HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

racional

872 karma · joined April 17, 2024

submissionscomments
racional··on Biden puts a bullet in Kaspersky: Sales, updates to be banned in America
The formulation you've chosen here is rather crudely hyperbolic, and not particularly helpful.

"Israel controls certain aspects of ..." would be somewhat more in the direction of a fair statement. But it's still not accurate. It's definitely quite fair to talk about something called the "Israel lobby", which by definition is made up of American citizens, and not even necessarily Jewish, which obviously does exert a great degree of control over, to be clear -- certain aspects of policy within the U.S.

But the Israeli government per se does not.

racional··on US Bans Kaspersky Software
Can we count that as war?

Yes of course, and I'm not defending it, but it's still totally different in both scale and nature from what Russia is doing in Ukraine.

At least on surface appearances the US isn't taking control of the oil and selling it on the market (the oil is owned and marketed by the autonomous Kurdish government which runs the region).

And unlike Russia, the US certainly isn't seeking to permanent annex the region.

racional··on US Bans Kaspersky Software
Yours is a non-standard usage of the term, then.

But I see the overall point you're making, and I've also taken the "Can we even call it a war?" perspective at times, not because of the lack of a proper declaration (which I see as insignificant), but from the sheer pointless, murderous insanity of it all.

A side note: It just so happens that the romanized version of the Russian acronym for SMO is SVO (that is, SVO = СВО and perhaps F meant "full"?) so I was temporarily confused by what you meant with that acronym. I now do see what you meant by it. But at the moment my mind was focused on the pointless insanity that we both agree is the situation in Ukraine, not math.

racional··on Notes on Tajikistan
I appreciate the detailed response, and will give it careful consideration.

I was hoping you could also respond to the question at the very top ("Can you point to even a single instance ...", up to the "If not, then why ..." part).

I'm not trying to split hairs here -- I'm really genuinely mystified by the apparent insinuation that I was responding to. That is, I don't see why would you bother to inject the phrase "When people start talking about other people's countries scornfully or aggressively" -- if you didn't think that was what you observed me doing.

At the same time I'm pretty that not only do I not talk about entire countries that way -- my language takes pains to avoid precisely such implications.

And just a slight addendum -- I have to say I'm a bit confused about what you mean by "political battle". Is it -- simply too many posts about politics (or history, which tends to get bloody and political)? Or just being too blunt about it? Is for example this post an instance of "political battle"?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40731093

I can see how it might look that way (especially if one has only vaguely heard of the political party I'm referring to, and hasn't looked into them in any detail). But I do believe that if one has done any homework at all on these folks -- then what I'm saying is pretty straightforward, and well, basically "obvious".

And in any case, while it certainly takes a position, it's not a pugnacious or uncivil statement I'm making there. The sibling post perhaps makes a better, less brusque explanation of the same basic point. But again, it's just stating major recent events that should be, well -- obvious to anyone who follows basic political events in that country.

racional··on Notes on Tajikistan
When people start talking about other people's countries scornfully or aggressively or snarkily, that's when it becomes flamebait and a moderation issue.

Can you point to even a single instance where I have done this, please?

Meaning -- in reference to the country or its people per se (as opposed to the actions or ideology of the people who happen to be running it; or perhaps entirely reasonable references to what a measured portion of the population might say or think, as can be easily verified by numerous news reports)?

If not -- then why are you setting forth the implication that this is something I have done?

And lasties -- a lot of postings here (or excerpts from them) are plainly BS. Whether the poster is simply naive, or has less charitable motivations -- there's simply no mistaking it.

I totally get that labeling these cases as such continuously makes for bad reading; and of course one should never to so spuriously. But what is so wrong or uncivil (or even "snarky") about pointing out this simple fact, in egregious cases when there's just no ifs, buts or mitigating factors about it?

Or is just the fecal labeling? Would you prefer we stick to more G-rated terminology like "nonsense" and "balderdash"? I suppose I could live with that.

racional··on US Bans Kaspersky Software
They could stop the war but they didn't.

So what's your proposal for how they should do that?

In particular: precisely which of Putin's most recently dictated terms do you think they should force Ukraine to agree to -- in order obtain this "peace" that you say is easily available?

racional··on Barcelona will eliminate tourist apartments
The entire impact of AirBnB + all housing built in the last decade does not offset the last half decade of population growth.

Your retort here simply isn't logical.

10k doesn't fully offset 100k but it's a significant chunk of it, and when supply gets so compressed as to become inelastic, a 10k amelioration (that is also prevented from creeping up to 15k or 20k within a few years) can be quite significant. Plus certain districts are obviously impacted disproportionately compared to others by not just the reduction in housing available but the sheer foot traffic and other blight that comes along with a lopsided rise in tourist accommodations.

racional··on Gilead shot prevents all HIV cases in trial
I'm honestly not sure how to combat that any more, outside of a ban on the party.

Perhaps by getting rid of these haughty, and one simply has to say: typisch-Wessi notions of the new Länder as being "flyover territory". Which is part of what drives people to vote for AfD in the first place. As if the former West Germany doesn't have its own stereotypically maligned areas as well.

racional··on US Bans Kaspersky Software
True of most armies -- even the worst we can think of. The architects of war know this, of course. That's why most the killing is usually done at a distance, out of sight and out of mind.

See also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mariupol_theatre_airstrike

Which was done (and, judging by the choice of ordinance, signed off on at the highest levels) not despite the fact that they knew there were children present at the carefully selected target; but because of it.

racional··on US Bans Kaspersky Software
A conflict without formal DoWs issued is not a proper war,

If it helps clarify things for you: most wars are deeply psychological in nature; and part of how they operate is by telling people (both the perpetrators and victims) that it's not really a "war". But rather a "special operation". They will even lie right to your face, and tell you that they are there to "demilitarize" the area and to bring peace. And that to the extent that it might look like a war -- that will insist that they had no choice; it was forced on them; the other side could stop it at any time if they wanted to.

Proper declarations do have significance of course; but they are always secondary to the basic facts of what's happening on the ground.

racional··on How babies and young children learn to understand language
I have never met someone who doesn't speak Russian.

Then you haven't traveled broadly in Ukraine. And more importantly you're missing the point. The vast majority do speak and understand a reasonable amount of Russian (hence they will almost never object when you use it with them; they get that you're a foreigner and are doing the best you can) -- but they don't speak it fluently and comfortably, and it's not their preferred language in everyday use.

Only the elderly people have sometimes a mixed slang

It's more prevalent among the older set of course, but still this is just not true across the board. Surzhyk (or less pejoratively: Russian borrowings/breakings) are everywhere, though they are often subtle and it may take some training to detect them.

Part of the problem is that there are no well-defined boundaries (and there's only a barely defined notion of what constitutes "standard Ukrainian"). They're literally still in the process of cleaning up the nation's preeminent (and clearly Soviet-, if not exactly Surzhyk-influenced) dictionary.

There are some hardcore nationalists connected to Bandera (pro nazi group) that refuse to speak Russian

Now you're getting into pure BS territory.

This is obviously something you've read or something you've heard said a lot, but not something you know from direct observation.

racional··on Notes on Tajikistan
There's nothing political or nationalistic at all in my comment.

My posts refer mostly to historical events, and attempt to correct the various (sometime rather bizarre) cognitive distortions that some people like to hold and promote about them. Along with many much milder and more innocuous misunderstandings.

Personally I eschew all forms of nationalism and nationalist rhetoric.

racional··on How babies and young children learn to understand language
As a foreigner a lot more useful to learn Russian.

Given that the state language is Ukrainian, and its overall dominance in media and culture -- there's no way this statement could possibly make sense.

Everybody speaks it in Ukraine.

This gets repeated a lot, but it's just not true. It's true that virtually everyone has some working comprehension of Russian because of earlier Soviet influences, and because the two languages are so similar (and in many parts of the country, the "Ukrainian" that is spoken is highly Surzhyk-influenced).

But realistically only about 70-80 percent of the population speak Russian fluently and comfortably. Given a choice, the vast majority would clearly prefer to speak Ukrainian (and many people have been switching voluntarily as a matter of preference since 2014; the government's mildly coercive efforts having nothing to do with this, really).

Even at our university in Ukraine, Russian was the main language amongst foreign students.

Probably because it's the only one among the two that they were able to study before coming there (and because they saw Russian as being more useful in other countries, as you say).

And even so, this applies only to certain universities in certain cities.

racional··on Notes on Tajikistan
I think Dan's point is that there's never a need to introduce references to a commenter's nationality or other presumed essential traits.

No matter how self-evidently full of excrement their droppings here may be.

racional··on I'm the hacker that brought down North Korea's Internet for over a week. AMA
Putin, at least, says he wanted to join NATO back in 2000 (according to the Stone interview). But he put it, "the U.S. delegation got very nervous."

Granted this was well before his total Machtergreifung, and he definitely was not equated with "Russia" at the time like he is now. But that's his telling of events, in any case.

racional··on It's Time to Learn How to Blow Things Up Again
https://archive.is/DrrtJ
racional··on EU Council to Vote on Chat Scanning Proposal on Thursday
There is no way one can describe the AfD as center-right. This is obvious fact that emerges from any amount observation of post-WW2 politics in that country, and how the AfD compares to standard center-right parties like the CDU/CDS and the FDP.

Complaints about fake news and what the mainstream media supposedly says about anything are usually, in themselves, fake news.

racional··on Malaysia to Join BRICS
If Israel wanted to genocide the Palestinians then it would have been a smoking pit with nearly 100% of the citizens killed inside of a month.

To the ecstatic delight of a substantial proportion of the Israeli public, no doubt.

However it doesn't actually have the munitions stock to do that, and plus, it would be bad PR and make the area more costly to re-develop as a prime real estate attraction. So instead it has opted the more "pragmatic" option of removing the indigenous inhabitants. Which is another form of genocide, just a softer, more palatable one.

racional··on Snowden eviscerates OpenAI's decision to put a former NSA director on its board
Like you aren’t secretly thinking you’re an expert in this in your mind.

If you were genuinely confident of your knowledge, you wouldn't feel the need to repeatedly respond in a purely ad hominem manner such as this.

racional··on Snowden eviscerates OpenAI's decision to put a former NSA director on its board
It’s not a personal attack or anything,

But of course that's precisely what is. You're not providing any insight into the subject at hand here. You're simply talking up your vastly superior knowledge, and making weird projections about the person you're talking to.

What I notice about people who are genuinely knowledgeable and confident about a subject is that in general their deportment and tone are exact opposite of what's on display here.

racional··on Snowden eviscerates OpenAI's decision to put a former NSA director on its board
It obviously wasn't a high security environment; he knew some risk was involved, and that major governments would have access to the data eventually.

If there were other precautions he could have reasonably taken -- that would also have been usable by regular journalists -- then you could state what they are, rather than alluding to them.

racional··on Snowden eviscerates OpenAI's decision to put a former NSA director on its board
I'm not offering a "theory"; but you did, and a plainly untenable one.

If the only response you can think of is to speculate about the background of the person pointing this out to you -- that's a pretty common psychological defense, and if it offers some form of comfort to you, you're more than entitled to it.

racional··on Snowden eviscerates OpenAI's decision to put a former NSA director on its board
It's certainly a credible thesis that's being offering here, and yours is probably the best formulation I've heard of it.

Still, from my own brushings with folks in "professional circles" -- they tend to be pretty consistent about packaging assessments such as these with probabilistic labels (e.g. "likely", "highly likely" and so on). My main concern here is quick toggling to "known" or "near certain" status (or insinuations that "everyone in the IC believes this", which I am noting is not your intention here, but it did sound like it at first).

It's also just a general policy I like to follow with events out in the real, messy world. No matter good our "model" may sound (to our own ears) about what someone did or why, it's always entirely possible we're missing something basic -- not so much a piece of bombshell evidence, but about the broader human context; or that our analysis is simply flawed.

On top of that there's a significant tail risk that comes with putting too much stake in our models, especially when they get coupled together, and motivated reasoning inevitably starts to kick in.

On a finer-grained note (and to explain why I can't assign this narrative too high of a degree of likelihood): It's not automatically clear that the Russians could have traded Snowden in by now -- they may be asking too high of a price (since he's apparently way more valuable than anyone the US has in their trading deck), and since 2014 they may have been coupling it with their hopes that the US will decide to start being "reasonable" about the situation in Ukraine (and so his transfer would be coupled with a deal in regard to that situation), and so forth.

I also don't see how we know that "they already had all the files he had leaked", or that anything about his case has the potential to destroy the intelligence relationship (which has always found a way of surviving, despite all the bile and vitriol we see on the surface).

(This is all in regard to the "weak" version of this model, that Snowden acted independently but had to have broken once he got stuck in the Motherland and was forced to ask for asylum. The "strong" version in the sibling post -- which asserts that he must have been cooperating with his current hosts from the very start -- has just way too many plotholes, and is way too top-heavy in my view. Not to be dismissive, but I have to limit my time here, so that's all I can offer on it at the moment).

racional··on Snowden eviscerates OpenAI's decision to put a former NSA director on its board
Likewise here, but as I recall from a mix of interviews, articles, and at least one documentary the main steps were: (1) being reasonably picky about the journalists he chose to reach out to; (2) making sure they were savvy enough to work with, and understand the imperative need to work with basic encryption tools; (3) encouraging these journalists to be very cautious in their handling of the material; and (4) destroying any physical copies of the data he had before boarding the plane to Moscow.

Perhaps some aspects of the above have been challenged or questioned in the interim. But that's my recollection of the precautions he took, or at least said he took, according to those sources.

racional··on Malaysia to Join BRICS
An agenda "to take over the world", no.

What they most likely said is that it's an endorsement of Israeli appropriation of Palestinian culture.

That's what seems to be their position. You can make of it what you want. But there's no reason to spin what that they're saying into something exponentially and categorically different ("the Zionist agenda to take over the world"), with the clearly implied charge of antisemitism that goes along with it.

I'm not saying that's your intent -- but the phrasing is clear there, in your words. I suspect it's far more likely you just slung the phrase "Zionist agenda to take over the world" in there for the nifty emotive effect it seems to bring, without regard to whether it had any logical connection to what you were talking about.

Especially the pro Palestine crowd

Vaguely lashing out at some unspecified target here. Seriously, what is this supposed to mean? The hardcore social media addicts who grab the most attention -- mostly by pushing people's buttons, in this case obviously yours? Are they the "pro-Palestine crowd"? Is therefore everything they say representative of everyone who considers themselves "pro-Palestine" in some form?

racional··on Pentagon ran secret anti-vax campaign to undermine China during pandemic
And about that guy they put in front of the Canadian parliament (even though he has absolutely nothing to do with Azov, and hence nothing one might say about him can have any bearing on the original assertions you were making) -- just to get him out of the way:

If you think that anyone who fought or otherwise worked for the Germans -- even if they served in the camps and did horrific things there (which this guy did not apparently), or served in a nominally elite military unit (as he did) -- is ipso facto a Nazi -- then it seems you haven't taken stock of one of the cardinal rules by which the Nazis operated in these countries (or any long-lived dictatorship operates for that matter, including certainly Putin's).

Which is: they don't need you to join the Party, or even believe the ideological flim-flam (and in the Nazis' case -- they definitely didn't need you to be antisemitic). You can even be a bit skeptical, or outright disdainful under the hood. At the end of the day, they don't really care about what your think as an individual. And they don't need you to be hip to their Master Plan.

They just need you to go along with it.

racional··on Pentagon ran secret anti-vax campaign to undermine China during pandemic
Didn't mean to ignore your half of your preceding post; just that takes time to unpack and respond to these points, and honestly, it seems a lot of your arguments just aren't well-constructed.

But leaving that aside, and to address just the first line, if I may, of your post above:

I'm quite familiar with Ukraine's collaborationist history in WW II. Of course callaboration was widespread, and the occupation forces had substantial support (or at least acquiescence) throughout the population -- again, as in all occupied countries. There's a reason they were able to pull of the multi-year Babyn Yar operation just outside the center of Kyiv, were able to recruit so many Trawniki to do the dirty in their camps, and so on. This isn't a revelation to me at all.

My question to you is -- how does any of this history move the needle (serve as "proof" in your words) -- or have any other kind of bearing, for that matter -- in regard to any of the assertions you're making about Azov today? As I asked in my most recent response (and you "ignored"): what is the actual chain of implication and substantiation here?

I'm just not seeing any. If you can enlighten me as to why I should, perhaps we can continue with the other points. But in any case that's all I have time for right now.

Because it actually takes a lot of time to answer you carefully and patiently like this, you know.

racional··on Snowden eviscerates OpenAI's decision to put a former NSA director on its board
That he grabbed as much as he could is reasonably clear. But it's objectively false to say that he simply "leaked it" with no precautions or regard to the consequences.
racional··on Snowden eviscerates OpenAI's decision to put a former NSA director on its board
Sounds like you're the kind of person who likes to build on on hypotheticals.

I'm not that kind of person. That said you can go on thinking that people who don't share your appetite for rank speculation are blithering idiots, as suits your fancy.

I'm fully aware of what he might have done. I just don't find it useful to pretend that I therefore know what he did.

racional··on Snowden eviscerates OpenAI's decision to put a former NSA director on its board
Can you explain in your own words what kind of "operation" are we talking about here?

The video sounds interesting, but I won't be able to give it a look for quite some time. Plus I'd like to know what your view specifically is on the matter.

← PreviousPage 7 of 19Next →