HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

racional

872 karma · joined April 17, 2024

submissionscomments
racional··on Tripping on Xenon Gas (2023)
Wikipedia cites the Holodomor

You cited, as an encyclopedic fact, 10M as having perished specifically "Yagoda's torture chambers" per your words, which can only refer to NKVD (or otherwise "political") persecutions -- not the various deportations en masse or the Holodomor. The WP page you cited confirms upper bound for the former set of excess fatalaties (i.e. the one that you were explicitly referencing) at 770k -- which we shall charitably round up to 1M for the sake of "civility" here -- for the entire USSR during the pre-war era.

Far short of the 10M figure you are introducing for whatever imaginitive and creative purposes.

Again: 10M in this category -- the number who perished "Yagoda's torture chambers" throughout the USSR before the start of the war; and "about half" being in Ukraine; or around 5M, is the number you put forth -- apparently for the nifty rhetorical effect you thought it might bring.

Whereas the historical consensus for this category is <400k.

racional··on Tripping on Xenon Gas (2023)
> And used today

In the mainstream, I obviously meant.

Check in on any American Nazi rally from the 1930s to the present day (the photos are all over the place); you'll see the Stars and Stripes displayed very prominently right along Swastika flags. Does that mean the former is, therefore, a fascist symbol?

Check what is the role of fascist militias like Azov in the 2014's Maidan.

Azov did not exist at the time of Maidan.

This is the kind of nonsense world you create for yourself by obsessively reading polemics, and pulling "research" from echo-chamber news sources. Rather than bothering to find out what Ukrainians are actually like, as a people.

The real problem with Ukraine as a nation is ...

The irony here is that you claim to be concerned about the dangers of Nazism. But then almost in the same breath, you dive head-first into weird tribalist diatribes like this.

racional··on Tripping on Xenon Gas (2023)
10 million people died in Genrikh Yagoda's torture chambers.

These are some wildly inflated numbers you're posting here. Total estimates for the number of persons killed in pre-war political repressions in the USSR top out at 1 million or so. I'm not sure what Ukraine's exact number is, but (in asserting that it was "about half" of 10M) you're easily inflating the true number by a factor of at least 10x here. Likely closer to 20x.

Why are you doing this?

racional··on Tripping on Xenon Gas (2023)
It was prudent to do anything to save Ukraine.

Including allowing the Germans to run the Final Solution on your territory.

And please, don't tell us he didn't know what was in store for Ukraine's Jewish population. By the late 1930s, everyone knew what was up.

You're really very naive with these justifications you're making here. Like Bandera himself.

racional··on Tripping on Xenon Gas (2023)
They weren't ideologically into Nazism.

The point is -- he was a willing collaborator. And you went out of your way to describe his actions as "at any given time, prudent for his country".

racional··on Tripping on Xenon Gas (2023)
Sieg Heil originated in Germany around the 1900, etc

A broken analogy. The difference lies in the fact that these symbols were utterly obscure to German public before the Nazis introduced them in the early 1920s; though they had previous incarnations, in essence the Nazis reinvented them. In fact, they were so successful at it that most people are surprised to learn that these symbols had prior origins.

The situation with "Slava Ukraini" is entirely different. It first appeared in a poem of Shevchenko in 1840, and gained widespread traction during the War of Independence. It was then co-opted by the OUN, but the point is, by that time it had its own "legs" as a slogan rooted in Ukrainian national consciousness, completely independent of Bandera and his program.

And used today, it has no fascist connotations, and does not indicate support for Bandera or the OUN. That's just a simple fact. You obviously want the slogan to mean something different in the current context -- but we're talking about a country of 44 million people here, and if you have any interaction at all with this society, it's perfectly obvious and clear what they mean by it. I take their word over yours.

The Poles have long gotten over all this history too, of course. They know what happened in those years, but they know that what's happening in the current day is infinitely more important. They know there's a fascist aggressor to the East which threatens their survival as a people, and it isn't Ukraine.

Your attempts to conflate the slogan with a meaning it simply doesn't have are disingenuous. You're clearly not interested in what's historically accurate, or what describes the feelings and intents of people who use slogans like "Slava Ukraini" today.

You're only interested in this stuff as scare imagery -- as a way to push people's buttons.

racional··on Tripping on Xenon Gas (2023)
At any given time, he was doing what was prudent for his country

By which you must mean his issuing the Act of Restoration of the Ukrainian State, which famously states:

  3. The newly formed Ukrainian state will work closely with the National-Socialist Greater Germany, under the leadership of its leader Adolf Hitler which is forming a new order in Europe and the world and is helping the Ukrainian People to free itself from Moscovite occupation.
racional··on Canceling Congestion Pricing Could Kill 100k New York Jobs
https://archive.md/M814m
racional··on Scientists Find First Evidence That Butterflies Crossed an Ocean
https://archive.ph/QOYIL
racional··on Julian Assange has reached a plea deal with the U.S., allowing him to go free
Do please try to appreciate the emotional toll of having non-Jews out there all helpfully informing us Jews what is, and isn't, antisemitism.

I have no idea what your essential attributes are. Nor do you have any idea as to mine. And I'm not telling you what to think about anything.

This thread is getting far from the original topic. Recommend we both close shop here, and move on.

racional··on Israeli documents show expansive government effort to shape US discourse
Israel is not [an enemy]

But judging from its actions it isn't exactly a friend of the United States either.

That's why these actions draw scrutiny.

racional··on Julian Assange has reached a plea deal with the U.S., allowing him to go free
The people critiquing Israel are almost universally singling Israel out for critique.

They're not, of course.

But labeling them as such is one of the myriad ways by which criticism of Israel gets automatically branded as you-know-what.

racional··on Can men live without war? (1956)
I'm not sure how that "conventional violent response" would work.

One can imagine scenarios of varying effectiveness, but this a separate matter. The point is -- the Biden administration has made it clear to the Russians that there would be a significant response, with strong hints that it would be military in nature and not limited to extra sanctions.

If Russia can use nukes against Ukrainian army entering the Russian territory, then for sure it would use them against NATO troops doing the same.

The response doesn't need to involve NATO troops in Ukraine.

Meanwhile it'd be kind of hard to use nukes against stealth bombers, cruise missiles, drones and SF operations.

racional··on Israeli documents show expansive government effort to shape US discourse
1. What are you suggesting “has been going on since before World War II”?

Before Israel's formation as a state -- a campaign to influence public opinion and policy in favor of that formation.

Afterwards -- a campaign to defend its unlawful and unrecognized territorial expansion; to deny its atrocities (from 1948 through the present day) for as long as possible; and to keep U.S. military and financial support flowing, no matter what Israel does.

And as an added cherry on top: an astonishly successful campaign to brand essentially any serious criticism of Israel's policies or its founding ideology as antisemitic.

4. Don’t be coy, you know precisely the “they” you’re referring to.

There is no “they”, scare-quoted or otherwise, in the commenter's posts in this thread (except when they're quoting from yours). However we see that you've introduced this formulation twice now.

Perhaps you'd care to explain why you are doubling down on this rather peculiar misrepresentation of the commenter's words.

Don't be coy now.

racional··on US Bans Kaspersky Software
You can call it what you want.

But the U.S. operation involves less than 1 percent as many ground troops as Russia has deployed in Ukraine.

And last I checked, hasn't resulted in entire cities razed to the ground, and 15 percent of the population displaced.

racional··on Biden puts a bullet in Kaspersky: Sales, updates to be banned in America
Depends what you mean by "public relations":

Haaretz and the New York Times recently revealed that Chikli’s ministry had tapped a public relations firm to secretly pressure American lawmakers. The firm used hundreds of fake accounts posting pro-Israel or anti-Muslim content on X (formerly Twitter), Facebook and Instagram.

racional··on US prosecutors recommend Justice Department criminally charge Boeing
Then write your congressperson. I'm just explaining the current policy rationale.

Which isn't random, and has nothing to do with Dick Cheney.

racional··on Can men live without war? (1956)
My mistake, misread you.
racional··on Can men live without war? (1956)
Actually Zyklon B came out of WWI research, and in the interim it was licensed worldwide for use as a fumigating agent. Including from 1929 onwards in the United States, where it was used by the Public Health Service to fumigate freight trains and clothes of Mexican immigrants entering the country.
racional··on US prosecutors recommend Justice Department criminally charge Boeing
That's a different topic. I'm just making it clear that it's not just about Ukraine.

The Baltics (and Poland) are currently in NATO, which means the US has signed a treaty that states is committed to defending them.

racional··on Biden puts a bullet in Kaspersky: Sales, updates to be banned in America
But the Israeli government per se does not.

Though we may need to qualify that:

https://www.theguardian.com/world/article/2024/jun/24/israel...

racional··on US prosecutors recommend Justice Department criminally charge Boeing
There are historical reasons why Russia would want to control Ukraine that don’t imply that they would want to keep expanding into Germany and France.

But they do imply they would want to start messing with Poland and the Baltics (and Russian leaders have stated as much openly).

I think the notion that Russia seeks to take over the world ...

No one is saying Russia seeks to "take over the whole world". But it is openly seeking to subjugate a country of 44 million people to whatever extent it can get away with, and has issued recent threats to other countries (see above) it has invaded previously, some multiple times.

racional··on About Deep Earth Microbes
https://archive.md/lhVbX
racional··on Can men live without war? (1956)
So the minute a 'Small Nuke' is used, we should just respond with the biggest nuke.

In any case the U.S. has stated that it won't do that unless it was a close strike against a very close ally (NATO partner or similar, or their deployed units). Most likely won't reciprocate to a nuclear strike against just Ukraine (provided it were of "limited" scope such as a warning or sequence of tactical shots).

racional··on Can men live without war? (1956)
And as for consequences I do not think the West would do anything about that.

The worst outcome of nuking Ukraine for Russia is to get even more economic sanctions, that's all.

The response won't be nuclear, per its stated posture on this. But it's hard to imagine the United States would do basically nothing of substance in response, and it hasn't ruled out a violent conventional response. And at least back in 2022, Biden took care to put this messaging out indicating there would be a "consequential" response, per his interview with Scott Pelley:

  "And I wonder, Mr. President, what you would say to him if he is considering using chemical or tactical nuclear weapons?"

  "Don't. Don't. Don't. You will change the face of war unlike anything since World War II," Mr. Biden said.

  When Pelley asked what the consequences would be if Putin crossed that line, the president wouldn't say.

  "You think I would tell you if I knew exactly what it would be? Of course, I'm not gonna tell you. It'll be consequential," Mr. Biden said. "They'll become more of a pariah in the world than they ever have been. And depending on the extent of what they do will determine what response would occur."
https://www.cbsnews.com/news/president-joe-biden-vladimir-pu...

US won't go on full scale nuclear war with Russia over some insignificant country at the end of the world

First, while it isn't a NATO partner or of similar status, Ukraine is absolutely not "insignificant" to the at least the current administration in the U.S., and the whole Atlanticist crowd. It would not have stuck its neck out (and expended its political capital) as far as it has on Ukraine's behalf thus far, if that were the case.

And while it won't go nuclear over Ukraine -- it is definitely concerned about its strategic posture and global stability, and the detrimental consequences of giving Russia perceived "pass" to use nukes in any offensive context. And would basically have to make some kind of genuinely serious response. Which some people close to the administration have quietly hinted could be a conventional military response.

racional··on Notes on Tajikistan
Thanks for clarifying -- but the referent of the implicit "they" in that snippet (via "their droppings") was an (abstract) commenter -- not their country or nationality!

Which is also something you'd also prefer we not do (that is: referring to individuals with implied scorn) -- and since you're asking nicely and it's your shop here, I will make assiduous efforts to catch myself before doing so, moving forward.

So perhaps what I should have said was something like this:

   There's never a need to introduce (gratuitous) references to a commenter's nationality or other presumed essential traits... No matter how much we may object to the message or import of what they have written.
Which I would hope is a general policy we can all get behind on.
racional··on Notes on Tajikistan
The 2009 EU report has been widely criticized as flawed, both at the time in years since. You can drill down on the details here:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Responsibility_for_the_Russo-G...

>Finland was a co-belligerent with Nazi Germany during the early years of World War II

Which happened after (and never would have happened without) the Winter War.

racional··on Internet Archive forced to remove 500k books after publishers' court win
Isn't it interesting that every example of an abuse by free markets actually turns out to be the government doing it?

Government instrumentalized to serve the interests of the wealthy elites, that is. So at the end of the day, it's the latter who are "doing" it.

racional··on Notes on Tajikistan
I think if you're going to exclusively comment on political threads, the bar is higher to stay assiduously within the guidelines, which basically means avoiding any kind of pejorative writing, even if it's oblique, about the commenters who disagree with you; write as if to a beloved but intractably wrong and somewhat thin-skinned uncle on an email thread just before Thanksgiving.

This is most excellent advice. Thanks for chiming in.

racional··on Notes on Tajikistan
That's not true at all, Israel doesn't operate any courts in Gaza.

Right - the people there are under martial law, which is even worse.

Gaza has a border with Egypt

Which Israel has seized control of.

← PreviousPage 6 of 19Next →