HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pwinnski

8,760 karma · joined June 28, 2016

submissionscomments
pwinnski··on Three Million U.S. Households Making over $150k Are Still Renting
I'm not talking about 12 months. Ha! I'm talking about over years. My spreadsheet model focused on the 5-year and 10-year returns, where capital gains is factor. What I found was counter-intuitive, but looking at historical returns on index funds and housing, the stock market almost always delivered higher returns. If you have to hire a property manager and pay for repair services, that gap widens.
pwinnski··on Three Million U.S. Households Making over $150k Are Still Renting
In most cities, rents are lower than mortgage payments, because rent is a multiple of when the house was purchased, usually not the price to purchase the house this year.

If I buy a house in 2009 when the market is depressed, and by 2023 the value of that house has gone up immensely, but my mortgage is still based on my 2009 purchase, I can charge less to rent it out than it would cost someone to buy it. Or I can charge the going rate, and hope I find someone willing to pay it.

But if I'm on the other side of the table, it is usually cheaper and easier to rent a house from someone who bought it years ago than it is to buy a similar house myself.

pwinnski··on Three Million U.S. Households Making over $150k Are Still Renting
Being a landlord is mostly profitable when two things are true:

1. You can maintain the property in question for less than the market rate.

2. You bought the property for less than the current market rate.

I looked into this in detail, talking with a realtor who very much wanted me to buy a second home to rent out, and determined that while the rental might be profitable a few years down the road--assuming I could keep it fully occupied and didn't end up with any "problem renters," even then it almost certainly would be more profitable to put the same capital outlay into the stock market, with the added advantages of liquidity and no renter headaches.

Most individual landlords are renting out houses they have already owned for a few years, so their mortgage is not based on today's price, and that is where their profit margin primarily comes from.

pwinnski··on Three Million U.S. Households Making over $150k Are Still Renting
We own the home outright, no mortgage. The repair and maintenance expenses are sporadic and extreme. $6k here, $8k there, without warning.

Rent increases are definitely something to watch out for, but in another six years we will no longer have any school-age children, and our ability to move around without regard for school districts increases dramatically. In 30 years, I will have exceeded my life expectancy at birth, although I hope to still be kicking, obviously. I will probably be retired in half that time.

I've watched my parents end up in a house far too big for them after kids moved out, and they downsize to another house that ended up still being far too big for them.

My willingness/desire to rent may be a reflection of my phase of life more than anything: when I was very young, I rented because I wasn't yet sure I wanted to be locked in somewhere for decades. Then I owned a house for decades until a divorce, rented while I figured out what my life was going to be like again, and now another marriage and another house, but my future looks like it will be a lot less locked in, a mirror of my youth. We intend to travel extensively, spending just shy of six months overseas. At that point we don't need to be paying expenses for a place in which we're not living.

pwinnski··on Three Million U.S. Households Making over $150k Are Still Renting
I lived in San Diego for many years, I'm aware of the trade-offs. My standard of living would decrease substantially if I moved back to California. Property taxes are much lower, but house prices for similar houses are much higher.

In fact, property taxes are not typically less than half of Texas. I think you mean that property tax rates are lower, but given the difference in house prices, that doesn't work out to half. For example, WalletHub[0] says that California's median home value is $573,200, resulting in property taxes of $4,279 at a rate of 0.75%. In Texas, on the other hand, the rate is more than double: 1.75%! But the median home value is $202,600, so the taxes end up being lower: $3,520.

In my case, home values in both cases would be more than double that, and so would taxes.

To be clear, we own this house outright. At this point we could sell it and invest the proceeds in index funds, and cover rent entirely by withdrawing about 3% returns per year. After the first year, that would all be long-term capital gains, too.

0. https://wallethub.com/edu/states-with-the-highest-and-lowest...

pwinnski··on Three Million U.S. Households Making over $150k Are Still Renting
"You're either paying your own repair and maintenance expenses or someone else is."

As someone who has been hit by a perfect storm of expensive repairs, I wish I were still renting.

pwinnski··on Three Million U.S. Households Making over $150k Are Still Renting
This thinking, about who ends up with the money, feels right, but the math doesn't always work like it seems it should.

My counter-argument would be that when you rent, 100% of expenses for repairs and maintenance are borne by someone else, but if you have a mortgage all of those expenses are your own.

Different cites have different ratios between rent and mortgage, with some similar, some higher rents, some higher mortgages. I don't know any cites in which rents require a 20% down payment, though.

Finally, when comparing potential returns, and remember that neither the stock market nor future home equity are guaranteed, don't forget that down payment! Many people focus on the month-to-month after closing, and forget that if they put that lump sum into an index fund rather than into a down payment, they'd be able to (after 12 months) sell shares over time and take income from the index fund in a way they wouldn't from the house without selling it or taking out a HELOC loan.

pwinnski··on Three Million U.S. Households Making over $150k Are Still Renting
We own a house, but have been considering selling it and getting an apartment, despite earning well north of that number in Texas, not exactly a high cost-of-living state.

Financially, we might (or might not) miss out on some equity growth, but our expenses would be more steady. Instead of sporadic multi-thousand dollar repairs and a giant property tax check every year, we'd make a single monthly payment to replace both. Some months we would pay more than if we stayed put, some months we'd pay much less. In the meantime, an apartment would be much smaller, and so utility bills would decrease, too. Rent would go to maintain the shared pool rather me having to pay separately for that, too.

In a state where property taxes weren't running more than $6k/year, the math might be different.

We'd likely have moved already if we didn't have two electric cars.

pwinnski··on Permanent daylight saving time? Where efforts to ‘lock the clocks’ stand
Okay, I generally agree with you, but it's hard to see how a change (er, lack of change) of one hour on clocks suddenly results in "3 hours before dawn." The hyperbole doesn't help, IMO.

Also, we see frequent posts here on HN about how schools ought to start later overall, for all students, so it seems reasonable to think that school could be made to start well after sunrise for everyone all year long.

pwinnski··on Permanent daylight saving time? Where efforts to ‘lock the clocks’ stand
"The coordination problem is impossibly large and annoying." Therefore, here's an impossibly large and annoying solution, demonstrating that fact.

Most things work in lock-step with other things, so even though business already have limitless ability to set their own hours, they tend to set very, very similar hours because there's no point in being closed when people expect you to be open, and not much point in being open when people expect you to be closed.

"But because noon is when the sun is highest, most people can look at the light quality outside and know immediately what time of day it is."

Where, exactly, is noon when the sun is highest? Chicago, Illinois, and Regina, Saskatchewan, are in the same time zone. When the clock ticks noon, is that the apex for both of them? Or to avoid crossing international borders, is the sun at the highest for both Indianapolis, Indiana, and Bangor, Maine?

Bangor today had a sunrise at 05:55, and expects sunset at at 17:35. Indianapolis, on the other hand, had sunrise at 07:02, and expects sunset at 18:47. They are in the same time zone, and yet solar events are more than an hour different. Today, "solar noon" is 11:45 in Bangor, but 12:54 in Indianapolis. Adjusting Indianapolis back an hour to bring noon closer to solar noon would put it at 10:45 in Bangor!

"The sun is highest in the sky in the middle of the day" is approximately true, but can be off by more than the one-hour adjustment for Daylight Saving Time, so it is clearly not precisely true, whether we shift by an hour or not.

The continental USA is 2800 miles wide, and even splitting it into four time zones doesn't make things make good sense for every location. But hey, it could be worse: China is more than 3100 miles wide, and uses a single time zone!

* This isn't aimed at you, but I always check this when comparing two cities, because it's fun: Indianapolis gets between 9:21 and 14:59 hours of daylight, December to June, while Bangor gets from 8:48 to 15:35 hours of daylight.

pwinnski··on A rant on web font licenses
Right, so, this is why we can't have nice things.

For a more gracious understanding of my comment, consider that I meant human decency might compel someone to honor the terms of the license, rather than abuse or ignore them. Relying solely on human decency would mean no auditing, no installed spyware, etc. That so few companies go this route suggests that despite having clear licenses, the humans involved aren't practicing decency enough to pay the bills.

pwinnski··on I used GPT-3 for the heavy lifting and now I have oh so many opinions
Must scroll down for the most interesting bit matching the title.
pwinnski··on FDIC Takes over Silicon Valley Bank
Counterpoint: Now and always, as many times as it takes.
pwinnski··on A rant on web font licenses
I suspect, and I'm just guessing here, that they're fine with people like us using their fonts and maybe tip-toeing over whatever lines they've set, but they don't want, say, Coca-Cola using their typeface everywhere without forking over big bucks.

Were I a typeface designer, I'd like to think I'd say to myself, Self, what are the odds? Just charge $20 and rely on human decency. But I'm not a typeface designer, and my guess is that people who have tried that have found that human decency is thin on the ground among the subset of people who care about using typefaces on websites. But I'm just guessing.

pwinnski··on 5.2% pay raise proposal for federal employees in 2024
How is this a response to what I wrote?

Are there people who exist in this world who make $500k total comp? Yes, I never said there weren't.

Is that the norm, the average, or in any way common? No, of course not. The average, as listed at the top of that page, is $133,806 base pay, and $51,995 additional pay, for a total comp average of $185,801.

Some big tech companies pay higher than average, especially for exceptional people, so yes, you can scroll down and imagine unmentioned stock grants and come up with whatever number you want to, but focusing entirely on the high end of the exceptions as if that were common seems disingenuous.

pwinnski··on Apple launches its new classical music streaming app for pre-order
> needs a dedicated interface

>> It really doesn't... You just need an app that is flexible

Do you have a suggestion about an app that doesn't suck for classical music? I'm aware that metadata fields exist, but that doesn't help with playback, which is why the original comment mentioned a dedicated interface.

pwinnski··on Apple launches its new classical music streaming app for pre-order
Come to think of it, Phish or Grateful Dead live shows have some overlap, but that's more about recordings on different dates by the same artist, while classical adds different artists, or sometimes the same artist on different dates, or sometimes the same orchestra but a different conductor, or...

But yes, that's the closest I can think of, but I think it's a smaller niche even than classical music.

pwinnski··on Apple launches its new classical music streaming app for pre-order
This is 100% accurate. Classical music is just different from other music in too many ways to make them work well in the same UI. I have yet to see a UI that does it well, so I'm looking forward to seeing Apple's stab at it.

Generally you can't go wrong with Deutsche Grammophon, or Hyperion, or even Telarc, but there sure are some stinkers out there, labels just trying to have a large catalog of any quality. And sometimes even a popular recording just doesn't work for me as well as a lesser-known recording, because personal taste can be strange.

pwinnski··on 5.2% pay raise proposal for federal employees in 2024
An extremely limited number of principal developers can clear $500k and get free food and stuff, but that is not the norm. Hacker News distorts common understanding, apparently. No survey I've ever seen suggests that is in any way the norm. Glassdoor suggests[0] that GS-15 comp is mostly in line with norms, especially based on the another commenter pointing out that your suggestion of $145k max is incorrect.

0. https://www.glassdoor.com/Salaries/principal-developer-salar...

pwinnski··on International Women’s Day: New factsheet highlights gender disparities in tech
I think that for desirable positions or roles or what-have-you, discrimination is a reasonable starting point, especially given history. It might not end up being a complete answer, or even a factor at all after further investigation, but it's not unreasonable to start there.

spoiler: it's definitely a factor here, but it is complicated.

pwinnski··on Georgia nuclear plant begins splitting atoms
During the long winter season, that water is largely in solid form, making it less useful for hydro-battery use.
pwinnski··on No, 15-Minute Cities Aren’t a Threat to Civil Liberties
The parent's conspiracy relies heavily on an ethno-religious component, which he dances around because it would give the game away.
pwinnski··on Hi again @elonmusk
He won both court cases I'm thinking of, which seem to be best described as "got away with it."

Public opinion might be up or down, depending on which community you're polling, but I believe he's back to being the richest person in the world[0], so I'd say he "got away with it" in every possible respect.

0. https://news.yahoo.com/elon-musk-once-again-richest-21554083...

pwinnski··on Signal is for everyone, and everyone is different
Signal isn't for everyone, because it's not for people in China who disagree with the Chinese government.

Requiring a phone number means it's not for everyone, period.

pwinnski··on Signal is for everyone, and everyone is different
So Signal isn't for everyone, because it's not for people in China who disagree with the Chinese government.

Requiring a phone number means it's not for everyone, period.

pwinnski··on Banning words won’t make the world more just
I am not British. Not even Canadian!

It's pretty simple: you have freedom to say whatever you want, but if you're worried about how you'll be judged, now or in the future, then you will curtail your worst impulses. Alternatively, you can lean into your freedom, say whatever you want, and then deal with the fallout when it eventually comes.

Look at the comment to which I replied, and then tell me my reply doesn't fit.

pwinnski··on Meta plans thousands more layoffs as soon as this week
I was contact by a recruiter from FB a couple of years ago. I knew I would never work there, but I talked to the recruiter long enough to get a comp number, and... suddenly my resolve to never work there took another day to firm back up.

That's mostly why, I think. In the end, I still said no, but it was much harder with the number in front of me.

pwinnski··on Hi again @elonmusk
He was probably expecting that his employer would follow employment law, rather than this nonsense.
pwinnski··on Hi again @elonmusk
And got away with it, sadly. He has now been to court several times and demonstrated that he can say ANYTHING, and face no consequences legally, and a large pool of sycophants will support every word, no matter how awful.
pwinnski··on Starbucks illegally fired US workers over union, judge rules
If it's clear that you have good reason to close the store, then you close the store. If you're closing a profitable store to avoid unionization, then you don't close the store. There's no need to wait, just don't close profitable stores in retaliation for union activity.

It's just like now: if an employee is bad, then you document it and fire them. If you're firing them to avoid unionization, then don't fire them. There's no need to wait, just don't fire employees in retaliation for union activity.

← PreviousPage 7 of 34Next →