HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

portman

2,605 karma · joined December 5, 2009

Portman Wills Cofounder @ https://wagestream.com

firstname.lastname@gmail.com -- please feel free to drop a line.

submissionscomments
portman··on Ask HN: Do people make money from Facebook Apps?
Yes.

The easiest way to monetize is with banner ads from one of the 40+ authorized Facebook ad networks. http://developers.facebook.com/adproviders/ Believe it or not, people DO click on banner ads, and you should see about a $0.10 eCPM for US and UK traffic. (Traffic outside of those two regions often have less than a penny eCPMs.)

The second-easiest way to monetize is to create a virtual currency that has value to your users, and sell that currency via Facebook Credits. http://developers.facebook.com/credits/

I've personally built about a dozen Facebook apps, and have been involved in close to 100. A general rule of thumb is to expect to make $100/month for every 10,000 monthly active users (MAUs). A modest success on Facebook can garner about 100K MAUs which should net you in the low thousands of $USD per month.

If you want to support yourself full-time, you'll need to aim for 1,000,000 MAUs.

Hope this helps, and good luck.

portman··on Amazon’s Android App Store Launches: Test Drive Apps Directly From Your Browser
On my device (Motorola Droid), you need to first enable unsigned applications in the system menu. Amazon guides you through this process very well on their website, but still, I suspect that a lot of nontechnical folks will dropoff due to the complex one-time installation process.

Do any people with better droid-fu know if it always has to be this way? Will future version of the Android App Store be able to have a more seemless install process?

portman··on Why aren't more women airline pilots?
Anecdote: the first time I ever had a captain was about 10 years ago on a Thai Air flight. (Bangkok to Chiang Mai.)

Since then, I've had a female captain on precisely 3 other flights (Laos Air, Thai Air, and United Express). This is out of probably 600-700 flights.

(And to those who are wondering, "are you sure you didn't miss any", I suspect you've never had a female captain. It turns out it's almost impossible to NOT notice a female captain's voice on the PA, because it's so unusual.)

portman··on Patrick McKenzie (patio11) on Japan Aid: Help for the Well-Prepared
Yes, I realize that Japan is the third largest economy in the world. But living in a wealthy nation doesn't mean that your home is magically rebuilt. (Just ask the residents of New Orleans' Ninth Ward.)

Thousands of residents of Minami Sanriku are homeless. The fact that you, in Tokyo, still have your home, is great for you, but totally irrelevant to those suffering in Minami Sanriku.

I'm very confused by posts which seem to suggest that the Japanese government can completely restore everything that was lost.

Until someone who has actually had their home and loved ones washed away tells me "please stop giving", I am going to continue. To each his own.

portman··on Patrick McKenzie (patio11) on Japan Aid: Help for the Well-Prepared
I have great respect for Patrick, and usually agree with him, but in this case I think his conclusion is far off-mark.

Japanese citizens need our help, on a massive scale.

The government may not need any assistance, but the families and communities ravaged by the disaster have an unbounded need for aid.

I've lived in Uganda and Cambodia, two countries which get a disproportionate share of Western aid. Yet still, even with all those development dollars, a $50 gift can completely transform an individual's life. I've seen it happen.

If your house, your church, your community, and much of your extended family has been annihilated, and you're rebuilding your life from scratch, then you need our help, no matter how well-equipped your government is.

Please give, and give generously.

portman··on Talk on making an impact by Seth Godin at Business of Software last year
In past years, the talks have gone up slowly during the year after the conference.
portman··on Live from Apple's iPad 2 event
For me, the most interesting announcement was that $2 Billion had been paid out to App Store developers to date.

That means Apple's 30% of App Store purchases is currently $857MM and change.

I also find myself wondering what portion of that $2B went to Angry Birds. I wouldn't be surprised if Angry Birds turns out to be the first >$100MM business on the App Store.

portman··on Building a Better Groupon
The title on the post has been changed to "Building a Better Groupon", which is much less linkbaity and more in-line with the story.
portman··on Whoa... Groupon Generated $760M in Revenue in 2010
Also, a large percentage of that was secondary, meaning it went to existing shareholders. So the actual primary funding was much less.

Edit: Hypothetical numbers for illustration purposes only:

    A invests $100M in company.
    B purchases half of A's shares for $200M.
    C purchases half of B's shares for $300M.
    D purchases remaining A shares for $400M.
So although they have "raised" $1B, the only amount that has been invested in the company is $100M.
portman··on Dear Google, I Have More Than 10,000 Contacts
You should coin this as "Scott's Law". It's brilliant.
portman··on Ask HN: What's the future of tipping?
This is a very good question, and I don't have any answers.

But one anecdote that might be relevant...

My wife and I were on a date last month at Chima, a Brazilian Churrascaria. The waiter took our drink orders on an iPhone. Throughout the rest of the night, we could ask any of the wait staff for something, they would just punch it into their iPhone and someone else would bring it right out. The system worked flawlessly. (This was also our first date in 10+ months, so I was probably pre-wired to be happy/impressed with anything.)

At the end of the meal, I asked to play with the app. It was really well done, with large, intuitive buttons, and a simple interface: [1] enter the table number, [2] choose the item category, [3] choose the item.

Most surprising of all: it was actually his iPhone. The servers get the choice of using one of the house's iPod Touches, or their own iPhones.

Now, Chima is an upscale, national chain, so it could be years (or never) before this trickles down to your local neighborhood bar, but I thought this was an inspiring indicator of how mobile technology might be integrated into the service sector.

portman··on Ask HN: What's the future of tipping?
I've lived in the UK, Italy, Uganda, and Cambodia, in addition to the US.

All of them have tipping.

portman··on What happens after Yahoo acquires you
"If the founders leave then what are you left with?"

By this logic, the maximum life of any company is about 40 years.

Walmart and ExxonMobil are two examples of companies that became gargantuan long after their founders had left. In fact, of the Fortune 5000, I would bet the majority no longer employ their founders.

portman··on Ask HN: What state do I pay taxes for an LLC?
You won't get many responses on HN because accounting is a regulated profession and you can't just post advice on a public forum.

But here is what you need to Google: "IRS pass-through entity".

portman··on Anonymous has chosen a new target
No, if anything they have declared war on a very specific tactic: protesting at funerals.

There are well established limits on free speech, such as yelling "Fire!" in a crowded theater (Schenck v. US, 1919).

Pretend for a moment that we live in a world where the Schenck case never happened. A group (call them the "Eastboro Baptist Church") has started using the tactic of running into movie theaters and yelling "FIRE!". After all the commotion, they spread their anti-gay message.

This "fire" ruse is starting to get on some people's nerves, so an online group (call them "NAMED") says that they are going to protest the Eastboro Baptist Church.

That's not a "declaration of war on free speech", it's an argument that shouting fire in a crowded theater does not deserve protection under the First Amendment.

Also, for anyone who isn't aware, the Supreme Court has already heard oral arguments (Snyder v Phelps) about whether these funeral protests are protected speech, and will issue an opinion at end of term in a few months.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schenck_v._United_States

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snyder_v._Phelps

portman··on Anonymous has chosen a new target
You're right that there is no need to exaggerate.

The raft of state legislation in 2007/2008 setting up perimeters (300 - 500 feet, depending on the state) was in direct response to the stepped-up funeral protests of 2006 which were in extremely close, personal proximity to the mourners.

Now, they are 300-500 feet away, but only due to specific state laws.

portman··on Anonymous has chosen a new target
At funerals? Screaming at small children, six inches from their faces, that God killed their father on purpose?
portman··on Ask HN: who would you recommend for failed hard drive data recovery?
I recommend OnTrack. I first used them 15 years ago, so I can assert that they're not fishy. Their clean room is in Reston, Virginia.

I've paid anywhere from $700 - $1800 per incident, and always had close to 100% data recovery.

I'm sure there are other great services out there as well, but I've been loyal to OnTrack ever since they recovered 2GB of digitized home video in 1996.

http://www.ontrackdatarecovery.com/

portman··on Ask HN: Would you fire this developer?
Where are you from?

You're absolutely correct that hiring and firing, like all management, is highly dependent on culture.

In North America, the overwhelming majority of research has shown that organizations that "hire slow, fire fast" have more positive work environments, with happier employees and lower job insecurity. You could literally fill a small library with the books and papers that have been written on this topic.

I would love to know more about your culture and the "hollow experiences" you're referencing.

portman··on Last.fm co-founder: Apple just fucked over online music subs for the iPhone
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Class_action#Criticisms_of_clas...

Increasingly, class action lawsuits are being settled with "Coupon Settlements", whereby the attorneys get millions of dollars, and the plaintiffs get -- no joke -- coupons.

http://www.rkmc.com/Coupon-Settlements-Under-Siege.htm

portman··on Last.fm co-founder: Apple just fucked over online music subs for the iPhone
Correct.

Also, small claims court is not based on tort law, it's quasi-contract [1]. So the judge (not a jury) uses the principle of equity. Even if Apple did send someone (unlikely), it's still a question of what is fair, not a question of what is contractually obligated.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quasi-contract

portman··on Last.fm co-founder: Apple just fucked over online music subs for the iPhone
Personally, I wouldn't ever join a class-action lawsuit. But small claims court sounds perfect...

If Amazon ends up removing the Kindle app over these new policies, I would sue Apple (via my local Apple Store to establish jurisdiction) in small claims court for $139.

The case would be relatively straightforward: I purchased an iPad because it could do everything a Kindle could do as well as more; Apple then caused functionality to be removed, so I would like Apple to buy me a Kindle to replace the functionality.

I've been to small claims court 3 times in my life, and each time won a default judgment because the other side didn't show up. Then, I faxed my judgment to my credit card company, and they promptly credited me (and presumably issued a chargeback to the merchant). This was in Fairfax County, Virginia.

I suspect that Apple will quietly reverse themselves, just like they did on the "apps can only be written in C, C++, and Objective C" last year. But if they don't, your local small claims court provides a wonderful opportunity to make your dissatisfaction known. And it only takes about 4 hours.

portman··on Is Your Job an Endangered Species?
If you liked this article and enjoy Andy Kessler's writing, you'll probably be happy to know that he wrote a novel called "Grumby":

http://www.amazon.com/dp/098271632X

It's about a hacker who reprograms a Furby, finds that he's created the New New Thing, and then hangs on for dear life as his startup rises and falls.

It's "creative destruction", as told through a work of fiction.

portman··on Ask HN: Would you fire this developer?
Yes, yes, a thousand times yes.

"Hire slowly, fire quickly" is an oft-repeated maxim for a good reason.

As for the most humane way to fire someone in a startup, I have a few thoughts (borne from several misfires earlier in life):

1. Sit down with your employee and give them a formal warning. "You're not performing up to our expectations, and if things don't improve within 14 days, we're going to have to replace you." Give them a list of specific items to work on.

2. On the day of the firing, always have two people from your company present in the room. This mitigates a surprising number of "he-said/he-said" type disputes, and also (surprisingly) leads to a less contentious conversation. If it's just the two of you, the odds of someone saying something they'll regret increase substantially.

3. Be generous with severance. I've never regretted giving an employee 4 full weeks of severance, no matter how junior.

4. Be direct. Resist the urge to treat it like a high-school breakup (i.e. "It's not you, it's me.") I have always been advised by HR professionals to never mention "cultural fit", as it's a gateway to wrongful termination suits. However, I have been ignoring this advice for about a decade. I believe an honest firing trumps a legally "safe" firing.

5. Most importantly: don't plan on doing anything else for the rest of the day. Take your team out and order drinks. If your other team members want to go home after lunch, by all means let them. In a small team, terminations can be very emotional for everyone, and nobody feels good about working right after their coworker got canned.

portman··on Jeopardy Champion Ken Jennings Q&A about IBM Watson
Ken Jennings is FUNNY.

    IBM: "There's a lot of you in Watson"
    Ken: "If it goes amuck and kills humanity and stuff so sorry lolz my bad!"

    Chat participant: "I read your first in practically a day, I loved it."
    Ken: "I'd like to thank my mom for taking part in the chat!"
portman··on Apple is actually asking for 100% of SaaS mobile revenue
You mean these terms? http://www.apple.com/legal/itunes/us/terms.html

Here is "content" being used to mean "everything that's in an app":

"The Application Provider of each Third-Party Product is solely responsible for that Third-Party Product, the content therein, any warranties to the extent that such warranties have not been disclaimed, and any claims that you or any other party may have relating to that Third-Party Product."

And here is the section on subscriptions, in which content is, in my opinion, not well defined:

"Certain App Store Products may include functionality that enables you to purchase content on a subscription basis (“Paid Subscriptions”)."

I just scanned all 72 mentions of the word 'content' and couldn't find the definition you're alluding to.

portman··on Apple is actually asking for 100% of SaaS mobile revenue
What would a "content-free" app look like? Aren't all apps, by definition, based on content?

I'm not meaning to be cute or trite -- I'm genuinely confused from the press release which category of apps will fall under these new rules. Which is why we'll need to wait for the legalese in the iOS developer terms to understand what this _really_ means.

portman··on Apple is actually asking for 100% of SaaS mobile revenue
"All we require is that, if a publisher is making a subscription offer outside of the app, the same (or better) offer be made inside the app" -- http://www.apple.com/pr/library/2011/02/15appstore.html

By this rule, all apps that offer subscriptions must additionally implement Apple's subscription mechanism.

This is what the OP (and everyone else) is reacting to.

portman··on [dead]
And by the way, the ownership table that is linked to isn't even CORRECT. Not even remotely.

Sinofsky isn't listed, and just 2 weeks ago he reported 737,000 shares, which would make him #4 on that list. [1]

Ray Ozzie has just under 1 million shares, and again he's not listed. [2]

The way you assemble these kinds of tables is by mining the SEC filing Form 4, "Statement of Changes in Beneficial Ownership of Securities". But you have to include every Form 4 for your data to be at all accurate.

So already we can see that Elop is #9, and that's just by me guessing two people who seemed conspicuously absent. There could be dozens of others. And don't forget that non-executives don't have to report their shares. I would bet a few grands that there are senior developers who have been working at Microsoft for 15 or 20 years who own more than $3M in stock.

In fact, I just cast my first ever "flag" vote on HN. (With gusto, I might add.) This doesn't deserve the #1 slot.

[1] http://google.brand.edgar-online.com/displayfilinginfo.aspx?...

[2] http://biz.yahoo.com/t/12/7827.html

portman··on Search Optimization and Its Dirty Little Secrets
Blatantly off-topic, but...

Matt, you are everywhere. I'm amazed that you have time to actually do work, let alone sleep, considering how prolific you are on blogs and forums.

It gives me the Warm Fuzzies™ to know that an actual human being is indefatigably fighting search spam 24/7. On behalf of teh interweb, thank you.

← PreviousPage 5 of 14Next →