HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

presidente20

42 karma · joined February 10, 2015

submissionscomments
presidente20··on The great British Brexit robbery
You don't actually need a trade deal with a country to trade successfully with them (hopefully I don't need to give examples of this).

I think you overestimate how long it takes to sign a unilateral trade deal when the parties want to make it happen. The reason the EU trade deals take so long is that 28 countries have to agree on the EU side (which will indeed be a problem for Brexit, but hardly the UK's fault).

Non strategy? As previously stated, we have a net trade deficit with the EU and are the EU's biggest export destination. Do you really think BMW group etc are going to want to stop selling cars to the UK?

Also as previously pointed out any import/export detriment to the UK from increased tariffs will be offset by the corresponding tariff reduction when trading with the rest of the world. That's not the case for the EU.

That's without considering the money we'll save on contributing to the EU budgets.

presidente20··on The great British Brexit robbery
The Remain camp did a bad job of arguing the case because there really aren't that many good arguments for staying in. I think you'll find it was the Brexiteers that made the 'subtle points' about trade, constitution etc.

Leave did have the advantage of some emotional pulls like sovereignty, but Remain had the advantage of all three main parties on its side (including a sitting government) and the very powerful emotional pull of 'fear of change'.

presidente20··on The great British Brexit robbery
If you want an elected House of Lords, why would you be in favour of the EU? In the EU the elected house is a ratifying chamber only (akin to the Lords). You're glad to be ruled by the undemocratic executive EU but not the undemocratic ratifying Lords?
presidente20··on The great British Brexit robbery
I think we do.

We're a net contributor so the rebate point is null.

Re. the euro, is there any point in being one of only 9 countries outside the euro (bear in mind most of those 9 are new members who intend to join). What kind of say do you think the non-euro countries are going to get?

presidente20··on The great British Brexit robbery
Care to point out the last war between two first world democratic countries?
presidente20··on The great British Brexit robbery
Can you clarify what this poor trade negotiation position is?

Worst case, we go to WTO tariffs. The effect of that in theory is that EU imports to the UK will reduce, as they become more expensive relative to the same goods from non-EU countries (note that our tariffs to non-EU countries will reduce post Brexit).

UK exports to the EU will also reduce for the same reason. However, given that we're a net importer it should be clear who is in the worst position.

If the UK can sign a couple of decent trade deals with large economies like India, USA, China then we won't be worried about the EU trade at all.

presidente20··on UK triggers the official Brexit process in a letter to EU
Agreed and thanks for the link.
presidente20··on UK triggers the official Brexit process in a letter to EU
I just don't think many people in the UK in general (not just Parliament and the media) like the EU. I spoke to a lot of people who voiced anti-EU sentiment but voted Remain out of fear of the consequences. I remember there being just as much if not more dislike in the early 90's after Black Wednesday.

I'm not sure what you mean by a tiny minority. IIRC the UK Parliament voted against Maastricht twice and it went through on the third attempt. I think UKIP has exploited and perhaps stoked the skepticism, but IMO did not create it.

presidente20··on UK triggers the official Brexit process in a letter to EU
I really can't see what you've got this idea about Empire and self-importance from. Seriously, it's not something anyone in the UK thinks about. Given recent history, I wonder if you are projecting your own Imperial ambitions onto the UK?

13% of UK GDP is from European trade (fact). So whilst the UK would quite like a trade deal it is hardly reliant on it. Any loss from tariffs on European trade may well be exceeded from the resulting drop in tariffs with non EU nations. Biggest difference post Brexit will be less BMWs and more Kias.

I think the thing you're missing is that the UK has a long history of democracy and slow improvements to it. Large parts of Europe do not have such a libertarian consciousness.

presidente20··on UK triggers the official Brexit process in a letter to EU
I think that is untrue. This thread is the first time I've heard anyone mention Empire in connection with Brexit.

There is xenophobia but I think if you look closely you'll find that in most European countries as well. No doubt that instinct will now be directed at the British.

This is clearly about political systems.

presidente20··on UK triggers the official Brexit process in a letter to EU
Clearly Europe has been highly intermingled throughout its history and shares some common roots but that is not what we're talking about here.

We're not talking about alliances (which happen all the time without political union) or trade areas (which the EU originally was) we're talking about supra-national centralised bureaucracy.

Change is inevitable and it's healthy to have multiple self governed states doing things differently from each other and co-operating from time to time.

presidente20··on UK triggers the official Brexit process in a letter to EU
I think it's unlikely that members skeptical of the institution itself would have much influence.

I think the Leavers were dissatisfied from the beginning. You can directly trace the formation of UKIP from the Maastricht Rebels. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maastricht_Rebels in the Major government.

UKIP was formed out of protest at what they saw as the EU going off in a highly political direction (i.e. becoming a lot more than just an economic area).

They may be wrong but the objections are based on fundamentals.

presidente20··on UK triggers the official Brexit process in a letter to EU
Fair point but do you think it would make any difference?
presidente20··on UK triggers the official Brexit process in a letter to EU
Can you substantiate that?
presidente20··on UK triggers the official Brexit process in a letter to EU
Yes but mainly the executive parts. No doubt the UK government could be more democratic but however imperfect it is why would you want to layer something on top of it that is even less democratic?
presidente20··on UK triggers the official Brexit process in a letter to EU
I'm saying that the EU is not sufficiently democratic because its executive bodies are not elected by the people whereas in national parliaments they are.

I'm not saying that national governments should give up sovereignty. I'm saying that what powers the EU already has should be more directly democratic.

presidente20··on UK triggers the official Brexit process in a letter to EU
That's a lot compared to Juncker.
presidente20··on UK triggers the official Brexit process in a letter to EU
Leaving aside mid term leadership changes as a different can of worms, I think it's pretty clear that the UK public elected the Tories and David Cameron (and it was fairly obvious who his Cabinet would be even if they are not individually elected) on a fairly specific manifesto and with each MP being individually elected (limitations with FPTP notwithstanding).

No such equivalent exists in the EU no matter how hard you try and twist the facts.

presidente20··on UK triggers the official Brexit process in a letter to EU
If you look at your description all the methods of selection bar one are nothing like methods for publicly elected officials and as such massively subject to cronyism. This is worth a read: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Commission#Appointmen...

The one that isn't is the European Parliament which as we've already established is pretty toothless.

On a slight tangent you'll also notice that none of these bodies are s/elected with any commonality of purpose. Hence why IMO the EU struggles to agree on any difficult issues. Just wait and see how much indecision and infighting will occur over Brexit negotiations.

Why on earth would we give up a successfully evolved system of government for this?

presidente20··on UK triggers the official Brexit process in a letter to EU
Ok you're right, I meant aside from the Leader of the Lords.

Nevertheless, having one or two Lords in the Cabinet out of 22 hardly invalidates my original point that it's an elected (by the people) executive.

presidente20··on UK triggers the official Brexit process in a letter to EU
Ok amendments as well as veto, but I think you see the point.

It is rare that a member of the Lords is in the Cabinet and it seems reasonable that the Leader of the Lords is from the Lords doesn't it?

Again the main point I'm trying to make is that the EU falls short of typical democratic standards which is a reasonably direct connection between the ruled and the rulers. Anything in between is highly subject to cronyism IMO.

presidente20··on UK triggers the official Brexit process in a letter to EU
On the first point I mean that the policy creators (in this case the Commission) can make any policy of their choosing. The veto-ers (i.e. the European Parliament) can only block the legislation. As the former control what gets debated, they frame the debate and the latter can only react.

On the second point; you may in a narrow technical sense be correct. Taking the Uk as an example, the UK Cabinet is literally appointed by the PM. However the wider point is that the executive power of the PM and the ruling party is granted by winning an election based on a manifesto etc. The PM and cabinet members are also individually elected to their seats.

In contrast, the Commission is more akin to the Civil Service.

On your final point, that's a far cry from being elected by a voting public. Also I presume there are restrictions on who can stand for Commission President?

presidente20··on UK triggers the official Brexit process in a letter to EU
Well as I say, they keep their heads down. However as you asked here's a couple off the top of my head:

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2016/09/04/britain-can-l... https://www.theguardian.com/business/2016/dec/26/mervyn-king...

presidente20··on UK triggers the official Brexit process in a letter to EU
That is exactly what I see too.
presidente20··on UK triggers the official Brexit process in a letter to EU
It depends on the timescales of the predicted problems. I believe the studies predicted choppy waters whilst the UK divorces from the EU (short to medium term) which in my view is likely. However that's not the same as saying that leaving the EU is in principle bad for the economy.

Secondly there are plenty of economists that think Brexit will work out fine but that is a somewhat unfashionable view so they keep their heads down. Such is the nature of groupthink.

What is it exactly that you think will cause the UK's economic demise?

presidente20··on UK triggers the official Brexit process in a letter to EU
The point is that powers of veto are less influential than powers of creating policy.

I don't think people are saying that the EU is completely undemocratic (as pointed out above, democracy is a somewhat muddy concept in practice), more that it falls short of the standards of a typical democracy (which to me means a directly elected executive body).

presidente20··on UK triggers the official Brexit process in a letter to EU
No. People see the EU as undemocratic because Parliament is neither the main policy-making body nor the main executive power. It is more of a supervisory body, akin to the role of Congress or the House of Lords. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Parliament#Control_of...
presidente20··on UK triggers the official Brexit process in a letter to EU
I think it's a little more complicated than people not being bothered to vote. The European Parliament has relatively little power (e.g. to propose new laws) compared to a typical national parliament. I think people see that and also see that Euroskeptic MEPs are largely ignored. In the last UK European elections, UKIP won the most seats. That didn't get reflected in any shift in policy did it?
presidente20··on Ask HN: What did you do after quitting the IT industry and how have things been?
I've been following the Money Moustache type approach for a while now myself. I highly recommend it, but the closer I get to the goal the more I realise I need something else constructive to do if/when I jack it all in.
← PreviousPage 2 of 2