HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

profitbaron

1,484 karma · joined December 22, 2010

HN Username: itsprofitbaron

https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=itsprofitbaron

submissionscomments
profitbaron··on Ask HN: Review my startup, sponzu.com
Clickable link: http://www.sponzu.com

Feedback:

The main problem of this idea is that I don't see how an advertiser would see a benefit from being involved in this because, people aren't really going to engage in the adverts they are going there to "support" an idea and letting the advertisement run rather than be engaged in it.

You need to show a benefit to the advertiser, as to why show an advertisement with yourselves as this would aid the advertiser problem and allow them to see a value in advertising on your website.

Additionally, you also need to look at how to keep users engaged when they come to the website because, when you first go to the website you are presented with the "How It Works" and if you want to get people engaged and involved in "supporting ideas" then you need to change this graphic as it is too small and isn't really engaging.

You need a 3 step "How It Works" from a user pespective AND not from an idea submitting pespective as well, save this step for the "Submit your idea" page.

Additionally, there are a few call to action buttons on this website soon as I arrive "Register" "Fb Login" "Submit Your Idea" (which is repeated twice) etc which don't benefit you at all because, there are so many of them. You should focus on one call-to-action button and acquire the user sign ups when submitting the idea in a slick user interface instead of trying to get them to click "Register" etc because, if they aren't submitting an idea there doesn't seem much value (if any) to join the service.

Additionally, when I went to click submit an idea I was immediately presented with "Login" or "Register" that really sucks from a user perspective, you should have a page with a form where people can fill out their information and at the bottom have a "create account" setting where a user registers a username, password and email etc (additional information can be acquired when they have signed up) as this will significantly improve the UI from a user perspective.

Also, why does it just have to be for "ideas" I mean you could contact charities to get them involved and they can get users to view the ads as a "donation" to their charities. Continuing with this idea, you should have a "widget" so people can place their ideas on another website etc, then they can go and view the ad such as on a Charities Website for instance.

profitbaron··on Please rate my startup (again)
I tried to look at your site to give you feedback but saw "Alright HN! Thanks for the input! I get it now. I should conform to a typical landing page and not try to be different. :)"

However, I was able to see it using Google's Cache and the site design is terrible, if I was a user I would instantly close the screen seconds after loading the page - it may be the best thing since sliced bread - but there is so much information to take in that you can't instantly tell what you do AND you don't know which bit to take in first.

After fixing the design, you also need to cut down the length of the video down since especially the part where it says

"Check this out to see what RELA can do in less than 9 minutes."

You need 9 minutes to tell me what your product actually does? REALLY?! This would definitely drive a user away, if you want to have a video which shows what you do then make sure that it is only about 30-60 seconds long and if you still love the "9 minute video" then allow users to see that after they've signed up.

Additionally, I can see that you say this landing page is based on the whole framework of the site, and if that is the case as you haven't provided us with a login to test//the site is now down I can't go further into the site and check out if the framework design is suitable for the rest of the site because, it may require you also altering other aspects of the website to make a more fluid design which has a better UI so users can use it better.

Afterall, user number is nothing these days, its all about the active user numbers!

profitbaron··on Ask HN: How much should we charge for a bespoke version of our site?
As they have 30k users, they are obviously prepared to spend a decent amount of money on using your product therefore, I highly recommend that you follow the route of Google Apps, Yammer, Salesforce's Chatter (Chatter Plus) etc and charge on a per user basis as well as, charging an inital setup fee.
profitbaron··on Ask HN: Can Apple survive Steve Jobs leaving?
I think so yes and the main reason for this is for the team Steve Jobs has built to replace him.

First of all there is Tim Cook, who as you will recall when Steve Jobs took a leave of absense in 2009, Tim Cook was calling the shots and he handled the storm caused by this extremely well.

Furthermore, the main difference between Apple and many of its competitors aren't just its "awesome designs" but rather its supply chain and inventory something, which Tim Cook is in charge of and handles very well - especially as you can see by his salary bonus which was $60million.

Additionally, most smart companies plan years ahead for their development roadmaps - Apple is an extremely smart company and will already have a development roadmap outlined for a few years in advance meaning that, they're already secure for the short-term well, they probably have a working iPhone 8 and an iPad 5 right now.

However, intead of just focusing on Tim Cook there is also Jonathan Ive who can take over the role as "visionary" having worked in the design aspects of Apples Products AND there is Scott Forstall who can focus on the "software" aspect of the business.

Again this shows, that Steve Jobs has built a great team to take over the day-to-day running of Apple with Tim Cook in charge and Scott Forstall and Jonathan Ive supporting in the design/new products and software departments that Apple will have continued success even without Steve Jobs operating as CEO.

profitbaron··on TechCrunch Tours Dropbox Offices
It still amuses me how the view is always mentioned before entering the startups office space. Although I have to say that Dropbox's 'Crib' is my favourite TC Crib so far.
profitbaron··on Ask HN: What's your favorite bookmarked HN thread?
Thanks! This is a really great list
← PreviousPage 5 of 5