872 karma · joined April 17, 2024
I don't think the Russian offensive is working, overall (given the very modest amount of ink they've gained on the map, during the course of the US spending freeze).
The Gaza situation is less clear -- but also gets into topics far from the original discussion.
Oh, absolutely. If the Nakba falls under the modern definition of genocide (as per the Convention), then the MENA expulsions and of course the Oct 7 pogrom do as well, in my view.
My intent is not to isolate blame on one side for this mess (which I see as ultimately symbiotic, the result of provocations by both sides). But to identify the common fabric between these events -- in the hopes of finding some way to stop if from continuing perpetually, ever forward.
Are Jews living through an ongoing holocaust now? Perhaps, since the term genocide lost all meaning why not.
Neither side is going through a true Holocaust in the sense of what happened to the European Jews (and certain other groups at the time), of course. We are very far from that, and I see your point here about a possible dilution of the term, and of the (nearly but not entirely unique) trauma and anguish related to those events (which I spent a certain phase of my life obsessively studying, BTW).
Again the overall intent is to identify sources of harm done to people, at scale and on the basis of group identity -- intended to diminish their numbers, destroy their spirit, and threaten their long-term survival as a people.
I just want it all to stop.
So ... if Palestinians are still going through what they're going today, at home or abroad, it's ultimately (or to large extent) a delayed result of the MENA expulsions, and the slight electoral tilt among the descendants of those affected (we're talking 2 full generations later, heading up on a 3rd by now) within Israeli electoral politics?
That is to say, ultimately an outgrowth of -- external antisemitism?
That's your thesis here?
The article refers to shelling done mostly by Russian forces.
The genocidal intent of the Nakba was as clear in 1948 as it is with the Nakba in its current form today.
And from what sources do you know this from?
People don't reach for plant milk (or butter) for the nutritive content; but rather for the texture and taste, which make other foods (smoothies, porridge), not to mention coffee / tea (for some), more palatable -- or in the case of baked goods (or pudding, ice cream, etc) they essentially are the texture of these foods. Thus expanding their range of what they can eat (and enjoy).
And to do so in a way not involving animal milk.
The MENA expulsions (which we have already acknowledged) didn't have anything to do either with Nakba '48 or the expulsions of Palestinians in other countries in subsequent years. Let alone with the topic of subthread we've all jumped in at here. (Which started with the Nakba after all; I didn't introduce it to make some broader moral point).
I wonder who made those videos, and who they're affiliated with. And also the persons speaking in them.
Perhaps you'd like to tell us?
Specifically -- what concessions should be Ukraine be forced to make in order for you to feel -- safer?
You're catching on! The Nakba is as fresh as ever. Just ask these folks -- who are definitely in a position to know:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40372975
As the Minister for Foreign Affairs instructs us: "Remember 48".
And he sure ain't kidding. It is all very much an ongoing process.
But we have to keep in mind that none of those people would be forced to live in such inhospitable places were it not for the bold, decisive actions of that man who got an airport named after him.
-- Defense Minister Yoav Gallant
If Israel disagrees, then it is welcome to withdraw its membership at any time.
I agree that the optics of that event don't look great. But the fact is, the ceremony was officially conducted in the name of "All passengers of the downed helicopter and their families". Because of that phrasing, the UNSC members who went along with it probably felt they had to do so as a matter of protocol.
Again - not something I would go along with, if I were in the room. But it also wasn't the personalized tribute to Raisi and no one else that you're making it out to be.
Meanwhile, Israel's primary airport is named after the architect of the 1948 expulsions, the Qibya massacre and countless other atrocities.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ben_Gurion_Airport
The point isn't whataboutism, but rather: "Credibility starts at home".
You can call it a "small" genocide if you want. But you won't get anywhere denying either the facts of what has been happening to the Palestinians, or their relation to genocidal acts as defined above.
But of course it does exactly that, via the intentionally deceptive euphemism "voluntary emigration".
For example he could set off a single low-yield high-altitude explosion to demonstrate that he "means business". And watch with delicious expectation as the Western world shits its pants.
It is unfortunately a comparatively low-risk, but sickeningly attractive proposition for him to consider -- especially if he finds himself backed into a corner with his own survival threatened (as will be the case if the war reaches a point where he is seen to be intractably failing).
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tanenbaum–Torvalds_debate
Which in a nutshell comes down to Linus's view that producing a system that meets current needs (for example by offering a simple API) and is reasonably performant -- even if it ran on but a single architecture such as the i386 -- was more promising than a design offering "theoretical" benefits (such as portability) but which either didn't deliver the goods today or just wasn't reasonably performant.
This is a vast simplification of a much broader set of issues but if one digs into the notes of why subsequent projects (e.g. Windows NT) moved away from microkernel designs, or the roughly analogous microservices debate of the past decade -- one often finds echoes of the same basic considerations.
The one thing that Musk, Putin, and the above commenter all seem to agree on.
It's one thing to defend Musk's unilateral decision to provide Starlink early in the war. But another matter entirely (and profoundly obnoxious in fact) to presume that one knows enough to tell the Ukrainians (even rhretorically) what they should think or do in regard to the situation that they're facing.
I think what you mean to say here is that these were the last modern states to hold recognized sovereignty over the respective territories. But of course they exercised any control over those places since 1967.
Historically, these areas were never considered Palestinian
Correct if, again, one is thinking in terms of a sovereign Palestine state. However there has been nonetheless distinct Palestinian identity in formation since the 19th century, or possibly further depending on whom you ask (even if it didn't align exactly with European models for such at the time).
Given this background, many Israelis believe that the Palestinian struggle against Israel has not primarily been about establishing an independent nation to coexist peacefully alongside Israel. Rather, they view the aim of the struggle as attempting to dismantle Israel as a Jewish state by systematically challenging its historical and political legitimacy.
This is pretty good summation of the mainstream position within Israel society. A corresponding view of the current mainstream Palestinian position might go like this:
Given this background, many Palestinians believe that current Israeli policy is not about establishing its own security (and certainly not within 1967 borders), but about the continuing removal from, and/or permanent subjugation of the Palestinian people within the Occupied Territories. In particular, they see absolutely no interest in a 2SS solution on the Israeli side. They therefore see the dismantling of the Israeli state not just as the only viable alternative to their own destruction, but as a historical inevitability.
That seems to be what it comes down to. The question is -- where to go from here.
As in literally every other case of prosecutor intimidation you will find.
Genocide is the intentional destruction of a people in whole or in part.
Once one understands enough basic regional history to connect the dots, and is aware of the modern definition -- it's perfectly bloody obvious what's happening.
It wasn't like they all got together and said, you know, it's time we did the Jewish People a solid for once.