HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

poof131

2,305 karma · joined November 30, 2012

submissionscomments
poof131··on Ask HN: If you're funded by the military, how do you tell people?
Please don’t feel guilty. Voting your conscience is fine, protesting a war is fine, but shaming people who work for the DOD is childish. Americans are risking their lives all over the world for our country. If you’re ashamed to help your fellow countrymen survive, to do their jobs better, and to return home to their families, that’s not good.

I spent over a decade in the military. I have issues with the military industrial complex. I have issues with a lot of the leadership. But I respect the people who need the tools you work on and wouldn’t want to see their lives put in jeopardy. I can understand not wanting to spend your whole life in the DOD world. If you want to focus on other things, move industries, I did, but don’t feel ashamed while you’re in and don’t let others make you feel ashamed either. I respect the job you’re doing. Thank you.

poof131··on Airbnb raises $1B at $31B valuation, became profitable in 2016
Thanks for sharing that link. Always good to see which investors look out for employees and which founders don’t. Taking a dividend out of the company when most your employees shares are options and not eligible for a dividend is definitely not team spirited. The more transparency to these things the better.
poof131··on Zebras Fix What Unicorns Break
Agreed. If you want more Zebras, raise interest rates. The capitalist system isn’t the problem, it’s the cheap money handed out by fiat from the government to banks that funds the madness and the impending fiasco as investors chase ever more fleeting returns. Zebras die when Unicorns have access to nearly unlimited cheap capital to chase after markets with subsidized products being sold at negative margins. It’s price dumping on a massive scale. ZIRP turns the economy into a lottery favoring those with the best access to the trough. Raising interest rates will be painful, but it’s the only way to fix the current situation and goes against the overwhelming Keynesian consensus. Central banks are great when you need to fund a war, but other than that, they can’t take their foot off the gas and simply distort the economy, increase economic inequality, and exacerbate business cycles instead of smoothing them out. We never should have removed political from political economics. [1]

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_economy

poof131··on Big Tech Companies Pounce as the Allure of Startups Fades
I recently made the jump from startups to bigger co. For me there were a few considerations:

1. We’re at the end of a bubble and doing a slow pop. Multiple companies that have raised a lot of money don’t have the revenue or unit economics to be sustainable. Employees with compensation tied up in stock aren’t going to do well. Had a friend leave two companies within 6 months (didn’t bother vesting) that both raised over $100 million because the executive teams were celebrating $900 deals.

2. Startups don’t exit anymore. Waiting 8-10 years for an exit is unacceptable. It might be okay for founders who take a couple million off the table at the B round or VCs who keep the IRR on their books, but for employees it’s a fail.

3. Founders as rockstars. The narrative is hurting the industry. People I like and respected raise money and become narcissistic assholes. Last founder I worked for who I considered a friend told me “he was like Elon Musk or Larry Paige, a technical genius, and not to question his leadership”. This was after he fired his cofounder and chased off the one other employee of our seed stage startup.

4. Risk vs. Reward. As an employee with founders trying to keep 50% of the company to be like Zuck, companies never exiting, and no idea what the terms of later rounds are, working at a startup is becoming stupid. Saying it’s about the mission, it’s about learning not earning, when the VCs and founders are doing great is disingenuous.

We’re at the end of the cycle. I’ve seen 3 now: 2001, 2008, 2016. Hopefully in the next round the powers that be will figure out how to better reward everyone who takes risk working at startups. Right now employees take almost as much risk as founders for much less reward.

poof131··on Investigation Reveals Silicon Valley’s Abuse of Immigrant Tech Workers
The 409A valuation should be used.[1] Definitely not the fundraising valuation for preferred shares. Employees should use the 409A too when trying to evaluate competing offers. While early 409A evaluations can be a bit of a swag they are much more reasonable then fundraising valuations. Example, left a seed stage startup where the founder liked to brag about the $10 million dollar valuation (had a convertible note with a $10 million cap so not really a valuation). The 409A was at $2 million, which was much more reasonable for the progress, potential, and risk.

[1] https://www.quora.com/What-is-a-409A-valuation

poof131··on Why Are Politicians So Obsessed with Manufacturing?
I could have worded it better: short term profit extraction at the expense of long term capital expenditures and growth through mechanisms such as stock buybacks and outsourcing. [1] Agree there is no easy way to 10 times more stuff but neither is everybody instantly replaced by robots and if everything is 10 times cheaper due to increases in productivity (robots) then more credit / increased wages isn’t required. I do believe the robots arguments is used in a fait accompli way that isn’t necessarily true. [2]

1. http://www.marketfolly.com/2016/05/stan-druckenmillers-sohn-... 2. https://www.brookings.edu/blog/the-avenue/2015/04/29/dont-bl...

poof131··on Why Are Politicians So Obsessed with Manufacturing?
I’m finding this robots argument a bit tiresome. Seems more of an excuse to justify outsourcing than the inevitable end state. If for every 10 workers, instead of 9 losing their jobs and 1 managing the robots, couldn’t we have 10 managing the robots and 10 times more stuff. The latter seems the more likely outcome to me of free markets, but instead we seem to have pivoted into a micro-managed (FED, ZIRP) government supported vulture market focused on profit extraction (outsourcing, stock buybacks, tax avoidance, etc.).
poof131··on Ask HN: How close to market rate do engineers get paid, post series-b?
You should get a market rate salary post series-B or damn close in my opinion. This is the round where founders can take money off the table, making them millionaires. If they take money off the table but tell you that you should take less then market, you are getting taken advantage of. At a large company, with stock and bonus you could be getting $100k more per year. Your startup stock should cover this and more since you are taking a risk it is worth nothing in the end. Your base salary should match what you would get elsewhere. Founders take money off the table so they can focus on building the company and not worry about finances. There’s no reason employees shouldn’t be treated the same way.

How would you like working at a place like Secret for a discount only to find out 18 months before shutting down the founders each made 3 million.[1] Don’t take a below market salary at this point. There’s enough money the company can afford to pay market. If the founders can make millions they can afford to pay you the wage you deserve. Even post series-A I feel should be close to market, since the company just raised millions. Seed can be lower, but you should have a guarantee that it goes up at the next funding round. There’s a lot of money in the market and a lot of bad founders, so don’t make personal sacrifices to make others rich. If you want a mission, join the Peace Corp. Startups are business, otherwise they would be incorporated as non-profits.

1. http://www.businessinsider.com/secret-founders-pocket-6-mill...

poof131··on America's Addiction to Mercenaries
I hope otherwise too, but believe you may be right. A similar theme was purported in a book I read awhile back: Empire of Debt.[1] I try to be optimistic that the future will be better. Many things are better. But there is a self-righteous, self-centered aspect to modern western society that seems to be indicative of a decline in public virtue, where words matter more than actions, and where the elite believe it is there right to lead and service and sacrifice is for poor people without other options. For my daughter and others, I hope the Pax Americana lasts a long time.

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Empire_of_Debt

poof131··on America's Addiction to Mercenaries
I appreciate very much your perspective and it’s made me think. You obviously view things outside the box. Though I still believe a draft isn’t inherently anti-democratic. If the majority votes for a war, and the majority votes for conscription, then that seems to me to agree with democracy. But I do agree that a draft is anti-individual-freedom. And I agree that democracy isn’t inherently good. The majority can vote in a manner that oppresses the minority. It’s definitely occurred in our past. A democracy combined with individual rights is the key in my opinion. I just don’t think the ability to avoid service should be one of those protected rights. But since I do believe in democracy, only a majority can vote to make that so, thus my outspoken attitude toward private contractors and the all volunteer force.
poof131··on America's Addiction to Mercenaries
I’m suggesting that military service isn’t normal labor and shouldn’t be treated as such. That war isn’t just a Kissingeresque chess move, but a last resort activity. You can’t use lethal force in business. Societies shouldn’t use lethal force as a matter of business. Both people and countries should act only in self defense.

War is a social cost that should be born by all members of the society. A draft isn’t an anti-democratic hack anymore than preventing a company from dumping toxic waste in a river is anti-democratic. We inhibit some freedoms to protect other freedoms. Certain actions have externalities beyond the person engaged in them. We have obligations beyond just serving ourselves.

Teachers unions don’t overthrow governments, but militaries, private or public, do. I lean libertarian in certain things, but no longer regarding the military. Allowing private companies to wield lethal force with military style units scares me. The military and law enforcement underpin the very laws that the country is built upon. Congress can pass a law, the courts can judge upon it, but without someone willing to pick up a gun and enforce it, laws are nothing more than words on paper.

Awhile back I saw an article about a private psyops contractor targeting american journalists who were critical of it, trying to tarnish their reputations. I scoured Google for 20 minutes but couldn’t find it. I believe there really is a threat that these private companies will engage in activities for their own self-interest at the expense of the country. I believe most of these companies do have a lot of patriotic people who are trying to make good money for their families and I don’t think the threat is extreme at the moment but that it grows over time as this becomes the pattern and the gulf widens between the military and the civilian population it’s supposed to protect.

I always felt that a key component contributing to the end of the Roman Republican period was the fact the elite echelons of society no longer felt obligated to serve and the soldiers no longer felt an allegiance to them or the institutions they ruled. From wikipedia: “The extensive campaigning abroad by Roman generals, and the rewarding of soldiers with plunder on these campaigns, led to a general trend of soldiers becoming increasingly loyal to their generals rather than to the state.”[1] I don’t want our soldier’s loyalty focused on a paycheck. I’m afraid more of where we are going then where we currently are.

Soldiers can’t quit. They can’t unionize. They can’t demand higher wages. But they can use lethal force to achieve their objectives. We need to make sure that those objectives are always in line with democracy. If we don’t, then you can vote all you want and one day it won’t matter, because democracy depends upon the rule of law and that depends upon the will of the military. I prefer a civilian military more than a private military and more than an all volunteer military. I think that is the greatest defense of democracy and the freedom you talk about.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roman_Republic

poof131··on America's Addiction to Mercenaries
Personally, I feel this military contracting is a disgrace and a threat to the democracy. Bring back the draft or don’t fight the war. Even in World War 2, America’s paragon of a “justified” war, 61% of troops were drafted. [1]

Not only does it create private military forces with significantly less allegiance to the country, it destroys the morale of active duty troops. When I was in Iraq, it seemed like there were more contractors than troops. Kenyan’s managed by dutch contractors provided internal security. Indian’s worked in the chow halls. Filipinos manned the commissaries. And on and on.

The Special Forces soldiers I worked with had former SF soldiers helping with the training of Iraqi forces. They considered them lazy and unhelpful in general, taking none of the risk but getting paid $1k a day. Compare that to the actual soldiers making a few grand a month, and you get the sense your country doesn’t really give a shit about you and your just a dupe.[2] Get out as quick as you can and get paid 5-10x more for less risk.

Throughout history, private military forces are the tool of tyrants. I don’t want this for America. War is a last resort. Either we go together or don’t go at all. Hopefully the latter, but contracting out the fight is stupid and lazy and destroys the fabric of our country by slowly eliminating our citizen military. Opposing the draft isn’t opposing war, it’s supporting war by contractor and making wars easier to wage by politicians who’ve never served, whose kids don’t serve, and who have no real skin in the game. Truly a sad state of affairs.

[1] http://www.nationalww2museum.org/learn/education/for-student...

[2] http://www.dfas.mil/militarymembers/payentitlements/military...

poof131··on Stop Treating Marijuana Like Heroin
Thanks! Fixed.
poof131··on Stop Treating Marijuana Like Heroin
The DEA needs to go bye bye, and be replaced by the DRA, Drug Rehabilitation Agency. While I respect the risks operational agents take against crime syndicates, the war on drugs is a disaster. Even the government’s own RAND corporation concluded enforcement is far worse than rehabilitation, with rehab being 7 times more effective than policing, 400 times more effective then border interdiction, and 800 times more effective than actions in source countries.[1] Not to mention the privacy violations it’s enabled. If the goal is to reduce drug use, the US policies are stupid. If the goal is for politicians to sound tough and maintain a never ending drug war so they can keep sounding tough, then it’s a success.

And letting the DEA decide what is Schedule 1 is like letting the fox guard the hen house. I’ve never heard of a government agency voluntarily reducing its scope and budget. Just more of our leadership deferring responsibility to so called “experts” with a vested interest. A pretty rampant phenomenon these days ranging from the banks to the military.

[1] http://www.rand.org/pubs/periodicals/rand-review/issues/RRR-...

poof131··on The Politically Incorrect Guide to Ending Poverty (2010)
Seems like we’ve entered some sort of post-modern neocolonialism. How do we “fix” the broken countries of the world. The neocons under Bush tried to remake the middle east by invading Iraq.[1] Debated with someone here who felt we just needed more time in Afghanistan so a generation could understand good governance.[2] In this article, the thrust seems to be benevolent foreign powers and businesses will lead the way to prosperity. All seem like colonialism without the name and all seem to totally disregard secondary effects.

Read a great article awhile back on HN that talked about the impulse to fix other people’s problems far away from your own.[3] Seems that SV and Stanford could do a lot more to fix the issues closer at hand in the Bay Area (homelessness, unaffordable living, rising inequality) and the US in general before solving all the worlds problems. Lead by example sort of stuff. Instead my main takeaway from the article is get rich in the startup lottery then proselytize your grand vision and plans from your bubble of prosperity. Sell the dream but don’t look in the mirror.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imperial_Life_in_the_Emerald_C...

[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11412172

[3] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10884840

poof131··on Show HN: Material Kit – Free Bootstrap UI Kit Based on Material Design
These tools: bootstrap, material, etc. seem to be exactly what you need. They make sure your style is consistent and looks good without too much work. You can then configure the framework to make it look unique to your application. My impression is these frameworks are used all over the place in production, they are just customized so you might not recognize them. The last three companies I’ve worked at, one used angular material, one used bootstrap, and one had a custom css framework. The later had a tendency to build internal frameworks instead of new product and is suffering the consequences.
poof131··on How becoming a pilot made me a better programmer
I wouldn’t totally beat yourself up. Multi-tasking is one of the toughest and most important aspects of flying. You get better over time, but it is different than the intense focus in programming. The key is to just keep moving your focus: your scan. This takes practice and comfort. You have to learn to force yourself to keep scanning and never stopping. Practice makes it easier. And fear does a great job of making this tough in the beginning. Your brain doesn’t function at full capacity when flying and only experience makes this better. And missing radio calls is always a problem. A slow scan and task saturation makes it almost inevitable. Again, more comfort and a faster scan makes it easier to catch radio call.

You may not have been flying regularly enough. To get qualified, you should really dedicate a few months and try to fly multiple times a week. Currency is critical. Spacing things out makes it tougher and more expensive in the long run. If you really want to learn to fly, don’t give up because of a slow scan. Just work on it and fly as much as you can.

poof131··on How becoming a pilot made me a better programmer
Flew for the military for a decade. Disagree with the black box take away. Feel that is beginning vs expert. In the beginning you learn the systems as a sort of firehouse training. But later, so much is black boxes. Certainly you want to try to understand inside the box, but the important part is to know the interface. The talk about intuition in a spin gets you killed. The spin recovery for his plane may not be the right recovery for other planes. Understanding the fuel system rather than memorizing emergency procedures is bad. It helps to know both, but intuition when in flight quickly falls apart and memorizing procedures until they become second nature is important. Loss of power off a carrier cat shot, engine failure, fires, out of control flight, and so much more, you better know your procedures for your aircraft. Understanding details is good, but knowing the procedures cold and not just relying on intuition is so important when flying. Seems similar to programming, at a small scale you can afford to know all the details, but working in a large company you would never be able to. The interfaces are critical.
poof131··on Dallas Police Used Robot with Bomb to Kill Ambush Suspect: Mayor
They could have waited for him to escape through the ventilation systems and kill more people? They could have waited for him to detonate the entire building and bring it down on everybody’s head, with more police inside and media watching? Either are possibilities they could have waited for and everyone would be second guessing those scenarios just like people are second guessing this one now. I don’t like the idea of robot bombs killing people, but when someone is shooting at police and not negotiating, I do support them taking out the threat and wouldn’t call it murder. Self-defense or defending innocents are probably better terms. And your statement that they would have waited if he was a different race is ridiculous. So you know better what would have happened than the african american chief of the Dallas police? You’re not helping the situation in this country by making these uninformed statements.
poof131··on Ask HN: Family friendly beach town in California?
Lived in the bay area, LA and San Diego for extended periods.

If I were remote, focused on family, and somewhat price conscious, first choice would be San Louis Obispo: beaches, nice downtown, college town. My next choices would be San Diego (north of La Jolla) or Santa Barbara. If you are less price conscious and want to move north, then Half Moon Bay or Santa Cruz. Can find more remote places too that are amazing if you want that, like the Big Sur area or north of the Bay Area. Tend to like the places mentioned more than Carlsbad or Ventura, but those places aren’t bad by any stretch.

Been to Costa Rica, it’s nice, but more expensive than people think and issues with crime, like don’t ever leave your house unattended. Brother goes to Nicaragua to surf a lot, sounds like Costa Rica but cheaper and less stable. Mexico still feels too dangerous to me. About three months ago our nanny was scared to go home because of the crime. When I was in the military not too long ago, you needed a General’s approval to go. Some areas are probably good but doesn’t strike me as family friendly, more like retirement and vacation compounds. No idea about Panama, but all sound like an adventure.

Good luck and have fun. Remote sounds better by the day.

poof131··on Dallas Police Used Robot with Bomb to Kill Ambush Suspect: Mayor
I agree. While using a lethal robot is scary, it is really no different than giving a police sniper the okay for a shot. Except in this case there was no possibility of a sniper shot.

This individual was likely well trained. He fires and maneuvers. He has a good stance and chooses targets. He is clearly an accurate shot. He is aggressive and circles his target. He is calm under fire. [1]

His skill level is damn scary and likely superior to many of the police he was up against. Makes me think of the Special Ops guys I worked with in Iraq. If he escaped somehow from the garage, he could have killed could more.

While this robot technique is a bit scary, if I was responsible for stopping him, I would probably have done the same thing. No way you can charge in to stop him. Not only is he well armed, he may have a bomb. You don’t rush entrenched people with assault rifles, it’s not Call of Duty. You use grenades, explosives, air-strikes, etc.

Perhaps a non-lethal option could be developed. This would be ideal. But this robot bomb may have been improvised on the spot by the police to deal with this incident. Without a non-lethal robot to shoot a tranquilizer, release gas, or stun the suspect, I see no other way to stop him.

[1] https://streamable.com/pgpb

poof131··on Misfortune
Personally, I think Tesla and Musk should shut up. This bantering back at the media might have been “new” and “cool” with other topics, but not when it involves somebody’s death. While it’s fine to respond to inaccurate facts, the catchy headlines (“Misfortune”, “A Tragic Loss”) and the condescending and confrontational tone is totally out of place. Stick to the facts. Talk about how you take this very seriously, are going to look more into it, but do believe the autopilot is safe.

After a decade in the military, where bad things happen frequently, I couldn’t imagine public relations acting in this manner: "We bombed the wrong house, but this happens, it's war, the media just doesn't understand". Don’t give people the impression you care more about your business than their lives. Don’t dismiss someone’s death as a statistic.

I want Tesla to succeed, but they are starting to leave a bad taste in my mouth. I remember my XO saying, “never get into a shouting match with an idiot, bystanders can’t tell the difference.” Ignore the media if you can’t respond appropriately. The real misfortune here is that somebody died in what was probably a preventable accident, not a poorly sourced Fortune article.

poof131··on Ask HN: Would elite video gamers, given training, be the best military pilots?
A little yes, but mostly no. I flew F/A-18s for the Navy for a decade including working as an instructor. There are probably 3 key areas you need to succeed as a military pilot (especially in fighters): stick and rudder skills, multi-tasking, and fear control.

1. Stick and rudder skills. You need to be able to make the plane do what you want, whether it’s landing on a carrier, dog fighting, flying formation, dropping dumb bombs, air-to-air tanking, or any number of other things. This is more like race car driving than video games, with a significantly higher level of hand eye coordination and spacial awareness.

2. Multi-tasking. Modern aviation, especially military platforms, have a ton of things going on. You need to fly the plane (stick and rudder), talk on the radios, operate weapon systems, and do a ton of other stuff. In the F/A-18 you had essentially 4 displays that could all contain information.[1] You could perform hundreds of different tasks without ever taking your hands of the controls (stick and throttle). Here are some good graphics on the controls. [2, 3] You even have a screen selector and mouse cursor so essential you are operating multiple computers without text input. You need to keep a constant scan going, inside and out, while processing information on all the different displays and the radios.

3. Fear control. Operating a fighter jet is like doing something at 50% brain capacity. Something easy on the ground becomes tough in-flight. When you are junior or new to the task or stressed because of a mistake, 50% can quickly drop to 10%. This is often called a “helmet fire”. Sometimes people just freeze and can’t function.

Being an elite video gamer would only really help with number 2: multi-tasking. Stick and rudder skills and fear control are more important in the beginning. You can make it a long way in training on these, but eventually multi-tasking becomes a key component. We would see kids who aced flight school with great stick and rudder skills but then would run into a ton of problems when learning the F/A-18 due to insufficient multi-tasking skills required in advanced air-to-air and air-to-ground scenarios. If you can nail all three of these things, you will likely be a good military pilot.

Physical is also a factor, but not that big of a deal. If you are in decent shape you can handle it. The primary limiting physical factor will be stress. Initially, the stress will be draining where a single flight can wreck you for the day. But as you become more comfortable, this becomes less of a factor so I didn’t include it as one of the 3 main requirements. I knew plenty of overweight pilots in average shape. But if you can’t handle the 3 main requirements, you won’t be successful no matter how good an athlete you are.

Should probably also mention work ethic and study skills since these play a huge roll. The training is long and intense and never really stops. Earning your wings is just the start. You constantly need to learn new missions and new systems. Got your wings, nice, but what about section lead, division lead, strike lead. How do you run a strike group (a dozen plus planes of different types) off a carrier into a foreign country in the first days of a war? Although this is more of pilot leadership than just being a pilot, it is related, since the less you understand what is happening, the less effective you will be even if just a wingman. I imagine elite video gamers are probably pretty strong here though.

[1] http://www.mudspike.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/2015-10-3...

[2] http://i295.photobucket.com/albums/mm137/Lightndattic/F-18th...

[3] http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v699/xu-an/control_f-14d_f...

poof131··on Can Capitalism Be Redeemed?
You nailed the point I think is the most critical: that artificially low interest rates (along with massive government debt) have resulted in an incredible misallocation of capital. Working in Silicon Valley I see (and benefit) from this first hand. Pensions, endowments, and all the other Limited Partners need 7-8% returns. Most directly access or are one to two steps removed from the free government money. With few “reasonable” investments that can return the required numbers, they are forced to chase returns. This leads to an abundance of capital in SV, one of the few places still believed to offer these returns (this is changing as this cycle comes to an end).

Others with first access to capital are doing great in this climate too: hedge funds, investment banks, government contractors, big companies. The rich get richer while the economy stagnates for the majority. Raising rates and stoping the bailouts of failed private institutions I believe will go a long way toward fixing this growing inequality. How we get leaders who can enact these policies is another thing since conventional wisdom (and much of academia) says dropping rates grows the economy. Amazes me that the world didn’t learn from Japan’s never ending stagnation. We hit the end of a 20 year credit expansion cycle in 2000 and there still is no will to let asset prices and credit deflate, instead we got the government “put” [1], not to mention the 2008 bailouts, and continued credit expansion.

The sad part is that instead of fixing the problem, micromanaged economic policy and money creation from on high, we will get jingoistic nationalism. While I do agree that some of our “free trade” has been anything but fair, the numbers, including those in the article, seem to indicate that it has helped large numbers of people throughout the world escape from poverty. I believe free and fair trade is a boon for all. These gains, unfortunately, will likely evaporate as fed-up, disenfranchised electorates in developed countries try anything to stop their slide backwards. It’s tough to sell a “help the world” argument to people who are hurting when those on the top are doing so well.

1. http://www.investopedia.com/terms/g/greenspanput.asp

poof131··on Software has diseconomies of scale, not economies of scale
A few days ago I would have agreed whole heartedly. Now, after reading the article about the formation of AWS I’m not so sure.[1] It seems that Amazon (and others such as Google) have achieved economies of scale in development with internal services and well organized APIs. Certainly much of this is being exposed externally for profit, but it does seem to indicate that well designed software has economies of scale for the development of future software. Certainly one monolith application with a team of a thousand starting from scratch is a bad idea, but once internal APIs and services exist, these definitely seem to aid in the rapid development of future software products for a company, which seems like economies of scale to me.

Bloated bureaucracies and bad processes can negatively impact any company in any industry, not just software. Some of the article’s logic doesn’t seem to differentiate software development from anything else, such as “working in the large increases risk”. So while a large monolith application is risky, building a hundred million widgets is risky too. Better to iterate and start with a prototype and expand, but the same goes for other industries too: better to prototype and market test your widget before mass production. Seems to me like the article is talking more about lean and agile and process in general than about economies of scale.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12022915

poof131··on How a team of young people helped rebuild healthcare.gov (2015)
God. I thought cost plus contracts were only used in exigent circumstances such as war, but apparently they are getting used more now, such as for the F-35.[1] Are software contracts really cost plus? These contracts shouldn’t be used for fighter jets or anything else. They should be banned except in critical situations and even then used sparingly. I remember stories about the boondoggle in Iraq, $20 coke cans and such.[2] Really sad if these are being used more now. Indicative of a lazy, corrupt government contracting process.

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cost-plus_contract

2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iraq_for_Sale:_The_War_Profite...

poof131··on How a team of young people helped rebuild healthcare.gov (2015)
And this is miniscule. The wars in Iraq and Afghanistan cost hundreds of billions more than they needed to (not talking about whether they should have been started, just the effects achieved for the cost). I flew F/A-18s off the carrier for 6 hour missions that could have been handled by a small propeller plane in country. These missions required a carrier (millions to operate), extra more-costly flight hours ($10k/hour for F/A-18s), and 3 air-to-air refuels (cost of tanker flight time and gas). Not to mention the deterioration of incredibly expensive assets that need to be replaced. I also saw artillery and tanks in country that had no use. Could go on about the waste.

The sad truth is government bureaucracies spend all their budgets so they can ask for more. Limiting cost is the least of their concerns. I applaud 18F and the Digital Service for their efforts to advance and streamline IT and development costs. It’s an uphill battle. There is no reality check in the public sector as there is in the private sector, where inefficient behemoths eventually go bankrupt to more efficient companies.

Outsourcing is supposed to prevent this, but the big contractors just milk it for all it’s worth (Oracle failing to build Oregon’s healthcare website for $250 million is an example, HP and NMCI is another). I don’t believe it’s just the byzantine contract bidding process but the fact it is easier for leaders to say they chose a big “reputable” company so it’s not their fault it failed, whereas if they had chosen a small no-name company and it failed it would be their ass. So real competition and efficiency end up being non-existent in government, unless the president’s legacy initiative is in jeopardy and he throws his weight behind the fix. I don’t know of any way to fix this behavior except to limit the size of government and make it more local so accountability is easier to maintain by the electorate. I wish more good people in government could change things, but there are already a lot of good people trying their best in a top-down system where CYA and optics are more important than efficiency and results.

poof131··on Ask HN: Just got an innocent man out of prison. What now?
One place to look is resources for veterans. California has some great ones.[1] See about filing for any disabilities that may be related to time in service and if there is any way to get treatment and help through the VA. Also, look for other non-profit veteran resources beyond just the state and federal.

[1]https://www.calvet.ca.gov/VetServices/Documents/Veteran_%20R...

poof131··on The Brexit Possibility
States being the source of money and not a neutral arbiter of it’s value is the major problem in my opinion, not the solution. With a set amount of money (or a slow fixed increase) markets are stable and operate efficiently (assuming minimal other burdens) in the allocation of resources and goods. But when governments ‘make’ money, the markets don’t allocate it, a small set of people do. This micromanagement of the economy leads to declining productivity and stagnation as money flows to the politically connected. The former USSR being a good example in the extreme.

So money becomes politics. We’ve seen that those with money have used this to make even more: regressive taxes, bailouts, corporate inversions, etc. But the spread between rich and poor is becoming worse, so now the talk about UBI. The affect of this money distributed by bureaucratic fiat is that the middle class dies. The rich get richer with access to the new money, the poor get poorer and live off handouts, and those surviving in the middle get pushed to the poor side or figure out how to get to the rich side. A fairly standard state of affairs throughout history (lords and serfs), but not the future I’d like to see.

poof131··on “Tomorrow belongs to me”
“Okay, so the idiots did it; they broke the UK.”

When this is your attitude toward your fellow countrymen and women of course it’s broken. A majority voted for something and they are “idiots”. Democracy is ugly, especially when the majority votes against what you think is best.

Dismissing the rise of populism as “idiots” is about as smug and idiotic as it gets. Populism isn’t rising because people don’t know what’s good for them, but because people don’t think the current structure of the system is good for them. If you’re doing well in the current system, of course it seems stupid to vote against it. If you aren’t doing well, then any brick to throw at the glass house looks good.

Populism and extreme nationalism is best kept at bay by a system that works for the majority of people, creating a strong “middle class”. That way fewer brick throwers exist. But lecturing people about “what’s best” for them or trotting out abstract economic figures and theories won’t do it, only forward economic progress will, where people believe the system works and they can move forward and not slide backwards. Most governments have tried to paste over issues with rhetoric, theories, and easy, central-bank money, all of which are only exacerbating the problems, not fixing them.

← PreviousPage 4 of 10Next →