HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pnmahoney

71 karma · joined March 17, 2011

submissionscomments
pnmahoney··on The Death of File Sharing
The conclusions here feel overblown to me. I'm all for being vigilant, but but there's nothing compelling Dropbox to madly scramble to (as the author puts it) "pass muster under the new regime".

But what new regime? I'm not totally sure what the basis is for claiming that the old-line industry _just now_ went after MegaUpload because of their legitimate features. Sure, shutting down MU is done on behalf of the interests of copyright owners, however vested they may be . . . but just because SOPA/PIPA (regrettably) come close to passing through Congress and this, truly, seems to betray the pull that RIAA/lobbyists exert over legislators does not also imply that - suddenly! - copyright owners control the government. Cf. "The U.S. government. Government in league with old-line corporate elites." U.S. Government? Which part? Which law? Since when? Which you know about . . . how?

And E-Mail?? That seems absurd. It's not as though your ISP garners revenues from you e-mailing a track to your girlfriend - ie, the basis on which your e-mail service would be disqualified for the DMCA safe harbor exemptions . . . not to mention that it seems an exceptionally remote likelihood that they'd even have knowledge of the e-mail you sent.

Just pause and notice how incredibly top-down for lack of a better term, the author's path to his conclusion really is. What only slightly less obvious is the implied conspiracy and obvious legal ignorance: "...the gigantic protest against legislative moves (SOPA and PIPA) that would smash the Internet turned out to be superfluous. The thing everyone wanted to prevent is already here." What?! I didn't see the laws change; all I really see is an egregious violator, a couple of trumped-up conspiracy charges with not much to them (sidenote: piling on grounds for action is standard practice), and an organization picked on for the immense and immediate unlikability of its CEO (Kim Dotcom). To say nothing about the differences between MU and Dropbox.

On that note, we're forgetting the evidence cited in Megaupload being shut down. This is referenced elsewhere, but there's a mens rea (state of mind / intentionality) requirement for infringement to rise to the level of criminal law. Ie, the reason why MU was shut down with a criminal action, etc. For another, it's not even clear that banning U.S. users would actually keep flagrant DMCA violators from breaking the law anyway.

The DMCA is working. Er, rather: it does a pretty good job of balancing what content hosts (Youtube, Scribd, Reddit, etc.) can do to keep functioning and continue doing what they're doing today, while leaving intact pretty good rules prescribing the means for that "old-line" elite to take content down.

Contrast this with

>SOPA/PIPA on the one hand, which is a comic and internet-autistic attempt for media co. to replace the current, working equilibrium we have with a way for them to call the shots on how the internet functions and

>MegaUpload on the other, from whom those enforcers already had found e-mails: not about the manner in which to address DMCA takedown notices, but rather explicitly writing e-mails outlining how/when not to do it.

Just remember, the charges being piled on megaupload right now don't have scant evidence or case law, or fall squarely under that class of things which smart/conscientious content providers would NEVER do. Sure, the instant reproducibility of digital content and flat ability for people to do so has CLEARLY outstripped that understanding of copyright law that was devised a couple of centuries ago . . . and, probably against their own interests, folks like the RIAA would like to see the clocks reset to those old days.

But MegaUpload being shut down seems more likely a show of how easy it should be to NOT get shut down, than it is any kind of trend for Box.net to be next. Let's not exaggerate the portability exposed by some kind of megaupload-styled "19th Century is back!" generic censorship strategy, ok? I think we should all be watching but there's nothing peculiarly concerning - or at least not here.

pnmahoney··on Why We Raised A $5M Seed Round
This is a pretty cool example of how important it was to change business model (or at least be sensitive to being wrong about your initial expectation) and the uncanny serendipity of the valley.

One question, though: what kinds of factors go into the decisions behind accepting funding?

Really, to anyone -- what drives the decision to try raise that first five million vs. the next six million vs. the final ten?

This is to a good degree a n00b question because a) we can't know what it was spent on and b) I'm truthfully not that savvy behind the business decisions.

But if anyone has any insight (or insightful speculation), I'd like to hear what the differences behind these different rounds -- or even the decision to keep fundraising at all. Genuinely curious. Thanks!

pnmahoney··on Megaupload: A Lot Less Guilty Than You Think
This is crucial: the difference between the state of mind (mens rea) requirement for the criminal charges, and the clear(!) violations of the civil statutes at hand.

Even if, for some reason, this isn't getting Megaupload off the hook, it's worth remembering why exactly this isn't going to (gasp!) destroy that "cloud" thing everyone keeps writing about.

pnmahoney··on Apology to 37signals
I guess downvote-burying is a pretty good way to stimulate discussion, huh? I don't know if I should interpret it as you agreeing with DHH or not.
pnmahoney··on YC and 500 Startups company Curebit caught stealing from 37 Signals
I don't think anyone has a final answer, but really _how close_ do designs have to be so as to lack integrity?

(assuming that they hadn't straight up lifted the CSS, images, button etc... which they did, which is clearly wrong.)

Ex: DHH says http://elance.com is inspiration, not theft. Ok.

Ex 2: A more difficult edge is http://coursekit.com I instantly recalled their design after seeing this scandal, although I'd initially taken note of it for its effectiveness. Their similarity to basecamp is on the front page only, and no assets stolen. (full disclosure: competitor, vaguely, for a hackathon-started education product I'm working on.)

Like, we can think up a MILLION edge cases. That's not the point. I'm really, really curious to hear what you guys think the difference IS.

and please, please, PLEASE don't respond to this with vitriol on other side. if you think there are problems happening here in the way we treat design, and how ppl react, just DON'T add to it in that way. reposted here b/c my q was downvote buried.

pnmahoney··on Founder Soup: Stanford and Andreessen’s New Startup Generator
ps, hosted at stanford? yes. stanford's program? no.
pnmahoney··on Apology to 37signals
I don't think anyone has a final answer, but really _how close_ do designs have to be so as to lack integrity? (assuming that they hadn't straight up lifted the CSS, images, button etc... which they did, which is clearly wrong.)

Ex: DHH says http://elance.com is inspiration, not theft. Ok.

Ex 2: A more difficult edge is http://coursekit.com I instantly recalled their design after seeing this scandal, although I'd initially taken note of it for its effectiveness.

Their similarity to basecamp is on the front page only, and no assets stolen. (full disclosure: competitor, vaguely, for a hackathon-started education product I'm working on.)

Like, we can think up a MILLION edge cases. That's not the point. I'm really, really curious to hear what you guys think the difference IS.

and please, please, PLEASE don't respond to this with vitriol on other side. if you think there are problems happening here in the way we treat design, and how ppl react, just DON'T add to it in that way.

EDIT: edited to match repost, because of downvote(?) here

pnmahoney··on The Magna Carta Essay
Edit: totally out of line, my apologies. I'll just stick with saying that it's absurd to say (as implied above) that "class homework" isn't _really_ plagiarism.
pnmahoney··on The Magna Carta Essay
This appears to be the guy's self-description on LinkedIn. He loves software-as-a-service:

Intense, energetic, and ambitious professional interested in staying as close to the bleeding edge as I can in the realm of SaaS, social, and mobile commerce.

I love fitness, tech, and good food.

found on http://www.linkedin.com/pub/aaron-kerzner/1a/b96/3b0 (same school, approx graduation date)

pnmahoney··on In Memoriam: Christopher Hitchens, 1949–2011
Note: This can't be a correction so much as (ideally) an opening point for discussion, but Hitchens certainly wasn't a Marxist in the sense of one who advocated replacing the market economy. (Or at least not the Hitchens that died yesterday . . .)

Definitely a Marxist in the sense of a historian -- one who understands events from the standpoint of class -- and even one who supported solidarity among laborers. But replacing the free market? No.

pnmahoney··on Stanford class on Information Theory
I think the rationale is that - at least as Prof Ng articulated in another ML course he taught this quarter - videos following a lecturer as he teaches on stage are actually _less effective_ than videos which just follow slides w/ audio narration. Another researched case was video lectures with the teacher's face in the corner vs. video lectures with only narration. In which they found that student's information retention was even better without _any_ on-screen presence at all. (Surprising, I know . . . I wish I had a citation, but I'm really just coming in on defense of the department's pedagogical choices here.)
pnmahoney··on Tuning out: How brains benefit from meditation
http://psycnet.apa.org/index.cfm?fa=search.displayRecord&... This seems to bear on the implied point here: that mental focus on a problem -- perhaps unconsciously -- can be reflected in our neurobiology. (Or vice versa? Not sure whether this should be a response to P or GP)
pnmahoney··on http://(Type any keyword here).jpg.to
http://dumbsluts.jpg.to/ goes to sarah palin
pnmahoney··on Open source digital DJ: Integrating Airtime and Mixxx
airport repository removed 'til wednesday -- http://forum.sourcefabric.org/index.php/t/3654/
pnmahoney··on Stanford CS enrollment increase "downright scary"
yeahhhhhh.... i think they would get Eric Roberts to teach a fucking class on Word/Excel. That sounds completely reasonable.

to clarify: 106a is java, basically an intro to OO stuff and 106b is C++, getting into data structures, etc.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2