HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

protonfish

1,958 karma · joined October 25, 2012

submissionscomments
protonfish··on A singular mind: Roger Penrose on his Nobel Prize
It's so unfortunate because he is such a brilliant mathematician and physicist. To hear him spew this pseudo-scientific nonsense makes me embarrassed for him.
protonfish··on A singular mind: Roger Penrose on his Nobel Prize
I find this argument unconvincing and harmful. The "will be exploited by few against the many" could be applied to any and all technologies. Our social systems have problems, and should be improved, but this has nothing to do with science and technology. I can't see how suppressing innovation and scientific discovery as a misguided solution won't make all of our lives even worse.

If we have a breakthrough that leads to a deep understanding of intelligence, it could be expected to also give us insight into our own behavior. And isn't that where most of our problems originate?

protonfish··on Glucose metabolism responds to perceived sugar intake more than actual intake
Yet another reason artificial sweeteners are not health food.
protonfish··on Git is too hard
I think that's unfair because I don't see that git even has a UI - it's designed to be a command-line API. The thousands of terrible GUIs out there are so bad that using the command line directly is still the best UI. (I think GitHub has done a great job managing remote repos - I am only talking about local tools.)
protonfish··on What Is Math?
Then they wouldn't be Platonists, would they? Wait, do people here even understand what Platonism means? Rejection of evidence is a key tenet of that philosophy. This is why the other school of thought is called Empiricists - because they believe in empirical evidence. It's frustrating getting all these downvotes by people that don't understand their own words, but I suppose it's not surprising coming from Platonists. Folks who, when faced with a contradiction between reality and their cherished beliefs, conclude reality must be wrong.
protonfish··on What Is Math?
A problem with "logic" is that there is no one, true system. There are many possible logics and at a certain level of complexity they are more or less equivalent (a Turing machine, for example) It's a just a system of symbols that we refine to represent our world. After we spend enough work inventing a powerful symbolic system we can get confused, turn it upside-down, and start thinking that it has some inherent meaning. That's silly.
protonfish··on What Is Math?
And writers explain nature using words.
protonfish··on What Is Math?
Unfortunately Platonists don't believe in evidence so this won't convince them that their religious beliefs are wrong.
protonfish··on American Academy of Sleep Medicine calls for elimination of daylight saving time
2 things I can think of right off the bat are that changing schedules can be done per-person, per-industry, etc. and doesn't have to be forced upon everyone whether it's good for them or not. Another reason is the technical difficulties of readjusting all time keep devices, scheduled software, etc. is a nightmare that should be avoided if you can. It's hard not to see that adjusting individual schedules is the easier and more effective implementation.
protonfish··on Interview with a Pornhub web developer (2019)
It possible that they are using the best current tech and what is fashionable right now is actually garbage that would never work for a high volume, easily maintainable site.
protonfish··on Rite Aid deployed facial recognition systems in hundreds of U.S. stores
At first I wasn't going to reply because you are clearly not discussing in good faith (you neglected to address my evidence to the contrary or the flaw in your reasoning but instead focused on my random afterthought.) But others might read this so I decided to elaborate a bit.

I was once misinformed with the belief that business' primary goal is to make money. But when you have the experience of explaining data to a CEO that clearly shows that their customer surveillance has a negative ROI and that the conclusions they are drawing from the data are not warranted. (For example, if you want to claim that your initiative increased sales, you need to compare an equivalent data point before and after the initiative, not just afterward.) If you say this and then look into the cold, dead eyes of a sociopath you'll know how foolish you were to ever assume the point of tracking customer data is to make money.

I felt dumb ever believing that business leaders care directly about money. I knew that to be false in high school when they made me read 1984. The lesson that O'Brien teaches Winston is one that we clearly have not learned.

> The object of persecution is persecution. The object of torture is torture. The object of power is power.

We can add to that list "The object of unrelenting invasive surveillance is unrelenting invasive surveillance."

protonfish··on Rite Aid deployed facial recognition systems in hundreds of U.S. stores
Having worked on customer-tracking systems for several companies and seen executive strategy first hand and compiled reports to assess the effectiveness of these types of programs I have witnessed clear evidence that what you are saying is NOT true. Yes, there could theoretically be value to this type of data but trying to explain this to VPs is pearls before swine.

"They wouldn't do it if it didn't work" should be added to lists of logical fallacies. People do dumb stuff and make mistakes all the time, but groups of people are collectively about as clever as a slime mold.

To assume unquestioningly the intelligence of our rulers during the Trump era is just, wow. I don't know what world you live in, but in mine, the worst people on the planet are the ones at the wheel.

protonfish··on Cold Showers: For when people get too hyped up about things
Please don't use weak/strong to denote type systems. Those terms are highly subjective and even non-technical people would quickly form an opinion about which is better. (Strong is good, weak is bad.) Static/dynamic is more accurate and less opinionated terminology.
protonfish··on We Reviewed Police Tactics Seen in Nearly 400 Protest Videos
This is the ACLU position https://www.aclu.org/issues/privacy-technology/surveillance-... It doesn't sound like they are against them at all.
protonfish··on Why Is Facebook So Afraid of Checking Facts?
That does not sound like a good solution to the problem of powerful bad actors using social media to spread conflict and misinformation. In fact, it is not a solution at all. I don't understand this attitude of defeatism. Clearly how things are is bad. We should explore solutions. Is that too radical for you? Asking private companies to discern between nonsense of good facts is something that is commonly done with all publications - newspapers, magazines, TV, radio. This is nothing new. Healthy moderation has always been a key part of civil discourse - and FB's moderation is utter garbage. The solution? Demand they moderate less bad.
protonfish··on Why Is Facebook So Afraid of Checking Facts?
According to your own beliefs, your statement above can't be true. But one thing about it is certain: It is not objective interesting to me in the slightest.
protonfish··on Why Is Facebook So Afraid of Checking Facts?
That is ridiculous. Nobody is asking FB to takes sides on the Reade vs Biden issue. We are asking them to remove QAnon level insanity.
protonfish··on Why Is Facebook So Afraid of Checking Facts?
Agreed there is no guaranteed way to only allow truth. However, there are many easy ways to remove utter nonsense. Maybe we should start with that and see how it goes.
protonfish··on Why Is Facebook So Afraid of Checking Facts?
I agree that I don't trust anyone to tell me what is true, but there is a base level of fact-checking that is beneficial: Remove anything that is completely fabricated and makes claims without a single shred of evidence. There is absolutely no need for this type of "news." No organization can definitely curate the truth, but almost any can sweep out the garbage.
protonfish··on As YouTube traffic soars, YouTubers say pay is plummeting
This is already how it works for a lot of channels except the funding comes through Patreon. This is strong evidence that viewer sponsorship works yet YouTube is just missing out on their cut.
protonfish··on Inkscape 1.0 Release Candidate
I recently had a major struggle with it's inability to export to CMYK. I eventually found a way to get my graphics into CMYK by exporting to PDF plus an assortment or ad-hoc scripts for conversion. That seems like a real deal-breaker for most professional print applications. I still love Inkscape though.
protonfish··on Why I Like Math [pdf]
Exactly my point - that viewing magic in math is more akin to religion than science.
protonfish··on Why I Like Math [pdf]
But that's what they they were designed for. The first "numbers" were arguably clay tokens meant to represent goods in storage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_ancient_numeral_sys... Numbers were and are primarily used for accounting purposes. If they didn't accurately represent the change in your pocket then the system would be improved until it did. There's nothing magical about it.
protonfish··on Why I Like Math [pdf]
That's not how I see it. Mathematics is not science, even though science has found practical uses for certain types of math. Pure math does not require observation of the real world for proof, only consistency with itself. As a system of symbols independent of the messy real world I see it closer to mysticism than hard science. I am not saying this as a bad thing, only something we need to be honest about.
protonfish··on Follow-up to “The dystopian world of software engineering interviews”
It seems to me that it should be straightforward to objectively measure hiring practices by correlating different interview questions and techniques with subsequent job performance (compared to a control.) Has this been done? If so, I'd love to see the studies, if not, then it would be hard to argue that current techniques aren't voodoo.
protonfish··on The Disneyfication of a University
Except we can't ship them into space.
protonfish··on Mini projects built with VanillaJS. No frameworks or libraries
Right now I am working with a React app that is even more striking - how little it does with so much code. Though I am starting to see the trick. Keep making wrappers that only reference other wrappers.
protonfish··on Building all of our new mobile apps using React Native
It makes sense that a company with a business model based on mining and selling personal data would not find mobile web to be acceptable - too many privacy and security protections that can be eschewed on native. For the same reasons, consumers should choose HTML.
protonfish··on Why numbering should start at zero (1982)
The first time I read this, I was ready to be convinced and left disappointed. His entire argument is based on avoiding "the pernicious three dots."

What's so pernicious about them? They are short, clear, unambiguous, easy to type. Why don't we just get our computer languages to understand what "2, 3, ..., 12" means? Is there any other argument to start counting at 0 other than not defining a range using the three dots? If not, maybe starting at 1 (like everyone does outside of computing) is the better option.

protonfish··on An Existential Crisis in Neuroscience
That's a question I asked myself about 10 years ago, so I made one. Is it perfect? Probably not, but I have strived to make it as rational and rigorous as I could. http://behaviorallogic.com/foundations/
← PreviousPage 2 of 24Next →