HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

portofcall

524 karma · joined March 13, 2018

submissionscomments
portofcall··on [dead]
Betteridge’s law strikes again! No, you shouldn’t trust Facebook for anything.
portofcall··on Theranos and Zenefits are a feature, not a bug, of Silicon Valley
The difference in Silicon Valley is that the shipments go out and there’s nobody checking. It’s a big fucking difference too.
portofcall··on Theranos and Zenefits are a feature, not a bug, of Silicon Valley
This is what you get with no oversight, tons of money, s lot of arrogance, and a focus on “hustle” over anything else. It definitely works for a while, but when it comes crashing down it’s going to take out a lot of innocent players with it.
portofcall··on Theranos and Zenefits are a feature, not a bug, of Silicon Valley
More like shades of black.
portofcall··on Disgraceful Dashcam Video Proves Uber Is the Theranos of Self-Driving
all of the following points are perfectly clear:

Uber is guilty of killing Elaine Herzberg. Uber's hardware and/or software failed. Many people at Uber need to be fired. The Arizona officials who greenlit testing need to resign. One or more people need to be prosecuted. The SAE Automation Classification System is vague and unsafe. Uber is the Theranos of self-driving. Volvo—one of the few car makers that truly cares about safety—is innocent and shouldn't be in bed with their craven opposites.

Thst sounds about right, especially the culpability, need for firings and resignations, and especially prosecutions. I really don’t see any of it happening, but it should.

portofcall··on IRS reminds taxpayers to report virtual currency transactions
It’s just experience in dealing with people online. I apply the same filter to “cuck,” “Overton window” and “Hegelian dialectic” for example. Offline it’s much easier to ascertain intentions and attitudes, and there aren’t millions of people all screaming at once. Online you have to filter, and alt-right buzzwords are excellent components of a healthy filter.
portofcall··on Mark Zuckerberg apologizes in full-page newspaper ads
Please don't feign surprise that facebook has been collecting your data. Everyone knew, but expected some level of privacy and security with the platform. That's what was breached here.

I’ve never had an account with them, but they buy records, they get to me through friends, family, and acquaintances. I expect some level of privacy when I don’t even use their sinking platform. I also expect that regulation is coming for FB, Uber, and the rest of Silicon Valley, and it’s about damned time. It’s too bad that it’s going to hurt people and companies that do nothing objectionable, but I prefer that to Facebook swaying elections and Uber killing people with their substandard SDV’s.

portofcall··on Mark Zuckerberg apologizes in full-page newspaper ads
3. Don’t apologize if it’s obvious that you’re being incredibly insincere, unless you’re a great actor. People can smell that kind of non-apology a mile off, and they’ll hate you for it, and distrust any apology that comes later.

4. Don’t make a big show of being apologetic if it’s likely that there’s another shoe waiting to drop; that looks less like an apology and more like a coverup.

5. Don’t make obviously misleading, false, or self-serving statements in an apology.

portofcall··on Everybody’s Lying About the Link Between Gun Ownership and Homicide
The single greatest risk factor for someone committing suicide is a first-order relative who committed suicide. Everything in life isn’t as obvious as crashing a car into someone, but the harm of suicide extends far beyond the victim.
portofcall··on Everybody’s Lying About the Link Between Gun Ownership and Homicide
One: They’re sneaking suicide in with the data, and then obfuscating that inclusion with rhetoric.

Alternative hypothesis: they’re including suicide data because it’s relevent. Suicide is homicide (not murder), and they’re including the copious accidental killings (also homicide, also not necessarily murders).

portofcall··on How Calls for Privacy May Upend Business for Facebook and Google
This is definitely the right attitude, and I’d add the critical step of talking about these issues with people who don’t know about them. It’s frustrating, it can be alienating and it definitely takes time, but it can pay off. Nothing beats building a useful tool (like Signal), but even useful tools require publicity.
portofcall··on The stability implications of the US nukes' burst-height compensating super-fuze
People are not evenly distributed on the surface of the earth, most of which is ocean. Nukes do. It target randomly, they target population centers and strategically valuable regions. Most people live where nukes are aimed, which is why they are aimed there.

15,000 warheads concentrated where humans live, on the fraction of the 27% of Earth that isn’t water. Be reasonable.

portofcall··on Silicon Valley's Regulatory Exceptionalism Comes to an End
Unless you’re offering a similarly objectionable issue with current ethical standards, you’re playing word games instead of a real argument.

Which is obnoxious.

portofcall··on Review of Steven Pinker’s Enlightenment Now
Of course there’s going back, and the history of progress is rebuilding, growth, advancement, entrenchment, stagnation and collapse. In the past that involved people with swords and spears or muskets, today it involves CBRN weapons.

We can go back, we’d just damned well better not, because the only way back is disaster.

portofcall··on Silicon Valley's Regulatory Exceptionalism Comes to an End
Not at all, but that’s definitely a cheap and easy shortcut to giving ourselves license to sink to the lowest common denominator. Don’t sell everyone short based on the actions and attitudes of the loudest.
portofcall··on Silicon Valley's Regulatory Exceptionalism Comes to an End
The Bar in every state, the AMA, the APA, and many other bodies enforce ethical standards.
portofcall··on In field tests, device harvests water from desert air
I agree, if we had the viable and affordable tech to do this, it would be low environmental impact. When you consider the impact of large scale ocean desalination, it would be a clear green choice.
portofcall··on The FBI Says It Can't Find Hackers to Hire Because They All Smoke Pot (2014)
Hacker culture in the mainstream workforce doesn’t exist, it’s SV and VC culture. Free food and casual dress doesn’t change that. The word hacker is thrown around a lot, as in the title of this site, but like this site it’s just a name.
portofcall··on In field tests, device harvests water from desert air
At 3000 feet it’s about .9 atmospheres of pressure, but honestly humidity is incredibly variable. The lower pressure at 3k feet just places an upper bound on possible humidity, it doesn’t tell you what it is. My instinct is that you’re right, and we’re still talking about vast volumes of moist air. We could also “enrich” the air with solar powered evaporation of seawater and wastewater.
portofcall··on Best bad idea ever? Why Putin’s nuclear-powered missile is possible… and awful
Technically feasible, practically worthless. This is a weapon that in no way alters the balance of geopolitical power, it isn’t an effective first strike, and it would be an insane vehicle for a conventional payload. This is posturing, dick swinging, whatever you want to call it, and possibly cronyism depending on who did the R&D.

Unless Russia has airtight missile defense or a means to track down every nuclear sub in the oceans, nothing has changed. The one thing this might do is further terrify their regional enemies, most of which were already terrified.

portofcall··on In field tests, device harvests water from desert air
It much simpler to make MOFs than other nanomaterials like carbon nanotubes and graphene.

Well yes, but nanomaterials are tough to make, and mass produced graphene is a nightmare. None of that changes the energy requirements to make the stuff, or the hazardous byproducts of production. If it’s not energetically and financially efficient, then it doesn’t compete with desalination, and is useless.

portofcall··on The stability implications of the US nukes' burst-height compensating super-fuze
I feel like this conversation is taking place in a strange parallel universe in which people don’t appreciate what 15,000+ nuclear warheads being exchanged would do. The fires started from them alone would be an extinction event, and the kinds of incredibly remote areas in which you might find long-term survivors would not be laden with caches of electronics and populations capable of using them.

Getting enough food and water that wasn’t dreadfully contaminated alone would be the preoccupation of generations. By the time anyone had ideas about rising from barbarism, what we think of as civilization now would be rusted, eroded, and overgrown.

All of that assumes the most optimistic of assumptions regarding global wildfires, teratogenic effects, and nuclear winter. We wouldn’t be using magnetic tapes, we’d be using rocks and sticks and animal hides.

portofcall··on In field tests, device harvests water from desert air
MOF’s are not mass produced, and while a method has been proposed to scale up production, as far as I know it’s never been tested. It’s also a solvent-heavy process, and often uses a lot of benzene.

MIT the university is an amazing thing, but MIT the press release machine is pathetic.

portofcall··on Man guilty of hate crime for filming pug's 'Nazi salutes'
They exist in two arenas, both (theoretically) subject to strict judicial oversight. The first as you reference is public safety, which includes inciting to violence, and other classic examples. The second is a bit murkier: national security.

That said, something like a super injunction for a celebrity’s sex life would be flat-out impossible and unconstitutional.

portofcall··on The stability implications of the US nukes' burst-height compensating super-fuze
It might seem counterintuitive for the reason you described, but the problem with water and ground bursts, is that the entirety of the radioactive byproducts interact with large amounts of dense material. I’m a true airbursrs, the fireball doesn’t touch the ground, so the air itself is contaminated, along with material from the ground which is drawn up into the fireball through convention and blast effects. That’s still dirty, and in the case of the Tsar Bomba (50MT) catastrophically dirty. The total volume of affected material though is relatively low.

If you detonate underwater, all of fission byproducts, and unburned fuel comes into direct and prolonged contact with a large volume of dense material. In a shallow blast, gigstons of thst material are ejected into the atmosphere, while the rest remains underwater. It will be diluted, it a 100MT device is still going to produce horrendous and long-lasting effects.

That material will poison the underwater environment as it settles in the immediate area, and for km away as it dissipates. Worse, it will enter the food chain and be concentrated through progressive predation.

This covers the explosive (not radiological) effects of non-airbursts for some context! http://www.abomb1.org/nukeffct/enw77b2.html

portofcall··on Police Say Uber Is Likely Not at Fault for Self-Driving Car Fatality in Arizona
Just an update, the Uber car did fail that badly, and it was a shocking failure.
portofcall··on The stability implications of the US nukes' burst-height compensating super-fuze
Coal in the quantities needed to rebuild a shattered civilization are not easily accessed unless you’re thinking of existing mines (which without maintenance would be inaccessible before we were done desperately trying to stay alive as a species). Hydropower and wind power both require advanced industry to work at any useful scale beyond the individual, and there would be no industry. Mind you, I’m ignoring the loss of knowledge, and just how people would remember to do these things, and I’m assuming a “best case” nuclear apocalypse.

I’d prefer that our fate as a species not rely on begging the question of industry and technology.

portofcall··on Man guilty of hate crime for filming pug's 'Nazi salutes'
In the USA thank god we still have the right to offend, but clearly this is something which has been lost to the UK and appears to becoming weaponized to surpress political activism as well (see recent stories of Tommy Robinson at Speakers Corner).

You can’t lose what you never had, and the UK doesn’t have the 1st amendment. They don’t have freedom of speech and expression (at least not In such absolute terms) and never have.

For example, super-injunctions and (I shit you not) hyper-injunctions.

portofcall··on The stability implications of the US nukes' burst-height compensating super-fuze
The truth is that we don’t know what the long term impacts of a total exchange would be. Theories range from extreme nuclear winter events, to just the fall of civilization. I sure won’t pretend to know where on that scale the reality is, and hope never to find out.

Here is some food for thought though, about the potential for our civilization to fall; it will not rise again. We’ve accessed far too much petrochemical wealth and burned it, and the same is true of coal, and metal resources. We get around that by using our existing industry and technology to go deeper, refine more, and in general access resources which require advanced technology to exploit.

There is nothing left which can be accessed by primatives, and so no way to claw back from such a reduced state. It will be many millions of years before those resources are reconstituted, far more years than the history of our species so far by orders of magnitude. This is our chance, and if we burn it away in nuclear fire, we are done. It probably won’t happen overnight, but the fall of our civilization is the fall of humanity. Let’s try to avoid that.

The same goes for any cause of systematic civilization-wide collapse, we would be done. The reason we clawed back in the past is that we has only scratched the surface before, but we’ve fully plundered global resources now. It’s onward and upward, or lights out.

portofcall··on The stability implications of the US nukes' burst-height compensating super-fuze
Think more in terms of killing a whole carrier battle group in one shot, or closing a major port (for a long time) due to blast damage and radiation. Larger bombs are diriter bombs, and detonating in water is pretty much the dirtiest use of a dirty bomb.

In short, this is a strategic terror weapon, an area denial weapon, and a radiological weapon.

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →