HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

poof131

2,305 karma · joined November 30, 2012

submissionscomments
poof131··on How Clinton’s email scandal took root
The government issues government accounts for different levels of classification. You get a normal .gov or .mil for unclassified, another one for secret, and another one for top secret. All the communication is done on separate networks: nipr, sipr, etc. Around 2008, the military got hacked so bad that you couldn’t even put a thumb drive in a non-secure computer. If you did, you had to talk to a General/Admiral and could expect punishment. Secret, Top Secret, and SAP were a totally different matter. Cell phones and electronic devices don’t go in secure areas at all. Red lights flash when non-cleared people enter areas. Hillary wanted a Top Secret blackberry which no one except the president had from reading the articles. She wanted to avoid FOIA so she avoided using any government email addresses. This is totally non-standard and I imagine was only permitted because she was the boss. It isn’t remotely similar to what Powell did and while I agree that the government classifies too much shit, that isn’t the case here either. She went against protocol because she wanted to and she could, and she should own the consequences. I don’t blame incompetence at State here. If she’d used her government accounts and followed normal procedures this would have been a non issue.
poof131··on Ask HN: Developers – would you ever consider becoming an SDET?
Sounds like, “I’m looking for someone in the majors who is interested in switching to playing minor league ball.” If you had a fantastic developer who you could use to build new product that drives revenue or use them to write tests for the current product, which task would you put them on? Which task would your CEO want them on? Which task is going to get the most visibility in the company and offer the best opportunity for promotion? If the org had a huge issue with quality, I may temporarily put them on QA to get things organized and structured, but after that I’d want them on new product or refactoring current product for faster velocity.

A business can exist without tests, but tests can’t exist without a business. I love and appreciate great QA people, but I also believe there is a hierarchy and you can’t ignore it. You can offer a path up, either to manage QA or a future switch to dev. You can offer to pay more for QA. You can integrate dev and QA. But I don’t think you can realistically get the same caliber developer at the same level in pure QA as in pure Dev without it being detrimental to retention and the business. You can try to create parallel org charts for the two roles, but the hierarchy will still form.

poof131··on Workers See Costs, Not Benefits, to Global Trade
That’s one of the problems with data. It seems so exact but can really be so misleading. You break out charts, I break out charts. [1] My gut feeling is that much of middle class america has seen significant wage and livelihood stagnation. I’m all for free trade and a competitive economy, but something feels off about the past couple decades and the distribution of economic gains. And I don’t really trust the Federal Reserve and their CPI metrics—the institution is far too political and the members have too much skin in the game, rotating in and out of banking jobs.

[1] http://www.epi.org/publication/charting-wage-stagnation/

poof131··on A better offer letter
Definitely agree that the iron law needs to be relaxed. You can give special voting rights to founders stock to make sure they maintain control of the company, but currently the risk/reward ratio between founders and early employees is way out of whack. Glad to hear investors are keen on this since I think it should make startups stronger.

Equity is a key component of modern compensation with better tax implications and more upside.[1] The “built in the garage” myth needs to die and doesn’t justify 100-1000x payouts when early employees are taking a significant risk too in opportunity cost. The main issue currently is information asymmetry as most early employees don’t see the cap table, don’t realize how much others own, don't understand how little risk most founders take, and don't know how much they are truly giving up in total comp from more established companies.

[1] https://medium.com/the-wtf-economy/what-paul-graham-is-missi...

poof131··on Veil of secrecy lifted on Pentagon office planning micro-drone swarms
You hit a part of the military that really upsets me and I feel garners virtually no discussion. As a former F-18 pilot, I saw this first hand, as the military spent $billions on using jets to target insurgents in Iraq and Afghanistan when Super Tacanos [1] would have been 10 times cheaper and more effective. Super Tacanos were requested by the Special Ops community but big Navy/AirForce/MarineCorps shut the program down. The military (and government in general) will spend every penny in the budget and then ask for more even if cheaper, more effective alternatives exist. The military-industrial complex needs curtailing and Americans need to ask why no government agency ever comes in under budget.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embraer_EMB_314_Super_Tucano

poof131··on The Voters Decide
Well written but disagree. I don’t see the internet playing a significantly larger role in 2016 than in the last couple of elections. The real distinction is the trajectory of the economy and people’s belief in the future. Sanders and Trump both represent populism, just on different sides of the political spectrum. Populism is the defining factor of this election cycle, not the Internet. I love tech, but sometimes it isn’t the center of the universe.

Perhaps the Internet has made insurgency candidacies easier, but I bet history would dispute this. A quick google search of underdog candidates shows that Lincoln may have been one.[1] I wasn’t alive then so can’t say for sure, but American politics seems to be a battle of insurgencies and their absorption by one party or the other to gain the upper hand. A strong vein of populism can even create a whole party dedicated to bringing down a single perceived elite institution.[2] Even while one of their main targets, Andrew Jackson, was trying to take down the elite bankers himself.[3] Populism is the undercurrent here, not a change in technology.

[1] http://www.amazon.com/Lincoln-President-Underdogs-Republican...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Masonic_Party

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bank_War

poof131··on Ask HN: How do you hire good developers?
Agree with all that you said and I have seen it first hand as I tend to be a poor negotiator and overly trust people. My main issue is the selling of the “mission” by investors and founders. Even in the first comment of the article you linked, Mark Suster talks about people obsessing about options. Certainly we should all be doing stuff for more than money, but if founders and investors weren’t concerned at all about the money why not make these companies non-profits. The reality is they use the information asymmetry for their benefit and then try to pretend it doesn’t matter and people should be about the mission. If you want a mission join the military or the peace corp. Your B2B app isn’t a “mission”.
poof131··on Ask HN: How do you hire good developers?
I think you are exactly right on equity and expose a problem of startups and recruiting that borders on disingenuous at the very least. VCs fund multiple startups expecting many to fail. As I’ve seen first hand, a prototype can land a million dollar convertible note at a $10m cap. For the founders to then turn around and act like 1 percent of the stock is really worth $100k isn’t even close to reality. To account for realistic exits you probably need to cut that by 1/3. So to match a big company offer of $100k salary and $100k equity (of liquid stock), you need to match the salary and offer 3x equity for the compensation to be about equal.

Yet most startups won’t match salary and then try to pretend that their equity is worth way more than it is. “We’ll pay you $70k but give you $150k in equity so the comp is more!” When the reality is the comp is actually significantly less if equity is more fairly valued. In this fictitious example, the $220k offered comp is really more like $130k, so about a 30% pay cut from the $200k offered by the big co. Startup equity isn’t worthless, but it needs to be valued at a significant discount which varies by the stage.

poof131··on Fixing the Inequity of Startup Equity
Really? How about early startups protect themselves by treating employees fairly and not trying to lock them in with equity tricks many don’t understand. The fact you suggest this course seems to indicate a certain level of disdain for employees. Try the carrot, not the stick.
poof131··on Brooklyn Judge: Feds Can't Use All Writs Act to Force Apple's Hand [pdf]
I’m not sure what your point is or how it contradicts the part of the opinion you quoted. Sure, the founding fathers weren’t perfect and the sedition act seems downright deplorable, but the wiki article you referenced describes how the law helped propel the Jeffersonian Democratic-Republicans to power at which point it was repealed. Seems like the process worked pretty well.
poof131··on Ask HN: Will JavaScript take over front-end?
Loading an application and hydrating with data seems like the ideal architecture. Especially when your single application can run on the web, mobile, or a desktop. A choice between thin and thick clients seems a little mainframe versus PC. The web started as a page-based text-focused entity, but I don’t understand why it needs to stay there or why thin clients are the ideal pattern. Certainly first load & SEO can present challenges, but both these problems are going away with React/Angular2 server side rendering and Google’s progress with indexing web apps.

Maybe I’m missing something, but SPAs seem like the future (perhaps compile to JS or whatever, but still thick clients). The backend should be concerned with clean APIs to data and not with rendering the view. If people want to turn off JavaScript for a text only web, well some people still use flip phones and everything depends upon what you are building and for who and how quickly you can move in either paradigm. I’d suggest studying either the Angular or React ecosystem, but don’t expect SPAs to go away.

poof131··on What Google Learned from Its Quest to Build the Perfect Team
I may be misunderstanding as I'm not familiar with your sources, but I’m not sure how you can have an effective team without accountability? If you are responsible for delivering something and you don’t and there’s never any ramification (accountability) things degenerate. I’ve seen this more than I’d like where a manager’s team is failing and he or she constantly blames subordinates and other teams for the lack of results, always ready to pull something out of the excuse matrix. When senior leaders fail to hold these managers accountable, the process continues, new mistakes, missed targets, and new scape goats found. Responsibility without accountability seems like the life of a Roman Emperor and I’ve never seen it work well with teams or leaders.
poof131··on Which Occupations Are Priced Out of Homeownership?
Sure. But when you do fly I’d say it’s pretty risky.[1] Even some of the training can kill you. Seems more risky than a typical desk job, but maybe that depends on how deadly boredom can be.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_spaceflight-related_ac...

poof131··on Which Occupations Are Priced Out of Homeownership?
Astronauts aren’t doing it for the money. The government doesn’t pay it’s people well for risk. Contracting with the government is much more lucrative in this regards. Military can often pay less than $50k a year[1] to people taking a ton of risk when a contractor taking significantly less risk is making $1000 a day. This is one reason privatizing so much of the military is corrosive.

http://www.militaryrates.com/military-pay-charts-e1_e5_2016

poof131··on The Elephant in the Room: Web design work is drying up
+1000. It’s not like developers are licensed and only so many exist. The reality is you can’t find someone with the experience and talent you would like, who is interested in your company, team, product, location, and compensation. Tough to change some of these, but upping the compensation or lowering your standards are fairly easy. Crying shortage in an unlicensed profession is getting really annoying. You either don’t have the resources to compete at the level you’d like or you are talking your book trying to drive down wages in a bid for more government subsidized training or increased immigration. While I agree with more CS/tech in schools and robust immigration policies (I feel they both work to make a country stronger), some people in SV/VC land definitely have ulterior motives and a stake in the game when talking about shortages and policies to address them.
poof131··on Stock Plan Used by Hundreds of YC Companies
I believe it’s very possible, just not standard. A number of companies have adopted such measures to great effect for the founders to maintain power over investors [1], but not many have used similar legal tools in reverse to help spread the upside with earlier employees as suggested in the first comment. Perhaps the standard should be for founders to get ‘super-voting’ shares and use some of the power to distribute better upside distribution. Sell it in both directions, longer term stability and more employee alignment.

[1] http://www.businessinsider.com/googles-co-founders-are-going...

poof131··on Stock Plan Used by Hundreds of YC Companies
Seems like a solid plan to address issues with disparity in compensation / upside between different tiers of employees. It spreads the reward but still allows the founders to maintain larger ownership chunks, which is the important part. Since equity is such a critical part of compensation [1], I’d love to see this implemented more, but I have a feeling it will mostly get lip service with people hiding behind “this is the standard.” Founders shouldn’t accept the “it’s standard” argument from VCs when negotiating terms, and employees shouldn’t accept the same argument from founders. You can’t have your circular logic and eat it too. Standards change and just because something is a standard doesn’t justify it’s existence. Slavery was pretty standard for awhile and I’m glad we got rid of that one.

[1] https://medium.com/the-wtf-economy/in-his-essay-on-income-in...

poof131··on Tell HN: Man, I quit
Congratulations. You built an end-to-end product that you sold for money. This is probably more than 99% of programmers have ever done. In many ways you are succeeding.

Be flexible. Your determination, focus, and drive allowed you to power through on a project that you are now recognizing in hindsight might not have been the best option. Changing targets isn’t quitting, it’s counter-attacking.

You are only 30. So many opportunities to keep swinging. All it takes is one hit. Be adaptable. Let yourself recharge. Figure out how you can take more swings in shorter periods of time. Figure out how each swing can work together to push you further towards your goal. As much as your work seems a failure now, there is a ton of learning in what you did. It will come with time. An incredibly successful entrepreneur I know said his break through happened on his 12th try. That’s a lot of projects.

Get away from the HN/SV bubble awhile. It’s like Facebook in that you only see the successes. The struggles are mostly manufactured fluff and don’t compare to what you put yourself through for 6 years. Most startups are built by people who took very little actual risk. Taking a year off your career at Google to go to YC isn’t a real risk, that’s like calling HBS a risk.

Don’t let people say “maybe starting a business isn’t your thing.” If a soldier got wounded on the battlefield, would you say “maybe war isn’t your thing” and that we should only celebrate those who didn’t take a hit? Of course not.

You’ve proven that you are an entrepreneur. You have the determination. You need to rest, recharge, and figure out what other skills need work and how you are going to counter attack. Whether it’s starting a business or doing whatever else you want to do in life. Seriously, building shit is hard and clearly you have the aptitude for it. Good luck in your journeys and know that you did something.

poof131··on Ask HN: Do you think security is part of a developers job?
Yes and no depending upon seniority and context. Senior developers leading teams should make sure the patterns being used are secure. Junior developers should mostly worry about getting stuff built. Companies of even a modest size should be having audits. Lessons from these audits should be taught to the team. Everyone (on the web dev side) should be familiar with OWASP [1].

The reality, however, is most companies will disregard security because a secure product with no revenue means no business. So revenue comes first, then security. And usually this is only done in a reactive fashion, like when (true story) a huge banking customer’s security audit finds a hardcode password string in your code that allows admin access. Guess it’s time to remove the back door for troubleshooting.

[1] https://www.owasp.org/index.php/OWASP_Top_Ten_Cheat_Sheet

poof131··on Entrepreneur = someone who resists the urge to play in other peoples businesses
What does this even mean? If you are starting a company you should be in other people’s business as often as you can. You need to be selling your product to people or companies.

Are you trying to glamorize the “not work for someone else” theme? Most entrepreneurs spent time working for someone else, usually at prestigious places. This “domain experience” helps them raise money.

And is work play? Certainly we should strive to enjoy the things we do, but a lot of people work for more than enjoyment—food, shelter, healthcare, supporting dependents, and so on.

poof131··on Ask HN: How much equity should I ask for?
Equity is the dirty secret of the widening wealth gap in society and especially poignant in startup land.[1] You’re taking a 50% pay cut for 0.2%. Assuming (for argument sake) no more dilution and $100m exit you get $200k. All that does is put you up to the salary you are giving up over four years. The founders (assuming 2, the other employees are at 0.2%, and 10% for seed funding) have 39% each. So their exit is $39 million each. Would you take a job where your future boss says, “I need you to take a risk, but assuming everything works out you’ll make $100k a year, your market salary, and I’ll make $10 million a year.” Does this sound remotely good or fair.

You needed more to start. The fact they gave you below market salary and crap equity is a huge red flag. Why help these people become rich if you can’t trust them to look out for you. If startups are all about learning and not earning [2], you need to really trust the founders. They should be helping your career in significant ways: prepping you for founding, introducing you to investors, helping you move quickly into more senior roles, bumping you up to market salary at the next funding event, giving you refresher grants, etc. Whatever helps you get where you want to go since you are taking a risk for them!

Depending upon your circumstances, I probably would just find another job. At least interview to get a BATNA for your negotiation. And look at total comp (salary, bonus, and stock) that you could get. Then compare to your current place and adjust for risk / reward as others have said. Ask to see the cap table. Look at likely exits with dilution and your percent ownership. Don’t fall for the snake oil of “10,000 shares and the founders (recruiter) said they could be worth a few hundred dollars each in a couple years!” Good luck.

[1] https://medium.com/the-wtf-economy/in-his-essay-on-income-in...

[2] http://www.bothsidesofthetable.com/2009/11/04/is-it-time-for...

poof131··on Custom resume from someone who wanted to work at Airbnb (2015)
While what you say can often be true, it is a sign of weak leadership. Strong leaders promote the best people and thereby lift themselves and the whole team. Bad leaders see strong subordinates as threats to their power and suffocate the team. Not saying there aren’t a LOT of bad leaders out there, but what you describe isn’t a law everywhere.

The bigger point I think is your first sentence. She’s way above average and couldn’t get a job for a year. “Woe is us, the shortage of qualified candidates“. Like I was telling one friend who was complaining about not being able to find someone good, “The reality is you can’t find someone good at the price you want to pay.” There’s a shortage of talent that wants to live in a one bedroom apartment with their family for scraps of equity while the boss lives in a mansion and makes millions, that’s the real shortage in SV.

poof131··on Zenefits Scandal Highlights Perils of Hypergrowth at Startups
The most telling quote for me was “The two men also differed over whether to address employee morale by re-pricing stock options to the new lower valuation, according to people familiar with the matter. Mr. Conrad favored the move, but Mr. Dalgaard believed it would train employees to expect a re-pricing any time the company’s fortunes changed.”

So the “we support founders” mantra may also mean we support founders and ourselves at the expense of employees. Despite all Conrad’s miss-steps, such as the ill-mannered Quora response, I now have a new respect for him. At least he was trying to fight for the employees. Sad to see a16z in this light. With fantasy valuations crashing to reality, repricing options should become the standard. Or you can follow the current SV playbook and hope employees don’t really understand what’s going on with equity.

poof131··on Multiple Black Vehicles with MD License Plates at Apple Executive Briefing Center
If the cars are armored, the difference between Tahoe and Escalade is probably minimal compared to the overall cost I'd imagine, but still would be a nice gesture to not bling out when working for the government no matter who you are.

Remember watching the news awhile back and seeing various directors leave the white house. Most in big, black luxury vehicles, except the CIA director who got into what seemed a very normal looking, grey, mid-sized SUV, Toyota maybe. Really shows who wants to be seen and who really cares about not being a target.

poof131··on Under-35s in the UK face becoming permanent renters, warns thinktank
Agree 100%.

It’s frowned upon to talk about this as a generational thing, but it very much is. Debt is the instrument to have now and pay later, and the debt burden is rampant everywhere. Modern economics has essentially disregarded the role of debt in the economy.[1] All our government institutions seem hell bent on maintaining asset prices at any cost.[2] There’s no sensible plan to even remotely reign in government debt. The world’s stuck at zero percent interest rates, handing out money to the politically connected, and growth is still anemic. Even at low rates people can hardly afford to buy anything since asset prices are so inflated.

I would like to believe we can deal with this in a reasonable fashion, but am skeptical. As can already be seen by the U.S. elections and elsewhere, populism is rearing it’s head on both the left and the right. It feels like a storm is on the horizon and I only hope it doesn’t devolve into war.

[1] http://blogs.lse.ac.uk/politicsandpolicy/ignoring-the-role-o...

[2] http://blogs.lse.ac.uk/politicsandpolicy/ignoring-the-role-o...

poof131··on Dear Startups: Here’s How to Stay Alive
I’m not sure I agree 100% with your thesis on the B2B side.

I’ve seen a few companies recently that seem to be getting strangled by the long tail. They have large numbers of low paying, price conscious customers draining resources. They can’t raise prices to a level that enterprises would be happy to pay since this would kill their established customers. Enterprises don’t want to pay a different higher price, why would they. The companies usually skimp on sales, especially field sales, so they have trouble competing in larger deals. And they can become arrogant that their niche solution, while better at one thing, can take on larger platforms that solve multiple problems.

Not saying your points are invalid, just that there seems to be a bit more at play and going from the long tail to the enterprise doesn’t seem trivial and shouldn’t be an after thought. In B2B it does seem like all the biggest winners have generally nailed the enterprise, but not necessarily the long tail.

poof131··on Building a Startup in 45 Minutes per Day While Deployed in Iraq
Stay in your lane isn’t helping the situation. Also, while fobbit is funny internally and helps maintain the operator focused hierarchy, calling these names on the outside is distasteful. We need to be supporting each other in our travails in the civilian world and not turning our service into a pissing contest. He didn’t make up his service or lie about the unit he was apart of. If he exaggerated anything, it was building a niche site more than a startup.

I applaud the OP for getting shit done while on deployment and having the courage to talk about it. And if he wants to get a little bit more attention by using the Iraq word, than by all means do it, because he was “deployed to Iraq.” The military beat into us not to self promote and not to bullshit. Both are somewhat a hindrance on the outside, especially in entrepreneurship. Good on the OP for trying to both build things and promote them.

poof131··on What I Wish I Had Known Before Pitching LinkedIn to VCs (2013)
While their growth tactics have pissed me off to no end (spammed my whole company once), I do see value in the product. I’ve found two jobs from LinkedIn and been contacted by recruiters at a number of companies I may want to work at. For me, the personal value seems greater than either FB or Twitter. Although personal connections tend to lead to the best jobs, for those starting out in a field this isn’t easy, and a more liquid market helps us all. I can’t imagine telling a recent grad not to put together a LinkedIn profile because there is no value. Certainly, this is more about the online resume hosting part than the network part, but I think the latter has some value too even if diluted. And the former is powerful because there are so many people in the network.
poof131··on Too many people have peed in the pool
The mass market isn’t so much “morons” as just the lowest common denominator. Everyone is “smart” about the niche areas that interest them. These niches seldom overlap. So the mass market is more about things that cross the boundaries: sports, weather, politics, jokes, etc. So what starts as a niche (not so much privileged or elite) either stays as a niche or appeals to a mass audience by finding the common denominators.

Personally, sports bore me and I find the hero worship disgusting, but I recognize that I lose the ability to relate with a lot of people because of this disinterest. I wish more people were interested in computer science, political-economics, and defense policy, but most aren’t. While at times I want to scream, “stop worrying about bread and circuses,” I understand peoples desire to find common ground with others. [1]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bread_and_circuses

poof131··on Silicon Valley startups rein in spending and prepare for layoffs
I feel like you are being harsh. Recruiting seems like a pretty essential part to a fast growing company. And to say they affect the “local intelligence culture”, well there’s a lot of locals in SF who say that about all of tech and there’s many a way to define intelligence.

As a developer, I appreciate the role recruiters play. Reaching out cold to people isn’t easy and the fact someone else spends time on this while I write code is great. And the fact that my LinkedIn has multiple leads from people about job opportunities should I want to move is fantastic. Are we so spoiled to scoff at people offering us jobs when so many people can barely find quality work.

Certainly there are some shady players, but not really more than I’ve seen on the Engineering side, and my main issues have been less with recruiters and more with the hiring managers who the recruiters work for. “Oh, your rocket ship hasn’t grown revenue for 6 months straight yet you told me 100% YOY growth.” It was two directors of engineering and not a recruiter that lied to me about growth at a well respected YC startup. I blame the people crafting the message more than the messenger.

← PreviousPage 6 of 10Next →