HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

propagandist

85 karma · joined August 28, 2020

Rate-limited flame warrior

Practice vigilance.

Be on the lookout for enemy propaganda. Stick to reliable news sources sanctioned by the Ministry of Truth. Report and downvote suspicious content.

submissionscomments
propagandist··on Killing invasive species is now a competitive sport
It sounds like a great way to earn the company of fellow psychopaths.

The ecological need is easy to understand, but turning it into a "sport" tells you a lot about the caliber of people we're living with. The people engaging in this activity are worse than poachers; at least poachers kill to earn a living.

propagandist··on What happened to the lab-leak hypothesis?
That was deliberate disinformation in order to save masks for the "frontline workers". Fauci has stated that in one of the hearings.
propagandist··on Six companies control 90% of what you read, watch, and hear
Some people don't need the FB algos to get all wound up :)
propagandist··on Six companies control 90% of what you read, watch, and hear
Sure, but they are also the arbiter of truth now.

FB tried to be purely a platform but society has asked them to "annotate" fake news or propaganda. So FB is now playing an editorial role.

However we got here, it's not a great place to be in. We have massive networks that we cannot escape which are actively firewalling information.

propagandist··on Six companies control 90% of what you read, watch, and hear
- People are spending all (slight hyperbole) their time on those platforms,

- The news is informed by the content on the platforms

The platforms control the information and they control what people see as the "news".

propagandist··on Former Xinjiang prisoner arrives in U.S. as key witness to abuses
Solid observation.

Please proceed to disregard my propaganda and consume information strictly from state-sanctioned entities.

propagandist··on Former Xinjiang prisoner arrives in U.S. as key witness to abuses
May I ask who paid for your comment? Why do you automatically assume that there's an organized campaign when the viewpoint disagrees with your own?

[Removed. Thank you commented below for the reminder to keep my background out of it]

I have watched the democracy, WMD, and human rights theatrics deployed before. There are always people saying "let's be a little skeptical" and they are always called treasonous and unpatriotic. Yet we find and time again that there is wisdom in heeding their warnings.

So please keep in mind that some of us are under the proverbial boot and so we have a good reason to remember how this play goes.

propagandist··on Former Xinjiang prisoner arrives in U.S. as key witness to abuses
If a had a penny every time ...

There needs to be a better response to pointing out hypocrisy. If you care about China's abuses but not ours and our allies, you do not have the moral high ground, and morality is a political tool to you.

propagandist··on Former Xinjiang prisoner arrives in U.S. as key witness to abuses
It's a little more interesting than that. The US has indicated it would invade if its servicemembers were prosecuted.

The act is colloquially referred to as The Hague Invasion Act.

propagandist··on Internet Backbone Giant Lumen Shuns .RU
It's the logical end to the social media arc.
propagandist··on Namecheap: Russia Service Termination
I'm happy to hear that and glad we're on the same page.

It is whataboutism, and I do it because I come from a place where people have been subjugated for decades, and if you protest that, you're called an antisemite. (Yes there is actual antisemitism too--I'm talking about legitimate protest of actions).

Calling out people who suddenly have a moral compass is something I'm obligated to do. It might help next time that moral compass is needed.

propagandist··on Namecheap: Russia Service Termination
I understand namecheap's decision because they have coworkers in Ukraine.

However, unless you apply that same logic to the US, UK, and a host of other nations, you are being hypocritical. They have murdered so many civilians, including kids, that surely they deserve the same punishment.

Yet we both know we're not about to see that, and I think we know why.

propagandist··on Namecheap: Russia Service Termination
Beautiful. FTR I'm totally against the war and completely understand where namecheap is coming from. But this is proper racist.
propagandist··on Namecheap: Russia Service Termination
The email and CEO's explanations say otherwise.
propagandist··on Namecheap: Russia Service Termination
That does need indeed put it into perspective.

This was a decision made by someone who has heard horror stories and seen their cheery teammates turned into shells of themselves.

propagandist··on Russian Ruble just lost ~30% of its value
No sympathy with people who have no control and don't support this war? The last pill had support at 8%.

You can't speak your mind in Russia. The population is not guilty.

propagandist··on KGB defector Yuri Bezmenov's warning to America (1984)
It's a great watch for that reason and for laying out just how much of our political systems are pure theatre. Fantastic production to boot.
propagandist··on KGB defector Yuri Bezmenov's warning to America (1984)
Simulation and Simulacra is probably where hypernormalisation got its inspiration.
propagandist··on Understanding the War in Ukraine
It's not really an easy situation. There were many complications even with states like Greece, Turkey, and (North) Macedonia. I cannot imagine what Poland and the other formerly occupied states would do if Russia were invited.

At the end of the day, NATO was created to counter the USSR. When the USSR collapsed, we had an opening to integrate Russia, and we squandered it. That was the real opportunity.

propagandist··on Understanding the War in Ukraine
I did not claim that was the case. It was a hypothetical to point out that sovereignty is wielded in an argument when it's convenient.

We don't care about sovereignty when we're violating it.

propagandist··on Understanding the War in Ukraine
And the same frequencies that were dominant in 2003 are now shutting out the other voices. The Bill Kristols and David Frums are going to awaken from their hibernation.

It's pointless to argue really--there's 0 hope that we'll do anything differently.

To be clear, there are limited options now wrt to Ukraine. Nobody wants to go to war with Russia. But being hardline and not pragmatic means we'll set ourselves up for similar issues in the next few years and decades.

We strung Ukraine along knowing we wouldn't come to their six when it counted. Honesty has to be the preferable approach.

propagandist··on Understanding the War in Ukraine
Great to know. Thank you for sanitizing this discussion and shutting out trolls and apologists (like myself).

I'm sure that if Cuba or Venezuela entered a pact with Moscow that placed ICBMs on their territory, we would respect their sovereignty the same way.

There are a few things I'd like to respond to below but the rate-limit hammer has dropped.

What I will ask is that we refrain from calling the brave people who stood against the grain apologists or naive. They warned of the dangers decades ago.

We owe them better than that; they were prescient.

propagandist··on Understanding the War in Ukraine
[Before downvoting, please consider whether you prefer debate or an echo chamber]

Let us please not be so passive aggressive and dismissive. Serious diplomats have been warning about this for decades.

Just because what's happening is evil and revisionist does not mean we should sweep all of that under the rug and buy into the mainstream a la the 2003 WMD hysteria.

Pointing at one person and yelling "he's a bad man" has not been helpful and yet we can't help but do the same thing every single time.

propagandist··on Twitter based map of Russian troop movements
People are wary of government messaging because of things like the Gulf of Tonkin and the WMD debacle.

Unfortunately in this case, it was credible and the strategy of declassifying did seem to work but clearly Putin has made up his mind.

One more thing: this is definitely not the place for "I told you so".

propagandist··on Russian forces invade Ukraine after Putin orders attack
Re: containing Russia.

https://www.nytimes.com/2022/02/21/opinion/putin-ukraine-nat...

It's actually exactly the opposite and the guy who wrote the book on containment called it a tragedy. We don't need to rewrite history.

propagandist··on China Built a Vast New Infrastructure to Imprison Uighurs
I agree wholeheartedly. Let’s discuss this along with lifting collective sanctions imposed on Cuba, Iran, Syria, and Venezuela. That is a form of collective punishments that starves civilians. I’m very cynical about the outrage re: those “re-education” sites. Not because they’re benign but because nobody bats an eye when America commits similarly heinous acts. It seems like a convenient deflection tactic.
propagandist··on China Built a Vast New Infrastructure to Imprison Uighurs
1. America declared the war on false grounds, like most wars since WW2

2. It makes 0 difference morally whether you’re targeting domestic or foreign civilians

3. America starves civilian populations outside formal states of war. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=RM0uvgHKZe8. This is the visible tip of the iceberg

← PreviousPage 4 of 4