HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pwinnski

8,760 karma · joined June 28, 2016

submissionscomments
pwinnski··on Apple Music Classical
I also lack the vision to see what could ultimately replace streaming as the primary delivery mechanism for music. It delivers an ongoing revenue stream, the monthly nature of which beats the old "put it out in a new format every few years so everyone has to rebuy everything" in terms of cash flow, although obviously not in overall revenue.

I could definitely see streaming wars in music happening like they are in video, although so far the music labels are content to watch the video labels hurt each other. But consider: Spotify's payouts are infamously low, lower than Google's or Apple's and I can imagine some labels deciding they can do better by providing their own streaming app. Since it's only a few labels, each will believe they have enough of a library to draw subscribers, and away we'll go.

But still: aside from the margins and market share concerns, what delivers a steadier income than streaming?

Streaming doesn't mean they can't experiment with additional revenue streams, including physical media sales and licensing opportunities, but it's hard to imagine something displacing streaming as a concept to the degree which streaming has displaced physical media sales.

pwinnski··on Apple Music Classical
The composers of some very early jazz standards are literally unknown, or unverifiable!
pwinnski··on Apple Music Classical
> For classical, streaming is not an option

> Streaming is the death of the classical recording industry.

Apple seems to disagree, so I guess we'll see. It clear that the best days are behind us, at any rate.

Bottom line: you might have been right that there was still a market to capture in 2017, but YC was also right to see that it was a shrinking market, not exactly the sort of thing in which they're most interested. It's hard to imagine a world in which the market for classical music is bigger today than it was in 2017, regardless of how well you--or anyone else--executed.

pwinnski··on I don’t want a new phone, but I’m probably buying one
I largely agree. I guess I would just say that every decision comes at a cost, and maintaining compatibility usually comes with a small performance cost, exactly the sort of cost Apple least wants to pay on their new devices.
pwinnski··on Apple Music Classical
That redirects to the non-classical music app page already.
pwinnski··on Apple Music Classical
Because that's already a redirect for the standard Music app?

My guess is that the team developed the site without knowing whether they'd have permission to deploy it on *.apple or not, so they put apple in the domain basename and it was deemed not worth it to take it out once they knew the deploy target. Just guessing, though.

pwinnski··on Apple Music Classical
It's always rights.

The composers may be largely long-dead, but the recordings are controlled by labels, so there are rights involved.

pwinnski··on Apple Music Classical
While you're thinking about playlists, I should introduce you to classical radio. Out-of-context movements are the norm there!
pwinnski··on Apple Music Classical
There are 1,182 recordings of Mozart's "Don Giovanni" alone, each running close to three hours. If you listen for 16 hours every day, you can cover this one in under a year, on to work number two! :D
pwinnski··on Apple Music Classical
Spotify has been busy shoehorning their "podcasts" (on-demand audio shows) into every nook and cranny of the app people use to listen to music. If they notice or think of classical music, one can only imagine how they'll try to "highlight" it.
pwinnski··on Apple Music Classical
You have to be logged into Apple Music before you can play Apple Music, regardless of whether you're using the Music app, the Classical app, or the web app. I'm not sure what's weird about that?

Oh, are you saying you can't log in using the Classical app, but have to use the other one? That would be weird.

pwinnski··on Apple Music Classical
I mentioned some of these numbers in another comment already, but for example: Search for "Don Giovanni" in the new app, and there are 1,182 "Works" that match. That's a lot of covers! The "Editor's Choice" is 79 tracks, while the five popular works listed under that one are 63, 64, 70, 38, and 59 tracks, all for the same composition.

It is true that there are complexities in pop music, especially in the modern age of "featuring" artists, but:

1. There are complexities and complexities, and classical music involves the latter.

2. If anything, much pop music seems designed to hide things like composers and session musicians as often as not. The fear seems to be that if people realized how few pop artists write their own music, they'd think less of them. I'm not sure I agree, but the point is that improved metadata is not what everybody involved in pop is looking for. Since the metadata would need be supplied by the labels, I don't think the uptake would be as high as one might hope.

The best example of non-classical music that might rise to a similar level of complexity and care is touring bands like Phish or the Grateful Dead, if all of their live recordings were available officially.

pwinnski··on Apple Music Classical
If your family had Apple Music Family rather than Spotify Family, you would have this option for free.
pwinnski··on Apple Music Classical
I decided to check this out. I searched for "Don giovanni" and my first match was under "Works", telling me that "Don Giovanni" by W. A. Mozart (little pic of him), K. 527, is available in 1,182 tracks. Second match, amusingly, was "Don Juan" by "C. W. Gluck," Wq. 52, available in 17 tracks.

Choosing Don Giovanni, I get a link to see more by Wolgang Amadeus Mozart, and a detailed description of Don Giovanni, K. 527, KV527. There's an Editor's Choice recording by Teodor Currentzis from 2016 (79 tracks, 2 hr 50 min), or five (with See All) Popular Recordings from 1960, 1986, 1991, 1960 again, and 1966, ranging from 2 hr 38 min (Herbert von Karajan, Vienna Philharmonic) to 3 hr (Philharmonia Orchestra). I'll choose the Editor's Choice.

Album art up top, I see (in dim gray) "Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart," (in large white type) "Don Giovanni, K. 527," and (in gray, but larger than the composer) "Teodor Currentzis," along with tiny type tell me that this was released in 2016 and is in Hi-Res Lossless. Then a large Play button, no Shuffle button as the normal Music app has.

The tracks are "Ouvertura" (5:12), Notte e giorno faticar (No. 1, Introduzione: Leporello) (1:30), Non sperar... you know what? You get the idea. The metadata is presented perfectly.

Last night I was listening to Rachmaninoff Symphony No. 2 by the London Symphony Orchestra, Sir Simon Rattle conducting, and it was presented perfectly as well.[0] And it sounded wonderful!

0. https://i.imgur.com/XEZn2My.jpg

pwinnski··on Apple Music Classical
People who care deeply about classical music will use this even at the same or higher cost than Spotify's now-inferior product.

People who don't care at all about classical music won't use this at any price.

People who like classical sometimes but don't listen to it exclusively should be happy that neither costs extra, both are included in the normal price.

I'm not seeing any market opportunity for charging a lower amount for this service separately.

pwinnski··on Apple Music Classical
I can definitely see why they passed. In 2017, it was already clear that streaming options render any music-purchasing platform niche at best, and a shrinking niche at that. Sad, but true.
pwinnski··on I don’t want a new phone, but I’m probably buying one
This is all true, and the interesting thing to me is that I don't think it's intentional. That is, it seems to be the natural result of steady innovation without special effort being made to keep things stable for those who want to avoid innovation.

Should they make that extra effort? Sure, arguably they should. Apple's philosophy has always been to look forward, not back, though, and things like supporting 32-bit code on 64-bit architectures require a lot of effort for little perceived gain.

Then again, that effort means people can jump off of the circular treadmill, so maybe it's worth it.

pwinnski··on Alibaba to split into six separate groups
There's too much focus on "monopolies" and the word "monopoly" itself. The Sherman Anti-Trust Act was about trusts, which are by definition different companies that work together to control a market. The FTC should be focused on trade, and the size of these companies hinders trade and eliminates competition.

Facebook should never have been allowed to acquire Instagram or WhatsApp. If competition is key to a free market, what distortion happens when rich companies can simply buy competitors, ensuring they don't have to actually compete?

Google should never have been allowed to buy DoubleClick for the same reason.

Some of the others are tougher, simply because blocking acquisitions is easier and more popular than breaking up divisions that appear to be developed in-house. To say Amazon shouldn't be allowed to buy Whole Foods wouldn't raise a lot of ire, but to say Amazon should be a separate company from AWS flies in the face of how many people think things ought to work.

pwinnski··on Alibaba to split into six separate groups
Which is amusing, given the history of anti-trust enforcement in the US. Most activity in the middle of the last century was aimed not at companies owning 95%+ of a market, but companies owning every step of a supply chain, smaller pieces of different markets. The focus was on encouraging competition, which has very much not been the focus for the last 40+ years.
pwinnski··on Apple Music Classical is out
I have very expansive taste in music, and enjoy Cardi B as well as Stravinsky (though not usually back-to-back). In a given week I might listen to rock, hip-hop, blues, classical, folk, world music, more hip-hop, and even Cantonese pop songs (when my partner is in the car), but I still get the frustration!

Apple Music's weekly customized playlist for me was consistently including 2-3 songs of modern country, which is the only genre I don't listen to. It was maddening, and I had to reset and clear my entire multi-year history to get it to stop.

pwinnski··on Apple Music Classical is out
Going out on a limb here, but I think you probably don't spend a lot of time listening to classical music. The reaction of nearly everyone who does is cautious optimism, because we know this is a very hard problem that companies and products consistently get wrong.

Possible because they think something like "none of this sounds anywhere near as complicated as people are making it out to be."

pwinnski··on OpenAI tech gives Microsoft's Bing a boost in search battle with Google
It's sad how most programmers are so terrible they need IDEs to automatically create stubs for required methods or getters and setters. They should have to type all of that out every time, and from memory, too! VIM with no plugins is the only way to do it!

Or, you know, smart developers use tools appropriate to the work, and some of us have figured out how to use this new tool before you have. That's okay, you can catch up!

pwinnski··on OpenAI tech gives Microsoft's Bing a boost in search battle with Google
I think that the concern about LLMs making up information are absolutely valid, and a serious concern. At the same time, I think most people focusing on those concerns aren't thinking much about the alternatives, namely Google.

For many people, Google results have gone from being an absolutely amazing demonstration of what could be done if one had the resources to crawl and process the entire internet to a complete waste of time at best, clogged with spam and nonsense and misinformation. I've been using Duck Duck Go for years now, and recently my middle-schooler switched to Duck Duck Go because I got answer to a question she had already asked Google before checking with me. Some people even pay for Kagi search, because Google is just that bad.

So LLMs don't have to be perfect to be better than the alternatives, not even close.

pwinnski··on OpenAI tech gives Microsoft's Bing a boost in search battle with Google
Bing is exposing source links for their answers, one-click verification.

Wolfram has a much wider scope of information than I think most people realize, but your example of local hunting laws is a good example of what they don't cover. I asked Wolfram, and it told me how many calories I'd burn while hunting.

I asked Google, and the first link was to Hunting Regulations - Outdoor Annual - TPWD - Texas.gov, excellent result.

I asked OpenAI, and it cautioned that it isn't up-to-date, since it's just a language model, advised that TPWD is authoritative (correct), and gave an accurate summary of the five major point of gun laws in Texas before reminding me to check with TPWD for the latest.

I've had some misses with OpenAI, but this was an excellent answer. I've also had some misses with Google, but this turned out to be something they surfaced excellent link for, too.

pwinnski··on OpenAI tech gives Microsoft's Bing a boost in search battle with Google
It definitely doesn't mean ads, and introducing ads would be a mistake.

They will likely lower the limits on free use once they're ready to handle a huge influx of paid users. They are in a tough spot temporarily ramping up things enough to take the limits of paid accounts, and since they can't onboard everybody they're being generous with the free tier, but that will end.

pwinnski··on OpenAI tech gives Microsoft's Bing a boost in search battle with Google
OpenAI's product is AI, all else is in service to that.

Google's product is ads, with all else--including AI--in service to that.

pwinnski··on OpenAI tech gives Microsoft's Bing a boost in search battle with Google
They had the resources, but the Venn diagram of gamers and people familiar enough with Google to doubt their commitment had a lot of overlap.
pwinnski··on Tell HN: Reddit removed i.reddit.com and reddit.com/.compact
> How on earth are solo indie devs outperforming entire well-paid teams?!

They have different goals. The solo indie devs are performing horribly on the metrics the internal dev team is judged by, and vice-versa.

pwinnski··on California bill would ban sales of Skittles, other ‘toxic’ snacks
California bill would ban sales of [current recipe for] Skittles, force them to remove chemicals to match the recipes they already use in the EU.

Good.

pwinnski··on We asked the SEC for reasonable crypto rules for Americans
BTC is leaderless, which seems to be a large part of why the SEC is convinced it is not a security.

ETH is not leaderless to the same degree, and to my knowledge has not been declared "not a security" by the SEC in the same way BTC has.

← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →