommend wordpress. If you're using a shared hosting service, there's a good chance they already have a one click installer with automatic updates for you. So you won't have to deal with installation and updating and you can get lots of great themes for under $100. If you do go this route, my only recommendation is that you avoid using third party modules to avoid any security issues. As long as you stick with WP core and you keep the overal size of your site down then you should be fine.
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →