HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pxeger1

1,983 karma · joined October 29, 2021

try https://www.pxeger.com?

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/pxeger; my proof: https://keybase.io/pxeger/sigs/pWFo0gTe2jOWx8j82aJ_hhdt2wU97tpY-l0AzxVfZFw ]

submissionscomments
pxeger1··on Melonking Website
Oh I guess it is supposed to be Melon-King, but I firmly read it as Melonk-ing at first. What could it mean to melonk?
pxeger1··on An engineer's perspective on hiring
> interviews should: be applicable. reflect the actual job duties

No, it doesn't matter that much what task the candidate is doing in the interview. It matters what the interviewer is looking at. I'm sure plenty of interviewers don't understand this, and I think this is often missed when people debate about Leetcode interviews - including in this article.

> most interview questions have very little to do with day-to-day responsibilities

You're missing what the interview questions are. Yes, one part of the interview is "here is a puzzle, can you solve it?", but many of the other questions should be things like "explain why this doesn't work", "why did you start with this approach?" and "are you sure that is the best name for that function?"

Leetcode interviews are perfectly "applicable", as long as the interviewer is using them as a convenient frame to see how you think, communicate, and write/read/edit code and isn't trying purely to assess your skill at quickly solving leetcode puzzles.

> cannot distinguish a senior programmer from a marketer using chatGPT

This is empirically false, because companies haven't suddenly lost all their hiring signal since ChatGPT came out. But if a company has this problem, they suck at interviewing.

(I admit the style of interviewing I'm describing has its own problems, and in particular doesn't address what I think is the biggest issue: the fact you're partly testing people's ability to (appear to) perform under acute pressure.)

pxeger1··on The mystery of Winston Churchill's dead platypus was finally solved
Why can you use Hacker News but not Google Images at work?
pxeger1··on Palantir: The Most Evil Company
FTR I don't necessarily believe that designing better arms is inherently unethical. But if one did, this is why your counterargument wouldn't make sense:

Knife sales are close to zero-sum, but Palantir is innovating with its lethal technology for the sole purpose of being a more effective weapon. If you were stabbed to death by a knife that is somehow designed specifically to be deadlier or harder to defend against, would you call its designer evil?

pxeger1··on I tried Servo
I succeeded with opening an issue and getting something to be supported in browsers (although I think it's not yet in the standard). It was a very small and fairly uncontraversial tweak which was easy to specify, implement, and test, though - bigger things are probably harder.

https://github.com/w3c/csswg-drafts/issues/6203

pxeger1··on The Convenience Trap: Why Seamless Banking Access Can Turn 2FA into 1FA
This is not a compelling argument that 2FA is reduced to 1FA. You need either: something you have (phone) and something you are (face), OR something you have (phone) and something you know (passcode). In either case, there are still two factors. For a criminal to perform shoulder surfing and theft, more things must go right for them than to do either individually.
pxeger1··on Pony: An actor-model, capabilities-secure, high-performance programming language
The designer's syntax decisions tell you a lot about their semantic decisions, which languages they take inspiration from, and the language's philosophy about things like flexibility, correctness, and opinionatedness.
pxeger1··on Show HN: A macOS clock that stays visible when coding or binging in fullscreen
Three/four finger swipe is unbearably slow for me. I'm ready to interact with 0.3s but then I have to watch the image slide the last 10 pixels for another 0.3s before focus switches (and if I use the keyboard before it's finished switching the input goes to the now-99%-invisible app that was previously focused!!)

[numbers made up, I don't know the exact values, but the general point still stands, and you can't change the speed!!]

pxeger1··on Air Force unit suspends use of Sig Sauer pistol after shooting death of airman
I think it's crazy to use anecdotal evidence to decide to continue to use a gun with a small chance of accidental discharge.
pxeger1··on UK Gov Petition: Repeal the Online Safety Act
I think you'd be surprised how many people are actually in favour of this bill. Mainstream press totally fell for the "think of the children" angle pushed by a mixture of legitimate children's safety organisations, anti-porn activists, and intelligence apparatus. Meanwhile the privacy argument got little to no lobbying or public discourse.

E.g.:

https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/aug/15/digital-g...

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/09/19/online-safety-ac...

It's how the (previous) government was able to look like it was doing something about the mental health crisis caused by social media, even though this bill won't fix that at all.

pxeger1··on Vet is a safety net for the curl | bash pattern
My problem with curl|bash is not that the script might be malicious - the software I'm installing could equally be malicious. It's that it may be written incompetently, or just not with users like me in mind, and so the installation gets done in some broken, brittle, or non-standard way on my system. I'd much rather download a single binary and install it myself in the location I know it belongs in.
pxeger1··on I am no longer chairing defenses where students use generative AI
I feel like debates about AI and plagiarism are quite surface-level definitional debates. They miss out an important discussion of why we believe (old-fashioned) plagiarism is bad. Answers about when using AI is acceptable should be based on that reasoning.
pxeger1··on UK government seeks way out of clash with US over Apple encryption
http://archive.today/7MdaI
pxeger1··on Coding with LLMs in the summer of 2025 – an update
The mentioned CPU uses unified memory for its built in GPU / NPU. I.e. some portion of what could ordinarily be system RAM is given to the GPU instead of the CPU
pxeger1··on The Halo Effect
I don't think a HALO is anti-competitive if the IP licence is non-exclusive as TFA says. The only exclusivity involved is that only (really) one company can hire a given team, but hiring is already exclusive in nature, and not considered anti-competitive. (Am I missing something on how a HALO is exclusive? To be honest I was surprised when I read in TFA that the IP licence is typically non-exclusive.)

If companies think the paperwork is too onerous for acquihires (convincing regulators the exclusivity inherent with acquisitions isn't creating an illegal monopoly), and they can get a satsifactory result with a non-exclusive HALO (which regulators therefore don't need to check), why shouldn't they do a HALO instead?

pxeger1··on Row Polymorphic Programming
I think you mean structural typing; nominal typing is the opposite, where field names are lexically scoped.

Anyway, row polymorphism can technically be used with nominal typing, it's just that it usually makes sense to use structural typing instead.

The key benefit of row polymorphism is a bit of an implementation detail - it lets you get something resembling (a limited form of) subtyping in your language, without needing as complicated a type inference algorithm as fully-general subtyping requires.

Row polymorphism can be (IMO should usually be) made opt-in, so you can avoid problems like the scenario you describe.

pxeger1··on Fully homomorphic encryption and the dawn of a private internet
> most of the expansion card tech is all done by general purpose hardware, which while cheaper will never be as good as a custom dedicated silicon chip that's only focused on 1 task

I think one reason they can be as good as or better than dedicated silicon is that they can be adjusted on the fly. If a hardware bug is found in your network chip, too bad. If one is found in your software emulation of a network chip, you can update it easily. What if a new network protocol comes along?

Don't forget the design, verification, mask production, and other one-time costs of making a new type of chip are immense ($millions at least).

> Its why I advocate for a separate ML/AI card instead of using GPU's. Sure their is hardware architecture overlap but your sacrificing so much because your AI cards are founded on GPU hardware.

I think you may have the wrong impression of what modern GPUs are like. They may be descended from graphics cards (as in graphics ), but today they are designed fully with the AI market in mind. And they are design to strike an optional balance between fixed functionality for super-efficient calculations that we believe AI will always need, and programmability to allow innovation in algorithms. Anything more fixed would be unviable immediately because AI would have moved on by the time it could hit the market (and anything less fixed would be too slow).

pxeger1··on Their Water Taps Ran Dry When Meta Built Next Door
Maybe building a heat exchanger in a river requires loads of environmental / planning permits, but just producing millions of gallons of (warm) "sewage" doesn't, because it's already allowed?
pxeger1··on Apple's Browser Engine Ban Persists, Even Under the DMA
Relatedly, all Google apps (e.g. Maps) on iOS try very hard to push Chrome on you (even though iOS Chrome still has to use WebKit). When you click an external link, they present you the options of Chrome, Google (the search app), or Safari. This happens even if you don't have Chrome/Google installed, so they take you to the App Store instead of opening the webpage. If you choose Safari, it still doesn't open Safari, it opens a web view inside Google Maps, from where you have to press yet another button to get it to open as a actual Safari tab. The menu has a "remember my choice for next time" switch, but it seems to reset every few times so it constantly re-nags you.

If the link goes to something that should open in another app (e.g. goes to instagram.com when I have the Instagram app installed), unless I satisfy its demands to install Chrome, it takes like 3 extra clicks to open in that other app.

pxeger1··on Lens: Lenses, Folds and Traversals
Being different to what users of ~all top-20 languages are used to is a great way to be obscure and somewhat impenetrable.
pxeger1··on GitHub CEO: manual coding remains key despite AI boom
Thomas Dohmke is CEO of GitHub .
pxeger1··on New Linux udisks flaw lets attackers get root on major Linux distros
Wouldn't Android's kernel have most of the hardening steps / disabled features described in GP's comment?
pxeger1··on Debunking NIST's calculation of the Kyber-512 security level (2023)
If NSA and only NSA can crack a particular system, they probably wouldn't mind using it for their own secrets.

And anyway why is there any reason to believe they really do use the system they say they use?

pxeger1··on Protecting your code from other people's bugs
An abstract ending "or does it?" is not a good abstract. The conclusions should be summarised as well as the questions.
pxeger1··on Show HN: A new programming language inspired by Go, no LLVM
Why do you prefer "proper" imports?
pxeger1··on Uber to introduce fixed-route shuttles in major US cities
I’m a fan, if only because Uber’s vehicle tracking is so much more reliable than any public bus network I’ve ever used.
pxeger1··on The 'invisible crew' who have 35 seconds to prevent a Eurovision blunder
Fernand's Live Show Show has a great behind-the-scenes minidocunentary: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qb_7uPzs188
pxeger1··on UK's Ancient Tree Inventory
I agree it is happening and is and will be interesting to study, but I don’t think there is any reason other than racism to be outraged by it.
pxeger1··on Everyone Is Cheating Their Way Through College
As usual, this article totally conflates "to help with homework" with "to cheat on homework". If you use it like a better Google, learning from its output rather than directly using the text, that’s definitely not cheating by any definition.
pxeger1··on Why are there no thunderstorms in the UK?
I knew the US was further south than one assumes, but wow. In fact, even all of Luxembourg is further north than all of the continental US!
← PreviousPage 2 of 19Next →