HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ragequittah

272 karma · joined June 14, 2023

submissionscomments
ragequittah··on Anthropic to receive high 'junk' rating from credit agencies following IPO
* results may vary depending on your specific definition of AGI.

I like the way Kevin Roose put it: if you were to bring Astra or Opus 5.5 back to 2017 and show it to the leading AI researchers at the time and ask them if it were a form of AGI what would they say? The goal posts shift too fast to keep up with. Some people still worried about it counting Rs in strawberry as the models are making progress in frontier math and physics.

ragequittah··on LLM Voice
My take is that most art, prose, and code was really bad before AI too. Now there's just more of it good and bad. It's like hating that YouTube exists because cable TV was so good. Now anyone with a camera can make and upload whatever nonsense they want but in the end lots of very good content was made on top of the huge pile of rubbish.
ragequittah··on Valve Responds to Developers Fearing AI Slop and Clones
Video games are a perfect example of how innovation all but stops when a few companies have access to all of the resources. Companies like EA, Ubisoft, Activision Blizzard all make mostly hot garbage these days because they 'innovated' themselves into making the same 4 games over and over. It's happening with movies too where everything is either a sequel or a remake because recognizable IP has been deemed more important than making something actually good.

Video games have always been about copying the other guy and making it better though. Blizzard famously akways just made the best parts of all other games in the genre packaged up with cool looking cinematics. Every single FPS borrows from every other FPS any time something new comes along. And thankfully when Nintendo tried to stop it with Palworld they (mostly) got egg on their face.

The one famous example that did stick that I can remember is warner bros patented the nemesis system in Shadow of Mordor. Nobody can use that actually rather cool idea until 2036 and it hasn't been used in a decade now. Real cool stuff and definitely pushed the industry forward.

ragequittah··on The foolishness of "natural language programming" (1978)
>But "sudo make me a sandwich" style of vibe coding is just removing the obstacles to enshrining ambiguities and bad decisions in code.

I'm of the opinion that if you think it will stay this way you haven't been paying attention. "sudo find me a security flaw" already embarrasses top security researchers who have been working on the same code for decades. "sudo decompile this program/firmware/game" is doing absolute wondrous things right now even if there are still some flaws. If it can do these things better / significantly faster than humans already, and if it keeps improving at the rate it has been "sudo make me an operating system" that spits out something actually pretty good is probably within a decade.

ragequittah··on Today, we hacked what we'd set out to hack: the iPhone
There's a reason why enterprises don't give you an admin account on Windows. Sure damage can still be done, but the blast radius is highly reduced. It was like the first rule I learned about Linux back in the day: don't ever log in as root, don't even bother enabling it. Hell it's not even a good idea to do it on an offline computer cuz you might accidentally bork something yourself. The barrier of at least a password to install system level software or delete critical files is a good one to have.
ragequittah··on Today, we hacked what we'd set out to hack: the iPhone
Such a wild take to me. I install an entirely different operating system on my phone (graphene) which also advises me not to root because it's stupidly unsafe to do so. I also don't log in as root on linux, nor do I log in as an administrator in windows. None of these are sane practices to anyone worried about security.
ragequittah··on Today, we hacked what we'd set out to hack: the iPhone
I can root my Android phone and have in the past, but I have absolutely no desire to do so now because it adds almost no functionality in exchange for a very large security risk. I consider rooting my phone in the past quite a foolish move by someone who didn't know better.
ragequittah··on Jailbreaking the Switch 2
I love Nintendo and have since the NES was released. Taking a day or 2 to set up an Ayn Thor w/ every game I've ever played from my childhood, the instruction manuals, and whatever other conveniences modern emulation affords really does beat trying to find the old hardware and games at a ridiculous premium. Also buying most all of the old stuff doesn't help Nintendo in any way so the 'morality' goes out the window. The setup IS a bit tedious but once it's done you rarely have to change anything.

I also own a Switch 1 w/ Breath of The Wild but I prefer to emulate it because you can increase the draw distance, get 60 FPS, add some HD textures [1], and fix some other issues that I had with the game because the Switch 1 was such terrible hardware. Even the Switch 2 version isn't nearly as good as the one you can get from emulating.

[1]https://youtu.be/YK2lkGsaoaw

ragequittah··on Tesla Roadster
Wait until you see how the Apollo lunar modules and such maneuvered in the 60s. This is pretty much all 60s and 70s tech we've seen before. Except it was much more impressive in the 60s on the moon. And I guess if you want cold-gas propulsion not chemical NASA Skylab is the way cooler actually practical example.
ragequittah··on Will it be a golden age or a dark age for mathematics (and science)?
Do we not see a path forward where the humans are further informed, don't need to do so much heavy grunt work, and thus can think on deeper questions? I really don't see the final outcome being knowledge work for humans completely disappearing. In fact having something that potentially can do it better and faster will make keeping up with that knowledge all the more fascinating won't it? This whole conversation feels like what someone with an abacus would say when they saw the first digital pocket calculator.
ragequittah··on Claude reveals ECDSA curve origins
I think when the open source models catch up (likely soon) we'll long for the days when companies could control it like this. I could easily see a teenager with openclaw and a single prompt causing millions of dollars in damage. Multiply that by the number of stupid people in the world and we have a problem.
ragequittah··on Tesla Roadster
I too remember when we started colonizing Mars back in 2021. And that time I called my neighbor's Tesla robotaxi to drive me around in 2020.
ragequittah··on RimWorld 1.7 moves from Unity to Ludeon's in-house Waylith engine
My guess is there's a whole plethora of important information you're ignorant about that you could just look up and have full knowledge of if you cared. But nobody has time to care about everything. People only have so much time in a day. After 8 hours of working and 2 hours commuting because nobody can afford to live in a city anymore people just want to eat dinner, relax for a bit, and go to bed. Maybe spend time with their kids instead of sitting around reading about how AI is going to make them obsolete.

Example I would give is I'm totally ignorant of local politics. I just don't have any time at all to parse it, and I probably wouldn't bother even if I were magically given the time. There's people out there that would be just as upset at me as you are at people ignorant about AI. And it's not that I'm lesser than the person focused on local politics, I just spend my time elsewhere.

ragequittah··on Why We're Banning AI
I predict this is going to change soon similar to how "look at how bad AI is at coding" changed. I understand that we all feel like something with a soul should be doing this stuff and it feels wrong to read something that "no thought" was put into. But if it's able to write better and more informed (because it can research and integrate ideas many orders of magnitude faster) than some of the better writers I don't see why you would ever read the less informed, worse written version. We definitely aren't there yet but I don't see any reason why we won't get there. It's not like excellent writing is such an onerous task it can never be solved.
ragequittah··on RimWorld 1.7 moves from Unity to Ludeon's in-house Waylith engine
I think that's a bit mean to the people (in my experience most people) who didn't and still don't see it. What's happening right now is really akin to magic. We're throwing incantations at sand and it's doing work for us. The rate of change is such that nobody can keep up with it all, even the people like me who use it daily.

What people DO see is having to use or be monitored by ABYSMAL types of AI at work or when they try to call x company for support or whatever. The outcry against data centers when the same people building them were moaning about how electric vehicles would crash our electric grid completely is quite justified. As is the outcry about creative and intellectual theft. Add deepfakes, scams, spam, misinformation, etc. and the negative externalities of AI for most people seem to far outweigh the "benefits". And everything beneficial seems to just be training the AI to do your job in disguise. Add in that the billionaires behind most of this tech come off as completely out of touch with the real world and I totally see the perspective of "screw AI and everything it stands for" even if I don't share it myself.

ragequittah··on Americans' social activity has steeply declined in the past 30 years
The flip side to this is thinking everyone is on equal footing and that your trying is the same as their trying. They're just doing it wrong.

Most people in this post's comments that are "not trying" seem to also be depressed in some way. If you've never experienced it, depression can make trying impossible not just a minor inconvenience. Going to therapy can help, or not. Taking anti-depressants can help, or not.

Also a "mild attempt at doing this once" that ends very poorly can cause a depressed or anxious person to spiral into a self-hatred looping hellscape. It's not a rational decision they're making it just happens. After you've experienced that you're very cautious and try to never feel it again.

And then the kicker is when you're paralyzed like this everyone just thinks you're lazy or unmotivated and pretty much tells you "don't be depressed stupid" which further sends you into having a poor outlook of yourself and it spirals from there. I've been in and out of this several times in my life, it's not pleasant. I've also tried every single remedy known to man and sometimes nothing works.

To put it simply: their experience is probably valid and nobody should tell them otherwise.

ragequittah··on AI is a tool and using it well takes skill
If the main effort is trawling through forums or poorly written documentation the main thing you've learned is how to trawl through these things. I'm of the opinion these should've never been useful skills to begin with.
ragequittah··on RimWorld 1.7 moves from Unity to Ludeon's in-house Waylith engine
I just heard the giantbomb guys describe how to block Claude code on Github so you don't have to play any filthy AI helped decompilations. It's a new kind of social benchmark among some people to be the most against AI.
ragequittah··on Scientists wonder: Is my AI stealing my ideas?
I have a feeling detaching your dignity and sense of purpose from something an AI can easily steal might be a net good for most people.
ragequittah··on AI is a tool and using it well takes skill
This I agree with. But it goes for people's attention spans due to social media, hopelessness because of the insane top-heavy economy and climate change, and a whole load of other stuff piled on top of it all. I feel really bad for the kids these days. There are of course ways to prevent kids from using AI but I bet it'd work as well as preventing kids using social media (they'll just find a way around the rules).
ragequittah··on AI is a tool and using it well takes skill
I push back on this idea hard. There's some things I consider not worth my time since an LLM will always be available to do it for me. But a whole lot of things you can learn far better with a LLM than almost anywhere else.

Been learning Linux, how to build a homelab, and quite a few other related topics since about chatgpt 3.5. If the LLM went away tomorrow I'd still know how to do most things in Linux, set up my opnsense router, reinstall xcp-ng, do everything in docker, and a boatload of other things that would've been so much more tedious to learn before an LLM. Simplicity of access to knowledge doesn't mean you don't learn it. A google search didn't make us learn slower than when we had to scour for books at the library, it increased the pace dramatically. Same goes for LLMs.

You can use LLMs and learn nothing. People who like to learn won't ever use it that way.

ragequittah··on Artificial Insanity
They seem more marginal because the models are already capable of so much. But there was a turning point about November of last year if I recall where software developers I know went from "lol look at how this thing codes, my job is safe" to "oh no". And the models back then were actually pretty bad at many things compared to Astra or Opus 5.5.

You're right that many of the less capable / open weights models are very good themselves, but that's part of showing how much more capable the frontier models are becoming. Cheaper (smaller) models are able to do the same things, in many cases better, as the way larger models were able to do a year ago. The efficiency is getting way better alongside the 'intelligence'. That'll also cause the models to become much faster over time which is the real improvement I'm waiting for.

I think a part of why many people aren't seeing big deltas if they're using it for code and they're actually coders is we actually sit down and reason out the project with the LLM. Someone who knows nothing about coding ~1 year ago wouldn't come even close to the kind of app they'd get now with the same instructions. If you just give it a task like "help me decompile this game" without knowing a whole lot about decompiling suddenly in the last 3 or so months you start to get some half-decent results.

The sea-change I see lately is about lifting up the people who couldn't do these things before more than the people who could. And I actually see problems coming from that already as people I've met think they can make enterprise grade software if they just tell their LLM to make it safe.

ragequittah··on Artificial Insanity
My guess is you're barely holding it at all if you haven't seen several more uses for it in the last year or so.
ragequittah··on Using AI for just 10 minutes erodes your ability to persist at hard things
Maybe more like an architect saying "I built" when actually construction workers did all the building. Even that's stretching it though because construction workers tend to follow the plans fairly well. AI has you constantly tweaking the beams and cement yourself mid-construction to get a usable product.
ragequittah··on Using AI for just 10 minutes erodes your ability to persist at hard things
Or is it more like creating machine code but using a tool called a compiler? If you've ever made anything with AI you know it by default generates things that aren't ideal. You still have to go in and debug, make the UI better, think of more elegant ways to present things. The fact that you're focused on those issues instead of tediously finding the block of code and maybe tediously looking up ways to fix / make it better is probably an overall good thing in the long run. We've lost the ability to code in assembly I'm not sure that's made software or life worse even if coders as a group are in all likelihood less intelligent these days.

In your analogy maybe it's more like creating a pizza except you didn't have to make the cheese, grind up the flour, go find the water in a stream somewhere, grow the tomatoes yourself, butcher the animal for the meat, etc.

ragequittah··on Artificial Insanity
If you haven't seen the (massive) increases in utility I'd wager you haven't been using the tools much.
ragequittah··on Open-source Microsoft Excel, PowerPoint, and Word replications
Which brings us to the other decentralization issue we're running into: a 16GB stick of RAM might be $1500 by then.
ragequittah··on No Man Is an Island
I mostly learn about my passions / hobbies so interesting conversations w/ others that share them come up pretty much daily. That said I find there's a group of people who will shun me like I kicked their dog for having any interest in using AI, which I find unfortunate.
ragequittah··on No Man Is an Island
If it had no other function than a better than Google search engine that is able to teach me topics I'm interested in at exactly my speed it would be the most interesting technology to come along in a while. The fact that it does all the other stuff it's doing is hard to even come to grips with in the time it's been around.
ragequittah··on I quit OpenAI because its culture is broken
Notable that when it couldn't count the "r"s in strawberry the LLMs were already solving problems most of the people laughing at it for not being able to count "r"s wouldn't be able to come close to figuring out with weeks of research. People have had a myopic view of this technology for a long time. Many still do.
← PreviousPage 2 of 9Next →