HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

powrtoch

1,968 karma · joined February 9, 2010

submissionscomments
powrtoch··on Stealing content was never easier than with HTML5
Agreed: if you can watch it, you can save it. Also, as a point of interest:

Last I checked, Netflix (Silverlight based streaming) serves up its videos in a series of tiny chunks (you can look at this with e.g. Safari's Activity window). I don't know if this is done with security in mind or just for practical/bandwidth reasons, but it seems like it would at least add a little hassle to the task of saving the video.

powrtoch··on Should employers be blind to private beliefs? (Richard Dawkins)
I simply don't understand how Dawkins can give a real life example of a person very successfully keeping his beliefs totally separate from his related work and still say that we should care what that person believes. If being an "honest astronomer" doesn't make you a better astronomer, then why concern ourselves with it, at all?

What I find alarming is that nothing in this argument really conflicts with Dawkins. He accepts that these beliefs can make no measurable difference, and maintains that they're important anyway. He seems to think that it doesn't matter if an astronomer can advance our understanding of astronomy by leaps and bounds, if the astronomer doesn't update his own beliefs too, and that society should therefore refuse to let itself benefit from what he can offer. Why? Who wins in this scenario?

FWIW, I do agree that religious beliefs should not be considered distinct from "non religious" beliefs (with obvious exceptions for e.g. clergymen).

powrtoch··on Why 3D doesn't work and never will.
To be fair, they of course were right. There are unique aesthetic values in silent film, and adding dialogue does do away with them (otherwise they wouldn't be unique values). They simply discovered that people consider it a worthwhile tradeoff.
powrtoch··on Why 3D doesn't work and never will.
Many of the cues you're referring to are already present in 3d and 2d movies. They're things like focus, texture, "what's covering what", how quickly something moves relative to the viewer, etc.
powrtoch··on Does email address obfuscation actually work?
The top rated answer has a couple of interesting techniques to get around this problem.

Also, not everyone has a Gmail account. I'm sure virtually everyone on HN does, but some of us also wind up making websites for people who are less savvy. So techniques for obfuscation could still be useful.

powrtoch··on Google search and search engine spam
Awesome, I look forward to that.
powrtoch··on Google search and search engine spam
Am I the only one who was really hoping for some specifics about what they're doing and plan to do about content farm rankings? Without that, the article is virtually devoid of content other than "we're really not so bad!"

Edit: By specifics, I don't necessarily mean implementation details, just anything more informative and plan-of-action than acknowledging the problem.

powrtoch··on Eric Schmidt: On April 4th I Will Step Down, Larry Page to be CEO
Agreed. It seems like it may just be a PR move... Larry doesn't have Eric's growing reputation for slight creepiness. People might like the idea (whether it's true or not) that he's the one making all the calls.
powrtoch··on Facebook is a Ponzi Scheme
Sounds pretty similar to the network "Up next" ads that run along the bottom everytime a show cuts back from commercial or is about to end.

The difference would be that you are "already watching TV", in the same sense that Google had you "already searching for something", but this same logic applies so long as the ad being placed is for something on Facebook, which many of them are.

powrtoch··on Mathematical answer to Infinite of monkeys/infinite time/Hamlet question.
As a side note, if you run the experiment with infinite monkeys, you get Hamlet almost instantly (that is, the shortest amount of time in which it possible to write Hamlet).
powrtoch··on Mac App Store: Open for Business
Disappointed to see Twitter among the most popular apps. For mobile devices the native-app-front-end-for-existing-websites was arguably necessary and beneficial, but for desktop clients it really feels like a big step back to start moving back out of the browser.
powrtoch··on Sega Brings Awkward Fun to the Restroom
Not to take away from the brilliance of this, but is it actually a good idea to encourage people to pee as hard as possible each time they use the restroom?
powrtoch··on 42 days of HN karma
I don't know that it's anything to worry about. When you throw a bunch of analytical people into a rating system, it's only natural that they'll be searching out its weak points. A lot of us have probably noticed various weaknesses in the karma system, but I don't think it's because we're all scrambling to game that system. HN is just full of the types of people who can't help but notice.
powrtoch··on Comic Sans Criminal
Here's what I would like to say about this issue of a font being for a purpose:

Yes, most of the examples presented on this site are heinous and tremendously bad typeface choices. But that has nothing to do with the fact that comic sans was designed to mirror comic book lettering. The designer's intent is not embedded in the typeface, only his actual results.

Papyrus falls into the same category. People get bent out of shape about it: "It was meant to look like Egyptian lettering, but now it's on my Greek menu! It makes no sense!"

Guess what? It doesn't matter what it was "intended" to convey, it matters what is actually conveyed when people read it. Frutiger was designed for airport signage, but it happens to look great outside of airports too. Granted, it was never meant to be a niche font, but the principle applies: you shouldn't get upset on account of people using something in ways you didn't foresee or intend.

All this to say, if you're going to argue that a font is ugly or doesn't belong somewhere, that's fine, but your argument shouldn't be based on what the font was intended for. Sometimes the things we make turn out to be way more useful than we thought.

And I'll stick my neck out here and even say that I think Papyrus often looks good on menus :)

powrtoch··on Who Can Name the Bigger Number?
While I was able to follow the Aaronson article with no particular trouble, I can't seem to grok this. I'd be very grateful to anyone who could give a slightly lower level explanation.
powrtoch··on Let's Dial Down our Enthusiasm over the Billionare Giving Pledge
I've not familiar with his writings prior to this, but you seem really, really certain that he unfairly despises the rich and is unthinkingly attached to this position without regard for the evidence or the greater good in general. Personally, I didn't get that impression from this article at all, so I'm curious what makes you so certain of his state of mind. I didn't feel that the thrust of the article was to attack the rich in any way, just to point out that their good intentions might not manifest themselves as powerfully as we expect.

Regarding [1], the author explicitly mentions the Gates' as an exception to the rule. And regarding [2], I don't think a single piece of recent anecdotal evidence invalidates his organization's actual study.

Personally, I read the article as a reminder that the Giving Pledge's success is no reason to rest on our laurels, and not as an indictment of its contributors. Is it so wrong to do something good and still want to do better?

powrtoch··on Woman With No Fear Intrigues Scientists
Pain, yes. Fear, debatable.

Fear plays a role in helping people to assess danger, and in making decisions related to your survival and well being. Neither of these things require a fear response though. The article mentions that the woman might have found herself in dangerous situations more often due to her inability to fear, but at best this means that fear might be a useful addition to our ability to assess danger.

It seems to me that the vast majority of situations that are dangerous are either a) obviously so, or b) the opposite. In obviously dangerous situations, you should be able to pick up on the danger by common sense and act accordingly (I don't feel fear every time I cross the street, but I also don't step out in front of cars). In situations where the danger element is very hidden away, it's unlikely you'd get a fear response anyway, since your intuition is only as good as its input.

That leaves a third category, that for which the danger is non-obvious, but fear gives us an evolved intuitive-response to be wary. My argument would be that this is a small and constantly shrinking class of situations, because the environment most of us find ourselves in is so strikingly different than the one in which we evolved. You might have an evolved, intuitive fear response to the sound of a lion's roar, but this does no good whatsoever for most people in the world. So most of the dangerous situations we actually encounter, we deal with using reason and learned behavior rather than fear instinct.

That's my stance anyway. The only area in which I can see a concrete use for fear is its ability to stimulate a very quick flight reaction in certain dangerous situations. That is, things that you need to react to before you have time to think them through. Again, less common in the modern western world, but it does put at least one point in the pro-fear column.

powrtoch··on The Top 50 Gawker Media Passwords
The list is basically identical to every "most common passwords" leak that's come out since the beginning of the web. Even "monkey", which the author seems to think is quirk of the Gawker community, is known to frequently be a top 20 password.
powrtoch··on Using CSS With No HTML At All
Thanks for the info. Perhaps I just got better about writing clean markup around the same time I started using XHTML, and confused the two. I suppose now's as good a time as any for me to embrace HTML5.
powrtoch··on Using CSS With No HTML At All
"But it's almost 2011, who’s still using XHTML anyway?"

This caught me totally off guard. My experience has been that XHTML is much easier to manage across browsers than HTML 4. Can anyone chime in as to whether I'm crazy?

powrtoch··on Morality is modified in the lab
"You think of morality as being a really high-level behaviour. To be able to apply a magnetic field to a specific brain region and change people's moral judgments is really astonishing."

Where do people think that high level behavior comes from, if not the lower levels?

"You think of WoW as being a high-level program, but I replaced your CPU with the one from my phone and look, it doesn't work."

powrtoch··on Five Principles for Choosing and Using Typefaces
CSS letter-spacing is under-utilized on the web. Obviously I'm not suggesting it be used for body text, but elsewhere it's a very easy way to make your design stand out online and give the feeling that a print-design level of attention to detail was put in.
powrtoch··on Five Principles for Choosing and Using Typefaces
Great article. Lots of good, concrete points, which is unusual for the subject matter.

This seems like an article for new designers, so I'll go ahead and chime in that I think the single most crucial thing you can do when choosing a typeface or making any other design decision is to be able to look beyond what you intended and see into what is actually conveyed. Once you've learned this skill, you'll no longer make dumb mistakes like trying to grab the audience's attention with the 30pt bright red candy cane font. Because doing that usually doesn't communicate "This is worthy of your attention". It communicates "The designer is desperate for your attention", and that's a surefire way to be ignored. So the chief rule is to put yourself into the audience's shoes, and make sure your design decisions don't topple under an (automatic, subconcious) examination of your motives.

powrtoch··on Stallman on Hacking
Well... it's possible to notice it's silly and unoriginal even if you do like it, and saying it's poor seems like another way of saying that one doesn't like it.

If her goal is to get famous and have hit songs though, I suppose we do have to grant that she accomplishes this expertly. It might be nice if she had loftier goals, like creating something with actual integrity, but I have to admit she's at least effective.

powrtoch··on Why intelligent communities will always fail
The point of the article is to argue that all sites like this (HN, Reddit) will devolve into 4chan. The fact that it has a large user base does not make up for the fact that it's full of banal memes, porn, racism, and idiocy.
powrtoch··on Kinect finally fulfills its Minority Report destiny
It's interesting how 3D, holographic interfaces have been in so many sci-fi movies etc., yet they all seem to get referred to as the "Minority Report" interface.

Relevant: http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/HolographicTermin...

powrtoch··on Nexus S
Requires extra hardware, and I have to imagine that the vast majority of people would prefer to listen to their 16 GB of mp3s. I think you're just in the minority on demand for this feature.
powrtoch··on Nexus S
I see what you did there.
powrtoch··on Photons cooled down to room temperature, made into a blob of matter
"The physics behind the Bose-Einstein condensation is the transition from a particle-like behavior at high temperatures to a wave-like behavior at cold temperatures"

I'm no physicist, but isn't this backwards?

powrtoch··on The Insanity Virus
Sounds like the bad kind of group selectionism hypothesis to me. Death bestows no fitness benefit to the individual, and is therefore not evolutionarily selected for. Organisms don't die because evolution says they should, they die because evolution doesn't care.
← PreviousPage 5 of 13Next →