HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

poof131

2,305 karma · joined November 30, 2012

submissionscomments
poof131··on FAA Moves Toward Treating Drones and Planes as Equals
My 2 cents as an F-18 pilot turned software dev interested in the space:

They need to break apart rules for the true hobbyists, the model airplane flyers: dedicated areas below certain altitudes. They also need to embrace private property rights to a certain altitude. Who wants an Amazon Prime distribution center doing 10,000 flights a day over their kids playing in the backyard. [1]

Future BVR (and autonomous) drone operations between 200-400’ will eventually more closely resemble IFR class-A than VFR airspace. [2] Routes need to be defined. [3] Emergency landing areas need to be determined. [4] Comms (network) out procedure need to be planned. [5] And more.

It will require significant local involvement. The FAA is going to make sure accident information is shared so lessons can be learned. [6] Part-135 will play a role. [7]

For manned aviation these things were implemented over a century with lessons written in blood. [8] It’s going to happen quicker for drones and this is a step in the right direction. People like this are helping to force the issue. [9]

[1] https://www.unmannedairspace.info/uncategorized/ulc-proposes...

[2] https://www.faasafety.gov/gslac/ALC/course_content.aspx?cID=...

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airway_(aviation)

[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergency_landing

[5] https://www.faasafety.gov/files/gslac/courses/content/38/483...

[6] https://uavcoach.com/daniel-elwell-interdrone-2018/

[7] https://www.faa.gov/about/initiatives/atos/135_certification...

[8] https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/13081/why-do-pe...

[9] https://sanfrancisco.cbslocal.com/video/3931613-drone-crashe...

poof131··on FAA Moves Toward Treating Drones and Planes as Equals
You should write the Uniform Law Commission to enact private property rights up to 200’. [1] They are already considering this. You should have the right to fly a drone just over your property the same way you could drive an unregistered, non-street-legal vehicle on your property. You can’t go on public roads (or over public property or other peoples property), but you should have rights over your own property.

[1] https://www.unmannedairspace.info/uncategorized/ulc-proposes...

poof131··on Ask HN: Who is hiring? (October 2018)
Salesforce - SIQ/Einstein | Backend, DevOps, Data Engineering, ML | SF / PA / Remote | Visa | $100-180k + equity & bonus

Help us find Insights from activity data. Our stack is primarily in AWS. Main languages are Kotlin, Scala, Java. Tech includes Spark, Storm, Kafka, Cassandra, Postgres, Docker, GraphQL and more. Plenty of challenges to solve. Good fun too like Russian River trips.

Please reach out to me, Scott, at s.young@salesforce.com if you’re interested and want to learn more.

poof131··on Drone Hobbyists Angered by Congress Ending the Aerial Wild West
Animal populations aren’t growing at exponential rates. The future scale of drones and autonomous airborne vehicles is going to be huge. The growing possibility of midairs with drones is more significant than bird strikes or deer on a runway. Hobbyist drone pilots are going to lose the safety battle. Just as you can’t drive however you want on public roads, class G airspace is going to resemble class A airspace. [1]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airspace_class_(United_States)

poof131··on Switzerland: Welcome to the Drone Valley
Don’t believe an solution based purely on current aviation rules will work for the scale drones will operate at. Firmly convinced that the 200-400’ feet will more closely resemble class-A airspace than class-G and will involve local. Rules will be standardized by the FAA but the administration will have to involve local and they will have a say in restricted airspace, routes, etc. A VFR free-for-all with drones will be a mid-air nightmare and no magical UTM solution will solve it. Don’t disagree that the FAA has preemption, but the current aviation model won’t work in the future and the FAA knows this. They are pushing for more local involvement and it seems to primarily be industry pushing back. Additionally, it isn’t settled law where property rights end. Causby said 87 feet for sure but possibly higher. [1] Still a lot to be worked out how drones will integrate in the national airspace.

https://www.oyez.org/cases/1940-1955/328us256

poof131··on Switzerland: Welcome to the Drone Valley
This is a very valid use case and something any UTM solution will have to solve. Currently the industry is hoping the FAA will create an uber solution and avoid “patchwork” solutions with state and local involvement, but that will never scale. Local administrators will need to be able to geofence areas in realtime. This will happen but it will take time to roll out and will require local, state, and federal involvement in a manner similar to auto transportation but with some unique aviation aspects.
poof131··on Why the Navy Misses the Old F-14 Tomcat, Despite All of the Problems
There’s a military quote that says, "Amateurs talk about tactics, but professionals study logistics."[1] I feel our current military leaders took this too far and forgot about the stupidity of putting all your eggs in one basket. The JSF is down to one engine, which if redlined, will down the whole fleet. If one of our adversaries finds a weakness, then the the whole fleet is vulnerable. Not to mention the crap with development: not getting the launch bar right [2], not getting the hook location right [3], the electronics being a mess. How do you screw up the launch bar, it’s not like carriers have changed. The JSF is going in the wrong direction. We should have aircraft focused on different roles: air-to-air, strike, close-air-support. We should be moving toward unmanned missile trucks for air-to-air and strike. We should focus on cheaper aircraft that can be updated with the latest tech.

Unmanned missile trucks are drones that carry missiles that can be guided by other platforms. After the drone launches its missiles, who cares if it blows up. Trying to make drones defensible like expensive fighters is just as stupid as the JSF. Some stealth and defense is good, but expendable and cheap is more important.

Carriers are too vulnerable to missiles. Missiles are the future. You can’t defeat something going mach 6 that pulls 25 g’s in the end game. 'The Future of War' does a great job describing the evolution of weapons platforms and how aging ones are depicted by ever increasing costs on defensive measures which are then defeated by new, cheaper weapons. [4] Carriers and fighter jets are becoming the modern battleships which is a bit ironic.

1. https://www.military-quotes.com/forum/logistics-quotes-t511....

2. https://news.usni.org/2017/03/23/f-35c-tests-offer-proposed-...

3. https://theaviationist.com/2012/01/09/f-35c-hook-problems/

4. https://www.amazon.com/Future-War-History-Lawrence-Freedman/...

poof131··on Why the Navy Misses the Old F-14 Tomcat, Despite All of the Problems
STOVL is the marines, and the shiniest of the Joint Strike Turds. And I think Boyd and the Fighter Mafia were actually wrong. For BVR air-to-air, I would have rather had an F-14/F-15 with phased-array radar and AMRAAM, than an F-16/18. Although the F22 clubs them all like baby seals. The Vietnam lesson was only good until missiles improved. Now the war is between missiles and radar more than planes. And a fast missile truck is better than a slow missile truck. Mach 2+ would be nice after you’ve shot your load and are running away.
poof131··on Why the Navy Misses the Old F-14 Tomcat, Despite All of the Problems
Yep, stupid. Submersible ships that can surface to launch and recover drones should be the focus. Though I would probably keep some carriers out of mothballs in case EMPs disable all the fancy electronic thingys. But we’d also need to keep around older mechanical actuated aircraft for that scenario. But most anything is better than putting all our eggs in the super carrier / joint strike turd basket. Keeping in mind the battle over the electro-magnetic spectrum is important though when fanboying drones.
poof131··on Why the Navy Misses the Old F-14 Tomcat, Despite All of the Problems
As a former F-18 pilot, I don’t think v2 of the Tomcat is what we need. Unmanned missile trucks are the future. The Joint Strike Turd should be the last manned fighter. The services are bankrupting the country with the current crop of do-it-all aircraft. Other countries are on a better track adding the latest tech to older airframes and accepting their expendability. Carriers themselves should be phased out for smaller more expendable ships that can launch and recover the missile trucks.
poof131··on Peak Valley?
Housing in the Bay Area (and California) is going to continue to get worse due to Prop 13. It destroys liquidity in the housing market. Elderly people can’t downsize since their taxes would rise dramatically, thus the abundance of retired couples in multi-bedroom houses and young families in apartments. People with multiple homes are incentivized to rent and never sell since they are receiving a government subsidy through below market tax rates. Until Prop 13 is dealt with California will continue to be the leader in inequality with a landed gentry extracting more than their share from the state. The density of tech only exacerbates the problem in the Bay Area, but it is a California problem.
poof131··on The Bitter Regrets of a Useless Chinese Daughter
Don’t view it as an either-or. Figure out the best step now for you, perhaps a higher paying job. But that job can lead to opportunities and you may have more cushion and connections to make a better jump into whatever else you want to do later. Think of it as risk management [1]. Too much stress and you won’t function. Manage risk and manage stress to a level that works best for you. Somewhere past perseverance lies adaptability & flexibility at number six on the life checklist. [2]

[1] https://www.public.navy.mil/NAVSAFECEN/PublishingImages/ORM/...

[2] https://slideplayer.com/slide/8751842/26/images/15/CRM+Situa...

poof131··on How to Hire Your First Engineer
The problem is market rate. You mention market pay and equity as two separate things. But market rate is really total comp: base, bonus, and equity. For a senior engineer in the valley this is hitting $300k+. Saying we are close to market on salary and ignoring the rest of a total compensation package is disingenuous but suits startups (and others). A package with a value of $1.2M over 4 years would take a significant chunk of equity from a seed stage startup, or about 10% of equity on a convertible note round at a 10M cap, right around what the parent suggested. It’s fair to say we can’t give that up, but it’s also fair to say you aren’t matching market rate.
poof131··on Ask HN: Who is hiring? (August 2018)
Salesforce - SIQ/Einstein | Backend, DevOps, Data Engineering, ML | SF / PA / Remote | Visa | $100-180k + equity & bonus

Help us find Insights from activity data. Our stack is primarily in AWS. Main languages are Kotlin, Scala, Java. Tech includes Spark, Storm, Kafka, Cassandra, Postgres, Docker, GraphQL and more. Plenty of challenges to solve. Good fun too like Russian River trips.

Please reach out to me, Scott, at s.young@salesforce.com if you’re interested and want to learn more.

poof131··on Larry Page is quietly amassing a ‘flying car’ empire
We will go up not down. The only limitation is legal, not technical nor economic. Working through the regulations will take a bit of time but is already underway with the FAA’s pilot programs. The problem people are missing in the industry is that it took years for the FAA to lay out the infrastructure and rules for the national airspace. It will take time to work this out for autonomous drones, which will operate on a much larger scale. Cities and states will play a key role. It’s not going to be a VFR free-for-all with collision avoidance, but very much mimic class-A airspace but between 200-400’ and will be fully autonomous. As an F-18 pilot, I use to hate drones, but I’ve been converted. We are at the palm pilot point for UAS. Musk’s comment about noise is correct, but that is solvable and no reason to go back in time and try to dig our way out of our transportation and infrastructure problems. Imagine a world with bridges on demand. Drones enable that future not tunneling machines.
poof131··on Flock raises £2.25M for on-demand drone insurance
Interesting. Just learned recently that the biggest insurance risk with drones is fires from the batteries, during flight and during storage.[1] Not sure how on-demand would help with the latter.

[1] https://jrupprechtlaw.com/drone-insurance

poof131··on A Well-Known Expert on Student Loans Is Not Real
I don’t think that’s the same at all. The submarine article is about helping journalists with stories. This article is about lying to journalists and everyone else by creating a fictitious person, all for their company’s financial benefit. And ironically they tout their intent to “provide transparency”. Too bad they didn’t make him a combat vet, then they could have been prosecuted.[1] Makes me think of a quote I once heard, “Integrity is what we tell other people to have.”

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stolen_Valor_Act_of_2013

poof131··on How vulture capitalists ate Toys 'R' Us
Why do I doubt they are the real losers here? Bloomberg states that they pocketed over $470M in fees.[1] And I imagine they were able to write off losses against wins elsewhere. So the real losers still seem to be the employees and the American people. A few years back I was talking to an east coast banker turned VC and he was pooping on the leveraged buyout industry. He said that all the debt payments are tax deductible, so you take a cash flow positive company, saddle it with debt, and essentially stop paying taxes to the government and turn that into payouts for the investors.[2] He said if you look at other countries with different tax policies in regards to debt, you don’t find the same scale of the industry. Perhaps with a better tax policy we could have seen a more natural outcome for Toys ‘R’ Us? I assume unfortunately that the limit on deductions in the second linked article never made it into law and went the way of closing the carried interest loophole.[3]

[1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-09-19/bain-kkr-... [2] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-tax-privateequity/u-s... [3] https://www.thedailybeast.com/republicans-love-welfarefor-th...

poof131··on I was Zuckerberg’s speechwriter
The problem is how those words have been coopted. While “nationalism” can be associated with nation state horrors of the twentieth century, the true alternative hasn’t really been been examined. The ideal is a global community, but the reality is much more a drift back into tribalism (i.e. company over country, or I and my Brother against my Cousin [1]). Tribalism is apparent in the growing intensity of intra-nation political conflict. Nationalism was an advance despite its flaws. Certainly the right kind of globalism would be best but we don’t seem to be there yet.

And populism can be defined as “support for the concerns of ordinary people”. [2] Is this a bad thing? Would we prefer our politics be for the rich or for the companies? Populism too has an association with reactionary movements, but what is the alternative? A platonic corporate king to rule us all? Democracy is inherently populist. It is ugly. But it is better than all other forms of governance. It feels in general that we “ordinary people” are being divided by those who favor companies over countries and in reality favor their own power and wealth over sharing power with others. Nationalist populism seems a better alternative than corporate oligarchy.

[1] https://eppc.org/publications/i-and-my-brother-against-my-co...

[2] https://www.google.com/search?q=populism

poof131··on Front-End Developer Handbook
"A whole lot of developers adopt static type checking for mostly subjective reasons or band wagon emotions. Some sell out completely to Typescript and the Microsoft way of doing things while others take on a slower approach with Flow. One thing is for sure, most developers don't need types, they are simply complicating already complex problems and solutions. Like most things, most of this trend is subjective dogma not objective value."

Wow, biased much. I love JavaScript and ES6. But anything that I work with a team on or expect to live beyond a month or so, I love types for. Making a large refactor without types is the wild west. Types help provide structure/understanding about the data flowing through your system. And if you need to eject you can with Any. I used to prefer pure JS (or Python), certainly quicker to prototype, but also more difficult to grow and maintain. Tradeoffs in both directions. Such an amateur statement makes me question the rest of the document.

poof131··on Ask HN: Do you have the courage to abandon your high paying job?
Avoid drastic moves. The older I get the more I realize most “drastic move” stories are bs PR pieces. Think how you can move in the direction you want to go in steps. Move to a cheaper location: see if you can move to a satellite office or work remote. No, then look at other jobs you could interview at in the area you want to move to. Translate your FANG experience into a career jump. Then you will have experience and connections in the area, so if your business flounders you have options to fall back on and aren’t starting cold. Starting your business: find a job with better work life balance and lay the foundation for the jump in your spare time. Focus on the some money path vs. the a lot of money path. See if there are people in the area you move to who can help. Take steps and avoid jumps. But it sounds like you should start moving in this direction now so you don’t get so fed up at work that you make the move in a reactionary fashion. Good luck and godspeed!
poof131··on Ask HN: Late career changer looking for resume and job advice
I made a similar career switch about 6 years ago. Profile is a bit different (got an online M.S. degree) so take all with a grain of salt.

1. Focus on your LinkedIn profile. Update constantly so the notifications percolate. Recruiter approached me for the first job and all subsequent jobs not through my network. Github is also an avenue but not nearly as popular.

2. React, react, react. Got my first job because the company was switching to Angular from Flex and I’d built two projects with Angular. It was new and popular at the time. Currently react is the hot thing (and I personally love it). I don’t say this as just opinion, it came from a recruiter I respect. She is seeing enormous demand for React, to the point where Angular devs are getting passed over since they have no react experience, which is a bit silly since good devs will pick up the tool, but nonetheless what she is seeing. She’s the one who said react, react, react, and has told me to steer away from anything else except maybe python and computer vision.

3. Algorithms and code puzzles. You may be able to find the dream shop that doesn’t require this, but I’ve yet to interview there. It will also open up the number of companies you can apply to. Many places don’t care if you have a CS degree or any degree, but they do care if you can play the depth first search, dynamic programming game. Friend prepped for 3-4 months and is on the interview circuit with his first $300k offer in hand. He’s senior with a big co name on his resume so not apples to apples, but he still spent the time to prep. The whiteboard pissing contests are going strong. This may be tougher without the academic background but worth doing as much of as you can.

4. Try to get in at a lot of places and don’t get discourage by rejections. There is so much randomness. One place will say you are awesome and the next won’t return your call after a phone screen. You aren’t broken, the process is.

So linkedin, react projects, study, and perseverance. My two cents. Good luck!

poof131··on Home Values Are Rising by $800 a Day in San Jose
It’s both. There clearly is a bubble. The Fed has essentially dumped easy money into the economy since the dotcom bust. 2008 saw another crash and again the spigots were opened. It only seemed to flow to certain areas though as top down economic policy tends to do. Now as the Fed raises rates, people can borrow less and thereby afford less. We may see zero percent interest rates forever and the government stepping in to prop up asset prices like Japan, but who knows for sure. [1, 2]

But California also has a unique factor, proposition 13. [3] This drastically disincentives people from moving. Palo Alto has the lowest property tax rates in the state.[4] Why move when you will pay significantly more monthly. This is especially pertinent to retirees. So no one moves which destroys market liquidity. Combine this with NIMBYism, an over abundance of protected lands, rent control, affordable housing measures and piss poor public transportation, and you get the shit storm that is the Bay Area housing market. Tech is simply a convenient excuse. There’s a reason California is building a bullet train between SF and LA, but no public transportation from the east bay to the peninsula which would help an enormous number of workers and the environment. Despite lofty rhetoric, people vote their self interests.

[1] https://www.wsj.com/articles/bank-of-japans-50-billion-quest... [2] https://www.zerohedge.com/news/2017-09-11/wtf-chart-day-boj-... [3] https://medium.com/@michaellevinson_64108/landlords-and-heir... [4] https://www.mercurynews.com/2016/12/01/high-priced-californi...

poof131··on Government to borrow nearly $1 trillion this year 84 percent jump from last year
How do you get 4:1? Wikipedia pegs the GDP to debt ratio at less than one.[1] So the US owes more than 100% of it’s income. Servicing the debt is approaching 7% of federal spending.[2] Are you using numbers other than GDP and National Debt for your ratio?

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_debt_of_the_United_St...

[2] http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2017/08/17/5-facts-abou...

poof131··on JS things I didn’t know existed
Side anecdote, but a number of people at my company were making fun of a candidate who used labels to break out of loops in JS. “Those don’t exist” they joked. I remember thinking, “I thought they did,” but didn’t say anything. The sad part is I really like the people I work with and they are generally smart engineers. There is just such an arrogance to the interview process in tech it is almost unreal. I haven’t noticed a lack of qualified candidates in tech, just a lack of humility in many of the gatekeepers. Whiteboard pissing contests.
poof131··on Why Aren’t Any Bankers in Prison for Causing the Financial Crisis? (2016)
I think that is entirely disingenuous. The banks have been borrowing from the Fed and lending to the Treasury for a profit.[1] The taxpayers have essentially recapitalized the banks. Now we are in a trap of low interest rates trying to edge our way out. We’ll see how it goes.

Free markets would have let the banks fail. Instead we’ve created a world with champions for free markets for trade, free markets for labor, but protected markets for capital. Absolute self-serving hypocrisy. FDIC was designed to protect the little guy. The bailouts protected the richest americans and excellerrated the growing inequality in this country.

I believe in capitalism, but 2008 was the crony variety. It still angers me thinking about watching the crying pundits talk about risk on monitors next to Americans taking real risks in Iraq. The bailouts were bipartisan fraud at a grand scale and epitomize the corruption of establishment politics and the revolving door between government and the private sector. But sure, “americans got paid back with interest.” Believe it if you want to.

[1] https://www.pbs.org/newshour/economy/are-banks-borrowing-fro...

poof131··on Education Startups Court Brand-Name Teachers, Raising Ethics Issues
But is this true, is US public education underfunded? These articles depict the US as one of if not the top spender per student [1, 2].

[1] https://www.cbsnews.com/news/us-education-spending-tops-glob... [2] https://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/indicator_cmd.asp

poof131··on The Sinking of HMS ‘Victoria’ Led the Royal Navy Astray
I’m convinced that the US needs to differentiate and separately fund resources for limited and unlimited wars. The military has squandered trillions fighting limited wars with assets designed for more conventional wars. It has also led to a less effective effort as the needs of operators on the ground are often disregarded for what the services want to provide to justify funding. Finally, legally separating the two would allow a better application of ROE and help prevent the current state of never ending “war”. The goal being to constantly strive to downgrade from unlimited war, to limited war, to state department diplomacy, with different funding for each and understandable reasons and criteria for transition between the categories.
poof131··on The Sinking of HMS ‘Victoria’ Led the Royal Navy Astray
The problem with mutually assured destruction is the “assured” part. There is nothing assured about it. Cyber, space, and other weapons could dismantle the assurance and we could be in a totally different warfare environment. Certainly this doesn’t seem to be the case yet, but I wouldn’t make assumptions about the future.
poof131··on Ask HN: If you're funded by the military, how do you tell people?
I’ve read War is a Racket. It’s a great piece and raises issues we all should think about. I also read A Bright Shining Lie, About Face, The Best and The Brightest and other books critical of the military [1, 2, 3]. Like I said in my previous comment, I have many issues with the military, but I’m also concerned when the elite of society no longer feel the need to serve, that makes me think of the Fall and Decline of the Roman Empire [4]. War sucks, but we all need to play our part, either in support or protest, but just pretending like it doesn’t exists and going about our day is the worst of both worlds.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Bright_Shining_Lie [2] https://www.amazon.com/About-Face-Odyssey-American-Warrior/d... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Best_and_the_Brightest [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_History_of_the_Decline_and...

← PreviousPage 3 of 10Next →