582 karma · joined September 21, 2011
Alice shows Carol and Bob a red ball and a blue ball, and two empty boxes. Without showing Carol and Bob which ball goes in which box, Alice puts a ball in each box and gives one box to Bob and the other to Carol. Carol is an astronaut going to Mars, and they've agreed to open their boxes when she gets there.
Fast forward 6 months later, Carol is on Mars, and she opens her box and sees a red ball. Immediately, without any speed-of-light delay from Earth, Carol knows what Bob will see in his box when he opens it. Note how there's no "useful" information transferred faster than the speed of light - Carol and Bob can't use this to make any useful decisions.
The quantum version is weirder because the balls are in a superposition of red and blue until one of the two opens the box - but there's still no useful information transferred faster than light.
See also: http://www.examiner.com/article/gmo-food-hybrid-poison-grass....
The reason for this is the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle, which states that there are certain attributes of a particle where we can't know both of them perfectly. The classic example of this is position and energy.
The relevant attributes here, though, are angular momentum (spin) in the "left/right" and "up/down" directions. Think of a particle as two arrows, one pointed either left or right, and the other pointed either up or down. The Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle states that if I know with 100% accuracy that a particle is pointed left (or right), I can't know anything about if it's pointed up or down, and vice versa. In fact, if I measure the left/rightness of a particle, the up/downness gets set randomly to be either of them.
So quantum communication works more or less like this: We agree that left and up correspond to a 1, and right and down correspond to a zero. So if I want to send a 1, I randomly choose a either a left or an up, and send it to you. Then, on your end, you randomly choose an axis to measure on, and after I've measured, we tell each other (through a public channel) which axis we measured on. If we agree, we use the bit, otherwise, we throw it away.
Ok, so now, what if Eve comes in the middle and steals our electron, reads it, and sends it again. Well, she doesn't know what axis to measure on! So if I send it on the up/down axis, Eve measures it on the right/left axis, and you measure it on the up/down axis, you have a 50% chance of getting a wrong answer. So if we take a few bits at random and publish them, we can get a pretty good idea if someone's snooping.
Also, Eve can't copy our particle, because if she could, she could read one axis from one particle and the second from the other, which would violate the Uncertainty Principle (this result is known as the No-Cloning theorem).
1) She was heavily involved in politics while a student and researcher.
2) Even more importantly, she came into politics right after the fall of the Berlin Wall - right after they threw away all the old career politicians. At this point, she abandoned her scientific career to fill this enormous vacuum.
Thatcher got a bachelor's degree in Chemistry, but within three years of graduating college she was in politics and another three years later she had a law degree, I don't think I'd call her a "scientist leader".
I'll admit my ignorance about the Chinese Communist party. But that whole system is very different, especially because the leaders don't need to get elected, so it's a much more technocratic system in general. In the US, there's a difference between people who come up with new policies and the politicians who get them implemented, I suspect this is less true in China.
I'm not going to say that politics is a game of lies, because it's not, but politicians essentially invent the truth as they go along. It's similar in some ways to law or the humanities, where the truth is very much a matter of interpretation, there's a case to be made for each side, and no one is ever objectively "wrong". Right and wrong are entirely a matter of personal opinion.
On the other hand, science is, in the limit, entirely objective. A physical theory can be objectively shown to be incorrect. Scientists can defend their theories, but fundamentally have to accept it if their theory is disproved, or else they become irrelevant. There was a great link earlier today on HN that talked about how the smartest people are the ones who are most skeptical of their own ideas. That's great in science, but if you don't believe yourself totally in politics, no one else will.
This means that scientists, who presumably study under and work with other scientists for decades, think in this scientific mindset. This makes them totally unsuited for the world of politics (and of course, vice versa). Politicians can't admit they were wrong, because that means that they'll probably be wrong again, and no one will vote for someone who's wrong. Case in point: Mitt Romney and universal healthcare.
I'll also make another point that a lot of people miss: Being a politician is roughly as difficult as being a scientist. If we expect our best politicians to get an advanced degree in something like business or law (things related to the process of running a nation) or to spend a long time working in politics or on social issues, why do we think that scientists with no such training will make good politicians? We certainly don't expect most law school grads to do much more than wash bottles in the lab.
Now, the good: 1. The one-box is really, really good. A lot of the time, I'm searching for domain-specific queries, especially when I'm coding. DDG brings up a one-box with something like a stack-overflow link and often has exactly the code snippet I'm looking for. 2. I don't have to give more information to google. Admittedly, they already get my email and stuff, but at least this way I'm spreading my information so no one has absolutely all of it.
Finally, the things that are in principle useful but I don't use much: 1. Bang commands. Seriously, I'm not going to type !cplusplus to search cplusplus.com, I'll just click the first link. I also can't remember all of them. I do use !g, !image, and !video, but mainly because they take me to a better search engine. 2. The search suggestions in the top right. It's a good idea, but I don't have the cognitive capacity to keep track of those in addition to the search results.
This is in large part because of the lack of strong typing and type annotations; if you aren't the only author or can't keep the codebase in your head, it takes real effort to figure out what a function does. Even the type annotations provided in a language like Java or C++ make this task much easier, not to mention languages with real strong type systems like Haskell.
That's not to say that building large systems in Python is impossible, but it takes a lot more effort and documentation that it would in other languages.