HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

poetically

325 karma · joined November 24, 2021

submissionscomments
poetically··on Ask HN: Please Give Me Advice
I'm not religious either but by reading the works of the folks I suggested I have a better sense of what is in my control and what is not so that I can focus on things that I can address and not worry so much about things that are out of my control.

Contemporary consumerist society is isolating for most people because even though they can buy whatever they want it doesn't change the fact that lack of communal structures makes them feel isolated. This is a systemic issue so there is no individual solution.

poetically··on Ask HN: Please Give Me Advice
This is the zeitgeist so what you're feeling is reasonable. We live in material abundance but spiritual destitution. So unfortunately I don't think there is anything you can do individually that will help other than maybe look into folks like Neil Postman, Alan Watts, Carl Sagan, etc. and read what they wrote to see if it can be applied in your individual circumstances. It's hard to do anything about an individual problem until you understand its systemic causes and can place it in the proper context for analysis.
poetically··on All Horses Are the Same Color
I don't think so but we can agree to disagree.
poetically··on All Horses Are the Same Color
I don't understand what you're arguing. What exactly is incorrect in what I wrote?
poetically··on Ask HN: Does anyone know what’s happening at GitHub?
Yes, I was making a joke since I was responding to a sarcastic reply.
poetically··on All Horses Are the Same Color
We'll have to agree to disagree then.
poetically··on All Horses Are the Same Color
Actually, now that I have explained the argument I realize it has nothing to do with induction. The logic of the argument is unrelated to induction, it's simply about functions that take constant values on some sets and what is required to extend a function to a larger set and conclude that it is constant on the larger set.
poetically··on All Horses Are the Same Color
See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29445794.
poetically··on All Horses Are the Same Color
The argument in the article is the following: Given some function f, if f(A) = f(B) = f(A ⋂ B) then f is equal to some constant c and f(A ⋃ B) = c. This argument is valid only if A ⋂ B ≠ ∅. It doesn't apply to the base cases because anything is true for the empty set and any function on a one element set is trivially constant. So the minimal case where this can be applied in a non-trivial way is a set with 3 elements.
poetically··on All Horses Are the Same Color
Where exactly is my error?
poetically··on All Horses Are the Same Color
So what would say is the error in the inductive step here?
poetically··on All Horses Are the Same Color
Yes, this is what I said in another comment.
poetically··on All Horses Are the Same Color
I don't think this is correct. The main argument uses a very specific inductive invariant of applying transitivity of equality to a non-empty set. The argument doesn't apply in the base cases because it is vacuously true so the minimal base case is actually a set with 3 horses because that is the only case where transitivity of equality can be used non-trivially.
poetically··on All Horses Are the Same Color
You have to find the minimal case where the inductive invariant is valid. In this case when the horses are separated into two groups, A and B, the assumption is that their intersection is non-empty (A ∩ B ≠ ∅). Because only in the case where the intersection is non-empty can we apply transitivity of equality to conclude that their union (A ⋃ B) satisfies what we are trying to prove. But as the article argues this fails for a very simple counter-example where A and B are non-empty but their intersection is empty.
poetically··on Ask HN: Does anyone know what’s happening at GitHub?
I wouldn't know. I don't really follow politics, seems like a waste of time.
poetically··on Behind Low Vaccination Rates Lurks a More Profound Social Weakness
It makes intuitive sense. Social cohesion requires trusting democratic institutions but that trust is currently at an all time low thanks in no small part of talking heads on platforms like Twitter and Facebook. With every ideologue pushing their own agenda and doing their best to reduce trust in democratic institutions it's not surprising that most people no longer hold any collectively coherent beliefs.
poetically··on Ask HN: Does anyone know what’s happening at GitHub?
Seems like a waste of time to worry about such things.
poetically··on Ask HN: Does anyone know what’s happening at GitHub?
I'm pretty sure that would make a huge difference vs Microsoft shuffling the people that preside over basic code hosting services.
poetically··on Ask HN: Does anyone know what’s happening at GitHub?
Why do you care? It's not like GitHub is going to be any different. It will still continue to host your code.
poetically··on An Interactive Reference to Ethereum Virtual Machine Opcodes
Does EVM have a foreign function interface? What if I want to "call" some web endpoint to get a price of something? How do people manage this currently?
poetically··on America Is Running on Fumes
Alan Kay has a very good explanation for why this is the case.
poetically··on US rejects calls for regulating or banning ‘killer robots’
War is now a video game.
poetically··on How the Virus Struck Back
It's a metaphor.
poetically··on Free Markets Provide the Best Feedback
Naval is a preacher of the market ideology.
poetically··on Ask HN: How to Live Alone
Not really.
poetically··on Unified sharing across all web platforms – Web3 communication is here
Related: https://web.hypothes.is/.
poetically··on Ask HN: How to Live Alone
Most people aren't cut out for solitude but if you want to get better at it then meditation is a good way to get better at it.
poetically··on Timnit Gebru Launches AI Research Institute on Anniversary of Ouster from Google
So what exactly is this institute going to do? I couldn't tell from reading the press release.
poetically··on Humans Are Doomed to Go Extinct
Awful lot of assumptions you're making there. One might even say it's arrogant and hubristic.
poetically··on Humans Are Doomed to Go Extinct
It's certainly a pernicious failure mode.
← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →