HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

raganwald

45,002 karma · joined February 21, 2007

http://braythwayt.com

http://github.com/raganwald

http://twitter.com/raganwald

submissionscomments
raganwald··on Lenovo to buy Google's Motorola handset division
My guess is, we're going to see big layoffs.

Sometimes, a company sells a division or wholly owned business because it is either that or massive layoffs, and it's better for morale to write down a few billion dollars than to fire thousands of people.

Even if you're working in one of the profitable businesses, a real chill goes around when the pink slip printing press starts hammering.

raganwald··on If I can do it, you can do it
I honestly don't know. When I first wrote a program, I felt like Mickey Mouse putting the sorcerer's hat on. My interest wasn't particularly rational.
raganwald··on If I can do it, you can do it
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poe's_law
raganwald··on If I can do it, you can do it
Reminder: The plural of anecdote is not "data."
raganwald··on Bro pages: like man pages, but with examples only
I was basically done with this thread, but your comment is sufficiently interesting.

Compare two programmers. One believes that code must be perfect right out of the gate or else it is very embarrassing. The other believes continuous iteration is the normal state.

If presented with a major design challenge ("This UX doesn't work at all for people using screen readers"), I posit that the first developer is motivated to explain why the code as it stands is a good idea ("Those users aren't our market.") The first programmer views the idea of being wrong as deeply embarrassing, and wants to avoid feeling shame, or weakness, or whatever it is that involves saying "I was wrong."

The second programmer makes changes and carries on without worrying about it.

And so it is with a word. If you are deeply embarrassed at the notion of having to change, you make up all sorts of reasons why you are right and the people pointing out another way are wrong.

Whereas if you believe that development is all about iteration, you make the change and move along.

I am the second kind of writer. Many times I have blogged something, been called out about some technical or social point, and simply edited my posts. To me, iteration is a sign that things are working properly.

So... If HN allowed me to edit my comment to remove a word I now know is inappropriate, I would do so without worrying about it. I wish more people would take the same attitude: "Oh, this may make things inaccessible for someone? Let's change it and move on without drama just as we change our code and move on without drama."

raganwald··on Bro pages: like man pages, but with examples only
I'll take that as a "I want you to burden yourself with justifying your position, but I'm not going to commit to any movement on my own position, and for that matter, I won't even commit to a position, I'm just lobbing a burden at you."

I choose not to play along.

raganwald··on Bro pages: like man pages, but with examples only
Your point has been raised elsewhere in this thread as well as many, many times in the last fifty-plus years when debating the effect of language on exclusion. I don't think I can add something new to the debate, so I'll direct you to do some research and find out why people do not accept your argument as axiomatically true.

Furthermore, the point that you're replying to says little about whether 'bro' or even 'white power' is offensive, it says that the debate about 'white power' was a distraction to a point about CoffeeScript.

And thus, my advice to the project authors is to change the name. Agree or disagree with whether it's offensive, it wasn't written to provoke you and I into discussing exclusionary language, it was written to help people be more productive.

The name works against that. Fair, unfair, what's the difference if your goal is to make people more productive?

raganwald··on Bro pages: like man pages, but with examples only
the legitimacy of your concerns is based in how women (in this case) feel. If you can't find a person who thinks he/she is being discriminated against here, you're obviously tilting at windmills.

Now what you're presenting me with is a proposition that if "X" is false, then I should reconsider my belief that "Y" is true. So before I give this further thought, let me call your bet:

Will you in turn agree that if "X" turns out to be true, will you reconsider your belief that "Y" is false?

I would hate to go to a lot of work to show you that there are offended women, only to hear you mansplain to me that well, there aren't enough women, or they're the wrong sorts of women, or even if they're offended that they shouldn't be offended, or some other such weaselling out.

raganwald··on Bro pages: like man pages, but with examples only
I would like to hear from first hand sources -- not a bunch of dudes on a software forum who claim to know what women want.

How very odd that despite all of our behaviour being so non-offensive and non-exclusionary, we don't seem to have any women who want to hang around this forum with us, and especially don't want to engage in discussions about exclusion where the immediate response to any questioning to for the questioner to be shouted down in vituperative terms.

raganwald··on Bro pages: like man pages, but with examples only
My experience is this:

Some time ago, I wrote a post about CoffeeScript. As you may know, CoffeeScript is a whitespace-specific programming language.

I am black, and there is a small cultural wiggle-room when it comes to black people making fun of colour-based cultural issues. So I thought I could get away with calling my post "White Power."

The response was immediate and scathing. Regardless of whether I was personally offended by my title, it was put to me that my title was inappropriate to go sailing round the front page of Hacker News, &c.

Maybe it was, maybe it wasn't, but you know what? These things are about how people react, not what was on my mind at the time. There is room for debate when people are doing these things specifically to provoke debate, as one finds in art and drama. But in this case, I was not an artist trying to make a point about culture, I was writing a blog post about CoffeeScript.

I changed the name, I think I renamed it after a Mondrian composition. A few people continued to rag me about it, but in time people forgot the name but continued to productively discuss CoffeeScript.

In any event, I feel for the authors. We all make our little jokes, and sometimes they land with a resounding thud. The problem, of course, is that unless we are artists provoking people into thinking about culture, these discussions are a distraction from the good work we're trying to do.

So the right thing to do as a developer is change the name and move on. If it is changed, the good things in this library will live on long after people have forgotten the rhetoric expended on the choice of name.

It would be a shame if the library is remembered for its name instead of its functionality.

raganwald··on Bro pages: like man pages, but with examples only
Dude(?), I'm not MLK, and I'm not into women's rights. I'm a selfish bastard who wants to double or treble the number of productive brains in my environment. Exclusionary behaviour stands between me and my dream, and I will crush it by any means necessary.

If you must compare me, think of Malcolm X. Do not make the mistake of thinking I'm nice to women, men, other people of colour, or anybody else.

raganwald··on Bro pages: like man pages, but with examples only
I'm offended, and you'll find I do not joke about oppression.
raganwald··on Bro pages: like man pages, but with examples only
I believe that Hacker News is worse off when it includes comments like yours. I don't know or care who you're talking to, the tone of what you're saying drags a good forum down past Reddit and into talk radio call-in territory. And even without the tone, the premise is puerile and an insult to good faith discussions.

Sometimes, a thing just stinks. It doesn't matter which way the wind blows the stink, it stinks. Your comment stinks.

raganwald··on Bro pages: like man pages, but with examples only
Your premise is flawed. For example, I don't give a damn what women think of my calling people out on misogyny. I am not pro-women, I am anti-jackass. Comments like yours are jackasstic. I can dislike them without a moment's consideration of what women think of your words.
raganwald··on Bro pages: like man pages, but with examples only
> How about an individual having backbone and integrity to stand firm, hold the line and not supplicate?

I have the backbone and integrity to know that as I walk through life, I am responsible for stepping carefully and thoughtfully.

I have no problem stepping forward to call people out when they're well-intentioned but wrong, or ill-intentioned. Even if it costs me karma, or sales, or popularity, it is sometimes the right thing to do.

In this case, I am calling you out on the word "supplicate.' I choose to make the world a better place. I'm not supplicating, or white knighting, or anything like that. It's not about appeasing anyone, it's about doing the right thing for us.

The very word "supplicate" implies a them vs. us dichotomy which is itself a problem. YOU are furthering these problems by using divisive language.

The library is an organic creation. Organisms grow and evolve and CHANGE FOR THE BETTER. If you think it would be better with a name that many find offensive and divisive, that's your opinion.

But you can guess what I think of the premise that when things are offensive, it's everyone else's responsibility to change. It sounds like a spoiled brat who thinks the world should revolve around them, and everyone else should change so that they can do as they like without pushback.

raganwald··on How Silicon Valley CEOs conspired to drive down tech engineer wages
free market != fair market
raganwald··on How Silicon Valley CEOs conspired to drive down tech engineer wages
And therein lies the problem. Although these companies are being prosecuted, nobody wants to run afoul of them or anybody else. I'm not saying that any one individual or company is presently a bullying wrongdoer, but what I am saying is that there is an culture of fear around speaking out or rubbing people the wrong way.

This atmosphere--along with the kind of proprietary shenanigans that make it difficult or impossible to truly own your own hardware and software stack--is the very opposite of the hacker ethos that created much of the value these barons robbed from the economy.

raganwald··on How I “hacked” Kayak and booked a cheaper flight
No, that's not what I said. What I said was, I understand his outrage, and here's an example of where I feel it too. Empathy.
raganwald··on Payments Startup Stripe (YC S10) Joins the Billion Dollar Club
"Where there's muck, there's brass"--Paul Graham, quoting some timeless business wisdom.
raganwald··on How I “hacked” Kayak and booked a cheaper flight
There is if you lie to the customer. There isn't if you say "Tough bananas, the written quote expired, we both get to renegotiate."
raganwald··on How I “hacked” Kayak and booked a cheaper flight
Your outrage is noted. I feel exactly the same way about the way highly admired companies around here behave, only they have nicer names for exploitation like "price discrimination" and "market segmentation" and "monetizing customers."
raganwald··on How I “hacked” Kayak and booked a cheaper flight
This technique goes back long before the Internet. I recall working in a computer store where it was a standard practice to give someone a quote with an expiry date, and if they missed the time limit extra money would be tacked on with some made-up BS excuse (We sold out of Foobars and the new shipment came in at a higher price).

It was the exact same reasoning: The customer walked away, shopped around, and came back because we have everyone else beat. So now we need to raise our price as much as possible without making it worth their while to go back to someone else.

And in fact, they probably are in our place because someone else raised their price on them, or disclosed hidden gotchas, so we have leverage.

raganwald··on New Year, New CEO for GitHub
And when you poke it with a stick, it falls apart. GANTT isn't an acronym, the chart was invented by Henry Gantt:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henry_Gantt

raganwald··on New Year, New CEO for GitHub
GRANNT Chart: A Grantt chart is a type of bar chart that illustrates a project schedule. Grantt charts illustrate the start and finish dates of the terminal elements and summary elements of a project, such that completion of the project qualifies the team for a research and development grant.

Serious answer: Issues are not--to my knowledge--a software estimation tool. I have worked for decades in estimation-oriented development environments, and in my (anecdotal) experience, it is a mistake to use the same tool for both estimation and delivery.

It is seductive for them to be the same thing, as you can feed actual times back into your project, but the conclusion I've drawn is that the estimate reflects a kind of "interface" visible to the outside world, while the issues reflect an "implementation" visible to the team.

When they are the same thing, you end up doing a lot of work fiddling with the estimate to keep it congruent with the internal tasks, even when that congruence is not relevant to the delivery date(s).

I realize that this is heterodoxy.

raganwald··on Windows 7 'back by popular demand', says HP as it targets wary consumers
Windows 8.1 vs Windows 7 is not so interesting to me. But Microsoft 2014 vs Microsoft 1994 is very interesting to me.

There was a time when they had enough weight that they could force their vendors to toe the party line on OS versions. Enterprises might drag their feet on upgrading, but consumers were force-fed the new release even if they hated it.

They had failures, but even so their vendors were reluctant to push back like this. Or at least, that's how I remember it. Not any more.

raganwald··on The decay and fall of guest blogging for SEO
I use markdown for my blog, which is then compiled by Jekyll. Why should I know or care what a nofollow link is? I link to things so that my readers can click on the link and read more about whatever I'm saying.

It's my job to act naturally and not try to game the system. It's Google's job to figure out whether I'm acting normally or gaming the system.

raganwald··on Prototypes Are Not Classes
polymorphism is actually orthogonal to the ideas around metaobjects like classes. They are both powerful ideas. but can be expressed in different ways. Languages like Common Lisp and Haskell allow you to express polymorphism entirely through overloading of functions, for example.
raganwald··on Prototypes Are Not Classes
Encapsulating instance state us not the point, encapsulating the class behaviour is the point. So, if you can make the prototype itself private and modify the prototype with class methods, you have something that prototypes by themselves do not express.

The analogy is not to a private instance variable in Ruby, the analogy is to a class method in Ruby Dutch as define_method.

raganwald··on Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me”
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Was_(Not_Was)
raganwald··on Prototypes Are Not Classes
This is the best feedback so far.
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →