HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pochekailov

129 karma · joined October 31, 2019

submissionscomments
pochekailov··on How Doctors die. It’s not like the rest of us (2016)
No, my point is that I personally am very afraid of death, and would fight death from the selfish reasons.

People who support the notion of death seem not to constantly fear it themselves, but view it as something hypothetical, that they wouldn't have to face themselves in the near future (likely several decades).

pochekailov··on How Doctors die. It’s not like the rest of us (2016)
Telomeres are only one part of the equation, and they likely natural mechanism for controlling the cell differentiation. My understanding they resemble natural breaks that prevent cells to divide uncontrollably where they shouldn't.

I doubt they are the primary cause of ageing.

I prefer the theory explaining ageing as an epigenome misregulation that David Sinclair describes.

pochekailov··on How Doctors die. It’s not like the rest of us (2016)
Ageing is natural and harmful. Hunger is natural and harmful. Earthquakes, hurricanes, plaque are natural and harmful. We should mercilessly fight all of those, and ensure either of those maladies cause people to die.
pochekailov··on How Doctors die. It’s not like the rest of us (2016)
I never understood people who defend death

If there is a tiger chasing you, wouldn't you try to escape or fight? Or just give up and let the tiger eat you? It is natural, tiger also want to eat, right?

pochekailov··on How Doctors die. It’s not like the rest of us (2016)
So you would rather die, and let everybody who live now die, for the sake of the potential future generation?
pochekailov··on How Doctors die. It’s not like the rest of us (2016)
Today's medicine is focused to treat the diseases, refusing to admit that people at 70-80 years old die not from disease, but from the old age.

Everybody but a few enthusiasts refuse to treat ageing instead of cancer or heart diseases. People in general refuse to treat ageing as a disease, thinking it is something natural.

I would not want a couple more miserable years on earth, I want a few million years of a healthy young life.

pochekailov··on Ask HN: What are you surprised isn’t being worked on more?
I really agree with you.

I feel the extension of young and healthy life (ideally to infinity) is a number one priority.

Surprisingly, people almost always strongly oppose when I just start expressing my views. I never understood this.

Wouldn't it be nice to see Mars colonized and terraformed? Wouldn't it be great to see the completion of a Dyson swarm and using 100 % of the Sun energy for some ultra-mega-project we can't even fathom yet? Wouldn't it be cool to see the spectacular Betelgeuse star going supernova show in 10 000 years? Wouldn't it be awesome to witness full Milky Way galaxy colonization?

If I would ever become an Earth dictator, I'd use all available resources to fight ageing :).

pochekailov··on The modern web makes me want to throw up (2016)
Author also forgets #3: instant availability of the user's data on each of his devices in the proper format.

As a user who has to work with several devices simultaneously (several laptops in my laboratory, each managing some equipment), I find it very critical to have my data immediately available between all the devices.

Also, how will it be possible for a 19 year old to become a billionaire unless they can build their stuff on top of the other frameworks?

pochekailov··on Build institutions, not apps
Why not build apps to build institutions?

Politics is quite complex and full of its own jargon. It is not simple to understand.

Why not to develop apps, which will streamline a complex political process? Take zoning for example. There are new construction hearings, which only few NIMBYists attend, while pro-builders do not even know where to search for those. Say I'm a pro-builder busy with my own career. I have many questions. Where are those hearings held? Can I attend them, or there are some requirements? How do I meet those requirements? Is there any voting taking place? Where is it actually decided whether to build or not? What is the next action I can take given I am an average city dweller able to dedicate few hours per month for politics? If there is an app that would bring the tasks down to small actionable points with descriptions, and offer simplest step by step instructions, I may find it actually fun to do.

pochekailov··on It’s Time to Build
Great reply, thanks, you are restoring my faith in the humanity.

I fully agree that we have to build build build, to surpass technological level of Star Trek. And yes, I do want to live in science fiction.

"Early retirement" is the most retarded concept to me. Yes, I will retire when I will be a retard. Retired = retard.

People in the late 1800 actually hated the idea of retirement; corporations forced them to retire to give way to young people.

Out biggest problem compared to people of 1800 that we have a facebook (or twitter, or instagram). So instead of building, we outjealousing each other with beautiful vacation pics.

pochekailov··on Ask HN: Getting started in biology with a software background
Thanks! The reason it was not automated yet, is that non-biologists (including CS engineers) don't know that individual steps are that simple; while biologists do not have experience in thinking in abstractions, and so they simply not seeing that they are doing effectively same operations, just with different reagents.

In general, biologists are very busy pipetting faster than their peers, so they can secure scarce professorship positions. They simply have no time taking step back and looking at more general picture.

People who have skills necessary to build a robot and understand biology, have opportunity to work for companies that pay salaries 5 times higher than academia pays, so they don't bother.

I would not recommend doing any home experiments, especially without professional laboratory experience. Most of the experiments contain dangerous, poisonous or potentially explosive chemicals, and as for a newcomer, the risk is too high.

Instead, I would recommend finding a local biotech interest group, join them and go from there. Alternatively, you can find a local biotech lab and volunteer to help a grad student or postdoc with their project. This is more common than anyone may think. This way, there are no obligations, and you can leave if you don't like it; at the same time, you will get exposure to the state of the art biology.

Again, don't be afraid that you will not be able to bring anything good; biology as a science is ridiculously simple, and if you already have CS or electrical engineering background, you will have no trouble catching up within a month or two (that is how long it takes to our grad students who come from non-biology background to start bringing in new valid scientific ideas).

pochekailov··on Ask HN: Getting started in biology with a software background
I completely agree about hands-on experience: yes, it is extremely useful to practically do a biology engineering project. What I claim, is that about 2 weeks to 2 months of that is enough.

Regarding your second paragraph: I was fortunate to work in 3 fields in my scientific career: organic chemistry, materials science/organic semiconductors and molecular (synthetic) biology. This gave me ability to compare. What I found out, is that biology has the most interesting problems nowadays, and biology day-to-day work is extremely, outrageously, ridiculously stupid. I can not even start describing how amazingly debilitating molecular biology methods are. Right now, in the middle of the night I am stuck in the lab doing a day-and-half long protocol, all consisting on steps like "put liquid in", "pipette liquid out", "incubate for 5 minutes" and "shake for half hour".

Now here I am, after 15 years of school, 5 years of PhD and 11 years after that, doing work which is less intellectual than flipping burgers in McDonalds.

Fortunately, the fact that biology is so simple, gives me hope that it can be automated fairly easily, which I am planning to concentrate on for the next 5 years.

Please don't mix the plain complexity of life, which appears like "too many things to memorize", and complexity of mathematics and computer science, which is "understanding deep layers of abstractions". While I haven't taken intro bio classes, I read books and tons of papers. They are just plainly simple, you don't need brain to read them, you only need to memorize.

pochekailov··on Ask HN: Getting started in biology with a software background
I think a part-time job would be an overkill

I have trained many students to do biology, and I can teach anybody, without any education, to perform molecular biology experiments in 2 weeks.

I 2 months, they are usually able to generate scientifically valid ideas for research (although, usually not the best ideas).

Biology is extremely simple as a field, and a computer scientist will have no problem getting into the field (while opposite is usually hard)

pochekailov··on Ask HN: Getting started in biology with a software background
You are absolutely right.

After those 11 years in molecular biology, I am absolutely convinced that the bottleneck of the field is not some fancy method, but a total lack of automation.

Modern "CRISPR" cool methods are done with essentially the same tools as the research from 50 years ago.

I would claim, that computer scientists are lucky ones: they have skills to create their own tools. To make a better, more automated programming language, you would need same skills as to use that language.

Biologists on the other hands are different. The skills to do biology are totally different from skills needed to automate biology. And so the gap appears: biologists don't even think of automating, and mechanical/electrical/computer engineers are not even aware of the problem

pochekailov··on Ask HN: Getting started in biology with a software background
I have spent 11 years in molecular biology research.

I must warn you about a survivorship bias. All the exciting news you are hearing are the tip of a giant iceberg that rests on the mounts of a most dull and repetitive labor.

Here are some realities that nobody tells you:

1. There are only 3 operations done in experimental biology: liquid pipetting, opening/closing tubes and moving tubes between machines. 90% of protocols may be reduced to those operations.

2. Just to reproduce an already published work, you need 6 month of 10 hour/day work, performing those 3 operations from point 1. It took 5 years to reproduce just 18 molecular biology papers [https://www.the-scientist.com/news-opinion/effort-to-reprodu...], while 1 out of 4 computer science papers can be reproduced in less than 30 minutes [http://reproducibility.cs.arizona.edu/].

3. It takes days, if not weeks, to perform an experiment and make an observation. That is, if you manage to make a mistake in your experiment at day 2, you will only learn that something went wrong at day 6. Often, it is even impossible to tell what went wrong.

3a. Imagine, that after days of coding, you hit "compile", and the compiler would find a typo you made somewhere in your code, and instead of pointing at the error, it would simply delete all your code, and never tell you what was the reason, so you have to start over writing the code from scratch. This is how day-to-day biology work looks like.

4. CRISPR technology is one of the most heavy on 3 operations from point 1.

5. If you ask biologists about how do they feel about doing experiments, 97 out of 100 will say they hate it the most and curse the day they decided to do biology.

Regarding starting a company, I would first try to talk to as many as possible industry people, trying to understand what they do day to day and what they find most problematic, difficult or annoying to do, and see what you need to do to solve their problem.

In fact, I so much hate the fact, that I spent 15 years studying, then 5 years doing PhD, just so I can spent the rest of my days pipetting liquid. I decided to try to automate away all manual work by creating a universal robotic framework. If you are interested, please check https://cartesianrobotics.xyz/

← PreviousPage 2 of 2