HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

qiqing

1,845 karma · joined May 18, 2009

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/jadewang; my proof: https://keybase.io/jadewang/sigs/myh-nYcLD3-yIOUuMpWjAQcYMj_CuIMiNsEd2qv7vdk ]
submissionscomments
qiqing··on Beautiful minds, wasted: how not to squander the potential of autistic people
I'm a little bit puzzled by your statement, "These were the only jobs the teenagers were qualified to do."

Surely there's other work, possibly more of it these days, for teenagers to do. For instance, with an increase in the percentage of dual-income households (as opposed to the single-income households which dominated in the past), there are more families in need of babysitters or tutors.

When I was a teen, there was a high demand for tutoring services, dog-walking, and minor web development work to be performed by teens. And wouldn't the teenagers for whom this bagging gig isn't a permanent sort of job be better suited in a position that offered more educational opportunity (e.g., tutoring younger students, or learning some web dev and making a website for a local SMB).

One could argue that the employees with disabilities are freeing up the teenagers to do work that gives them more educational benefit, like the power looms freed up textile manufacturing workers to find more economically valuable work in the long run.

qiqing··on How the “what’s your current salary?” question hurts the gender pay gap
If you look at the trendlines for what certain types of jobs or fields paid (e.g., doctor, nurse, programmer, marketer), you'd see that when women enter a particular field en masse, the pay drops. And when the gender balance in that field goes from majority female to majority male, the pay increases.

Some well-intentioned parent is probably telling their daughter right now, "Look at field X, which is male-dominated and pays really well! You should study that." And by the time they've grown up to be of working age, the field is at 60F/40M, and the pay has gone way down.

qiqing··on Why Apple's fight with the FBI could have reverberations in China
On that note, if the government has a warrant, should they be allowed to use EEG to get your phone's PIN code regardless of your consent?

https://www.usenix.org/conference/usenixsecurity12/technical...

qiqing··on What Your Microbiome Wants for Dinner
Yep, rates of evolution (in particular mutation rate and drift) are proportional to population size, and we have a larger population size than we ever have in the past.

~2 billion base pairs * ~1 in a billion error rate = 2 mutations per generation (on average)

Edit: Slight clarification and a brief (and greatly oversimplified) lesson on how this works.

Let Ne = effective population size. And I'll define "fitness effect" as the advantage conferred by a particular mutation in a particular fitness landscape. e.g., If you're an E. coli, the fitness conferred by penicillin resistance is very high if you're sitting in a pool of penicillin, but generally mildly negative otherwise because you're wasting energy.

When the fitness effect size is much larger in magnitude than 1/Ne (or 1/2Ne if you're diploid, like us), the fate of the gene is largely determined by natural selection. (But add the occasional coin toss in there b/c the real world is messy.)

When the fitness effect size is much smaller in magnitude than 1/Ne, the fate of the gene is largely determined by genetic drift. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetic_drift (tl;dr Mostly chance mod a few other effects, like if the mutation of interest has a physical location close to another mutation with strong selection pressure)

However, there are slightly deleterious or slightly advantageous mutations, whose fitness effect size is close to 1/Ne (or 1/2Ne for diploids), and things get kinda interesting, because it's a combination of genetic drift and natural selection. For instance, if it's a slightly deleterious mutation, it will decrease Ne slightly (increasing the proportion of mutations that are considered neutral of the new value of Ne), and the previously "slightly deleterious" mutation may now be effectively neutral for the new value of Ne.

There is a lot of evidence that the "slightly" deleterious and the "slightly" advantageous mutations contribute substantially to evolutionary dynamics.

This is further complicated by the fact that the fitness (whether a mutation is deleterious or advantageous) is not constant everywhere geographically, or over time.

qiqing··on China Cuts Mobile Service of Xinjiang Residents Evading Internet Filters
> The action also shows that despite spending billions of dollars to create one of the world’s most sophisticated Internet censorship and surveillance systems, blind spots abound.

Does anyone here have a source that compares the reach of Chinese surveillance with the NSA and GCHQ?

qiqing··on Alibaba's Singles' Day sales surge 60 percent to $14.3B
> I am very skeptical of any self reported numbers coming out of Chinese markets

Would you say that you are less skeptical of large U.S.-based companies (banks, energy, or any other sector) when self-reporting?

qiqing··on Fears of immigration in ancient Rome and today
Note that I did not claim China doesn't have racism. But by personally comparing my experience growing up Asian in the U.S. (having lived in non-diverse small Midwest towns for several years) with the experience of Caucasian friends who spent some childhood years in China, I'd really have to say: they got a much, much better experience as far as race is concerned.

And every time that I have confronted a Chinese person about prejudice against black people, I also asked them where their preconceptions came from. Without exception, they tell me that they have no first-hand experience, but they get all their information from American movies, whose makers they assume to know more about American culture than they do.

But if you actually want to compare relative levels of racism quantitatively (which is hard because there are so many confounding factors), I challenge you to compare the incarceration rate of African Americans in the U.S vs. African Chinese in China.

qiqing··on Fears of immigration in ancient Rome and today
My mom's childhood friend who was a Holocaust refugee has no reason to lie to me (about not being able to go to any other country they tried to escape to), I think. But here, I pulled up some sources to placate you guys:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shanghai_Jewish_Refugees_Museu...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_Jews_in_China

http://www.ushmm.org/wlc/en/article.php?ModuleId=10007091

qiqing··on Fears of immigration in ancient Rome and today
I would also like to offer another data point. The way that Jews were treated in Europe vs in China in the same time period.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kaifeng_Jews

qiqing··on Fears of immigration in ancient Rome and today
Here's an interesting pickle about linguistic diversity: Jane Austen is roughly temporally equidistant between modern day and Shakespeare, yet our level of mutual intelligibility is so much higher.

What changed? Standardization (such as printing a standard dictionary) drastically reduced the rate at which languages evolved. And one major historical difference between China and India is a history of unification, starting with the Qin Dynasty, which introduced dictionaries, standardized weights and measures, a single currency, and standard widths of roads. They were brutal in their implementation and it ultimately led to popular revolt, but the standards stuck. However, that would not be the last attempt at unification. In China's history, there have been repeated efforts at unifying an empire, splitting into multiple nations, re-unification, rinse, repeat. Have you noticed that all the terms that translate into "ethnic Chinese" in English are named after dynasties? At one point in time, identifying oneself as "Han" was like saying "I'm an American." Sure, my ancestors are a mix of Wu and Manchurian, but now we're part of the Han Nation. Or a different mix of other ethnicities for the Tang Dynasty.

To put it another way, let's say the EU became one nation that lasted at least a century. People who previously identified as "German" or "Italian" (or Anglos? Saxons? Celts?) all self-identify as European. Fast forward another century. The empire is expanding, and Central Asia is part of the equation now, so European is defined "as opposed to" another group, but another unification event happens, and now everyone on that continent refers to themselves as Eurasian. And sometimes, on the East Coast, there's an influx of Australian immigrants which adds up over the next century. How arbitrary is it to say that Eurasia is 95% Eurasian?

As for visual phenotype difference between Northern and Southern Chinese being "minor" -- these differences look very pronounced to me. Yet I have trouble telling the difference between, say, British and German people, for instance.

Maybe we're just trained on different data sets?

qiqing··on Fears of immigration in ancient Rome and today
FWIW, I'm 1/8 Manchurian even though my birth certificate says "Han" and the Qing Dynasty, which ended in 1911, was ruled by Manchurians.

China was the only nation that welcomed refugees fleeing from pogroms in one era and fleeing concentration camps in another era, when nations like the U.S. would not let those ships dock.

It's just unfortunate that the U.S. tends to be rather selective in what gets taught in schools.

Side note: you can tell something about the inclusivity of a culture by how children of mixed race are treated and labelled by the broader society. Historically, if you're part-Han (a term which originated from the Han Dynasty to be an inclusive term that described all the diverse people from the diverse nations that comprised it), then you're Han (part of the mainstream, dominant culture). Historically, in the U.S., children of mixed race get categorized with the less-mainstream less-dominant minority culture, with all the lack of privilege that accompany that. This sort of edge case may seem minor to those who don't live it, but as an edge case myself, I feel that it's indicative of how the dominant culture views me.

qiqing··on Fears of immigration in ancient Rome and today
China was also very open to immigration and inclusive in what counted as "Chinese."
qiqing··on The Two Asian Americas
People often forget that systemic racism against Asian Americans is also racism. That's part of the point. That you can do everything right and have things go reasonably well, but have it all taken away from you because of the color of your skin.

Like the physicist who was innocent but had his family dragged through an espionage trial because the officials didn't even bother to consult experts in the field.

qiqing··on The Illinois Mathematics and Science Academy, a public live-in high school
Most IMSA kids I knew went home to their parents on the weekends, every weekend.

Most boarding school kids I knew only went 'home' for summer, winter holidays, spring break, etc.

qiqing··on From Radio to Porn, British Spies Track Web Users’ Online Identities
Can you imagine if the GCHQ had a breach and all the dirt on all everyone they spied on suddenly became public?
qiqing··on The Journal That Couldn’t Stop Citing Itself
In theory, the journal could also tell authors who have submitted articles that their submissions don't have enough citations. And to go back and revise until they do. That wouldn't be so entirely out of the ordinary.
qiqing··on The Journal That Couldn’t Stop Citing Itself
First paragraph:

"The Journal of Criminal Justice has been on a roll. Once considered a somewhat middling publication — not in the same league as top journals like Criminology and Justice Quarterly — it is now ranked No. 1 in the field according to its impact factor, which measures the average number of citations a journal receives and is meant to indicate which titles are generating the most..."

It sounds like the tl;dr is: the incentives created by how 'impact factor' is measured caused the journal to game the system by citing itself ad nauseum.

qiqing··on Why Is Europe Failing to Create More $1B Startups?
The article also doesn't mention an obvious bias, that is, if a startup starts in Europe, there are a lot of incentives for that startup to move to the U.S. early in its life cycle.

In that scenario, the startups who become successful (and who originated elsewhere) all get counted as U.S. successes. This would vastly undercount both the total number of startups elsewhere as well as the number of successful startups.

qiqing··on Where Are Chernobyl’s Children?
I can see this being a scene in a film (from the article):

'I arrived the next morning to be greeted by two men, with cheap suits and attaché cases, looking like the East German Stasi. They were government officials. They asked, “So what do you want to do here?” I said openly, “I want to take photos here because I’m looking for victims from Chernobyl.” Their answer, “None of these kids here are in any way connected with Chernobyl. You know that malformations can happen anywhere, none of this is connected to Chernobyl.”

Even though it was still very early in the morning, I had a great thought — I had obviously already had enough coffee — and I responded, “Okay, if you give it to me in writing that not a single kid here is in any way connected to Chernobyl, I will pack up my bags and my cameras, and I’ll leave.” And then I said, “But of course, we will need to report in National Geographic that because none of the kids’ diseases are related to Chernobyl, you’re no longer interested in receiving funds from Chernobyl charities.”

P: Wow. Power move.

G: You should have seen how fast they changed their minds. “Oh, there may be this child, and may be this one, and, well, the parents of this kid lived in Chernobyl.” All of sudden the whole situation turned. So in that kind of encounter you learn that you cannot trust officials today any more than you could in the past. It’s gotten better in Ukraine, but Belarus was pretty bad.'

qiqing··on A Woman Who Spent Six Years Fighting a Traffic Stop
Wow. "A woman told the paper that she was pulled over by Woodworth police while in labor — and was kept for more than a half hour."
qiqing··on Facebook ‘Spam King’ Guilty for Sending 27M Messages
In China, Xiaomi phone users have a "report spam" button, and if X number of people report that phone number as a spammer, calls from that number get blocked on all other Xiaomi phones. (I think X = 5, but I'm not sure.)

I really wished we had something like that here. One of the only times I'm jealous of my mom's phone.

qiqing··on Corn Wars
Or poor Chinese farmers, in this case.
qiqing··on Registered clinical trials make positive findings vanish
We humans are biologically quite different from a lot of the species we experiment on. To take a salient example, we've cured cancer (all sorts of cancers) in mice hundreds of times. It's unlikely you'll find a tumor in a mouse we can't fix. But the same things don't work in humans.

And although I feel like a weird contrarian saying this, it's entirely possible that by selecting for treatments that are effective in other species, we may be inadvertently missing out on things that might work in humans.

qiqing··on Brains Sweep Themselves Clean of Toxins During Sleep (2013)
Huh, I hadn't seen that until just now, but I looked up this paper (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11557177) and a more recent one that cited that one: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4110174/

Notes for below:

* CHB/CHC -> chronic hepatitis B/C

* NAFLD -> Non-alcoholic fatty liver disease

When discussing possible mechanisms for their findings:

"We postulate that the observation of the benefit of coffee on the progression of liver disease may be due to its effects on the oxidative stress/lipotoxicity pathway, which underlie the pathogenesis of cirrhosis related to alcohol, NAFLD and possibly, in part, CHC. However, since oxidative stress is not the predominant mechanism of injury seen in CHB, coffee has no beneficial effect. Polyphenols and melanoidins, which are major components of coffee, have been shown to mediate multiple protective mechanisms in a rat model of steatohepatitis, ranging from increased fatty acid β oxidation, mitigating oxidative stress and curtailing liver inflammation (47). The other components of coffee, cafestol and kahwoel, can induce phase II detoxifying enzymes, including sulfotransferase, UDP-glucuronosyl transferase, glutathione transferase and peroxidase, and thus contribute to the anti-oxidant properties of coffee (14, 48). In addition, chemicals in coffee such as polyphenols and the diterpenes have been shown to down-regulate proinflammatory, fibrogenic cytokines such as transforming growth factor beta (TGF-β) and its downstream modulator, connective tissue growth factor (CTGF), collagen and stellate cell activation (13–16).

Epidemiologic studies on caffeine have been inconsistent in demonstrating a protective effect in liver disease since other caffeine-containing beverages such as tea have not shown to be protective (19–21). Similarly, in our study, the inverse association with caffeine became null after adjustment for coffee, suggesting that ingredients of coffee other than caffeine appear to be responsible for this beverage’s effect on risk reduction. Furthermore, other caffeine-containing beverages like green tea and black tea had no significant effects with cirrhosis mortality in this study."

qiqing··on Brains Sweep Themselves Clean of Toxins During Sleep (2013)
Three senior officials lose their jobs at APA after US torture scandal (The Guardian)

"As the American Psychological Association copes with the damage reaped by an independent investigation that found it complicit in US torture, the group announced on Tuesday that its chief executive officer, its deputy CEO and its communications chief are no longer with the APA.

All three were implicated in the 542-page report issued this month by former federal prosecutor David Hoffman, who concluded that APA leaders “colluded” with the US department of defense and aided the CIA in loosening professional ethics and other guidelines to permit psychologist participation in torture."

Link: http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2015/jul/14/apa-senior-of...

qiqing··on Brains Sweep Themselves Clean of Toxins During Sleep (2013)
Original source: asked doctor for modafinil to enable working harder for more hours. Doctor said, No, you might think it's a good idea now, but if you're back here a couple months later with depression, you'll realize it's not worth the risk.

Looking up some primary source just now: http://www.oncologypractice.com/fileadmin/content_pdf/cpn/ar...

(for some reason the UI doesn't let me reply to the reply, so here goes)

Now that I'm looking around at papers, it seems like there is evidence that it helps patients who are already depressed get some energy back.

qiqing··on Brains Sweep Themselves Clean of Toxins During Sleep (2013)
Personally, I enjoy the flavor of Swiss water decaf more than others (and by reasoning of the "Dorito effect," that flavor may have something nontrivial to do with the nutrients left in it; it also happens to not use additional solvents).

That said, a lot of the risky solvents used in the usual methods of making decaf are no longer commercially used these days, so I don't think there's a serious health risk in drinking any ol' decaf you want.

qiqing··on Brains Sweep Themselves Clean of Toxins During Sleep (2013)
A non-precise answer: a surprisingly large amount if you're careful about which parts to remove and if you do it really, really early in life. ;)

In adults (or even adolescents) though, not as much luck.

In the case of hemispherectomies on Rasmussen's patients, you can analogize it as: people are dual-core by default. If you remove one of the cores early enough in life (like <5 yrs old), you can re-route the wiring so that processing can done by one of the cores, and still be pretty much normal. But whatever subtle thing is lost when if we don't do parallel processing like we usually do -- that things is pretty subtle to test for as well.

qiqing··on Brains Sweep Themselves Clean of Toxins During Sleep (2013)
Thank you for the correction. I mis-remembered a minor detail from a lecture that was 9 years ago, and have find/replaced cAMP -> adenosine in the above post. The gist of the post, though, remains the same. That is, caffeine competitively inhibits receptors that gate ion channels, and the mechanism of tolerance is an increase in the concentration of the thing that it competitively binds.

(My thesis was on auditory cognition and I haven't touched ion channel biophysics in that long. I have a long-ago memory that adenosine (now corrected) operated as a retrograde transmitter, though since I'm probably not going to spend my afternoon looking for the citations, I'll delete as well for now. Not because I believe it's wrong, just that I can't immediately back it up.)

Are you still doing research yourself or have you left for startup land like most of HN?

qiqing··on Brains Sweep Themselves Clean of Toxins During Sleep (2013)
I think it's useful to think of it not as a "bad thing" but as a very high-interest loan from your future self.

In moments of weakness and pushing a deadline, I have sometimes rationalize the trade-off of future time/health to present time, and sometimes, that sticks me with tolerance that it takes time to wean off. I have made a conscious effort to quit caffeine dozens of times in my life, and the most recent time it has stuck, and I plan to stick with it. The thing is, when I gain "time" with caffeine, it's not necessarily time with high-quality cognition or productivity compared to my well-rested self, and it's easy to forget to take that into account when you're making trade-off decisions when tired. You still perform like a tired person, you're just not subjectively feeling the tiredness.

FWIW, drinking decaf gives you the health benefits of coffee with 5% (kinda negligible) amounts of caffeine.

← PreviousPage 6 of 10Next →