HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

qnleigh

2,052 karma · joined March 12, 2023

submissionscomments
qnleigh··on Sharing AI progress in mathematics
Can you elaborate/give context? I haven't heard of this problem before, but curious to hear from someone who has.
qnleigh··on Sharing AI progress in mathematics
I was talking with a number of physicists this evening, and of the papers who's problem statement we understood, I don't think any of them will have near-term applications. For most of them, they were results that I think the physics community believed to be true, and the paper provides the first rigorous proof. For several it was news to me that they weren't already theorems! These results are important advances in mathematical physics, but they don't tend to have much impact on experiment.

From what I can tell, all of the physics results here are quite mathematical. But I am very curious how the internal model they used would perform on more applied problems.

qnleigh··on Sharing AI progress in mathematics
> it would be the single greatest advance in math

Did you mean to not qualify that? That is a bold statement indeed.

qnleigh··on LeCun has "zero concerns" about AI wiping out humanity, recent "rogue" incidents
Can you name something specific that you think LLMs will not be able to achieve? Do you just mean consciousness or are there any specific intellectual tasks?
qnleigh··on Math's pedagogical curse – Grant Sanderson [video] (2023)
> After scratching the itch of knowing that something's been written completely rigorously, it's easy to call a work done when maybe we shouldn't call it done yet. And there's contexts where this is maybe OK, research comes to mind...

It's funny, because all of the advice he gives in the rest of the video would be amazing to apply to research papers as well. I've had people discourage me from writing research papers pedagogically because it is "unusual," which really meant that it would be looked down upon. It's kind of tragic that the norm is to write research papers that strip away the human details of how a definition is motivated or how something was discovered. This kind of information is usually only shared through in-person discussions or occasionally research presentations, but it is often the core knowledge that enables one to do research in a given field.

It's a great video though. He gives a little checklist of ways to check if your work is clear:

- Do definitions have motivating examples?

- Do proofs [or other results] feel rediscoverable?

- Is there personality?

- Are core ideas illustrated with diagrams?

- Is relative importance highlighted?

...

He also gives a beautiful example of how powerful it is to give a motivating example for an abstraction before introducing it. I really got the sense from watching this of what makes him such a great math educator. Highly recommend his YouTube channel 3Blue1Brown for anyone who hasn't heard of him

qnleigh··on Vote on which of Hacker News' challenges for AI have been met
I wouldn't have guessed foot either, and I'm a human.*

*In case there's any doubt, there are three r's in strawberry.

qnleigh··on Responsible Release of AI-Generated Mathematics
If your life's work were to get outsourced to AI and you lost your job/the opportunity to do it, I doubt you would make this argument.

I would rather live in a world where mathematicians get the opportunity to do math with AI, rather than AI companies doing the most important mathematical work and leaving them behind. I hope this for all professions that people want to do.

qnleigh··on Responsible Release of AI-Generated Mathematics
I see two separate arguments in favor of this logic:

1. Academic mathematics has traditionally been meritocratic, and this is a good thing. If you work hard and demonstrate results, then you will be given further opportunities to do math research and the resources to do it. We are concerned that AI will reward money and access to frontier models instead.

2. There is a general concern that AI could lead to massive accumulations of wealth (see concerns of massive job displacement). AI companies claim that they want to raise standards of living and benefit humanity, which means that they will need to share their resources and wealth in some way. If they effectively destroy the mathematical community be racing ahead and taking all the major results for themselves, that does not bode well for the rest of us. It seems like a great opportunity to show the world how AI will benefit humanity rather than replace it.

qnleigh··on GLM-5.3 and the spread of advanced cyber capabilities
Wait I have been wondering about this. How do banks make sure that a cyberattack couldn't change the numbers in people's bank accounts? How do you know that they're safeguards are sufficient?
qnleigh··on GLM-5.3 and the spread of advanced cyber capabilities
Many of us concluded independently that bioweapons were a serious risk of widely-available AI. Like I remember what I was doing when this occurred to me and who I talked to about it first.

I've seen this sentiment in many discussion here lately, that anyone concerned about these kinds of risks is blindly falling for marketing hype and not thinking for themselves. Please give people the benefit of the doubt and engage with what they are saying. Because if you don't think that bioweapons/nerve agents are a serious concern, I would sleep better if you could convince me if this!

qnleigh··on Gravity seems holographic. What does that mean for reality?
Yes, lots and lots of stuff. For all we know, space may extend infinitely in all directions.
qnleigh··on I'm the mom in that viral Giants clip. Let me tell you about my husband
I'm imagining someone who actually did have a deadbeat father growing up then seeing messaging on social media about deadbeat men. Probably their social media feeds create a vicious cycle that only solidifies their distrust of men. It is just showing them things that they saw to be true since they were young children.
qnleigh··on The World as a Hologram
This is one of the original papers that described the concept of holography, which is a central concept in quantum gravity research. It's a neat paper because although the subject matter is highly technical, the author describes the basic idea largely using undergraduate physics and without a lot of fancy math.

Posting since there was some interest in a related Quanta article here recently https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49845998

qnleigh··on Gravity seems holographic. What does that mean for reality?
Susskind's original paper is shockingly readable, at least the first section. It doesn't use a lot of fancy math or derivations to justify holography. Mostly it uses basic concepts from undergraduate physics to show how the idea of holography is consistent and makes sense, despite it seeming incredibly counterintuitive at first glance.

For instance, figure 3 shows how you can't hide a black hole behind another black hole, which has implications for how a 3D universe can be completely encoded in a 2D region.

https://arxiv.org/html/hep-th/9409089v2

qnleigh··on Ask HN: Any nerds out there who've read a lot of research papers?
Oh this is a super-important question, and I wish I'd gotten the following advice much earlier than I did:

1. First read the abstract and conclusion

2. Then flip through the figures and their captions, and try to understand them as best as you can (though this doesn't work for all papers)

3. Make a deliberate decision about whether it's worth it to dive into the details and read the full text.

LLMs are incredibly useful for parsing dense literature, but I think it's better to ask specific questions about the paper, jargon, equations etc. rather than to have it summarize the paper for you. Summaries are often shallow or even misleading, and they rob you of the opportunity to engage actively with the paper.

qnleigh··on Meta takes down a critical video about meta AI Glasses after filming at Meta
To me he crossed a line by asking the woman to turn around and then crouching down to film her butt. That is a really creepy thing to do and a lot of women would find that threatening. Ask a female friend how they would feel if you find that surprising.
qnleigh··on The Advisory Group on Mathematics and Artificial Intelligence
OpenAI put together an advisory panel to provide guidance on how to release their results. Where do you see bullying?
qnleigh··on The Advisory Group on Mathematics and Artificial Intelligence
The composition of the panel might give us some clues as to the nature of OpenAI's unreleased results. Some of Ed Witten's work is quite closely related to the Yang Mills existence and mass gap problem, which is one of the remaining Millennium problems. I went through the list of panel members and asked an LLM to associate each member of the panel with one or two millennium problems. Here is the resulting count:

Hodge conjecture: 5 Birch and Swinnerton-Dyer Conjecture: 3 Navier-Stokes: 2 P vs NP: 1 Yang-Mills existence and mass gap: 2

So this gives a bit of further evidence that they made progress on the Hodge and Birch and Swinnerton-Dyer conjectures. Maybe also Yang-Mills.

Notably absent is the Reimann hypothesis.

qnleigh··on Why do we need human mathematicians anymore?
You realize this is a guest post, right? Terrence Tao didn't write it. He's been using his blog to facilitate discussions about math's future.
qnleigh··on Frontier Labs Are Selling Garbage to Fools in Washington
I'm frustrated by articles like this that categorically dismiss the risks of AI in security. If you don't trust OpenAI's and Anthropic's motives, that's fine, you probably shouldn't. But don't tell me that there's nothing to be worried about; we need an alternative proposal.

So let's stop talking past each other and engage with the arguments on both "sides." For example, let's discuss how to ensure competition and availability of open-source models in the long-run while giving the world time to prepare for the immediate security risks of agent swarms.

qnleigh··on OpenAI agents carried out an undisclosed attack on RubyGems
It's possible that they didn't notice.
qnleigh··on We must pace the frontier
Waitwaitwait multiple millennium problems? What was the other one???

Increasing a bound on the fraction of Reimann zeros on the critical line doesn't count; even Anthropic says they don't think this line of work will lead to a solution.

qnleigh··on We must pace the frontier
> OpenAI / Anthropic models have largely stopped advancing

I'm shocked anyone could conclude this. This year it became common for people to entirely delegate coding to AI (I know many competent programmers/researchers who do this now). Progress in math has just been insane. An internal model at OAI just resolved one of the most celebrated open problems in mathematics. If anything, progress has accelerated.

qnleigh··on The little holes in your bread are telling you something
That was interesting. Highlights for me:

> The Chorleywood bread process allows the use of lower-protein wheats and reduces processing time,[5] the system being able to produce a loaf of bread from flour to sliced and packaged form in about three and a half hours. This is achieved through the addition of vitamin C, fat, yeast, and intense mechanical working by high-speed mixers, not feasible in a small-scale kitchen.

> The process significantly reduced fermentation time and allowed greater use of non-imported wheat, which helped reduce the price of bread.[4] According to a representative of the British Federation of Bakers, "UK bread is around the cheapest in the world."[5]

As of 2011, 80% of bread made in the United Kingdom used the process, which has also spread to other countries such as Australia, South Africa, South America, Turkey and France.

qnleigh··on Navier-Stokes – Tristan Buckmaster [pdf]
He doesn't seem to be after the prize himself. In this statement he credits the approach of another two researchers:

> I believe Luis Mart´ınez-Zoroa deserves a Fields Medal.

qnleigh··on Navier-Stokes – Tristan Buckmaster [pdf]
> It was also said that if OpenAI posted after us, they would say that we deserved the Clay Prize, and that we were the “closest humans to the problem”. I declined both offers. I said that if OpenAI released its result in the way proposed I would go public with what happened. The reply was, “Why would you ruin your career?” I replied that I am an academic, and asked why he thought going public would ruin my career. The reply was, “If you don’t want me to be nice, then I don’t have to be nice.”

I'm not even sure what to say to this, but I think this should be widely known if it is indeed what happened.

qnleigh··on Formalizing Fermat's Last Theorem
I wonder what he's feeling about this. Formalizing Fermat's last theorem was a huge undertaking, and has been a big part of his career for some time. Now the announcement has been made, and even if there is more work that he wants to do, he has in some ways been scooped by an LLM.

Fortunately he is a very well-established mathematician, so career-wise he will likely be fine. But if an early-career mathematician gets scooped this badly it could be career-ending.

qnleigh··on Ask HN: GitHub employees what's going on? Why?
This is no excuse. Prioritizing new features so far above reliability is exactly what makes most Microsoft products infuriating to use.
qnleigh··on How I use LLMs to learn complex topics
Learning is an unproductive use of your time??? No one knows how LLMs will change things, but that sounds like terrible advice.
qnleigh··on How I use LLMs to learn complex topics
> Another one is having the LLM quiz you on your topics of interest

This is a great idea. I'm going to try it.

← PreviousPage 2 of 17Next →