HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

psychoslave

2,321 karma · joined April 2, 2019

submissionscomments
psychoslave··on Margaret Hamilton has died
Oh so that's were Hamiltonian graph are coming from?
psychoslave··on “Math 2.0” will need to value mathematical progress more holistically
On some consideration, surely. On the other hand, but at some point this is borderline like saying "universe already solved every physical problems, including possibility to represent deep important point of its own structure in compressed intelligent ways" and then tell that reaching it in an actual grabbable artifact is left as an exercise.

Possibly yes such a representation is possible. But it doesn’t mean it’s certain there is a "best compressed representation". And even less one that encompass everything important and that is understandable by any human brain, even the most exceptionally brilliant ones sponsored by a whole society to reach their best possible achievable performance on that goal through full dedication on that sole task.

psychoslave··on “Math 2.0” will need to value mathematical progress more holistically
Etic is a factor of productivity, and the larger the contextual window is the weightier it becomes. That’s even integrated within the paperclip parabola.

If the focus in placed on maximizing some easily measurable output on a narrow perspective, situation is unlikely going to match a sweet spot of holistic equilibrium which is maximizing harmony and happiness through humanity as a whole.

psychoslave··on AI firm HUMXN offers free plumbing and HVAC service in Minnesota to train robots
https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/gg-dl/AAQ_wbGsz_mqtCLKLF9g...
psychoslave··on AI firm HUMXN offers free plumbing and HVAC service in Minnesota to train robots
That’s hilarious really, genAI at it’s finest neglecting use case!
psychoslave··on What's Earth's dominant species by mass?
Did you try active volcanoes and under water places?
psychoslave··on Integer multiplication below n log n
Ok. I liked how in this thread some people mentioned instead "faster than causality" instead. Which is both obviously non sense and more relevant than "light".

Causality is conceptually out of time, so it's not traveling. Instead we except causality to operate everywhere anytime uniformly, and all physical dimensions to be bound by causality.

psychoslave··on Sharing AI progress in mathematics
Communication is not only about being able to make sense of what the utterer expressed. As tricky as it can be, that's still the easy surface level part of the issue. Gaining an intuitive and empathic equivalent representation is the nub of mutual understanding. It actually doesn't even need elaborate language to be operative.

The famous "how does it feel to be a bat" also comes to mind as a tangent consideration.

Two people can just exchange a sight, and both understand what the situation means and what each need to do to reach a common mutually beneficial ground.

Two people might exchange at length with highly technical vocabulary and still both feel deeply not understood.

psychoslave··on Integer multiplication below n log n
What's FTL?
psychoslave··on The technology to eradicate mosquito-borne disease exists
It's not like aedes has been so widespread all around before the last decades of wild exchanges worldwide.
psychoslave··on An AI agent emailed researchers for help. It told us why
Who would care if it is conscious of not?
psychoslave··on An AI agent emailed researchers for help. It told us why
Spam can't be categorized as someone either
psychoslave··on Why the Bronze Age Collapsed
Wasn't it like the biggest factor was they benefited from biohazard weapons they didn't know they were carrying?
psychoslave··on Responsible Release of AI-Generated Mathematics
Air is not impossible to disrupt in quality as side effect of industrial hubris.
psychoslave··on 37,500 border drawings: a map of the world as people remember it
Very few countries without lines within the actual boundaries. China and Brazil almost have some internal clean core. Russia also, but with considerably reduced core, somehow like Spain, and maybe France.

For some "narrow stripped" lands, that’s not that surprising, that lines also overlap so much in the middle, but for some countries with very distant straight lined boundaries, it’s far more astonishing. Some really looks like "drow some random strokes" was the sole instruction.

psychoslave··on Why is the liver so weirdly regenerative?
Same as Necronomicon, surely.
psychoslave··on Why is the liver so weirdly regenerative?
Interesting. It seems to have a blind spot of "what evolution want", though it does exposes that point "because evolution’s goal isn’t to make you happy, it’s to maximize reproductive fitness."

And so, from the very same premise, evolution don’t necessarily need individuals that are long standing, even less in environment which are themselves very unstable. As long as species continues to exists, evolution made its job. In more stable environments, long life span is causing less pressure on chance for the species to remain viable. A large motile animal in ocean don’t have to face that much significant changes in environment compared to their out-of-water counterparts. Of course the environment alone don’t explain everything in term of most efficient strategy, size matter, mobility mode matters, how much of such an environment exist and how large the population can grows before facing a demographic cap, just to cite the first that comes to mind.

I’m not a biologist, at all, and even a random layman as myself can comes with these obvious ideas.

That said, I also have all kind of blind spots, no doubt about it, and I didn’t even write a very nice to read issue on the topic unlike the author of TFA.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_longest-living_organis...

psychoslave··on Claude discovers a novel enzyme system with CRISPR-like repeats
Actually, I would like that for every single manufactured object around me. Not a physical book of course. But knowing who contributed and how to the construction of the fork I am about to eat with is definitely something I wish we had.

If I'm using objects whose construction involved child exploitation and benefit pedocriminal CEO and stakeholders, I should be aware of it.

If I'm using objects which where produced by a great place to work cooperative filled with happy consentent and well remunerated adults, I should know it.

I would also like to be given lesson or humility against the complexity of building every single manufactured object around me, and a manual of "how to build one by your own means".

psychoslave··on Montreal adopts bylaw banning insults against police, municipal employees
Laws and rights can’t be based on logic and reason alone, starting by the fact that reason alone can’t justify the rationality of its own basis.

And in fact they are never based on logic and reason alone. Everyone has reasons and anything can be framed under some logical system. Admittedly, having a sound logical system is harder and having something like that might seem preferable for the average HN reader. Now, let’s face it, there is not a single juridical corpus that ever met such a high standard of soundness. Really, everyone is free to seek a legal system that can be proved sound on ZFC grounds, good lucks.

That’s just not how it works.

psychoslave··on Montreal adopts bylaw banning insults against police, municipal employees
That’s sad that there are people ready to throw their low level of self control and rhetorical ability. The officer should be formed and continuously supported (ie. dedicated professional psychological access) to face that kind of reactions.

That’s even sadder that people can’t refrain from supporting such a juridical decision with huge possible side effects in terms of abusive application.

In both cases, that’s some kind of impulsive reactions lacking proper rational counterparts to balance the performed actions. And the second one feels far more problematic at societal level, without dismissing in any way the due empathy for the officer.

psychoslave··on AI Has No Wisdom and Neither Will You
Not all rules survive by this fact alone, which obviously is as true as the fact that there are people that don’t care about any rule and people that will deliberately break rule for the mere sake of the thrill. Rules can also stop being used, they can keep going on charming sufficient fan base willing to fight for their application in an environment which changed upside down and were every other new rules are directly conflicting with this old one.
psychoslave··on AI Has No Wisdom and Neither Will You
> Experts don’t follow the rules, they make the rules.

No. Most rules are there before and will stay after the expert enter the field within its career path, unless the field is bright new territory no one fooled before, which is rare.

Not only experts have to know the rules, otherwise they wouldn’t be expert, but good experts also ideally know why the rules were set, and at least have a fairly well aligned representation of what it would likely lead to to follow or not each rule in this or that situation, which rules are in conflicts and what the tradeoffs are when favoring one on the other.

Everything is context dependant, yes. And LLMs can help to leverage on far wider contexts that a single individual would be able to do on its own. It’s require interest to reach some goal in some social context, and not everyone will use LLMs with the same creativity.

This week-end I was discussing with a friend about our respective use of LLMs. At some point they told me they no longer read the MR, as LLMs can also do great job on that matter now, which is in sharp contrast with what I do. Not that I don’t auto-review with LLMs, but I use that as a first step, be it mine or some other colleague. And then I ask an LLM to prepare me a reading plan to check the MR, taking into account the activity scope and the implementation architecture. To me it was an obvious way to go, but for them it was something they never considered. That’s random sample, of course they would certainly be cases we would switch the "I wouldn’t have thought about it" role.

So yes, LLMs can be used to produce faster giant piles of unmaintainable codebases. Or they can be used to strengthen processes that lead to code quality. The nail won’t prevent us to knock our thumb, to use a nail in reverse side, or to smash our coworker.

I get the paperclip plant issue, but that’s some extreme scenario (which is of course the point of the allegory), and most bad uses will be far more mundane in how they look and what the consequences are. And most good uses will look more and more transparent to users to the point they won’t even wonder about it at each use. Like, most people open the tap, see water fall and they don’t get a sense of wonder, not giving a thought to this masterpiece of engineering and gratitude for all people that works daily in the shadow for this miracle to happen. They don’t leave the toilets thinking "how freaking amazing such a complex system of wastewater is something I can benefit from everyday, unlike so many other of the 100G humans that walked this earth."

Next time you go to WC or tap some water, think about it.

psychoslave··on What happened to the Snowden archive
There is nothing like "the most powerful", though.

Already at individual level, even the last "powerless" isolated homeless can go out, steal a gun and start to kill random people in the street, no matter how wealthier and more prominent in martial art they are.

And at geopolitical level, representations are even more scattered. "Swallow its pride" might work with small groups, but at larger scale, there is no nation that can prevent some of its own side of the line to go into asymmetric engagement. Even in the most efficient totalitarian government, there will always be insiders willing to get rid of a head that is is considered weak with outsiders and abusive with insiders, and hurt in all reachable manners the outsiders.

>People are not always rational, particularly when they have a false perception of the world.

That really sounds like "prediction are hard especially about the future"; as everyone is basically operating with limited knowledge, limited resources to acquire and process accurate data, biological and cultural biases. Streets are not exactly crowded with legions of buddha acknowledging each other enlightenment by mere deep and significant sights. Plus rationality is unable to serve as foundation for itself.

psychoslave··on A Cop Searched 19,000 Flock Cameras Across 1,558 Cities. His Reason: 'LMAO'
A higher standard would not let such a mass surveillance network exist, even less give the possibility of such a large look up in it without single use accreditation by a judge or some tierce relevant to keep in check citizens right for privacy.

Any large enough population will also include people failing at doing the-right-thing™ (when such a thing could at least reach some societal consensus) at least sometimes in their life. Expecting anything else is dooming the standard at the lowest possible floor level.

psychoslave··on How much of F-Droid is LLM generated?
That’s fn lazy.
psychoslave··on How much of F-Droid is LLM generated?
Yes, but the equivalent of "sent from Invasive·marketing·of·some·MUA™" would be "generated with Ludicrious·Laughable·Mockery™".

That is, the MUAs don’t add "co-authored by myMUA".

psychoslave··on How much of F-Droid is LLM generated?
Co-author is so strange. Like, would anyone credit an IDE or even a script generating code as co-author? Even legally, tools don't have the ontological requirement to be credited as author.
psychoslave··on How much of F-Droid is LLM generated?
What is fkn?
psychoslave··on 4,400-Year-Old Tomb of Egyptian Judge Found at Saqqara with Colors on Walls
One can still suspect that something might not have been uttered through some AI assistance. There might even be still some living humans outside, who knows.
psychoslave··on Oil Executives Say the Great Fuel Crisis Is Here
Civilisations will end before all oils underground is completely extracted, obviously. Because the harder to extract will remain were it stands, and civilisations will turn attention to other forms of energy.
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →