78 karma · joined October 7, 2025
What youtube educators don't get is every time a student suffers a setback some one has to take responsibility and sit there with them till they get over the obstacle. Views and Likes don't provide that signal of how many are lost or stuck.
Books and Libraries have existed long before Edu systems or Youtubers emerged, but kids and adults can easily get lost in that jungle if they don't have a feedback loop for guidance and support system when they stumble. Design of that system can be co-opted by Commercial and Political interests. Power corrupts all systems. But then there is always a counter reaction to pull the system back. Boundaries and balance emerge. It's a long slow process.
People maybe frustrated about how long it takes for trees to grow, but whether they are interested in designing a botanical garden or a healthy forest a good sign they will fail is when frustration starts turning into resentment.
The only way to prevent that happening is to stay humble at how complex it all is. Go into the garden. Get your hands dirty. Get one plant to flourish.
There are unpredictable and complex problems that competence can't solve - see The Theory of Bounded Rationality.
So what happens when the "competent" can't solve what falls in their lap given constraints like resources/time/team etc?
They will either say we can't do it (someone else like Trump will put up his hand immediately and say but I can, I can do anything, Hilary is just a clown choose me). Or they will say we need to buy more time/resources/team etc.
The point here is - if they can't fend of the Opportunists and if they can't buy more time/resources etc by themselves but end up being reliant on some one that can easily be framed as incompetence and will be framed as such by Opportunists.
So you want to change the game, be honest about what "competent" people do when faced with unpredictability and complexity ie understand their limits. They generally exit the space. And others fill the space.
Hegel tells us consciousness about self comes through dialogue with another - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bKz-HtOPvjE
Kim Kardashians empire is now worth 5 billion $$$. These new life forms the attention ecosystem produces hardly resembles anything seen in the past. Everyday people start adopting celebrity techniques. Visibility is like oxygen to them, while the pre-attention ecosystem life treat it as exposure. We are seeing two diverging sub species.
And that is when faced with randomness, unpredictability and lack of control, in general, a retreat takes place.
"There is no solution in the book/there is no time/there are no resources/it's not my fault/everyone else has to do x y z/don't hold me responsible for that persons suffering".
Basically any time a problem doesn't have a solution or a "elegant" solution, do a poll on how many scientists/innovators/business leaders/engineers will avoid it or not take responsibility for orchestrating an organized response to hold the space, until a solution is found. Its not in their training. So the majority just retreat. Into their work. "Doing" science/tech provides a very easy path to detachment. And then that detachment gets defended in all kinds of misguided ways, causing more confusion and misunderstandings as can be seen in this specific debate. But it applies in all debates.
Religious systems are much older and they have learnt to occupy the space when things get unpredictable. They will be there when people get cancer holding hands. They will offer rituals and prayer. They will be there praying with soldiers about to enter the battlefield and die. They will be there after they die. They will show up when people have health issues/financial issues/relationship issues. Do they fix all the problems? No. But all problems can't be fixed.
Showing up and holding the space and having something to offer and doing it in an organized and institutional way until a solution is available is what is missing.
All religious systems, not just the Abrahamic ones, people are trained for years to not run away from suffering but hold ground and have something to offer. Its not easy and can't be done without training.
Very few Fred Rodgers are produced by science and engineering institutions.
What is produced instead is mockery of religious systems, the uneducated, the misguided, the ignorant. And it naturally creates more issues.
modern charisma arc thanks to youtube engineers - I discovered delusions of my mind. I have discovered other delusions. I am far ahead of everyone. So here is a new delusion for you. Validate it with views and upvotes and likes.
Engineers have built systems that make people question stories, dismantle old one, produce new ones, provide validation. Is the system feature complete?
Main thing to notice and focus on are the 2 graphs, and then develop some consciousness about your own oscillations and hill climbs.
What we now call "Pastoral Care" emerged out of the behavior of some Irish monks in the sixth century embedding themselves in local communities exchanging advice for free mead and shelter. They started writing books about its effectiveness.
And so it became institutionalized world wide. So they would send a bloke to Ballykissangel, pay him to sit there, listen to the villagers’ woes on Sundays, and spend the rest of the week in the pub providing cultural enrichment.
Most importantly no numbers and report were used to justify these programmes. And this is what Sociologists say is the problem with modernity.
Corporate wonderland and McDonalds has convinced the "educated" numbers are somehow magic. And its easy to break that spell. Just ask a Kid to come up with a business plan to run a McDonalds. Its a super simple exercise involving costs and expenses. After they do that, ask them to scale it up so McDonalds can feed the world. Once you learn the McDonalds model cannot feed the world, the only path forward (for people who care about these things and most don't) is coming up with models that aren't built on top of numbers. There is a big reason the Church has outlasted corporations and empires. And its not numbers and reports. Its pastoral care.
tldr: people have been thinking about this stuff for a long long time and all their answers boil down to not trying to control everything that happens in the universe (cuz its a guaranteed path to suffering), but to find ways to live and flourish despite all the things we can not control. And there are many ways to do that.
The network was built because engineers figured out how to build it (with out routers and switches bursting into flames handling all the traffic).
So the system was built and post facto people started coming up with stories and use cases for the system.
Once the stories and use cases start getting coherent, people start saying ok I like this feature or that, but I don't like everything else that comes with this system, can I get the features without all the other crap.
And the answer is yes. There is no technical reason you can't. So the "old internet" is probably destined to die.
r/textingtheory on the other hand shows texting and sexting mastery and high elo require serious hard work.
Within that context people who are unable to perform either break down, find shortcuts or start doing strange things to keep up appearances leading to new problems. Asking people to be vulnerable within that context won't save anyone and just creates more confusion. It absurd watching management and HR dealing with people who have issues cause they are trained to filter out people who have issues.
What she is not saying is while it is a complex and uncertain world, corporations are optimized for Avoidance of complexity and uncertainty and and so are fundamentally flawed and highly unstable structurally if pushed into any situation requiring dealing with complexity and uncertainty.
People inside such structures will not be able to resolve the contradiction. Its like expecting farm and circus animals to change how the farm or circus works.
Don't wait for the structure to change. Get what you need and get out. There are other things going in the universe beyond the farm and circus and everything doesn't revolve around what is happening inside them.
End of the day, a chimp with a 3 inch brain has to digest the info tsunami of flagged content. That's why even the Israelis didn't see Oct 7th coming.
Once upon a time I worked on a project for banks to flag complaints about Fraud in customer calls. Guess what happened? The system registered a zillion calls where people talked about fraud world wide, the manager in charge was assigned 20 people to deal with it, and after naturally getting overwhelmed and scapegoated for all kinds of shit, he puts in a request for few hundred more, saying he really needed thousands of people. Corporate wonderland gives him another 20 and writes a para in their annual report about how they are at the forefront of combatting fraud etc etc.
This is how the world works. The chimp troupe hallucinates across the board, at the top and at the bottom about what is really going on. Why?
Because that 3 inch chimp brain has hard limits to how much info, complexity and unpredictability it can handle.
Anything beyond that, the reaction is similar to ants running around pretending they are doing something useful anytime the universe pokes the ant hill.
Herbert Simon won a nobel prize for telling us we don't have to run around like ants and bite everything anytime we are faced with things we can't control.
"I'm ready, man. Check it out. I am the ultimate badass. State of the badass art. You do not want to fuck with me"
"Well, that's great. That's just fuckin' great, man! Now what the fuck are we supposed to do? We're in some real pretty shit now, man!"
"That's it, man. Game over, man. Game over!"
"What do you mean they cut the power? How could they cut the power, man? They're animals man!"
"They're coming outta the walls! They're coming outta the goddamn walls! Let's book!"
From that emerging at the individual level, when we move to group level, we get things like Veblen’s Theory of the Leisure Class.
Look at what I eat. Look at where I live. Look at who I spend time with. Look at all my toys, my hobbies, my mate. And naturally look at what I wear, and what I spend on my mates appearance. Each is a small piece of that same signal - Look how much I can afford to waste so I must be fit. Think of the military medals, religions rituals, the judiciary robes, the scientist lab coat, the elaborate parades and buildings they need to be housed in etc etc. Every system invents its own costume to show who belongs and who leads.
Veblens theory came out a century ago and he predicted tech (rooted in efficiency/optimization/waste elimination) would disrupt or dilute the need for all this. But the opposite happened. Tech made signaling cheaper, faster, and global. Everyone is running some kind of circus act cause its become easy to do. As Attention available is finite and bounded by number of people and hours in a day, we enter arms race territory. Things get more and more ridiculous.
But what goes out of focus in all the attention wars is signaling was never about waste. It was about cohesion.
In any group, people differ by a lot in strength, wealth, beauty, luck etc etc. Biology says this leads to violence/schisms/chaos. But social signaling creates a pecking order that keeps the peace. There is silent agreement you look the part, you get to lead - you like what you see me doing then do what I tell you to do.
Fashion plays a big role in building hierarchy. So even commie and egalitarian groups end up doing a whole lot of signaling. Through it, there is constant testing who notices, who approves, who follows.
Most of the cost of this system falls on women. Cuz thro history the rules of beauty have been written mostly by men and enforced through fashion.
In classics like Herland or Sultanas Dream the question that gets pushed is what happens if women designed the rules themselves? Such thought experiments imagine worlds ruled by women and how the signaling becomes less about power/status/hierarchy maintenance and more about cooperation, play, self expression. Until these experiments run in practice the peacocks shall still strut.
This is also not like the other bubbles. It feels more like working on nukes or CRISPR but without the barrier to entry and constraints on rate of change. Market loves fast feedback loops. They can actually feel and touch this stuff unlike other game changers.
Some are curious, some are anxious about getting things wrong, some are doing the bare minimum and ya some are full of themselves. Each one exploits the tool differently. But I get them to ask it about these things too (are there things I am missing cause I want to get this right/why is my boss saying I am full of myself/my boss told me he doesn't have time to teach me about X but if I am curious thats something I should look into etc) which you couldn't do with them in the past.
Once you move into the broadcast realm, the 1-to-all, you’re no longer dealing with a tank or a pond but with an ocean.
And once you’ve created an ocean, you cant divide it so that predators swim in one corner and parasites in another. Everything coexists, mixes, mutates.
That’s why debates about what platforms like TikTok “should” or “shouldn’t” do are hollow. There is never ending debate but all sorts of strangeness and surprises emerge every single day, that no one can predict or control. That is the nature of the Ocean.
Their success lies in avoiding anything unpredictable, and all the systems and processes they build leverage that kind of thinking. They call it Efficiency and Optimization. So its very narrow success.
If you have met people who have had to deal with unpredictability like financial crisis, epidemics, riots, war etc where problems just can't be handed of to Lawyers, PR and HR you see a very different breed from your avg tech leader.
So focusing on them is like focusing on sheltered circus animals sitting inside a disconnected popular circus tent, and what they think about what's happening outside the tent in the jungle.
The entire point of that subject called Philosophy revolves around the simple question - how do you stay free despite having no full control over your own mind, your own body, over your history, over the religious/social/cultural/economic rules you have inherited, no control over what wastes your time on HN etc etc.
People have recognized these traps since before Plato. No AI threat was required. So there is a lot of info out there on how to cope and even flourish despite all the constraints the universe has imposed on the chimp troupe. Ignore the moan and groan, cry and die crowd as the shrinks call them.
Instead go study some philosophy - https://oyc.yale.edu/philosophy/phil-181 It won't save your ass from all the randomness and unpredictability in the universe, but it will expose you to how people throughout history have already dealt with traps.