HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

politician

6,434 karma · joined June 12, 2011

submissionscomments
politician··on President Trump bans Anthropic from use in government systems
Unlike Europe, the USA is not a technocracy. If you want to learn more about the 3 branches of government and the scope of their powers, ask your AI.
politician··on Statement on the comments from Secretary of War Pete Hegseth
Are you an American? Do you understand that your safe easy life depends on a mostly autonomous nuclear deterrence capability maintained by the military you oppose? Deeply think about why you still have right to free speech, and what it takes to sustain those rights.
politician··on Statement on the comments from Secretary of War Pete Hegseth
"This has never happened before." US could compel Anthropic to act; simply not doing business with them is restraint, not escalation.
politician··on Statement on the comments from Secretary of War Pete Hegseth
This is ridiculous. These aren't unreasonable demands and the government has tools to compel tech companies to support the country regardless of any "collective action" shenanigans -- ask your AI to tell you about the Defense Production Act and the history of its use.
politician··on We Will Not Be Divided
I simply do not understand why Americans tech companies and their employees will hew and cry about supporting the military. For those of you who support their position, have you ever stopped to consider that your safe, comfortable lives of free speech and protests and TikTok and food and gas and Amazon Next-Day deliveries is enabled by a massive nuclear deterrent operated by the very military you oppose?

It is just so disappointing to come here and read these naive takes. Yes, Anthropic should be compelled to support the military using the DPA if necessary.

politician··on How I use Claude Code: Separation of planning and execution
Wow, I never bother with using phrases like “deeply study this codebase deeply.” I consistently get pretty fantastic results.
politician··on AI coding assistants are getting worse?
Other people are dumping on you, but I think you're getting at where the real 20x speedup exists. People who are 'senior' in one type of programming may be 'junior' in other areas -- LLMs can and do bridge those gaps for folks trying to work outside their expertise. This effect is real.

If you're an expert in a field, LLMs might just provide a 2-3x speedup as boilerplate generators.

politician··on US blocks all offshore wind construction, says reason is classified
Global human populations are in decline; fossil fuel use will decline along with us.

If humans no longer use as much carbon (because they no longer exist in large numbers), doesn’t that alone adequately address the climate change concerns? Does it really make sense to overhaul the global energy generation infrastructure given these conditions?

politician··on PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant program
"Maybe you should [get some education], because [my anecdotes]" is rude and not particularly convincing.
politician··on PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant program
If your point is that corporate lawyers tend to see monsters behind every blade of grass, I agree. This is what they are paid to do. If I am a cavalier, it is to calm this community, to point out that they are over-indexed on this language and that it is the courts jurisdiction to decide what is meant.

There is no language that will magically prevent a government from canceling a grant and requiring a grantee to pursue relief from the court. This type of guarantee does not exist.

politician··on PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant program
Ok? But that wasn't the OP's argument. Did you reply to the wrong thread?
politician··on PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant program
You say, paraphrasing, "It's harder to prove that a DEI program violates Federal anti-discrimination laws than it is to simply terminate a grant to an undesirable grantee."

Ok. Suppose that's true. The government can terminate grants that don't include that language equally as easily -- and, indeed, I just found that there are multiple current cases against the government for doing exactly that: health grants [1], solar grants [2], education grants [3].

Is your point is that the inclusion of this inoperative language makes it easier than it already is for the government to cancel grants and to defend against the subsequent lawsuits until the plaintiffs are pressured into compliance from lack of funding?

[1]https://coag.gov/press-releases/weiser-sues-hhs-kennedy-publ... [2]https://news.bloomberglaw.com/environment-and-energy/state-c... [3]https://www.k12dive.com/news/state-lawsuit-Education-Departm...

politician··on PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant program
> Why would the grant agreement specifically highlight it?

I would humbly suggest that it mentions this particular example because the NSF administrator serves under the pleasure of the Executive and they have been tasked to demonstrate that they are following the orders of the Executive branch.

However, the inclusion of this specific example confers no higher priority than any other possible example. It has no weight; it is inoperative.

politician··on PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant program
> The GP's point is that it puts recipients in the position of having to argue that something they agreed to is invalid. This presumably places a higher burden of proof on the company.

Understood; while I disagree with the GP's point, I do appreciate your response.

I don't believe such example clauses raise the threshold for the defense against a claim given that there could be practically unlimited number of such examples. I don't believe that any such example so highlighted creates an effective higher priority than any other possible example under 14th amendment equal protection grounds.

politician··on PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant program
> I read it as an agreement to an interpretation that doing those things would violate the law.

The Executive branch can make any claim it wants, but the Judiciary branch has the authority to decide what a reviewable claim means.

politician··on PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant program
The requirement that grantees not violate existing laws is common in Federal grants. Taking umbrage with the DEI coloration on this entirely reasonable and standard requirement is absurd. There could be a long laundry list of such clauses that all have equally zero weight ("don't promote illegal drug trafficking", "don't promote illegal insider trading", ...).
politician··on PSF has withdrawn $1.5M proposal to US Government grant program
Could you clarify that you're suggesting that "it's un-American" for the government to require that the grantee not violate any of its anti-discrimination laws?
politician··on Show HN: ChartDB Agent – Cursor for DB schema design
> There's a concerning lack of attention to detail here.

I choose to believe that it's a brilliant feint. The author will run all these comments back into their LLM to generate fixes for all of these issues.

politician··on Dgsh – Directed graph shell
A solution to the One Billion Row Challenge (1brc.dev) written in dgsh would be a interesting as a benchmark.
politician··on Microsoft has urged its employees on H-1B and H-4 visas to return immediately
Honestly, what I see is that one side murders the other side when they talk about being opposed to the changes being forced upon them.

Complaints about "the whataboutism" is a strawman, to distract and deflect.

politician··on Microsoft has urged its employees on H-1B and H-4 visas to return immediately
Aren't the left the ones making the claim posed by your opening sentence these days? Could you clarify whether it's seditious only when one side is making that claim or is the seditiousness of the claim group-independent?
politician··on Microsoft has urged its employees on H-1B and H-4 visas to return immediately
I'll bite. Do they get to decide what "fascism" means and change it to mean whatever they want on a whim? It might be simpler to just say that they can make whomever they don't like today illegal and don't allow them to run for seats.
politician··on Learn Your Way: Reimagining Textbooks with Generative AI
Absolutely, the obvious best use-case for this technology -- from the ROI perspective -- is corporate HR training modules.
politician··on Learn Your Way: Reimagining Textbooks with Generative AI
An exciting step closer to Neil Stephenson's Diamond Age.
politician··on AI coding made me faster, but I can't code to music anymore
FWIW, I am not your doctor: Taking a daily antioxidant, glutathione, has helped me manage memory-related symptoms that appeared coincident with other burnout symptoms.

Disclaimer: talk to your doctor. I don’t know if your doctor can tell you whether this is a good idea, but it might help in some countries with good medical systems.

politician··on The Coming Robot Home Invasion
It would be amazing to have robot-delivered butler service. However, I'm deeply concerned about privacy and, given OTA updates, physical safety. There are enough bad actors on the Internet as-is, I don't want my butler deciding to reenact Order 66 after a Wifi update.
politician··on Open Banking and Payments Competition
> Banks suck so goddamn hard and are allowed to operate without any real competition and don't innovate at all.

It's not really the banks' fault. They're all stuck leasing expensive information systems from entrenched third-party technology shops. They don't have software development dollars and they are extremely risk averse, to a paranoid degree. Thank the regulatory environment for that (state and federal).

Companies like Moov.io are trying to crack open this space and provide the levels of integration we see in other industries.

But it's really hard and slow.

politician··on Scientists may have found a way to eliminate chromosome linked to Down syndrome
This comment and the original question ought to be pinned to the top of this discussion.
politician··on Facts don't change minds, structure does
It’s impossible to argue with the biased framing you’ve setup: any single good outcome due to vaccines is sufficient to declare victory for your argument while opponents face defeat unless they show that all harms outweigh all benefits based on your evaluation methodology.

Anyway, for everyone else, the J&J COVID vaccine is known to cause heart problems in certain men and boys. Here’s an article about the issue from the pre-RFK HHS era:

https://health.mountsinai.org/blog/wynk-heart-inflammation-m...

politician··on C# Language Design Meeting for June 30th, 2025
Consider:

    // math/adder.cs
    package math;

    …code…
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →