HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

r-johnv

118 karma · joined November 10, 2023

submissionscomments
r-johnv··on Any application that can be written in a system language, eventually will be
uv is a good example of this.
r-johnv··on The hidden engineering of runways
I absolutely love that Grady includes full transcripts of his videos.

It's much faster to read the article than watch the video, even though that hurts him by 1 view.

I just watched parts of the video after reading because I wanted to see his explanations.

One of the few really good creators out there.

r-johnv··on FTC Finalizes Order Banning GM from Sharing Driver Data
Important to note that it does not include a fine.

So the penalty for breaking the law is being forced to follow the law for 5-20 years? (Or am I simplifying it too much and missing something?)

r-johnv··on 65% of Hacker News posts have negative sentiment, and they outperform
Thank you for pointing that out.

I'm recalibrating my own behavior to upvote more.

Is it the desired behavior of HN that silent upvotes are for agreement? (Instead of a positive comment that doesn't add substantially to the discourse?)

r-johnv··on RemoveWindowsAI
Which are these? Information online didn't seem very clear on that split?
r-johnv··on Xkcd: Python Environment (2018)
Uv and uvx have been such game changers when we tried to distribute our python packages.
r-johnv··on Scientists may have solved why this ancient, advanced civilization vanished
"New clues as to why the ancient and advances Indus valley civilization vanished" is the original article title.

More informative, less clickbaity.

Other than that, I quite enjoyed the article and the parallels to how modern cities might shift with changes in climate patterns.

r-johnv··on Scientists may have solved why this ancient, advanced civilization vanished
https://archive.ph/WLV0n
r-johnv··on Scientists Found a Weird Way to Make People Kinder: Add Batman
Probably a better title would be "Found a way to make people aware of opportunities for kindness"

The hypothesis that they propose is that 'the addition of an unusual character like Batman on the subway made people who otherwise may have been lost in their own thoughts or podcast look around and be more aware of people around them, and this more likely to notice the pregnant woman and offer their seat'

I'm looking forward to the follow up paper to test the hypothesis.

r-johnv··on Tiny Electric Motor Is as Powerful as Four Tesla Motors Combined
Does it need liquid cooling in order to sustain operation at that power density?

I see ports on its edges that look like fluid connectors.

r-johnv··on OpenAI Set to Challenge Google with New ChatGPT Atlas Browser
So Google did roll out some of this in it's built in Gemini for chrome.

I'm not too sure how I activated it, but on one occasion it did launch into a search of my history when I was trying in the address bar.

It looks like Google is just silently adding the useful features into their AI. Product (like they did with the ai overviews)

r-johnv··on Why China is winning the trade war
https://archive.ph/KHusi
r-johnv··on Show HN: Bible Both Ways – See how the Bible can justify any moral claim
Love the idea

I found though that yielding just one response per side seemed pretty weak, especially when it's not always picking the best arguments for each side. (And not returning enough of the passage to fully show the argument)

It doesn't sound thorough but rather just like it's picking the first vaguely similar set of lines that it could find.

I wonder if subtle tweaks to your prompts could make it significantly more convincing?

r-johnv··on Ask HN: What is a passkey and why is everybody asking for one lately?
People who take the time to genuinely write out and present an answer.

I had a fair understanding of passkeys before reading your response, but I too learnt something from it.

Thank you.

r-johnv··on Technical Debt vs. Architecture Debt: Don't Confuse Them
This was exactly my thoughts.

The article proposes a new word 'architecture debt' for most of what people consider 'tech debt', and then tries to say that architecture debt is a more serious concern than tech debt.

r-johnv··on Hydrogel-based expanding pill for weight loss shows promising results in trial
Could you share a link to what the pill you take is? (Specifically how many mg to have the effect you're describing)
r-johnv··on Highest bridge unveiled at more than 2,000ft above ground
I'm glad I clicked your link though. That I-91 bridge is beautiful.
r-johnv··on Laptops create systems. Phones feed algorithms. The asymmetry determines power
I agree. Good core idea, but it feels quite stretched.

Most of the examples used to justify creation vs consumption can also be explained by low scale vs high scale (cost sensitive at high scale) or portability.

r-johnv··on Laptops create systems. Phones feed algorithms. The asymmetry determines power
Personally I make use of it heavily in how the TV is used at home. An old laptop with Firefox+unlock origin connected via HDMI.

I invested in two wireless handheld keyboard+pointer inputs to match the different input styles of me and my wife.

Completely bypasses all ads with less effort than setting up a pihole or torrent+Plex server, and the bonus is avoiding the surveillance from the TV's 'consumption OS'

r-johnv··on Are touchscreens in cars dangerous?
Where is that located in the car? Near the gear stick I assume?

Does it move a mouse pointer on the screen?

r-johnv··on Are touchscreens in cars dangerous?
That is so sad. The knob on my CX30 is such a favourite feature for me that I want to rule out car models that don't have a physical input in that location.

Sad to hear that I'm in a minority for loving that input.

r-johnv··on Show HN: Robot MCP Server – Connect Any Language Model and ROS Robots Using MCP
Thank you for trying it out. Do you have any feedback on how it worked for you, and things that you would hope to see in it?
r-johnv··on Show HN: Robot MCP Server – Connect Any Language Model and ROS Robots Using MCP
Conflicting commands from multiple clients is one of the open questions at the moment.

We're also building out a technical steering committee to help guide our direction on topics like this. Safety is a big category where having direction from across the community will be important.

r-johnv··on Show HN: Robot MCP Server – Connect Any Language Model and ROS Robots Using MCP
It should be possible to do it from one client. The MCP server would handle the parallel connections.

We're using websockets as the interface between the server and the robot itself, which to the best of my exploration does have the ability for simultaneous connections.

r-johnv··on Show HN: Robot MCP Server – Connect Any Language Model and ROS Robots Using MCP
(Mentioning beforehand that we're still very early when it comes to the exact behavior of each language model)

So far, I've observed that for Claude and Gemini, which are what we've been testing most with, the Language model has been pretty good at recognizing its a faulty initial interpretation when it queries more information from the system.

Running out of tokens is a more significant issue. We saw it a lot when we queried imaged topics, which led us to try writing better image interpreters within the MCP server itself (credit to my collaborators at the Hanyang university in Korea) to defend the context window. Free tiers of the language models also run out of tokens quite quickly.

PS - Thank you for the questions, I'm enjoying talking about this here on HN with people who look at it critically and challenge us!

r-johnv··on Show HN: Robot MCP Server – Connect Any Language Model and ROS Robots Using MCP
Adding direct links to two of the videos of the MCP server in action.

This is the video of interacting with and debugging an industrial robot. (A few of the other comments here have been talking about this, that we see some amount of what looks like emergent behavior) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SrHzC5InJDA

This is a video from a collaborator research lab controlling a Unitree Go (robot dog) https://youtu.be/RW9_FgfxWzs?si=o7tIHs5eChEy9glI

r-johnv··on Show HN: Robot MCP Server – Connect Any Language Model and ROS Robots Using MCP
I'm actually reviewing a PR right now that enables the MCP server to have a library of common robots with a specification file for each robot containing important context to the language model.

The demo video with the Unitree Go (robot dog) uses this approach to give the LLM additional context of the custom poses available to it.

r-johnv··on Show HN: Robot MCP Server – Connect Any Language Model and ROS Robots Using MCP
Not starting from clean slate improves the interaction significantly. I started from a clean slate on the industrial robot video in order to highlight how much is possible even when starting from one.
r-johnv··on Show HN: Robot MCP Server – Connect Any Language Model and ROS Robots Using MCP
Thank you!

The underlying stack definitely can connect to multiple robots simultaneously. Our current implementation is sequential, where the language model can connect from one robot to the next (and then back).

But it is definitely possible for us to write it to be simultaneous as well.

r-johnv··on Show HN: Robot MCP Server – Connect Any Language Model and ROS Robots Using MCP
Thank you! This has been an exciting project to work on!

For the industrial robot (in the video on the main readme page) I intentionally gave Claude no context beforehand. All of the inferences that you see there are based on information that it got through the MCP tools that let it analyze the ROS topics and services on the robot.

In fact, I had a starting prompt to ignore all context from previous conversations because this looked to be like an example of emergent behavior and I wanted to confirm that it was not picking things from my earlier conversations!

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →