HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

qPM9l3XJrF

604 karma · joined June 18, 2020

submissionscomments
qPM9l3XJrF··on In Mexico, cartels are hunting down police at their homes
Part of what's going on in Mexico is that the cartels have spread romanticized images of themselves to the point where many Mexican youngsters actually aspire to cartel life. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Narcocorrido
qPM9l3XJrF··on In Mexico, cartels are hunting down police at their homes
I'm reminded of this recent viral Youtube which depicts what is apparently a routine occurrence in South Africa: A professional gang, armed with heavy caliber weapons, executes a sophisticated highway ambush in an attempt to capture a vehicle loaded with cell phones:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KAvqDF3Wujc

I watched an interview with Leo Prinsloo, the star of the video. He mentioned that although this incident went viral, it is actually a common occurrence in South Africa, and many gangs have ex-police and ex-military members. Unsurprisingly the police don't provide effective protection against these professionalized gangs, creating the need for private security guards like Prinsloo.

In the US, we are used to thinking of "crime" as just another political issue. But observing countries like Mexico and South Africa, where gangs and police forces have started to merge, has helped me realize that there are important nonlinear effects.

Once "crime" gets bad enough, the state begins to lose its monopoly on force, and I'm not sure it is possible to recover from that. I'm starting to understand why people in the Philippines might support politicians such as Rodrigo Duterte who disregard due process--at a certain point, it becomes more important for the state security forces to win than for them to play fair.

qPM9l3XJrF··on Please commit more blatant academic fraud
Yes, I'm very skeptical of Buckman's claim that more fraud will help. Seems similar to a claim around 2015-2016 that voting for Donald Trump will inspire America to clean up its act politically. Institutions aren't biological systems that operate according to mysterious hormetic processes. Institutions are created by humans and thrive or decay based on whether they effectively channel human effort. Be the change you want to see in the world. And if you wreck something, and others apply blood sweat and tears to recreate it in a way that's better than the original, you don't get to take any credit as the wrecker.
qPM9l3XJrF··on Offload Mental Simulation
Sounds like Light Table http://lighttable.com/

Unfortunately it looks like it's no longer under development.

qPM9l3XJrF··on Mammalian Hybrids
We know that different animals have different numbers of chromosomes. For example, humans have 46 and chimps have 48 even though our common ancestor is relatively recent. So at some point there must have been successful reproduction between two apes that had different numbers of chromosomes, no?
qPM9l3XJrF··on Trials begin on lozenge that rebuilds tooth enamel
How about rebuilding the bone the tooth grows out of? My dentist says that my teeth look great, but the x-ray of my alveolar bones that support those teeth look like that of someone 10 years older than me.
qPM9l3XJrF··on Berkeley Lab Debuts Perlmutter, World’s Fastest AI Supercomputer
Dude is getting stuff named after him while he's still alive!
qPM9l3XJrF··on Twitter confirms Twitter Blue
reddit can be incredibly angry as well. Downvoting has advantages, but a disadvantage is creation of echo chambers where people feed off each other to get more and more angry, only hearing the worst from those who disagree.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rE3j_RHkqJc

qPM9l3XJrF··on Twitter confirms Twitter Blue
HN has an interesting business model relative to other social sites. Instead of serving targeted ads, the site itself is essentially one giant ad for Y Combinator. That creates better incentives to promote high quality discussion because low quality discussion more directly harms the YC brand. But it's still gotten a lot worse over the years.
qPM9l3XJrF··on Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side
The point is it invalidates the Zinn quote
qPM9l3XJrF··on The “Marketing Is Evil” Problem
The strength of your claims is vastly out of proportion to the strength of your evidence.

Remember all the furor over the Gates divorce because people were worried that it would impact their global health work and so on? I guess that was all bogus concern because the Gates Foundation is actually a giant tax scheme?

qPM9l3XJrF··on Just 20 firms behind more than half of single-use plastic waste – study
Global warming is an emergency. Ultimately what matters is minimizing the amount of CO2 in the atmosphere. You could do that by pumping oil into a landfill in a way that it can't be burned (note that it could be burned in its original state, that's why it was extracted for fuel!), or you could do it by taking CO2 out. CO2 is CO2. You should do whichever will reduce atmospheric CO2 most effectively.
qPM9l3XJrF··on Just 20 firms behind more than half of single-use plastic waste – study
The entire field of economics is based on the idea that if you increase the price of something, people will buy less of it. If we increase the demand for plastic, that increases demand for fossil fuels (since fossil fuels are needed to make plastic), which makes the price go up, which means people will buy a bit less fossil fuel to burn in their vehicles etc.

Just search for "gas prices" on Google News and you'll see that people are very concerned about the price of gas. Much more than most commodities, actually.

qPM9l3XJrF··on Just 20 firms behind more than half of single-use plastic waste – study
>It's not nothing, but it's not a good excuse to waste more single-use plastic (as you're implying here saying "Single-use plastic waste is 'good'")

Suppose I get upset about all the fossil fuel which is being burned and decide to do something about it. I buy up fossil fuel and instead of burning it, I sequester it underground in such a way that it can't be used by drilling companies. This seems clearly good for the environment, no?

"Wasting" plastic does exactly this. If you buy ordinary non-biodegradable plastic, and dispose of it in the garbage so it goes to the landfill, you are effectively buying up fossil fuel which could have been burned, paying someone to transform it into solid form so it can't easily be used as fuel, and sequestering it underground.

Of course it is not a complete solution to global warming. But it is something we should encourage people to do.

qPM9l3XJrF··on Just 20 firms behind more than half of single-use plastic waste – study
>the claim pertains to non-biodegradeable bioplastics only.

That's most plastic though. Your average soda bottle is not biodegradable on any meaningful timescale.

As the article puts it: "If we're going to extract carbon from the ground at all, far better that it ends up in a soda bottle that will last 400 years than in the combustion chamber of your car."

qPM9l3XJrF··on Just 20 firms behind more than half of single-use plastic waste – study
>As the linked article admits, it only sequesters carbon if it is plant-based

At the very top: "It’s usually made from petroleum, which is better in a landfill than in a tank of gasoline"

"It" being plastic. The common non-plant-based kind.

And later: "If we're going to extract carbon from the ground at all, far better that it ends up in a soda bottle that will last 400 years than in the combustion chamber of your car."

It's good if there is more demand for non-plant-based plastic, because then we burn less fossil fuel.

>It is dumped in whichever way is cheapest and easiest

The most common way plastic is disposed of is in a landfill. The carbon is being sequestered underground, in other words.

qPM9l3XJrF··on Just 20 firms behind more than half of single-use plastic waste – study
Single-use plastic waste is good. It sequesters carbon.

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/wait-plastic-can-...

qPM9l3XJrF··on The “Marketing Is Evil” Problem
"Excuse me, but did you just compare the number 1 to the number 1000 by pointing out that they are both positive integers?"

The point I am making is simple. There are approaching 3,000 billionaires worldwide. Suppose 90% are upstanding and 10% are unethical. That's 300 unethical billionaires. Suppose each unethical billionaire does just 1-2 unethical things per year, that is plenty of "unethical billionaire" stories for journalists to write about an unethical billionaire every day if they want.

You write: "The only way to amass that sort of wealth is to exploit the labor of others." Then you cite a few examples of billionaires behaving, in your view, unethically. That's very nice, but to prove your claim, you need to show that every billionaire has done this. You mentioned 3 billionaires. With about 3,000 worldwide, you are about 0.1% of the way there.

But the examples you've provided so far don't even pass the sniff test. Example:

"ABC News[47] and The Economist[48] both conducted comparisons, and found that although the number of workplace suicides at Foxconn was large in absolute terms, the suicide rate was actually lower than the overall suicide rate of China[49] or the United States."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foxconn_suicides#Analysis

>Simply the fact that some people are amassing such wealth, while millions of people in the world starve and cannot access even basic education or healthcare. That alone makes being a billionaire unethical, by default.

This argument only applies to billionaires who haven't signed the giving pledge. Those I will agree with you on. However, it would be highly unethical to tax away the wealth of those who have signed the Giving Pledge, in order to provide even more goodies for Americans who are already quite wealthy by global standards.

qPM9l3XJrF··on The “Marketing Is Evil” Problem
"Targeted advertising", in other words.
qPM9l3XJrF··on The “Marketing Is Evil” Problem
I rarely buy a product without reading the reviews. In the long run, selling bad products is usually not a good way to make money. (Unless the government is subsidizing your industry, e.g. for-profit colleges.)

And competence of advertising usually correlates with product quality. That's why you're less likely to enter your credit card details in a website that looks like it was designed in 1998. Quality ads serve as an honest signal that the company is making enough money to pay for them. If they're making money, that means people are buying the product, and if they're buying the product, it probably isn't terrible.

qPM9l3XJrF··on The “Marketing Is Evil” Problem
Is there such a thing as an ethical thousandaire? Millionaire?

If you think there is, why can't there be ethical billionaires? An ethical billionaire is just an ethical millionaire who kept working to make the source of their income grow until it grew 1000x as large.

Big businesses are generally more ethical than little ones -- subject to more customer and regulatory scrutiny. It's much easier for a small business to get away with flouting environmental regulations or treating its employees harshly. (When's the last time the manager at a tiny roadside restaurant got fired for sexually harassing his employees?) This increased level of scrutiny means it is easier to bring to mind examples of unethical behavior by large businesses even if the actual rate is about the same. The media is biased to cover misdeeds by billionaires due to billionairephobia, the same way it is biased to cover misdeeds by Black people due to racism.

qPM9l3XJrF··on The “Marketing Is Evil” Problem
Elsewhere in this thread, people are complaining about ads for useless and inferior products. This problem would only get worse if we handed out ad space via lottery, since most products are useless/inferior. Selecting for deep pockets means selecting for products that people are actually paying money to buy, which serves as a basic quality filter.
qPM9l3XJrF··on The “Marketing Is Evil” Problem
It looks like a billionairephobic dog whistle to me. Why is it necessary to emphasize that they aren't humans if what he means to refer to are corporations?

But here are some interesting stats for you. raspyberr thinks that "things with large amounts of money aren't humans and don't have morals". So let's consider the thing with the largest amount of money of all: the US federal government. The federal government's annual budget is almost 6 trillion, approximately 30 times that of Google Inc. Google gets 100% of its energy from renewable sources. The corresponding figure for the federal government is 10%. Shall we tax Google more? I'm not sure. Seems like we'd just transfer assets from a moderately amoral entity to one which is even more amoral.

qPM9l3XJrF··on The “Marketing Is Evil” Problem
If what you say is true, billionaires who inherit their money should also be among the most ethical. Is that what you believe?
qPM9l3XJrF··on The “Marketing Is Evil” Problem
Why do you believe that?

And if you believe that, how are you so sure that it hasn't already happened? If you're a software developer making $100K annually, you are already in the global 1%. Should people like you exist? Have you signed any sort of giving pledge, as many billionaires have? https://givingpledge.org/

qPM9l3XJrF··on The “Marketing Is Evil” Problem
If I gave you a billion dollars, do you believe that you would suddenly transform into an amoral non-human monster?
qPM9l3XJrF··on The “Marketing Is Evil” Problem
Sometimes marketing tells me about a product that I didn't know existed, or tells me about a superior product to the one I'm currently buying.
qPM9l3XJrF··on The “Marketing Is Evil” Problem
>I don't believe this, likely he just made that up to make marketing look better.

Can you find 3 examples written prior to today of people demonizing the marketing of products they love?

qPM9l3XJrF··on The “Marketing Is Evil” Problem
>things with large amounts of money aren't humans and don't have morals

"Dehumanize when it's trendy." This is billionairephobia, friend.

qPM9l3XJrF··on Absolute wealth, relative wealth, taxes, and staying rich
Sure, but the sad thing to me here is that no one even seems to care much about this. Note these articles are both from over 5 years ago. We aren't even capable of having that level of discussion nowadays.

Our federal government is projected to spend $5.8 trillion in 2021 alone. The entire Gates fortune is $124 billion.

And yet Gates probably does more for the world's poorest -- the federal government is overwhelmingly focused on serving Americans -- globally speaking, mostly wealthy white people: https://howrichami.givingwhatwecan.org/how-rich-am-i

What good is being done with that $5.8 trillion exactly? Is the federal government with its military interventionism, agricultural subsidies, etc. really doing 1000x as much good annually as the Gates Foundation? (The annual budget of the Gates Foundation is around 0.1% as large, at around $5 billion.)

The failed F-35 stealth fighter project alone has a total cost estimated at $1.7 trillion. Note that this has received almost no coverage. Defense contractors milk the federal government like there's no tomorrow and it doesn't get any attention because mentioning it doesn't serve either party's political goals.

Suppose we hypothetically took the entire Gates fortune and added it to the federal budget, so the government spends $5.9 trillion this year instead of $5.8 trillion. Would you even notice? How would you expect the $5.9 trillion budget world to be different from a $5.8 trillion budget world? I'm pretty sure that people in developing countries will miss the work done by the Gates Foundation a heck of a lot more than already-wealthy Americans will appreciate another $0.1 trillion in the federal budget.

Using evidence to focus on the most effective possible programs for helping the world's poorest goes a long way, and unfortunately the vast majority of the federal government's spending is not that. Increasing taxes on rich people isn't gonna change that. Before plowing more money into ineffective federal spending, we should first make it effective.

"It's ok to waste trillions, the important thing is for us to feel really egalitarian about it"

← PreviousPage 4 of 9Next →