HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

qqii

710 karma · joined July 27, 2016

Mainly interested in having interesting conversations.

PMs via reddit, at the same username. Or find me elsewhere.

submissionscomments
qqii··on Update on beta testing payments in Signal
Signal is still not a good way for phishing/ransom anyways.

Users would either have to already have the attacker in their contacts list or enable sealed sender. Enabling and funding a cryptocurrency wallet is going to be difficult. Even for WeChat who's payment service is popular it only captures 40% market share and as a result generally people are more educated about the risks.

qqii··on Update on beta testing payments in Signal
> someone comes up with a playbook convincing nontechnical users they need to send mobile coin to them in order to keep using signal.

This sounds pretty unlikely, as long as signal does not integrate a payment processor (and they've made no indication they will) the majority of users will not have enabled or funded their cryptocurrency wallet(s) (whichever cryptocurrency they settle on).

Funding MobileCoin requires steps of non insignificant difficulty, not to mention Signal's trust model of using your contacts by default.

qqii··on Update on beta testing payments in Signal
I think signal is and have been very clear that they won't remain "just a chat app". I don't have anything against cryptocurrency but I'm taking this as an opportunity to evaluate my alternatives.
qqii··on Update on beta testing payments in Signal
Companies is one thing, individuals are another. Rough estimating using the people I know barely anyone has or uses PayPal.
qqii··on Update on beta testing payments in Signal
And to take it even further, doesn't this bend the AGPLv3 licence to an extent?
qqii··on Update on beta testing payments in Signal
To play Signal's advocate, MobileCoin is one of the only cryptocurrencies that meets their requirements. The only other cryptocurrency that I know of that might come close is Grin.

The details of the distribution are lacking but as a beta it meets the experience they're going for - it's not as if they'd choose something that doesn't meet their requirements for the beta.

qqii··on An Introduction to Minecraft Modding
Yes, and the official and community name for that is a resource pack or addon.
qqii··on An Introduction to Minecraft Modding
Calling this modding is technically true but misleading, modding commonly refers to Java mods and not resource packs.
qqii··on Social networks neither ‘social’ nor ‘networks’ – what should we call them?
Opinion amplifiers.
qqii··on In Defense of Signal
As the article describes you cannot spend any transaction until a fixed number of block confirmations.

This is a non issue if you already have coins in your wallet but it's not a very pleasant first time experience.

qqii··on In Defense of Signal
I get the point but it's misleading to attribute the entire year to integrating payments.

The server code base has historically had periods of non public updates and doing a quick grep of the commit log payments first appears in October 2020.

It's been clear since 2017 that Moxie has wanted to integrate payments to "stay competitive", so such effort was always on the schedule.

qqii··on In Defense of Signal
They're not doing payment proceeding, it's just a wallet.
qqii··on Could index funds be “worse than Marxism”?
Even if you could tell a big winner in advance, the time volatility in return is still a risk factor.
qqii··on Could index funds be “worse than Marxism”?
This argument only seems to hold if everyone was a passive investor. Also not all investors can take the same amount of risk, which naturally results in passive investors.
qqii··on Could index funds be “worse than Marxism”?
Exactly, those that are interested in the performance of a specific company will invest and effectively have the same proportion of power as if the passive investors didn't exist.
qqii··on Could index funds be “worse than Marxism”?
I had a similar thought when reading the article.

As an example individual or smaller investors simply cannot create lower risk options like an index fund by themselves. We don't have the ability to index specific markets and apply a personal weighting. The broad options are: low risk index funds from a broker, medium risk managed funds or high risk individual investments. Most individuals cannot tolerate the risks so have no option but to choose from a list of index funds.

qqii··on In Defense of Signal
I hate that theory for a number of reasons.

It avoids so much evidence of Signals past controversial changes, Moxie's past interviews about MobileCoin and his current tweets or the amount of work done to create MobileCoin. Even a quick look into it creates many holes that can only be filled with speculation.

qqii··on In Defense of Signal
Signal's developers are not MobileCoin's developers though.

All Signal's developers have done is integrate the work of MobileCoin into their backend (fog) and client (fog wallet).

qqii··on In Defense of Signal
You have to begin wjth the premise that Moxie would like to add payment integration to Signal, in which cake making another app doesn't fulfill the goal.

You could also argue against the premise that a secure chat app needs payment integration, but that's one to bring up on twitter against Moxie.

qqii··on In Defense of Signal
Not to excuse signal but has the response really been justified for a beta feature being tested in a single country? The signal press release and activity on the forums makes it clear that they're asking for feedback.

Their intentions were never hidden either, you can see interviews dating 2017 thst matches their current stance.

qqii··on In Defense of Signal
I think the article does a decent job at explaining why signal didn't go with existing privacy cryptocurrencies. The two points are:

* Signal wants to make money (and they cite Tor as an example of the problems of not making money)

* Monero's isn't fast enough.

The first point obviously isn't really very good defense and the second point could be considered refuted by this tweet[0].

Monero is simply unlikely to reduce their block time or the number of confirmation blocks. Given the work in integrating SGX, Stellar Consensus and fog calling it a scam is going too far but its not a good look for sure.

[0]: https://nitter.dark.fail/moxie/status/1379560902463119361#m

qqii··on In Defense of Signal
I'm glad someone has written this article as the converse on HN has been overly negative. This is an article I would have probably written so I'd like to add:

> Third, private transaction retrieval requires downloading blocks to your phone and manually filtering them. If you’ve ever used the Monero CakeWallet, you’ll know it can sometimes take quite a while before everything is synced and you actually see your full balance. MobileCoin solves this by using fog, which allows for instant and private transaction retrieval without putting a heavy computational load on your phone.

MyMonero and OpenMonero is this kind of light wallet and has similar privacy guarentees. Fog is still vulnerable to timing based attacks.

> Even if you assume that Intel SGX is completely broken in every way possible, MobileCoin provides at least the same amount of privacy as Monero. The purpose of SGX is to provide defense-in-depth by potentially mitigating heuristic analysis that CryptoNote protocols are vulnerable to.

Federation fundimentally offers less privacy guarentees and relies on trusting the nodes and fog servers. Malicious actors can perform all kinds of timing attacks.

> If anyone has read through Josh Goldbard’s comments on Hacker News, you will undoubtedly understand the frustration here. In multiple instances, he simply avoids answering a question altogether in his replies. I don’t believe he is trying to hide any foul play here.

This is quite an optemistic take, even other cryptocurrencies are more transparent about their initial token sale price, companies and amount purchased, distribution schedule, etc.

The article also doesn't touch on MobileCoin's lack of credit for Monero[0] and the founding engineer's now deleted post about the Monero codebase[1].

[0]: https://nitter.dark.fail/fluffypony/status/13795592735046410...

[1]: https://nitter.dark.fail/fluffypony/status/13796045413903441...

qqii··on Et Tu, Signal?
It's been a while since I checked it out but key management on encrypted group chats.
qqii··on Signal Adds Cryptocurrency Support
How so? When I consider how to build it on top of an existing smart contact platform you'd have to have a whole extra, nonstandard layer for key rotation and you'd miss out on privacy guarentees. If we assume their goal of privacy and sub 10s finality I can't see how they could have done it on an existing cryptocurrency.

What they've done is essentially take Monero as a base, remove mining and use Stellar Consensus then solve any new privacy issues that arise.

qqii··on Et Tu, Signal?
Okay, so do the current node operators publish their peering requirements?

Given your description it sounds like governance is whatever the MobileCoin foundation and its partners dictates. Unlike the consensus in this thread I think there's a lot to like and explore for a privacy token that chooses a different set of tradeoffs but the opaque governance, token holder distribution/circulating supply and lack of acknowledgement to the Monero project really sets it back.

qqii··on Signal Adds Cryptocurrency Support
It should be obvious by now that signal is aiming for a different balance of user friendliness and privacy. At this point it seems unlikely that they'd change their minds on phone numbers.
qqii··on Signal Adds Cryptocurrency Support
You'd be suprised, WeChat for example is almost a platform of its own.
qqii··on Signal Adds Cryptocurrency Support
Do you have a link to where they're discouraging people to use it to store wealth?
qqii··on Signal Adds Cryptocurrency Support
On most clients spending and receiving is instant.

What takes a maximum of 2 minutes on monero is waiting for your received balance to become available.

qqii··on Signal Adds Cryptocurrency Support
I'm actually going to go out on a limb and defend their choice of MobileCoin.

Signal has always been a decent privacy/convenience tradeoff and MobileCoin is no different. Features like phone numbers and contact uploading were always a user friendly tradeoff. They also seem to trust SGX.

Monero's isn't slow by any means but isn't fast either. UI changes can alleviate the issue but being unable to spend your entire balance until the next block is a step back in UX.

ZCash's lack of privacy by default doesn't fit with Signal's E2E by default ethos.

Using most privacy coins on a mobile device with limited storage is a privacy tradeoff no matter how you cut it.

The reality is that integrating a cryptocurrency for payments into Signal was probably the actual misstep rather than their selection of which token to use.

← PreviousPage 3 of 15Next →