HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

rafterydj

580 karma · joined December 10, 2020

submissionscomments
rafterydj··on Uber's $1,500/month AI limit is a useful signal for AI tool pricing
I agree with you. I think that if we're talking about actual reliable problem solving, we have to be discussing robotic / drone systems. Software is as complex as you want to make it, and always has been.
rafterydj··on Meta workers can opt out of being tracked at work up to 30 min
If you are trying to say that it's not just Meta but all tech giants, you have an oddly defensive way to make that point.

Just because the entire industry was doing bad things does not absolve the largest members of the industry from doing bad things. They were leading the charge!

rafterydj··on Meta workers can opt out of being tracked at work up to 30 min
Facebook is forcing people to use Facebook. If there were realistic alternative social network systems that allowed account migration with contacts and messages, Facebook would be dead in the water.

You can't seriously argue that everyone can just drop a mainstream communication tool without acknowledging the lack of replacements.

rafterydj··on Meta workers can opt out of being tracked at work up to 30 min
Putting Meta next to Netflix in terms of moral culpability is in my opinion laughable.

I don't disagree that there are reasons people compromise on things like the morality of their employer - tale as old as society itself. I do disagree that many people like Meta's services - the only things I have seen people like about Meta is Facebook Marketplace (which is really just Craig's List or eBay if you are looking at technical problems) or the Meta Quest VR (which they've since gutted employment wise since the metaverse debacle).

Not only is it a morally bad employer, but it's also not a very good employer overall. They've just got institutional inertia keeping them entrenched, and are trying to buy their way into AI dominance to boot.

It's hard to imagine a tech company with more clear disdain for their employees than Meta. To me, that seems like a recipe for a dead company, but by all means, build your resume and network.

*Edit: people also use Instagram, but the engineering problems with that are also found in newer social networks like Bluesky, with a little less engagement addiction focus.

rafterydj··on Codex just found a "workaround" of not having sudo on my PC
Could you elaborate on this?
rafterydj··on The solution might be cancelling my AI subscription
Wow. I've essentially been circling that exact thought for awhile now. But your blunt phrasing really strikes a chord with me.
rafterydj··on The literary world is sleepwalking into an AI disaster
Here is the problem with the idea of "banning online advertising" - there is a large amount of people who spend a lot of time online. To the point that even small local businesses will buy advertisement space on social media. If such advertising is, it can be assumed social media overall will die, and we will regress back to a world where the previous media incumbents (network television) once again gain all the power.

Not a very wise solution in my opinion.

rafterydj··on The Best Engineers Write Less Code
This is in all likelihood an improvement on just measuring lines of code output, but not at all a silver bullet. I'd imagine this skews heavily towards developers who were around first in large projects. Also skews towards developers who pick certain tasks over others - there's always circumstances where the library you are building on passes breaking changes, etc. but that I feel might be more minor in comparison to the first concern.
rafterydj··on The Best Engineers Write Less Code
There has to be some language for what you're describing, because I've experienced similar perceptions of people. I've been on both sides of the "you don't actually understand what is being said until years later" discussions as well.

One thing I'd posit is that it might not be the people, but rather an ability or skill people can improve. It takes difficulty and focus and time, but it can be honed. I know this to be true; otherwise I would not be able to understand that which I dismissed years ago!

The problem with this, if it is an active ability rather than a person's inherent traits, is that it becomes impossible to recognize by any identifiable markers. I've often found that some of the most intelligent and "look at the problem from all angles" kind of minds often have very glaring blind spots (look no further than political subjects, for example). These blind spots manifest even in the most generally intelligent thinkers, that's what makes people human after all. So it can be said that good thinking is a very delicate thing, and it can be difficult to recognize against noise no matter who is speaking or what they are discussing.

rafterydj··on Why Ctrl+V won't paste images in Claude Code on WSL, with a fix
I see arguments like this particularly against Electron and the web development sphere in general and I think it's more nuanced than either programmers or "marketing" (read: anyone not a programmer) gives credit towards.

The "elusive dream" of 'write once, run anywhere' is realistically just people wanting to write software with direct product or service use in mind. Native OS conventions are subject to the middlemen of OS vendors, whereas the web (while basically subject to the same vendors) makes a substantial attempt at bridging the gap of writing software for your own purposes without native OS problems. This is a symptom of OSes catering/selling to developers as a platform and hooking them in the 1990s and 2000s.

This attitude that wanting to just make useful code for people and not worry about a windows 11 update breaking everything because they are irresponsible - to think that is not a valid desire is IMO a big problem.

On the other hand, you have a point that it quickly gets out of hand in terms of standards and accessibility and performance bottlenecks. WebAssembly and the WASI are so slow to come out and will by design always be slower than native performance. This doesn't and shouldn't stop us from having decently performant and decently usable program experiences, but it is a prerequisite to care about those things, and the other inheritors of the web development sphere clearly do not want to develop things properly if they take longer than the next fiscal quarter.

There is 100% good Electron code out there, just as 100% there is bad native OS code. The problem isn't inherently the goals of the 'write once, run anywhere' idea; it's more the casualty of other interests pulling away from what developers actually want.

rafterydj··on What Apple and Google are doing to push notifications
100% agree. The spam problem is, I fear, a symptom of the walled gardens of Google and Apple not being very judiciously maintained. They continue to push the bare minimum of notification controls out for the user, but double deal when they allow e.g. custom app-defined notification lists. Something like this would simply never fly if the Unix philosophy were an actual consideration in their product design.
rafterydj··on I spent 50 hours drawing a line graph
I'm glad I'm not the only who seemingly has a taste for "older" diagrams from that period. It makes me think of the same aesthetic roots of what's now called "cassette futurism" or "NASA-punk". Older engineering charts really feel like there was more care and thought put into each line or facet, even though I'm sure it's a trick of time.
rafterydj··on The quiet renovation at Bitwarden
Maybe this is me being a little wet behind the ears, but I don't know if lifestyle businesses are really possible to start at the moment, given the uncertainty of the current software sector.

See this thread from a few days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48118727

The economics of software creation is changing, so it stands to reason how people engage with software will change too. Finding a niche may be a game of luck more than observation/perspiration at this stage, similar to discovering oil on your "barren" property rather than building a farm. As someone who's generally independent, though: I'd love to be wrong here!

rafterydj··on AI didn't delete your database, you did
That's really interesting. Are there any things you advocate for with respect to curtailing those practices? I hesitate to throw all liability on the individual, but I don't see how we can even legislate this category of behavior, much less enforce regulations on them.
rafterydj··on Lessons for Agentic Coding: What should we do when code is cheap?
+1 for any mention of Fred Brooks. I like your point about software as a whole not being a bottleneck. In the 1970s the hardware was co-evolving with business uses (it still is, but constraints were much more severe) leading to large headcounts on software projects that _absolutely_ had to work and _absolutely_ required uncommon expertise. Most people had no concept of a computer's capabilities, computer science was not as widely distributed.

One thing that I would point to today to show that the landscape is different - the average programmer/engineer/developer today has no actual admin staff. Fred Brooks' example team setup of "The Surgical Team" has more support staff than programmers. Anyone who responds to the questions like "who manages the calendar" and "who manages the documentation" will state that the engineers doing it themselves offer the best results. Same goes for designing test cases, performing rollbacks, etc.

The fact of the matter is that any self respecting engineer today works in an environment where pro-activity and self-sufficiency are prerequisites. Managing your calendar and workload, communicating to leadership and users, these are all common tasks that would have been another person a generation ago.

So when discussing writing code more efficiently and aiding in software development, what I am essentially seeing is more people trying everything they can to offload work that used to be another person's job anyway. If you care about communication - you offload coding standards. If you care about security - you offload feature refactors, and so on.

In my opinion, I think that at some point we'll either realize that we need highly competent people _and also_ regular people to help us ensure the work gets done to a good standard. Or, we will each eventually survive by working alone in a room with a suite of AI tools, and wonder why we're still making software in the first place.

rafterydj··on AI's biggest critic has lost the plot
Not sure why you're being downvoted, your comment seems interesting to me.
rafterydj··on Drunk post: Things I've learned as a senior engineer (2021)
> Hacker news and r/programming is only good to get general ideas and keep up-to-date. The comments are almost worthless.

LOL can't disagree with that opinion.

rafterydj··on AI could be the end of the digital wave, not the next big thing
For my money, while surely it must have been jarring, that experience would seem to say that on-device LLMs are more important programming tools than package repositories.

As another commenter said, the affordability of LLM subscriptions (or, as others are predicting, the lack thereof) is the primary concern, not the technology itself stealing away your skills.

I am far from the definitive voice in the does-AI-use-corrupt-your-thinking conversation, and I don't want to be. I don't want LLMs to replace my thinking as much as the next person, but I also don't want to shun anything useful that can be gained from these tools.

All that said, I do feel that perhaps "dumber" LLMs that work on-device first will allow us to get further and be better, more reliable tools overall.

rafterydj··on The Future of Everything Is Lies, I Guess: Part 3 – Culture
Man, I completely agree with your thinking here. I've been trying to be more active in online communities, to try to discuss this exact idea.

LLM code can be leveraged, but pretending that tokens are just going to turn into money printers at some point is not productive. The primary source of software's value to an end user is the thought that was placed into it. Where does that go for the AI-natives? As you say, they are seemingly brute forcing software engineering, at least so far.

One thing I have been considering is how LLMs primarily change the "build vs buy" calculus for a fair number of software niches, particularly things like developer tooling and small libraries and packages. Partially due to a projected increase in supply chain attacks, and partially due to the changing standards of engineers. There's no longer anything stopping someone from working with an ugly or clunky syntax, presuming it's a well documented standard. So many "developer experience" tools are going to hit this - Tailwind primarily comes to mind.

It's a sort of "erosion" of niches in the current landscape - although to me this does not really work out for the worse in the long term, since again, the thinking in the process will need to just go somewhere else.

rafterydj··on ML promises to be profoundly weird
I feel the future includes the sentiments you describe. It was a little before my time professionally, but I grew up reading that kind of thinking.

I do think that the open web stuff, decentralized, or at least more decentralized than currently, is the path forward. I've been reading about the AT protocol and it recently becoming an official working group with the IETF.

I feel a second order effect of making decentralized social networking easier, is making individuals more empowered to separate from what they don't believe in. The third order effect is then building separate infrastructure entirely.

As sad as that can be - in my personal opinion it runs the risk of ending the "world wide" part of the web - it appears to be the only way society can avoid enriching the few beyond reason.

rafterydj··on Sam Altman may control our future – can he be trusted?
Well, redistributing their money is (in some cases disingenuously) exactly how they are able to pitch investors. "Sure, value my company at $10B and my shares make me $2B, but we're alllllll gonna make money when hit AGI!!!" That kind of thing.
rafterydj··on [dead]
Yeah, LOL. "Nothing leaves your machine except network payloads containing all of your personal data." Private and secure!
rafterydj··on The threat is comfortable drift toward not understanding what you're doing
ChatGPT 3.5 came out coming on 4 years ago now. I don't think a human generation (~20-30 years) needs to be the benchmark here, but new juniors in the industry for a handful of years can be said to be a whole "generation". That how I was reading OP.
rafterydj··on Good ideas do not need lots of lies in order to gain public acceptance (2008)
No, but what else is there to do?

If, despite best attempts for me to communicate facts to them within our common language, they still can not recognize basic truth or fact from their subjective truth? I don't really see that a problem for the speaker, but a problem for the listener.

That's no way that the opposite expectation can scale as a society. Otherwise we would all need to validate everyone else's words constantly with primary source documents. There must be some level of trust in order to communicate efficiently, surely.

rafterydj··on We replaced RAG with a virtual filesystem for our AI documentation assistant
Stuck it on my calendar, looking forward to it.
rafterydj··on Mercurial Dyson – a plan for the disassembly of planet Mercury
This reads like an LLM plagiarizing this video from Kurzgesagt:

https://youtu.be/pP44EPBMb8A?si=fSwWPOCnCsC1QEny

rafterydj··on Good ideas do not need lots of lies in order to gain public acceptance (2008)
No, turning it around doesn't work because it's cause and effect.

"Present the facts and all the people will cheer and support stop using coal" -> correct

"If not it means stopping using coal is a bad idea?" -> incorrect, because people are against switching to renewables because of lies, not because of facts

rafterydj··on Solar and batteries can power the world
Unsure why you're getting downvoted. I know politics is generally frowned upon here but this is absolutely relevant to the conversation.
rafterydj··on Artemis computer running two instances of MS outlook; they can't figure out why
Well, on the software design side, there's plenty of scenarios where undocumented behavior crops up on unexpected network interruption. In the example above, Windows can even pre-download updates on metered connections during one time period, then install those updates during another. The customers really can't take the blame for that, IMO.

I think overall society has rapidly deteriorated in software quality and it is mostly because of the devaluing of software design. No one expects quality from software, everyone "understands there are bugs", and some like to take advantage of that. And so the Overton window gets pushed in the direction of "broken forever good luck holding the bag if you use it" rather than the more realistic "occasionally needs to restart IFF you hit an issue and it takes less than <10 seconds and has minimal data loss".

rafterydj··on I quit. The clankers won
I don't disagree about the core CS fundamentals - 100% the same page. I suppose this really boils down to a difference in what constitutes "training/education".

Any $PROGRAMMER_TITLE worth their salary can learn a new stack for a project, because they know the fundamentals. BUT there's still a lead time on being comfortable with new languages, frameworks, problem domains, etc. It's this kind of time and effort that I am trying to get at when discussing companies paying for training/education. It can be worth investing in your people if your goals are longer horizon.

I don't think it makes sense for companies to pay for their employees to learn basic data structures or other "prerequisite" fundamentals, though. That would be a large investment!

← PreviousPage 3 of 6Next →