HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

rafterydj

580 karma · joined December 10, 2020

submissionscomments
rafterydj··on I quit. The clankers won
I've definitely felt this kind of way in the past. But these days I'm not so sure.

Setting aside the AI point about it, the idea of people becoming essentially irrelevant to the economy is an indictment on society. But I'd argue that the indictment really is towards what constitutes measurement in the economy. Not an indictment on society itself, or technology.

Sure, someone may not spend much money or produce much money, but if they produce scientific research or cultural work that is intangibly valuable it is still valuable regardless of whether economists can point to a metric or not. Same goes for the infinite amounts of contributions to our world from nature: what is the economic value of a garden snake or a beetle? A meaningless question when the economy can only see things in dollars.

rafterydj··on I Quit. The Clankers Won
I agree - I was mostly trying to think of an example against OP's rather facetious attitude towards the time and effort required to maintain engineering performance.

In my experience, a lot of the Rust fighting with the borrow checker is really just enforcing better quality code I should've been writing anyway.

rafterydj··on I quit. The clankers won
Point still stands. You're going to take up the mantle for suggesting a computer science degree from 2000 completely qualifies someone for work in 2026? No further education needed?
rafterydj··on I quit. The clankers won
How wildly dismissive of the foundation of the X$ billion dollar software industry. You think humans just stumbled into writing code by accident or something?

How does building agentic systems, a "really hard" problem, not just end up a "regular code" problem? Because that is what it is. A distributed systems problem with non-deterministic run lengths. How do you switch agent contexts? Similar to how you solve regular program context switching. How do you search tool capabilities and verify them? How do you effectively manage scheduled tasks?

Oh, look, you've just invented the operating system kernel. Suddenly, those 'dozen or two' experts don't seem so archaic after all!

rafterydj··on I Quit. The Clankers Won
This argument falls apart if you consider what field we're talking about. At what point would going to school for 5 years give you the whole education you actually needed? Does learning C in 1995-2000 prepare you for Rust in 2026? No, and it shouldn't, but work needs done, so _yes_ there is a dollar amount of value for educating your workforce that has already been vetted and already knows the context for your business goals. Asking what that number is completely misses the point.
rafterydj··on I quit. The clankers won
I mean, sure, for programming macros. Or programming quick scripts, or type-safe or memory-safe programs. Or web frontends, or a11y, or whatever tasks for which people are using AI.

But if you peel back that layer to the point where you are no longer discussing the code, and just saying "code X that does Y"... how big is X going to get without verifying it? This is a basic, fundamental question that gets deflected by evaluating each case where AI is useful.

When you stop being specific about what the AI is doing, and switch to the general tense, there is a massive and obvious gap that nobody is adequately addressing. I don't think anyone would say that details are irrelevant in the case of life-threatening scenarios, and yet no one is acknowledging where the logical end to this line of thinking goes.

rafterydj··on I quit. The clankers won
I see this line of thought put out there many times, and I've been thinking: why do people do anything at all? What's the point? If no one at all is even reviewing the output of coding agents, genuinely, what are we doing as a society?

I fail to see how we transition society into a positive future without supplying means of verifying systemic integrity. There is a reason that Upton Sinclair became famous: wayward incentives behind closed doors generally cause subpar standards, which cause subpar results. If the FDA didn't exist, or they didn't "review the output", society would be materially worse off. If the whole pitch for AI ends with "and no one will even need to check anything" I find that highly convenient for the AI industry.

rafterydj··on I use excalidraw to manage my diagrams for my blog
Hey look, someone else has the exact same problem I do! I even use Excalidraw for diagramming as well, and have been wondering about how best to generate them according to some kind of binary format.
rafterydj··on We haven't seen the worst of what gambling and prediction markets will do
I definitely think there's a middle ground here, that the commenter to which you are replying may also be alluding. If a human is scanning resumes, job titles tend to be more important than the company, although both are obviously relevant.

So yes, if one is "Senior VP - Engagement Optimization" at e.g. Draft Kings, that would imply a level of culpability for "gambling experience = do not hire".

But if the title is "call center support - kelshi - 6 mo. contract"? Sure. I don't think the policy needs to be as stringent as all that.

Not necessarily disagreeing with either perspective, since they don't seem incompatible to me.

rafterydj··on Show HN: I built a tool that watches webpages and exposes changes as RSS
What an interesting glimpse into the blogosphere. That post in particular is interesting, given the much larger discussions that followed it on essentially the same topic: how to decide what people can and can not say when there are those who ruin the commons. I'm thinking of Twitter/X's Community Notes feature and the many reputation mechanisms people put in place, and the subsequent griping of community politics that arise from those mechanisms...
rafterydj··on AI is killing B2B SaaS
Hey, that sounds like OpenAI!
rafterydj··on Claude Code for Infrastructure
Super interesting. I don't know why, but something about this comment made something click for me, as an "AI fatigued" engineer.

From the view you describe, it seems AI just lets you experiment faster, when all you want to do is experiment. You find product market fit easier, you empower designers more, etc. Much easier to iterate and find easy wins from alternative designs - as long as your fundamentals work!

Only problem is that you are experimenting in public, so the massive wave of new AI generated features come to the public from everywhere at once. Hence the widespread backlash.

Not to mention, the core job function when you are experimenting is different from what defines a lot of hard technical progress: creating new technologies, or foundational work that others build on, is naturally harder and slower than building e.g. CRUD services on top of an existing stack. Deep domain expertise matters for selling, deep programming expertise matters for stability. I don't know, curious where the line will end up getting drawn.

rafterydj··on Waiting for dawn in search: Search index, Google rulings and impact on Kagi
This is a woefully naive view on the nature of monopolies. You could have made the same argument for Standard Oil.
rafterydj··on American importers and consumers bear the cost of 2025 tariffs: analysis
What are you saying? "None of the doomsday predictions have come to pass." -> nothing is wrong and the USA is fine

"There's been major impact to some things" -> so bad things have happened

"but for the most part the economy has hummed along without a blip." -> so despite bad things happening, just plug your ears and sing loudly?

As for prices in Walmart, they HAVE gone up. Several companies have had press releases stating they need to increase prices because of tariffs:

https://www.cnbc.com/2025/05/31/trump-tariffs-here-are-the-r...

"Retailers like Costco and Best Buy said they have already raised some prices, while Walmart, Target and Macy's plan to follow suit"

I'll be the first to say that given the circumstances our underlying economy and people have held up better than complete collapse. But you can't pretend this is not happening.

rafterydj··on Software engineers can no longer neglect their soft skills
That's a false equivalence. You might read a blog post about engineering from someone who paid a maid to clean their house, and sends their laundry out.

But would you read their blog post on laundry tips?

No - it's just as easy for you to send out your own laundry.

rafterydj··on Apple is fighting for TSMC capacity as Nvidia takes center stage
I tend to agree with you, feels to me like the root of this is essentially whether foundries will "go all in" on AI like the rest of the S&P 500. But why trade away one trillion-dollar customer for another trillion-dollar customer if the first one is never going away, and the second one might?
rafterydj··on Provenance Is the New Version Control
I'm not sold on the idea that commits and PRs are always easily tied back to tickets. Ideally, sure. In practice? Not always.
rafterydj··on Mozilla's open source AI strategy
I'll be contrarian to the thread sentiment and say: Mozilla has misstepped in the past, and will continue to do so, and they're partially funded by competitors for antitrust reasons, etc.

That said, I can't really disagree with anything in this. As a developer (and socially conscious human) I want to move in the direction of openness.

rafterydj··on Computers that used to be human
Thanks for pointing out this section, but "race baiting garbage" is a strong term, no?

There were historical inaccuracies, some of which I expected like timeline issues and things like that, as well some things which were actually true that I did not expect (John Glenn asking for the calculations personally). In the end it is a movie meant to spark interest in NASA / science and tell a compelling story about people who helped us during a time before the Civil Rights Act. To call it "race baiting garbage" is overly dismissive and I think exposes an alarming personal bias.

rafterydj··on Himalayas bare and rocky after reduced winter snowfall, scientists warn
This is inflammatory, dismissive, and hardly constructive for discussion. Flame wars are discouraged by the rules.

All said, you're comment worked. I'm angry now. Good job.

rafterydj··on Ask HN: What are you working on? (January 2026)
Do you have any concerns about production bugs or human-in-the-loop?
rafterydj··on ChatGPT Health is a marketplace, guess who is the product?
I believe existing laws carve out exceptions for medical fitness for certain positions for this very reason. If I may, stepping back for a second: the reason privacy laws exist, is to protect people from bad behavior from employers, health insurance, etc.

If we circumvent those privacy laws, through user licenses, or new technology - we are removing the protections of normal citizens. Therefore, the bad behavior which we already decided as a society to ban can now be perpetrated again, with perhaps a fresh new word for it to dodge said old laws.

If I understand your comment, you are essentially wondering why those old laws existed in the first place. I would suggest racism or other systemic issues, and differences in insurance premiums, are more than enough to justify the existence of privacy laws. Take a normal office job as an example over a manual labor intensive job. No reason at all that health conditions should impact that. The idea of not being hired because I have a young child, or a health condition, that would raise the group rate from the insurer passing the cost to my employer (which would be in their best interest to do) is a terrible thought. And it happened before, and we banned that practice (or did our best to do so).

All this to say, I believe HIPAA helps people, and if ChatGPT is being used to partially or fully facilitate medical decision making, they should be bound under strict laws preventing the release of that data regardless of their existing user agreements.

rafterydj··on How we automated federal retirements
If it was really down to two engineers, it's almost certainly what one or both of them were already comfortable or familiar with and no other reason. Six months is such a short time frame for long term projects like this that I imagine they could not spare much time for analysis of alternatives.
rafterydj··on What happened to all the gold Spain got from the New World? (1985)
Could you elaborate a little bit more?
rafterydj··on AWS CEO says replacing junior devs with AI is 'one of the dumbest ideas'
plugging your AI newsletter at the end of your comment comes off as an indicator you want to farm engagement, not genuinely stimulate conversation.
rafterydj··on Using LLMs at Oxide
>it seems likely that it's going to be on the LLM user to know if the out is protected by copyright.

To me, this is what seems more insane! If you've never read Harry Potter, and you ask an LLM to write you a story about a wizard boy, and it outputs 80% Harry Potter - how would you even know?

> there will be probably be some "reasonable belief" defence in eventual laws.

This is probably true, but it's irksome to shift all blame away from the LLM producers, using copy-written data to peddle copy-written output. This simply turns the business into copyright infringement as a service - what incentive would they have to actually build those "secondary search thingies" and build them well?

> it definitely isn't as simple as "LLM wrote it so we can ignore copyright".

Agreed. The copyright system is getting stress tested. It will be interesting to see how our legal systems can adapt to this.

rafterydj··on Instagram chief orders staff back to the office five days a week in 2026
This is a frustrating comment. Please elaborate with a real point! Just highlighting something that used to be the case, does not imply that it should always be the case, nor does it imply that it reflects the case now.
rafterydj··on How to Attend Meetings
Wow, I might need to steal that idea for bypassing Jira discussions. I hate Jira with all my might.
rafterydj··on GitLab discovers widespread NPM supply chain attack
This sounds very interesting to me. I'd read through that blog post, as I'm working on expanding my K8s skills - as you say knowledge is very scattered!
rafterydj··on What OpenAI did when ChatGPT users lost touch with reality
Respectfully I disagree there. Social media is dangerous and corrosive to a healthy mind, but AI is like a rapidly adaptive cancer if you don't recognize it for what it is.

Reading accounts from people who fell into psychosis induced by LLMs feels like a real time mythological demon whispering insanities and temptations into the ear directly, in a way that algorithmically recommended posts from other people could never match.

It will naturally mimic your biases. It will find the most likely response for you to keep engaging with it. It will tell you everything you want to hear, even if it is not based in reality. In my mind it's the same dangers of social media but dialed all the way up to 11.

← PreviousPage 4 of 6Next →