HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

racional

872 karma · joined April 17, 2024

submissionscomments
racional··on United States discloses nuclear warhead numbers; restores nuclear transparency
You can try having a fruitful discussion with them if you want to.

Based on the carefully worded sibling comment to yours - it would seem they have other goals in mind.

racional··on United States discloses nuclear warhead numbers; restores nuclear transparency
Only one side has had meaningful advances.

That's not true, as Ukraine has scored significant non-territorial advances (like forcing most of the occupier's fleet to retreat from Crimea) in the same time frame.

Also you're setting an arbitrary time window of 1 year (when if we want to evaluate the conflict meaningfully, we need to look at how things are moving now compared to the start of the conflict. Which is definitely not the outcome Russia intended. And ignoring Russia's considerable losses in achieving the paltry gains that it has (which are very much part of the attrition equation), etc.

What never works out is a smaller country winning a war of attrition against a (much) bigger opponent.

You're missing the point -- the smaller country doesn't need to "win" the war of attrition (in terms of effecting a complete reversal) in order to win the conflict. It just needs to outlast the occupier. For which there are no end of precedents in history, recent and ancient. Including (ironically) the U.S. withdraw from Afghanistan, which is apparently what gave Putin the gigantic (for him) hard-on that inspired him to sign his country for the same inevitable fate in the first place (but with much higher cost and KIA/WIA rates to his people along the way).

Did you catch Zelensky the other day? He knows where this is going.

I don't see any significance to that quote.

But it does seem pretty clear which side you're cheering for, in any case.

racional··on Ask HN: Is it possible to make FAANG salaries without working there?
Believe it or not you get over this.

You can get over it if you dig the day-to-day of running a business. But not everyone digs it.

Everyone should attempt to start a small business or a side consulting gig.

No they shouldn't because as an endeavor it just doesn't appeal to lots of people.

The "everyone should try and become good at the stuff I think is fun" tone of this response is just weird, and grossly out of touch with observations of human nature.

racional··on Ties between Google's Project Nimbus and Israel's military
More to the point -- the land was plenty "prosperous" to the people who lived there. Whatever uses for that land that outsiders deem to be prosperous (for them) are completely irrelevant.
racional··on 10% of Cubans left Cuba between 2022 and 2023
Don't make such far-flung analogies.

The Russia/USSR transition is more akin to that of the Roman Republic to the Principate/Dominate. Or the different stages of other closely related empires throughout history after dealing with internal regime, partial reversals and so forth.

Even Putin sees Russia/USSR as parts of a organic historic continuum, and this is a key component of his rhetoric. That the USSR's territorial losses are Russia's losses and must be reversed if Russia it to "save face" and so on.

racional··on United States discloses nuclear warhead numbers; restores nuclear transparency
Also, you do realize that Russia is currently winning in Ukraine

They are not "currently winning". By any objective measure, the war on the ground is currently a stalement.

Only problem is that in the long term -- stalemates never work out for the occupiers.

In Russia's case: If the situation continues as it does, and moving at the glacial pace that it does, and draining 10 percent of its GDP every year -- they will ultimately have to give up on their optional neocolonial adventure, pick up their toys and go home.

racional··on Ties between Google's Project Nimbus and Israel's military
Looks like we disagree axiomatically about certain things.

But life is short, so I'll just respond to one particular item for now:

The only problem is that some pushing for Arab nationalism couldn't stomach the existence of Israel or Jews in general.

No, the "only problem" was a bunch of armed foreigners attempting to carve an ethnostate out of their ancestral territory. They could have been Greek, Italian, Russian, Turkish, Persian -- it wouldn't have mattered a bit. It was the usurpation of their land, their resources and their rights that took issue with, and rightly so.

So no, it wasn't "because antisemitism".

racional··on The Data That Powers A.I. Is Disappearing Fast
https://archive.ph/EEQQB
racional··on Ties between Google's Project Nimbus and Israel's military
The Nakba was (and still is) a Nakba because ...

The colonizers sought to impose an objectively unfair partition plan (granting them far more valuable territory and resources in proportion to their population at the time), with the muscular support of their European friends.

The Palestinians rejected this "proposal" outright of course, exactly as any self-respecting people would. Exactly as the Algerians rejected France's proposed "partition" of their historic homeland, and the Vietnamese (by and large) rejected America's proposed carve-out of theirs, etc (just to pick a few notable exactly from approximately the same time frame).

And yes, they made some poor choices of friends (as they readily acknowledge), and woefully miscalculated their own strengths and capabilities and so on. And then there are other factors you're carefully not mentioning, such as the expulsions and massacres already underway in Jaffa, Deir-Yassin and elsewhere before this supposedly entirely unprovoked and one-sided "attack".

But there's no reason to keep punishing the current population for these decisions, and exploiting this history (and the continuing indifference of both their so-called friends in the Arab world and the international community at large) for the sake of current and future land gains. Which is basically what the continuing (having of course never really ended) Nakba (that certain very notable public figures are proudly and openly hoping to officially upgrade to Nakba 2.0, in their own words -- do we need to name any names here?) is really about.

And whatever is happening in the ground today (and however much blame can justly attributed to both sides) -- there's nothing to be gained from nullifying history, or reducing it to such trite oversimplifications as in the parent comment.

racional··on The only tourist in Moldova
Wasn't its industry developed?

The exact same justification/apology used by every colonizing power ever (including the U.S. and all the European powers), of course.

Welcome to the club.

racional··on The only tourist in Moldova
Nifty diagrams, but they should be taken with a huge grain of salt of course.

For example it shows EN/DE and EN/NO as having equivalent distances (49) when obviously EN/DE are much closer than either is to NO (in any holistic comparison of the three languages). It also shows IT/FR as being significantly closer (31) than IT/SP (40) when that's also plainly not the case -- again if we consider the distance between respective language pairs holistically (which includes a whole lot of other factors like phonemic footprint, meter, etc).

In short this reads like pretty much the kind of post one would expect from a "brain candy" site like this.

Less harshly (assuming good indent on the author's part), it demonstrates the pitfalls of relying on a single score (which in itself can be subject to all kinds of weighting and sampling biases) simply because it's a "score" and we're all supposed to be "data-driven" in our analyses these days.

But again -- nifty diagrams, and they do at least give a feel for the topic of mutual intelligibility and language distance (even if the scores themselves don't seem to be particularly meaningful).

racional··on The only tourist in Moldova
Do share a few links to stories about the border town rampage and any other particularly notable incidents, if you can.
racional··on Russian Missile Attack Levels Children's Hospital
My words shall mean whatever you wish them to mean.
racional··on The only tourist in Moldova
The situation with articles and country names in German is quite different. The article is essentially affixed to many country names as a standard part of the language, and the lack or presence of the article does not immediately convey regional or sub-national status like it generally does in English.

If anything the connotation is the opposite from English -- articles are generally more attached to certain countries for which Germany has historically had significant relations (for good reasons or bad). In modern times though, it's just another fussy part of the language that one is obliged to put up with and not give a second thought to. One simply has to say "im Frankreich", "in der Türkei", "im Iran" and so forth (but also not attach the article to most other countries), and that's all there is to it.

I wish I could point to an authoritative reference for this, but that's impossible nowadays that we have the zombie internet and everything online has been reduced to shitty apps, flashcards and "didya know?" pages.

racional··on The only tourist in Moldova
English is spoken very widely in Ukraine in fact, and was just promoted to an official status (not as a primary language, but to a secondary official status nonetheless) in the past month.
racional··on The only tourist in Moldova
I'll believe it when I see it in sources other than, well, that website that some people seem to think of as a news source.

(One of the two links posted corresponds to widespread news reports. The other just shows some dead guy in a field).

racional··on The only tourist in Moldova
This is meant in jest, of course.
racional··on The only tourist in Moldova
Yup - Polish is in a different family (Western Slavic), with lots of unknown words and a different phoneme density that immediately lights up as "foreign".
racional··on Ask HN: Is Serverless Overkill?
Can you expand more on what these practices are, in your view?
racional··on The only tourist in Moldova
The Telegraph article predates the shooting incident at the border by 14 days.

You are referencing "men" getting shot when the incident involves 1 person getting shot, and this is the only such incident that has been reported 2+ years into the full-scale invasion.

racional··on TSMC rides AI demand to raise revenue forecast, says no to US joint venture
What does a "fine" outcome for Ukraine look like, in your view?

Say by 2029 when Vance certifies himself as President.

racional··on Russian Missile Attack Levels Children's Hospital
Fear is an element of your world, not mine.
racional··on Trump says Taiwan should pay the U.S. for defense
The imperative to defend Taiwan is a half-century old commitment; breaking it would mean repealing the Taiwan Relations Act

How so? The TRA does not compel the U.S. to "defend" Taiwan in the event of an invasion. In fact it was specifically worded to avoid providing security guarantees as such. Only to provide "arms of a defensive character" and the like. So what you're saying about repealing the TRA in such a scenario is plainly incorrect.

You're also clearly hyperbolizing in regard to Ukraine, but we'll leave that aside for now.

racional··on Learn German grammar with AI-generated exercises
The UX and concept are both quite good.

Aber, aber -- do we have to tarnish this app's reputation by drawing attention to the fact that it is somehow AI-connected? Given what we know about its rather poor sense of accuracy for such things (compared to, you know, stodgy old things like dictionaries, grammar textbooks and the like):

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40931790

racional··on Russian Missile Attack Levels Children's Hospital
C'est la vie.
racional··on Microsoft cutting crucial link to Gaza, Palestinians say
They required compromise which the Palestinians aren't capable of as a people

This is where your post veered from invective into pure and simple racism, unfortunately.

racional··on Russian Missile Attack Levels Children's Hospital
But it isn't really fact-based. It only appears that way.

It doesn't matter how many individual factoids you lay out -- if the greater narrative you cast around them (and subordinate these facts into) is so plainly and fundamentally broken. That's why your salad wilts at first contact with fresh air, and your essay yields such a terse response.

Je ne regrette rien.

racional··on Human history in the very long run (2021)
Folks who dismiss Marx tend to conjure a fantasy and then dismiss that fantasy and then claim victory.

That's what you're saying now; initially you said something much stronger.

You keep trying to pivot away from that initial (and rather untenable) formulation, for some reason.

racional··on Human history in the very long run (2021)
Okay, let's try curiosity then:

"Didya really mean to say that there's literally no one walking this Earth with meaningful criticisms of Marx who has in fact also read what he's written? "Without being hyperbolic", no less?" 'Cause it sounds like an awfully weird and authoritarian thing to say."

Inquiring minds want to know.

racional··on Human history in the very long run (2021)
You were starting to get a bit slippery there with that attempted rewording of that rather peculiar claim you made.

That was my point, stated much more clearly this time.

← PreviousPage 3 of 19Next →